Backlash Against School Phone Ban: Canadian High Schoolers Walk Out of Class — Forum Split on Who’s Right

From our other sites

The story

In New Brunswick, Canada, high school students staged a walkout to protest a ban on smartphone use at school. At Moncton High School, more than 200 students reportedly held signs reading things like “Give us back our phones” and “Recess is ours,” arguing they had nothing to do during breaks. When an article covering the scene was posted to Lemmy’s c/canada, the thread erupted into debate, with some dismissing the students — “practice your spelling,” “that’s just addiction” — while others pushed back, warning against judging today’s youth by the standards of one’s own past.

High school students in New Brunswick walk out of class to protest cellphone ban

Source: cbc.ca / Original article here

What people said

2Anonymous2026-11-20 10:22
"More than 200 students at Moncton High School joined the protest, holding signs reading 'Give us back our phones,' 'Recess is ours,' and 'Let students keep their phones,'" the report says. Just go to school properly, kiddos.
8Anonymous2026-11-20 14:05
Nice signs. Maybe spend recess practicing your spelling instead? After I learned to read and write, reading books actually built my English better than class did.
3Anonymous2026-11-20 11:24
Guess they need to learn how to tolerate being bored.
4Anonymous2026-11-20 10:50
"We need our phones so we have something to do at recess. Without them, we're just sitting around bored at school," he said. 🤔
6Anonymous2026-11-20 12:41
Stand in a circle and talk, play hacky sack… they'll figure something out eventually.
5Anonymous2026-11-20 11:46
Or they could just read a book.
7Anonymous2026-11-20 12:24
Or commit some crimes lol
9Anonymous2026-11-20 13:54
So brave lol
10Anonymous2026-11-20 13:30
Aw, poor little babies…
11Anonymous2026-11-20 15:27
These kids are just addicted, plain and simple.
12Anonymous2026-11-20 16:03
Fine by me then. Just fail them.
13Anonymous2026-11-20 16:32
It's honestly pathetic how everyone here is so quick to look down on kids who are really no different from how they themselves used to be.

Background and Key Points of This Debate

In recent years, concerns over declining academic performance and negative effects on mental health have reportedly driven a growing number of Canadian provinces to restrict smartphone use in schools, and New Brunswick’s policy is seen as part of that broader trend. Where the thread split was over how to read the students’ complaint that they have “nothing to do” during breaks — some see it as simple phone addiction, while others frame it as a matter of student freedom and self-determination. Many older commenters mocked the students by invoking “back in my day,” but commenter #13 called out that very attitude as pathetic, arguing it’s hypocritical to look down on young people for behavior no different from one’s own youth — and that gap between generations’ memories of themselves became the crux of the debate. School phone bans are a familiar flashpoint in Japan too, and the same split in opinion plays out abroad as well.

*This article is excerpted and translated into Japanese by our editorial team from a thread on the overseas forum Lemmy c/canada, “High school students across N.B. walk out over cellphone ban.” Our site takes full responsibility for the translation.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *