From our other sites
The story
Japan’s Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare is reviewing the standard benefit amounts for welfare (seikatsu hogo). The periodic review, normally conducted every five years and originally scheduled for 2027, has been moved up by a year due to rising prices, with a new benefit standard set to be finalized before year’s end. The review comes amid criticism that welfare’s basic living allowance now exceeds the full amount of the national pension. On 5ch, this sparked a mix of resentment — “there are too many people on welfare (‘namapo,’ slang for welfare recipients) and it’s wrecking society” — and comments questioning the system design itself, like “politicians are the ones who created this mess.” Opinions are split over whether pensions should be raised or welfare should be cut, with disagreement over where the burden should fall.
Ahead of a planned revision of welfare benefit levels, a panel of experts convened by the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare has begun its review. The periodic review, normally held once every five years, was originally scheduled for 2027, but has now been moved up a year in light of prolonged price increases. The ministry reportedly intends to set new benefit standards by the end of this year, with the revised amounts taking effect in October 2027.
At issue is the standard rate for the “livelihood assistance” portion of benefits, which covers costs like food and utilities. This review is reportedly weighing the spending patterns of ordinary low-income households against resident-tax thresholds, but it has already touched off fierce debate online.
First, some voices sympathetic to the review, mindful of the hardship rising prices are causing recipients.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
The LDP's been causing that very problem for over 30 years.
Take your complaints to them.
Smartphones are a necessity though.
Pachinko, cigarettes, and booze — sure, ban those.
If you think your pension's too small, just pay in higher premiums.
Why aren't you using the system?
But staying on it unchanged for years on end is just wrong.
If someone still can't work years after going on welfare, they should be grouped together in communal housing to keep costs down.
Not much point suggesting something that would violate the constitution…
Honestly, I think collective farms where they grow their own food would be the way to go.
Then everyone outside those two groups should have it cut off immediately, right?
Raising pension payouts means raising the monthly premiums everyone pays in, you know.
I'd rather see national pension premiums dropped to zero, even if it means cutting the payout amount.
In the UK and other countries, once you turn 60 you get your pension fully funded by taxes, no premiums required.
Japan's about the only country that levies what amounts to a 200,000-yen-a-year poll tax even on someone earning just 2 million yen a year — that's a flaw baked into the system itself, if you ask me.
Even if it costs more to administer, it's worth it if it helps people get off welfare ("namapo").
I also think they should expand the ration-based approach.
Cut the cash benefit and switch part of it over to rationed goods.
That's a violation of the right to make your own choices, even foolish ones, and the right to pursue happiness.
Even people on welfare ("namapo") have the right to enjoy a drink, a smoke, or some entertainment.
Man does not live on bread alone.
Even so, I bet they'd just resell the food vouchers and gamble with the cash anyway.
If someone can't even keep a budget log, treat that as proof they can't manage cash, and have a proxy handle their benefits instead of them.
I've seen caseworkers already giving that kind of guidance.
Re: #202
Caseworkers already keep tabs on them.
And when that monitoring goes too far, it ends up causing all sorts of incidents and accidents.
So it's only fair to make welfare recipients submit a household budget log too.
If they can't manage that, don't give them cash.
Exactly this.
Year-end tax adjustments are a hassle too, but at least you get some money back for the trouble.
Compared to that, a household budget log is nothing.
I think it'd be fine to make it a legal requirement.
Re: #220
People on welfare ("namapo") can't handle something that complicated.
Anyone capable of doing that would already be working.
Just give up on the idea.
Think about how much tax money would be wasted just checking all of that…
Then what's everyone else even working for?
Shareholders: "So we can exploit you."
If you earn under 6 million yen a year, you're effectively not paying income tax.
Don't tell me you think paying consumption tax alone counts as 'paying your taxes'?
Background and Key Points
Once every five years, a Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare advisory panel reviews standard welfare benefit amounts by comparing them against the actual spending patterns of ordinary low-income households. This time the review was moved up because rising prices have widened the gap between the standard rates and real-world costs, with a revision targeted for October 2027. Where the thread’s debate really splits is over the instinct to compare pensions and welfare as a simple matter of who’s getting the better deal — but the two serve different institutional purposes: a pension is a return on premiums paid in, while welfare is a last-resort safety net for people with no income or assets. The reality that most recipients are elderly people or disability-pension recipients, with only a small share being working-age people capable of employment, is easy to lose sight of amid the thread’s more heated posts. Beneath what looks like purely emotional conflict lies a mix of distrust in the pension system itself and misunderstandings about how the welfare system actually works.
*This article is compiled as an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (News Speed+) thread “‘Can’t be helped’ vs. ‘This makes no sense no matter how you look at it’ — Online split over welfare benefit review moved up a year, as unfairness spreads over payouts exceeding the full national pension amount.”
Leave a Reply