From our other sites
The story
A +0.1 change to coin-boost acceleration in Mario Kart 8 Deluxe’s latest update has pulled the rug out from under years of Time Attack (TA) records. On 5ch’s hardware/industry board (“Geha”), the change split posters between TA enthusiasts furious that their records were rendered meaningless without explanation, and cooler-headed users who shrugged it off with “just set new records under the new rules” or “TA players are a tiny minority, this is overblown.” Some pointed out that records from the old ruleset aren’t actually deleted, just archived separately by patch — leaving a noticeable gap in how seriously people took the controversy.
What people said
Don't lose your mind over something this trivial
Why'd they even add +0.1?
Go ask Nintendo
If they patch something that changes times with zero explanation, yeah, people are gonna be pissed
By that logic, racing games could never be updated again
Why rage on a gaming forum instead of complaining straight to Nintendo?
Not that I'm stopping you
The old patch's champion title doesn't just vanish
Let them rage among themselves
Why not just compete in the new-ruleset category?
Right now you could probably blow past the old times and grab the top spot
I get the argument that it's meaningless if you can't keep playing under the same conditions, though
And records from the old ruleset stick around too, preserved permanently
I genuinely don't get the appeal at all
Even watching TA runs, they cut corners in weird spots that just look wasteful, so I never think "wow, impressive"
They just seem like an odd bunch to me
If you care this much, you must be a Time Attack guy yourself
Show us your times, then
That's clearly aimed at people who want more reasons to keep grinding 8DX
If you want to be cynical about it, this update could also be read as trying to keep people away from 8DX
Ah, I see
So it's about bringing it in line with the Switch 2 version
The whole point of the update is probably to funnel people toward the Switch 2, so that tracks
If you're a TA player this is basically your one big shot at touching the #1 world ranking, so getting mad about it makes zero sense to me
I can picture someone who doesn't even understand how TA records and rankings work just picking a fight based on assumptions
It's kind of scary how it's a perennial fixture on the yearly sales charts
Then they need to be more careful with their updates
But if it got faster, doesn't that just mean more to dig into? Shouldn't that be a good thing?
That's an easy thing to say if you don't actually play it
Though apparently people went ballistic demanding Shell no Surge (a game title) get pulled from the KOTY list ("Kuso of the Year," Japan's unofficial worst-game-of-the-year award) just because it can be patched
If updates had kept coming steadily since launch, you'd figure more were on the way, but this really came out of nowhere — like, why now?
For reference, Sonic Racing handles it by tweaking multiplayer balance separately while leaving Time Attack mode on the old specs
So it's a timing issue, huh
Though if they patch Time Attack separately, wouldn't that make it harder to practice?
Background and Key Points of the Debate
Mario Kart 8 Deluxe’s Time Attack (TA) system is designed so records are sorted and managed by patch (ruleset), and even after this update, records set under the old ruleset are preserved rather than erased. Several posters in the thread made this same point (>>8, >>12), suggesting the thread title’s claim of “wiping out the past entirely” is something of an exaggeration. The debate split along two lines: (1) whether even a small tweak like a +0.1 coin-boost change — which alters racing lines and undercuts the foundation of existing TA strategies — should be seen as an “unreasonable blow,” or whether players should simply take it as a chance to “chase the top spot again under the new ruleset”; and (2) whether the whole controversy deserves to be taken seriously at all, given how small the TA-playing population is. Some posters also speculated that the change was made to align with, or nudge players toward, the Switch 2 version, though this can’t be confirmed from the thread itself.
※This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware/Industry, “Geha”) thread “Mario Kart 8 Deluxe: Time Attack Players Furious Over Update That Wipes Out the Past“.
Leave a Reply