From our other sites
The story
According to a survey by Teikoku Databank, engineering has overtaken law to rank second among the academic departments Japanese company presidents graduated from. While a little over 60% of presidents have humanities backgrounds, nearly 40% come from science and engineering — a reality that doesn’t quite match the common image of the president as a “humanities type.” In a 5ch thread, users debated how academic background connects to running a company, touching on discomfort with economics being classified as a humanities field, examples of companies known for having many science/engineering-background presidents, and the relationship between founding generations and the management that succeeds them.
“Science-grad presidents” — pushed up by a generation that used technology as its weapon to start companies
“When you think of a company president, you think economics or law.” Not a few people picture those two, plus commerce, as the standard trio of humanities departments that produce executives. And indeed, the big-company CEOs who show up in the media are disproportionately graduates of humanities departments at famous universities. But look at Japanese companies as a whole, and a slightly different picture emerges. The single most common department was economics, but engineering came in second. Two out of every five presidents have a science or engineering background, and that ratio is especially high among “founders” — people who started their own companies. The reality is that Japanese executives are nowhere near as uniformly humanities-trained as the “president = humanities type” image suggests.
The analysis covered 46,095 companies in Teikoku Databank’s corporate database for which the president’s university and department were identified in surveys from October 2024 onward. Of these, 62.7% (28,910 companies) had presidents from humanities departments and 37.3% (17,185 companies) from science/engineering departments — meaning two out of every five presidents had a science/engineering background. By department, “economics” (8,697 companies) was the most common. “Engineering” came in second (7,976 companies), beating “law” (6,780 companies) by about 1,200 companies and leaving “commerce” (5,168 companies) far behind.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
In Japan it's filed under humanities, so it can never win a Nobel Prize — even though most of economics is statistics and risk calculation.
You can't forget the basic fact that economics is, at bottom, done by human beings.
The "science" parts of it are grade-school arithmetic at best, and it's driven by greed, so really it belongs in the incompetent-humanities bracket.
Fine if that were the whole point, but it gets used as ammo to bash humanities grads — "CEOs are humanities types! Humanities ruined Japan! We need more STEM grads!"
And even STEM grads only have limited job options after graduating anyway — they end up stuck doing work they didn't want, stressed out, and then it's "damn those humanities people" all over again.
Manufacturing is part of it, but I think it's mostly the result of a glut of tech-focused startups.
Even if it looks like a takeover, they're the ones making money off trading the stock.
humanities types only think about how to skim wealth off other people.
Not clear that the technology is actually what's generating the wealth, though.
Is law a humanities subject or a science subject, anyway?
Science grads from bottom-tier ("baka-dai") universities are so dumb and useless you'd wonder if they even count as "science types." A reasonably sharp junior-college woman can have way better comprehension than that. So yeah, university ranking does matter.
Source: my own workplace. It's genuinely bad — you can't even have a logical conversation with the managers in the R&D department.
That's because there's zero logic in your post to begin with.
Economics and business administration are totally different fields.
It was originally all one field called "commerce studies," which covered economics, business administration, public administration, statistics, accounting, and more. It later branched off — economics and business administration split into their own departments, and commerce studies was left with just bookkeeping and accounting. And then commerce was
Hitachi is trustworthy on this front — there, a humanities grad could never become president. There's never been a president from a private university either. It's basically always a national-university engineering grad.
The previous president of Nissan — "the technology company" Nissan — was a theology major. Ended up with a massive deficit and was forced into mass layoffs, including shutting down the Oppama plant.
Which "Honda" are you even talking about?
Unlike the founder, management in the mature phase has no real vision, so a sharp, unconventional person actually becomes a liability. You end up with a bunch of "70-point" executives doing Frankenstein-style management, trying to imitate the founder, and the result just comes out weird. But that's unavoidable — founders really are just special.
That might be true of the "classes" at an F-rank (bottom-tier) university, but if it's that much of a grab-bag, it's probably really more like a "Business Whatever Department" lol
Some of Japan's private-school humanities programs, in particular, are basically knockoffs of the American model, where business schools carry as much prestige as law school or med school.
As long as the executive in charge is properly overseeing that area, it's not a problem. What exactly do you think a company president's job is, to write a post like that?
TEPCO's president is a Tokyo Tech graduate who came up through research before moving over to management.
I don't really get what "tataki-age" (rising through the ranks via hard graft) is even supposed to mean here.
Have you never actually had a job?
Re: #196
I get that back in the analog era there was this nonsensical "guts and grit" philosophy around "rising through the ranks," but I genuinely don't know what that phrase is supposed to mean in this day and age. Isn't that basically just workplace harassment?
There's no way "rising through the ranks" counts as workplace harassment. It's used to mean building up real skill over time through your own effort.
If you think that's harassment, you're not cut out for working life. Obviously actual power-harassment is a different story and completely unacceptable.
Background and key points of this discussion
Teikoku Databank’s tally covers 46,095 companies identified from October 2024 onward, and it’s worth noting that the 62.7% humanities / 37.3% science split is based on the department of just one person — the president — per company. Economics is classified as humanities, but it also involves areas like statistics and risk calculation, and thread commenters pointed out how fuzzy the humanities/science split really is. Companies cited as having many science/engineering-background presidents, such as Hitachi and TEPCO, are technology-heavy firms — a bias driven by industry type rather than a trend that holds across all sectors. Some commenters drew a direct line between academic background and management quality, but the original survey only shows the distribution of departments — it doesn’t prove any correlation with business performance, a point readers could easily misread.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (News Speed+) thread “Is “president = humanities type” just an assumption? The surprising reality that 40% of presidents are science/engineering grads, with “engineering” beating out law.”
Leave a Reply