From our other sites
The story
A thread questioning why Dragon Quest III alone gets singled out as the series’ “greatest masterpiece” has sparked debate. Some praised its groundbreaking freedom to freely build your own party, while many others pointed out that companion characters have no personality or dialogue, leaving the game feeling “empty.” The discussion expanded to cover how people felt about IV’s AI-controlled battles at the time, the ongoing debate over Kiryl’s Full Heal and Kazap (an instant-death spell) spam, and the brutal King Hydra added in the III remake — all of which highlighted just how hard it is to rank the series by “fun” alone.
What people said
IV onward is where they actually got personality.
The only one with any real character is the merchant who ends up thrown in jail.
Maybe little brats would be better off with something like "Jubei Quest" (a jokingly made-up, dumbed-down RPG title)?
Nah, the people who actually played it in real time are half-joking about it — it's the people who weren't there taking it seriously and making noise. Even back then, everyone knew exactly which command made which character take which action.
There was plenty of frustration with it even at the time — people are still bringing up Kiryl's Kazap (the instant-death spell) to this day.
Though it's nothing like today's deep-learning AI.
The first Demon Lord and the first Hero.
You don't remember beating enemies senseless with the Hero, Ragnar, Alena, and Torneko?
I like II — does that make me a contrarian too?
II is just plain fun, so that's not being a contrarian.
II jumped straight to top-tier with the remake.
but over time the standard people judge games by shifted toward things like story.
For that era, the games with free party customization would be
Wizardry
Dragon Quest III
Final Fantasy III
Ultima III (Exodus)
something like that, I guess?
Kids back then filled in the gaps with their imagination, but today's kids are so used to advanced games that they can't do that anymore…
Filling in the gaps with your imagination is what an RPG is, though.
If the game hands you everything, it's not an RPG anymore — it's a visual novel.
I think character designs that appeal to otaku have also become important these days.
I hate the IV remake. Didn't need the extra content.
As for Kiryl, Yuji Horii's book "How to Make Dragon Quest" explains why he ended up that way.
I've seen explanations online and on YouTube too
about how that decision actually got made.
I do think it was genuinely innovative to pull off given the storage capacity back then,
but whether that was good for the player is… well, a different question.
If you go in judging old games by "is it fun" alone, you'll end up pretty disappointed.
Now that you mention it, being the first RPG with battery-backed save data
was a genuinely huge deal as a game.
Even so, there are plenty of interesting ideas in it either way.
Anyone can clear it, but the tough spots are properly tough.
Sorry, but I have zero confidence I could clear it without ever using Defend.
the Rotting Corpse from original III,
the Clockwork Soldier from VII, and so on —
but the three King Hydras in the III remake are in a league of their own.
A King Hydra shows up as part of the gauntlet of fights leading into final boss Zoma,
so why does the very next area throw THREE of them at you at once?
And all three of them keep spamming a move that hits three times and inflicts both paralysis and spell-seal, so you just die over and over — it's basically an unwinnable mess.
Why is something several times stronger than final boss Zoma or hidden boss Shinryu showing up as a random encounter?
There's no "weak" enemy stronger than this in the whole history of the series.
Yikes, something like that exists?
Does it show up in Zoma's Castle, not the post-game hidden dungeon?
It shows up right at the start once you beat final boss Zoma and unlock the hidden dungeon.
He's the only mage-type who ever actually gets used — decked out in heavy armor plus the Happy Hat, casting the strongest Full Heal in the series.
Because the Famicom version has no command option.
I felt the same about IX and dropped it early on.
That's because Wizardry, the series Dragon Quest took inspiration from, is a character-creation game.
XII's characters have no appeal, so I might not even buy it.
The hero, the lizard guy, the woman — all garbage.
Background and Key Points of This Discussion
Dragon Quest III was released in 1988, and the ability to freely create and organize your party members was groundbreaking for its time. On the other hand, because companion characters have no unique dialogue or defined personalities, the game tends to feel like it “lacks individuality” compared to the character-driven style the series adopted from IV onward. What divided the thread was a difference in evaluation standards: whether to view this lack of individuality as “room left for the player’s imagination to fill in” or simply as “emptiness.” Meanwhile, criticism of IV’s AI-controlled battles (the “leave it to them” command) is often assumed to be a modern, after-the-fact complaint, but issues like Kiryl repeatedly casting Kazap were already being pointed out back when the Famicom version released, so it isn’t necessarily a criticism that only emerged recently. Whether a game counts as a “masterpiece” is discussed not just in terms of simple fun, but also by standards like how innovative it was at release and how much influence it had on the genre — and it’s this difference in standards that ends up dividing opinion.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5channel (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “Why does Dragon Quest treat III like it’s the one true masterpiece?“.
Leave a Reply