From our other sites
The story
Shinji Saito (44), former member of the comedy trio Jungle Pocket, was handed a four-year prison sentence (prosecutors had sought seven years) by the Tokyo District Court on November 16, after being convicted of nonconsensual sexual intercourse and related charges against a female co-star. On an information program airing the same day, comedian Ringo of the duo Heels brought up the case, remarking “those of us from an older generation than that…” — a comment that hinted at a generational gap in how people are reacting to the verdict. On 5ch, threads split between posters hoping to see Saito return to show business and others pushing back with “why would he think he’d be forgiven?”, while opinion was also divided over whether what happened at the time was a mutual misreading of the situation or an act that overrode a clear refusal.
Heels’ Ringo Comments on the Trial of Former Jungle Pocket Member Shinji Saito: “Those of Us From an Older Generation…”
Ringo of the comedy duo Heels appeared on the information program “Shunkan LIVE Toretate!” (Kansai TV) on the 16th and commented on the trial of former Jungle Pocket member Shinji Saito (44).
That same day, Saito, who had been charged with nonconsensual sexual intercourse and other offenses, was sentenced to four years in prison (prosecutors had sought seven years) by the Tokyo District Court.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
Telling 'everyone else' to just go watch him is way too irresponsible.
Must be nice for you, huh — must be nice.
I guess once you're a celebrity, this kind of thing just stops registering as a big deal.
Saito thought she was into it,
and the woman didn't want it.
They just talked past each other and it happened anyway.
But even factoring that in,
making a move on a woman during downtime at work is just plain indefensible.
No — the trial established that the woman clearly said 'please stop.'
Which means Saito forced her into oral sex — that's flat-out nonconsensual sexual intercourse.
Would you really make a move on someone you just met, in the production van, during a work break?
They'd just met and she was refusing — that's not some gentle 'miscommunication,' it's way worse than that.
Wasn't there that time Shinsuke and Ryusuke blew up at him for messing up the stopwatch timing, and kicked him while he was sitting in that tall chair, nearly knocking him off?
She did it three times total, apparently.
He doesn't need to come back.
Why on earth would you root for a criminal?
He's not even a special case —
plenty of people who aren't even criminals get frozen out of this industry…
It's also an industry where, with enough pull from your talent agency, even a criminal can make a comeback.
Probably just a difference in talent as a comedian.
Yoshimoto's in-house favoritism. (Yoshimoto = the talent agency)
If a woman's survived this long in show business, and the guy is some company president she needs to stay on good terms with, she'd probably say 'just put up with it, no big deal.'
Apparently back in their NSC days [Yoshimoto's comedy school] they were in the same class, and all four of them — Downtown and Heels — used to hang out together.
But Downtown moved to Tokyo in their mid-20s,
while both members of Heels got married and have lived in Osaka ever since.
So she probably doesn't know the details about the Matsumoto gang.
Though being with Yoshimoto, she's probably well aware of how badly male comedians can behave in general.
I see — if they're not actually friends, then it makes sense she wouldn't know.
Momoko is close with Natsumi Ogawa, and stays at Hamada's place whenever she's in Tokyo,
so she might hear about Hamada through Natsumi,
but she probably doesn't see Matsumoto privately these days.
Was it that kind of company, or that kind of industry?
Well, in that case it's probably something that happens 'before the job even starts' — it's pretty rare for it to happen on set itself.
Background and Key Points of This Story
The crime of “nonconsensual sexual intercourse” was newly created in Japan’s 2023 revision of the criminal code — notably, it covers sexual acts carried out by exploiting a position of power or a relationship to put someone in a state where resisting was difficult, even without violence or explicit threats. The backdrop to this verdict is testimony, accepted by the court, that the woman told him on the spot to stop. That’s exactly where opinions split in the thread: against the view that this was “a case of crossed signals after a misread of mutual interest,” many replies pushed back, pointing to the court’s finding of fact and arguing it was simply “nonconsensual sexual intercourse that overrode a clear refusal.” There were also comments noting that “comeback-hope” narratives for comedians who’ve caused scandals tend to hinge heavily on the internal power dynamics of talent agencies — meaning Ringo’s remark is being read not just as a generational gap in values, but also as a comment on that particular undercurrent within the entertainment industry.
※This article is an excerpt and summary based on the 5ch (Geino Supo Sokuhou+) thread “[Entertainment] Heels’ Ringo Comments on the Trial of Former Jungle Pocket Member Shinji Saito: “Those of Us From an Older Generation…”“
Leave a Reply