Which Store Sells It Cheapest? 5ch Erupts Over the ‘C’ Math Puzzle

From our other sites

The story

A thread on 5ch’s “Nandemo Jikkyo G” board kicked off over a math problem asking which store sells a piece of clothing the cheapest during a sale. The original post was framed as “72% of 2,000 high schoolers answered ‘C’ when given this problem,” but partway through the thread the poster themselves admitted it was just a doctored image — there were no 2,000 students and no real answers, it was all made up. Even so, the debate over whether C is really the cheapest option — hinging on how you factor in the “second item half price” condition — kept splitting the thread, with the pro-C and anti-C camps going back and forth on their reasoning.

What people said

1AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:08
We gave this problem to 2,000 high schoolers —
72% answered 'C'
2AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:10
No matter how you slice it, it's C
4AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:12
Re: #2
Try running the numbers assuming you bought two of the same item.
13AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:14
Re: #4
Even if you did buy two, the problem only asks about one specified item.
5AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:12
Couldn't B work too, given how this question is phrased?
11AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:14
Re: #5
Can you walk me through that logic?
7AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:13
This is actually a great question — the 'correct' answer can change after you've already submitted yours.
9AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:13
C is ¥5,000 per item, that's the cheapest, come on
16AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:16
Re: #13
That doesn't mean the specified item itself actually gets cheaper though.
21AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:19
Re: #16
Just pick whichever option makes it cheaper. Can't you talk to the store staff?
18AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:18
I can actually get on board with C being wrong because, at the end of the day, you spend ¥15,000 total just to get the one specified item.
26AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:22
Re: #18
Re: #19
It's not asking "which store sells clothes cheapest" — it's "which store sells THIS item cheapest." So no matter what other costs are involved, C is the store where you can get the specified item cheapest.

In other words, you're only supposed to count the cost attributable to that one item.
19AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:18
Wait, C is two ¥10,000 items — even with the discount that's ¥15,000 total. Why would anyone pick C?
22AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:21
This question is just badly written. It dodges saying "which option costs the least overall," and that's exactly what's making it confusing.
82AnonymousNov 16, 2026 23:04
Re: #22
So if it were worded plainly like that, are you saying a different answer would be correct? That's precisely what "the question is badly written" means.
23AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:21
Re: #21
Isn't that just semantics though? If you sent someone to buy it for you and they came back saying "Got it for ¥5,000! Oh, and I grabbed a second one while I was at it, so that's ¥15,000 total, please" — would you actually accept that? If not, it's no different when you buy it yourself.
29AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:23
Re: #23
Whether I'd personally accept it is irrelevant. The question is purely "can you get the specified item for the lowest price possible."
37AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:29
Re: #29
Okay, shifting the goalposts here, but: "just negotiate the specified item down to half price" adds a condition that isn't among the listed options, so that breaks the rules. At minimum, at the moment the question is posed, it's not established that this is "the store where the specified item is cheapest."

If you allow "it counts as long as the negotiation works," then technically any store might throw in a surprise discount if you just ask.
41AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:34
Re: #37
Don't just move the goalposts on me, lol.

By that logic, option A doesn't mention a price the way the others do, so we don't actually know what the 30% off even applies to — guess it's not necessarily A either 🫠 Maybe it's 30% off the cotton content, lmao.
48AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:38
If you've only got ¥10,000 on you, you can't even afford C though
50AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:39
Re: #48
Why are you just inventing how much money I have? Is this a math problem or a shopping errand?
53AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:42
Re: #50
You get to tack on your own condition like "just negotiate it down," but when someone else adds "what if you only had ¥10,000" you shut that down? You lose this argument.
54AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:42
"Whoa, scored it half price! Guess I'm a shopping genius!" — meanwhile you just got talked into blowing an extra ¥10,000 on stuff you didn't need, lol
59AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:46
Re: #54
That's not the point being made here. It's only asking which option is cheapest — it's not asking "where would you personally shop."
58AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:45
By the way, this is just a photoshopped image — there were never 2,000 real high schoolers, and the "student answers" are something I (the OP) just made up on the spot.
66AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:52
Buy two at C, then resell one on Mercari (Japan's big resale app)
69AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:55
Re: #66
Nice to meet you! I've got my very first date ever this weekend and was looking for an outfit, and I found a nice one here. But I'd like to save some budget for the date itself, so could you give me a discount?
67AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:53
Say you buy a ¥100 steamed meat bun and the clerk says, "Since you bought that, we'll give you a red bean bun at half price — ¥50" — if you take the deal, you'd say "I bought the bean bun for ¥50."

You wouldn't say you "bought the bean bun for ¥75" just because you paid ¥150 total.

That's exactly what "THIS item" means in the question. The ¥10,000 for the first item is irrelevant. You treat the end result — getting "this item" via the deal — as costing ¥5,000.
73AnonymousNov 16, 2026 22:58
Re: #67
If that's the premise you're going with, then isn't "buying two of the same item" an equally valid premise?
76AnonymousNov 16, 2026 23:00
Re: #67
Only the second item gets the discount. When you're told to buy "this item" as cheaply as possible, tacking on some mystery first purchase is against the rules — that's nowhere in the listed options.

My conclusion: buying "this item" at C costs ¥10,000.
79AnonymousNov 16, 2026 23:02
Buy a ¥10,000 item as a set with "this item" → "this item" gets knocked down to half price → that's ¥5,000, isn't it?
81AnonymousNov 16, 2026 23:03
Re: #79
But you wanted to buy "this item," and you still ended up paying ¥15,000 total to get it.
83AnonymousNov 16, 2026 23:05
Getting it at half price only works on the premise that you first bought a ¥10,000 item — so C doesn't qualify. Calling it "bought for ¥5,000" is just sophistry.
89AnonymousNov 16, 2026 23:18
Re: #83
Somehow this reminds me of that old "show up before 1 o'clock" loophole trick.
92AnonymousNov 16, 2026 23:20
Re: #83
Wait by the checkout for some poor soul buying just one item. Spot one, then get them to split the bill with you. Boom, 50% off.

Gotta put that brain to use while you're still alive, lol.

Background and What’s Really at Stake Here

This kind of “which sale option is actually cheapest” math puzzle is a classic bait question that circulates online periodically, where the answer shifts depending on how literally you read the wording. This time, option C’s “second item half price” condition sparked disagreement over how to count the real cost when you only want to buy the one specified item. Worth flagging: the thread’s founding premise — that the puzzle was given to 2,000 high schoolers and 72% answered “C” — was revealed by the original poster themselves, in post #58 of the thread, to be entirely made up. So this isn’t a real academic survey at all; it’s a case of 5ch users latching onto a math puzzle that was already circulating online and arguing over it. Reading just the thread title and taking it as evidence of “declining academic ability” would be a misreading — what’s actually worth paying attention to is the debate over how to interpret the arithmetic itself.

*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (“Nandemo Jikkyo G”) thread “[Image] High schoolers’ academic decline is stark — 72% get a simple math problem wrong 😱.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *