From our other sites
The story
A news report discussed on 5ch covered how the meat industry is pushing back against a WHO study finding that eating 50 grams of processed meat a day (roughly 2-3 slices of ham or bacon) continuously raises the risk of developing colon cancer by 18%. The thread also picked up on the fact that red meat has been flagged as carcinogenic too. Posters pointed out that nitrites, the compound blamed for the cancer risk, are actually consumed in larger amounts from vegetables, and opinion split over how to compare the increased lung cancer risk from smoking with the processed meat risk, sparking a long debate over how to read the statistics.
“Guess I’ll just have to die with a strip of bacon in my hand…” — Eating 2 slices of bacon or ham daily raises cancer rate 18%, WHO report sparks fierce backlash from meat industry
The report states that eating 50 grams of ham or bacon (about 2-3 slices) every day raises the cancer rate by 18%. It also noted that red meat like steak carries carcinogenic risk.
Source: sankei.com / Original article here
What people said
Pretty much all processed meat. Sodium nitrite is an extremely lethal poison.
Re: #40
Nitrites are actually found in huge amounts in vegetables — in a normal diet, about 80% of your nitrite intake comes from veggies.
You should know why it's not a problem when it comes from vegetables, and be able to explain why it becomes a problem in meat (which has less of it, but is preserved with it) instead.
And you should also mention the danger of what happens if you remove the nitrites used as a preservative.
In the US, colonoscopy is the standard screening. In Japan, stool tests are used too.
I recall seeing data saying they're actually worse. Some of them pump junk scrap meat full of chemicals too.
The problem is that if you eat too much, the stomach and small intestine can't fully absorb it, so the compound reaches the colon still intact and does damage there.
It's the bad version of a drug that 'reaches all the way to the ◯◯ without being absorbed.'
If your diet also includes a good balance of vegetables alongside it, this cancer risk doesn't actually happen.
It's not misinformation at all. It's a properly evidence-backed issue.
Though it is true that if you drop the premise that this only applies under certain dietary conditions, you end up way off the mark.
Guess we just have to eat fish.
This issue isn't limited to meat, actually — it happens with fish too.
Nitrites: commonly used in fish roe (tarako, mentaiko, ikura, sujiko), and since the harmful compounds form more readily than in meat, the residue limits are stricter.
Smoking: occurs at the same rate as with meat.
The 'charred steak' problem: rarely occurs with fish.
You see unhealthy old folks who smoke like chimneys and eat tons of sugar living long lives just fine, so stress really is the number one cause of disease after all.
Nah lol, it's genetics lol
The lifetime risk of getting colon cancer is said to be about 6%, and this raises it to around 7-8%.
It's similar kind of evidence to how lung cancer risk goes from near 0% for non-smokers to 4-7% for people smoking a few cigarettes a day — 10-15 out of 100 for a 10-a-day habit, 20-30 out of 100 for 20-a-day.
Even among smokers, plenty of people never get lung cancer. In terms of probability, even among heavy smokers it's only about 1 in 3 or 4.
Maybe it's happier to just eat what you like and die.
It's really just the difference between 3/5 and 4/5.
When it's your time, it's your time.
It's not a multiplier on cancer overall.
The processed meat thing is specifically about colon cancer risk going up.
Smokers' lung cancer risk is about 4.5x that of non-smokers — that's on a totally different level from processed meat. Stop spreading misinformation.
Is that claim actually based on evidence — what percent for non-smokers, and what percent for smokers broken down by cigarettes per day?
Explain it concretely.
I'm sure once you do, you'll see my explanation wasn't misinformation.
Non-smokers: 3.2% (32 out of 1,000)
Smokers: 14.9% (149 out of 1,000)
Official data from the National Cancer Center and the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (including the JACC Study, which tracked 120,000 people for over 20 years) has shown that smokers' lung cancer death risk is about 4.5-5x that of non-smokers.
Re: #75
Please point out exactly which part of what I explained contradicts what you're saying.
>The lifetime risk of colon cancer is said to be about 6%, and this raises it to around 7-8%
>Lung cancer risk going from near 0% for non-smokers to 4-7% for the few-cigarettes-a-day group — calling that → 'similar kind of evidence' ←
>→ 'Even among smokers, the ones who don't get lung cancer just don't.' ← In terms of probability, even among heavy smokers it's only about 1 in 3 or 4.
That's way too malicious a spin.
Can't help it, it's data based on cherry-picked conditions.
There's proof of ways to eat it that don't worsen the risk too, so I have to say: put that in the report as data as well!
Re: #80 nailed it.
Compounds in vegetables neutralize the harmful ones. To begin with, vegetables are the ones that contain large amounts of the 'bad' compound being discussed here.
Leaning too far to either side is what's risky, basically.
Dropping one line out of my four-line explanation and cherry-picking only three to quote — isn't that malicious sophistry?
Uh, you're the one who told me to pull out the quotes though?
Are you seriously claiming that 'Even among smokers, the ones who don't get lung cancer just don't' is malicious misinformation?!
I'm saying manipulating impressions counts as misinformation too. Lining up a bunch of assorted numbers and throwing around phrases like 'similar kind of evidence' and 'even among smokers, the ones who don't get lung cancer just don't' — it's steering people into thinking eating processed meat and smoking carry basically the same risk.
✕ 'assorted'
✓ 'similar' (correcting my own word choice)
I get that you haven't actually read the numbers I posted earlier with their caveats, or my interpretation of them at all — just that I'm being unfairly labeled.
You're free to feel that way, but I'll trust other readers will get what I actually meant.
Thanks.
Background and Key Points of This Debate
This report traces back to the WHO’s specialized agency IARC classifying processed meat as a “Group 1” carcinogen in 2015 — worth noting that these groupings reflect the certainty of the evidence, not the strength of the carcinogenic effect. The 18% figure also isn’t a jump in overall colon cancer risk; it’s the relative increase in colon cancer incidence tied to continuously eating 50 grams of processed meat a day, not an 18% rise in cancer rates overall. In the thread, opinions split over how this compares to the increased lung cancer risk from smoking (roughly 4-5 times that of non-smokers) in terms of which counts as the “higher risk,” and the discussion sprawled on without ever settling the point that nitrites, the compound blamed for the cancer risk, are actually found in larger amounts in vegetables.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch Hardware/Industry (“Geha,” the gaming-hardware board) thread “[Sad News] Ham/Bacon ‘Bad For You’ — Eating 2 Slices Raises Cancer Rate 18%.”
Leave a Reply