From our other sites
The story
In fiscal 2025, 323 municipalities across Tokyo and six surrounding prefectures paid a combined total of over ¥18 billion in fees to the operators of furusato nozei (hometown tax donation) portal sites like “Rakuten Furusato Nozei” and “Furusato Choice,” a Tokyo Shimbun tally has found — more than a tenth of all donations received. The figure, revealed for the first time in a performance survey the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications published in July, has prompted the government to call the fees excessive and press operators to lower them. On 5ch’s News Flash+ board, reactions poured in from every angle: criticism of intermediaries “skimming” money off the top, suggestions that the government simply build its own portal, and a recurring Tokyo-versus-the-regions framing.
A Tokyo Shimbun tally has found that in fiscal 2025, 323 municipalities across Tokyo and six surrounding prefectures, together with their wards, cities and towns, paid a combined total of over ¥18 billion in effective fees to the operators of furusato nozei portal sites. Billed under line items like advertising costs and payment-processing fees, this amount accounts for more than a tenth of all donations received. Donations meant to benefit local residents are instead flowing out as corporate profit, and the government itself has flagged the fees as excessively high. (By Kiyomi Ishii)
◆ Ministry survey reveals the true scale of the fees for the first time
Many municipalities that receive donations outsource tasks such as placing online ads and sourcing and shipping the “thank-you gifts” given to donors to the operators of sites like “Rakuten Furusato Nozei” and “Furusato Choice.” How much each municipality actually paid these operators had been unknown until now — it was revealed for the first time in the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications’ fiscal 2025 performance survey, published in July.
Source: tokyo-np.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
Same thing happens with electricity and gas subsidies — operators subcontract the work out and take their cut as a matter of course.
Everybody does it everywhere, honestly. It's just like any other handling fee.
If there's no profit in it, nobody would bother doing it.
…"hometown tax evasion"? (a pun: furusato nozei, "hometown tax donation," vs. furusato datsuzei, "hometown tax evasion")
Wait, you're telling me YOU'RE not doing hometown tax evasion? lol
Pfft.
Yeah, fair enough. More like "hometown No!-tax" at this point. (another pun: nozei, "tax payment," vs. "No! zei")
It's basically regional online shopping that piggybacks on the furusato nozei system.
If there were no middlemen skimming off the top, the corporate tax, income tax, consumption tax, and property tax it generates would recoup the cost within a few years, so it genuinely helps regional revitalization.
…if there were no middlemen skimming off the top.
I can already picture it — they'd budget ¥100 billion just to consolidate everything under some "Ministry-certified operator."
Can't speak for Osaka, but Tokyo has so much surplus cash it wastes anyway, so it's not even a problem.
Tokyo and Osaka poach people from the regions in the first place, so it evens out — no problem.
So you ARE doing hometown tax evasion after all. Congrats, you just contributed to the middlemen's cut.
Which just means it flows back to Tokyo, lol. Same deal as the pick-and-shovel sellers during the gold rush.
They're raking in huge profits purely from skimming fees, so cutting their pay wouldn't exactly be unfair.
It would've just flowed to some cushy amakudari organization in central Tokyo instead (amakudari: retired bureaucrats parachuting into post-retirement jobs) 😂
The usual "big four" vendors would just end up building another garbage system.
Yeah, you could still get reward points last year.
Re: #131
No way bureaucrats would do it themselves — if they screw it up, they'd get sidelined or canned, so of course they won't touch it.
It's tolerated because the money ends up benefiting the local area. That said, it also works as a de facto consumption-tax dodge, so it'll be interesting to watch whether the mix of food items among thank-you gifts shifts during the two years of the 1% food tax cut.
Exactly — if the thank-you gifts got scrapped, Tokyo would collect less in metropolitan and ward corporate taxes from companies headquartered there, which would mean trimming welfare budgets too, including welfare payments ("namapo," slang for livelihood-protection benefits).
The amakudari angle —
please, go into detail.
It's a tax scheme that undermines the whole point of resident tax, really. If people don't need to take responsibility for the self-governance of the area they actually live in, we might as well scrap resident tax entirely and just let the national government redistribute everything.
As "payment" for doing that job, we get thank-you gifts, the operators get their handling fees, and the local governments get the redistributed tax money.
If people don't like that, the government should just do its own job properly.
What I'd really like verified, though, is whether the headcount and pay of the bureaucrats who no longer have to do that job actually went down.
Background and Key Points of the Debate
Under the furusato nozei system, municipalities pay portal-site operators like “Rakuten Furusato Nozei” and “Furusato Choice” commissions billed as advertising costs, gift-sourcing costs, and payment-processing fees — and the real scale of that spending was only quantified for the first time in the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications’ survey. The thread splits between those who see the operators’ cut as a perfectly normal handling fee and those who call it middlemen skimming donations away from resident services into corporate profit. The debate also expanded into a Tokyo-versus-the-regions framing, with some arguing it’s only natural for tax money to shift from Tokyo and Osaka to the regions, while others countered that Tokyo-based portal operators are the ones actually vacuuming up donations from across the entire country. One easily overlooked point: the Ministry only tightened its commission standards starting in October 2026, meaning the fiscal 2025 figures revealed here still reflect the old rules — in other words, this is a snapshot of the period when middlemen skimming was at its absolute worst, right before the system changed.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (News Flash+) thread “Over ¥18 Billion in Furusato Nozei Donations From Seven Tokyo-Area Prefectures Siphoned to Portal Sites… Even Though the Government Pushed Operators to Cut Fees“
Leave a Reply