From our other sites
The story
In Hello! Project, when a member’s romance or a “personal connection with a fan” comes to light, it often leads to severe punishment — and a debate broke out on 5ch’s Hello! Project board over whether that standard is really fair. It started with the question, “Wouldn’t a warning be enough?”, which drew a wave of responses arguing that such leniency would undermine the fairness of fan services. The discussion centered on two main points: the view that favoring one particular fan through an “otaku connection” (giving a single fan special treatment) should be judged more harshly than romance itself, and the observation that the severity of punishment varies widely between agencies and groups.
What people said
Purchase perks already scale with how much money you spend.
They call him an actor, but nobody's ever heard of him.
and she asked me, "Want to grab a bite?" — but there were too many people around, so I turned her down that time.
Sounds like something you dreamed up, huh?
Can't you stop and think about why it's wrong in the first place?
because the other guy was a Hello! Project otaku.
how that girl would actually feel about it just takes some imagination.
Permanent ban.
If you still want to be an idol after that, go do it at another agency — goodbye.
That's basically what an "otaku connection" is.
Because other customers pay 1,000 yen for 8 seconds, while that guy gets it free every single day.
Yet Tsubaki Factory gets left alone despite that.
The fact that info does leak means the guy isn't decent.
For Tsubaki Factory I only followed them up through Asakura's graduation.
I've never once seen the "Hinaazu" (a member's fan nickname) live.
Background and Key Points of This Discussion
Hello! Project is known for its strict punishment policy on romance and dating compared with other talent agencies, and this discussion takes that as its starting point. The ℃-ute member scandal from before the group’s disbandment, the NGT48 incident, and the reports of Tsubaki Factory members visiting a bar that came up in the thread are all real events that were actually reported at the time — not fabrications. The debate split roughly into two main points. One is where to draw the line between an ordinary relationship (simply “having a boyfriend”) and an “otaku connection” — giving one particular fan special treatment. The other is a difference in perspective between those focused on how such favoritism undermines the fairness of paid perks and fan services, and those focused on the severity of the punishment itself (instant dismissal versus a warning). One point readers might easily get wrong is the idea that “Hello! Project is uniformly strict” — commenters in the thread themselves pointed out that the actual severity of punishment varies by group and by individual, so the policy isn’t applied completely uniformly.
*This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “Is it really bad enough for an idol to have private contact with a fan to warrant an instant red card?“
Leave a Reply