From our other sites
The story
A news report describing the reality facing elderly people who, despite working 25 days a month while battling chronic illness, are left with only ¥40,000 in hand has sparked discussion. While the report highlights elderly people “working to survive” because pension payments alone aren’t enough to live on, users on 5ch were split — some questioned whether the article’s numbers actually added up, others debated the gap between national pension payouts and welfare benefits, and still others argued over whether elderly poverty is a matter of personal responsibility or a structural problem with society.
Working 25 Days a Month, Left with Just ¥40,000: The Reality of Elderly People “Working to Survive” While Chronically Ill
Published Sun, Nov 15, 7:50 AM
CBC Television
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
You're better off living on welfare.
Thanks a lot to all the Diet members who turned Japan into that kind of country.
You're not even paying your pension?
Pension payouts get taxed when you receive them and that money flows into the general budget. The more people like you there are, and the more pension revenue shrinks, the bigger the hit to other social security programs.
The lower brackets only get a bit over ¥100,000.
When I see people on the “Ice Age” threads (the Employment Ice Age / “lost generation” who job-hunted during Japan's 1990s–2000s hiring freeze) whining “it's because of the Ice Age,” I know, as someone from that same generation, that they're just blaming the era and society for their own lack of effort.
It's been 30 years since then. The real question is: what exactly were these bottom-feeders doing all that time?
At that income level you'd still end up stuck in the same spaces as poor people all the time, buying the same stuff as everyone else — seems like an awkward, stressful in-between spot to be in.
My pension notice already shows something like ¥200,000 at this point.
If it's just the national pension, the average is ¥60,000 — half of welfare.
Mine's ¥6,000, and I'm in my 40s.
If you're even asking that, you probably don't understand how the pension system works — are you even reading the notice correctly?
If you hadn't gotten sick, you'd probably still be working at 65 anyway, in which case you wouldn't get the full pension either way.
I bet there are a lot of self-employed people like that.
If you have to keep working because the pension alone isn't enough to live on, but working also shrinks the pension you'd otherwise get, the whole thing's pointless.
Once you can't work anymore you can just go on welfare anyway.
National pension premiums are basically money down the drain.
You probably just didn't file the paperwork properly, right?
In my 20s I was doing live-in part-time jobs where my address changed every year, so I've literally never once seen a pension bill.
If you just become a normal full-time employee, marry a normal cute girlfriend, and work until retirement like a normal person, the two of you can get ¥300,000 a month in pension. On top of that, with your retirement payout plus ¥40 million in savings and a paid-off house, you can live comfortably, spending your weekends playing with your kids and grandkids.
By then the house will probably be due for a rebuild —
loan!
seconds, please!!
If both spouses are former civil servants, that's ¥400,000 a month — comfortable retirement, right?
National pension premiums are lower, so it's built on the assumption you'll invest the difference yourself.
Spinning that into a “life is so hard” sob story is exactly the THE GOLD ONLINE playbook (a financial news outlet known for sensational money-trouble stories).
Even so, ¥50,000 a month combining national and employee pension sounds like way too many unpaid periods.
Plenty more to pick apart here too.
Income of ¥20,000 for 25 days of work a month (so, 30 minutes of work a day, lol?)
The ¥40,000 “left over” is what's left AFTER subtracting rent and food (so it's basically just hernia hospital bills and utilities).
If he barely paid into the pension and still ends up with this much, that's actually not bad.
If “working to survive” only nets you a measly ¥20,000, then getting the full pension would basically break even.
Isn't it just his own fault for not paying in?
The pension history here is a bit hard to make sense of.
If those 25 years as a taxi driver counted toward employee pension, he should be getting a bit more than this.
The source says it's piece-rate pay.
It's just hauling groceries from the hospital to the facility, so it's not going to add up to much income.
This organization is probably the one handing out jobs to elderly people who can't find work elsewhere.
But if that's ¥40,000 left over AFTER rent and food are already deducted, that should be plenty.
Maybe it's going toward cigarettes?
If you just go to college like a normal person, enter the workforce like a normal person, and start a family like a normal person, there's basically no realistic way, as a matter of practical fact, that you end up like this, lol.
That's just a view from today's standpoint.
Prevailing attitudes change with the times.
Back in the era of rapid economic growth, there was a widespread sense that running your own business paid more than being an employee, and quite a few civil servants and bank employees actually left their jobs to start businesses.
Even then it should come out to more than ¥50,000 a month, so for the numbers to add up, he must have only paid premiums for maybe 10 years out of those 25 years of work at most.
Though I have no idea how you'd end up with unpaid pension when it's deducted straight from your paycheck.
Maybe so — that might be why he can't get disability pension either.
What a rough system.
Employee pension is a two-tier system, so something about this still feels off.
Background and Key Points of the Debate
The average payout for the national pension is said to be around ¥60,000 a month — roughly half of welfare benefits. Because employee pension is a two-tier structure layered on top of the basic pension, payout amounts vary widely depending on years worked and periods of unpaid premiums. In the thread, many users found it hard to follow the relationship between the article’s figures — a “monthly income of ¥20,000” and “¥40,000 left over” — and a number of posters pointed to a likely long history of unpaid premiums. Opinions were also split between those who viewed elderly poverty as a matter of personal responsibility and those who saw it as a problem with the pension system or the structure of society, with no consensus on which was the primary cause.
*This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (News Express+) thread “[Working to Survive] Working 25 Days a Month, Left with Just ¥40,000: The Reality of Elderly People “Working to Survive” While Chronically Ill.”


Leave a Reply