From our other sites
The story
A thread asking “Is it really okay for the gaming industry to shower remakes with hype while completely new titles get ignored?” went up on 5ch’s Hardware & Industry board (“Geha”), splitting opinion down the middle. Citing the FF7 Remake and the remakes of Trials of Mana and Romancing SaGa 2, some argued that “good games simply get recognized no matter the era,” while others—pointing to Dragon Quest as a cautionary tale—worried that “constantly catering to people who played the originals fails to bring in new fans and leads to a slow decline.” The debate widened further with claims that lengthening development cycles for mainline numbered entries are what’s really driving the reliance on remakes, plus comparisons to the music industry’s City Pop revival.
What people said
Guess it's just harder to pull off with a brand-new IP.
Off the top of my head, the only completely new title that really blew up and sold is basically just "Mecha Chameleon" (an online nickname fans use for one particular new release).
Getting some attention is fine, but
this is like a cover of an old song becoming the biggest hit of the year.
If the cover beats the original, what's the problem?
Domestically the #1 seller is the brand-new Tomodachi Collection anyway, and overseas GTA6 will probably win too.
Whoever's hyping this thing up can't actually like games.
It's full of middle-aged guys who've lost all motivation to try new games and just want to chew on stuff they already know 😅
Basically the same as those Dragon Quest uncles who get thrilled over and over by remakes of games they've already played.
"The Switch's specs are too weak to run the remake lol"
"Just make do with the old game lol"—nonstop trolling.
Already forgot about that?
And once it actually came out on Switch and sold well, they turned around with some shameless line like "guess you really wanted to play it after all that trash-talking."
Having a hit like that is totally fine, but
if it becomes the biggest hit of the year, you've got to wonder what the newest songs are even doing.
It'd be better if a new song influenced by older music topped the charts instead.
There can be years like that, no big deal.
A weak year for original songs happens all the time—it was practically normal 10 years ago.
That's exactly why Japanese pop music from around 10 years ago gets treated as a "dark age" by some people.
I'm pushing back against the attitude that treats that as just fine.
You're saying it's bad that remakes get showered with hype, but isn't the real problem that new titles are the ones having their spotlight stolen by remakes?
Same goes for games, really.
The difference is that in games, remakes get way more coverage.
Doing it once—"oh, that classic is back"—isn't bad, but remaking something two or three times makes me think, "just make something new instead."
Good stuff gets recognized no matter the era.
It's not bad for the thing itself to get praised.
But the people buying it skew toward older players who already experienced the original.
And Dragon Quest is a cautionary example: keep catering to those players forever while leaving new ones behind, and the franchise slowly withers.
Is wanting a fun new game over that really such a strange take? 🤔
Exactly this.
I don't mind remakes themselves, but separately—hurry up and put out a new game already.
So doesn't that mean remakes are only getting hyped because there's nothing like that out there?
Or maybe the whole premise that they're "getting hyped" is wrong to begin with.
Same goes for FF Resonance—just focus on making the game actually fun to play.
Isn't that just leftovers from a mobile gacha game thrown together into something light?
I get that they're not treating the brand with much care, but…
It's a careless mobile-gacha knockoff recycling Super Famicom-era graphics,
but the diehard fans defending it are way too much.
A lot of people act like this is just normal for the game industry, but
if the same thing happened in the anime or manga industry,
wouldn't you find it pretty pathetic?
I wonder why it ended up in such a pathetic state in the first place.
Well, I get that development cycles have stretched out and remakes are the only way to paper over the gap, but
if that's the case, there are still plenty of titles that haven't been remade yet, you'd think.
Why go back to Ocarina of Time, which already got a remake on 3DS? Same with Star Fox—doesn't feel like Nintendo to keep recycling.
How many times are they gonna put it out?
Geha folks really are like nomads, huh.
Right, Square Enix?
Square Enix's remakes are god-tier.
Trials of Mana and Romancing SaGa 2.
I've only ever heard that opinion from diehard fans.
Honestly, I've started looking down on anyone who brings up Romancing SaGa as having no taste.
Exactly this.
If you're such a jaded old-timer that you don't need remakes at all, go find the niche, cutting-edge stuff yourself.
There's no way a big publisher selling to the mass market is going to fine-tune its lineup for picky eaters.
Background and Key Points of the Debate
The rise in game remakes ties into an industry-side reality: development cycles for major numbered entries have stretched longer, making remakes a convenient “stopgap” to fill the wait. As one thread comment put it, “push the numbering forward too fast and development drags on, so remakes are the only way to buy time”—a reminder that this isn’t purely nostalgia-driven demand but also reflects production costs and risk-avoidance logic that’s easy to overlook. At the same time, some pushed back on the very premise that “remakes are being showered with hype,” noting that the #1 domestic seller is the brand-new Tomodachi Collection title, with GTA6 the likely frontrunner overseas—suggesting buzz and actual sales don’t necessarily line up. The comparison to the music industry’s City Pop revival further reinforced the question of whether it’s fair to simply equate praise for nostalgic content with a slump in new releases.
*This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware & Industry, “Geha”) thread “Is It Really Okay for the Gaming World to Shower Remakes With This Much Hype?.”
Leave a Reply