Rena Ichioka Could Actually Sing — 5ch Thread: ‘It Just Hits You’

From our other sites

The story

A thread on the 5ch message boards about Rena Ichioka, formerly of Hello! Project, has drawn attention after posters argued that “it’s not talked about much, but she could really sing.” Ichioka never became especially popular within her group, but several commenters praised her natural voice quality and the way she strained to hit high notes, saying it actually created a sense of poignancy. At the same time, she left the group without holding a graduation concert, and the thread was also filled with speculation about the circumstances — making it a thread that mixed a reassessment of her singing ability with complicated feelings about her departure.

What people said

1AnonymousNov 19, 2026 20:51
It kind of seeps in, you know?
5AnonymousNov 19, 2026 20:55
Her voice quality was great.
Since her high range was narrow, the way she sounded like she was straining to squeeze out the high notes actually gave it a sense of poignancy.
8AnonymousNov 19, 2026 20:59
Yonemura should theoretically be able to pull off that kind of poignancy too…
nah, probably not.
10AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:00
She wasn't technically great, but she had a good voice.
I wonder if that would change if she gained weight.
11AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:04
Every member of BEYOOOOONDS was talented, so it was probably an explosion of inferiority complex… but given her age, I wish she could've just put in a normal graduation request and graduated normally.
15AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:05
She was handed the leadership position of a brand-new group that hadn't even been finalized yet, and even as just a trainee she scored a lucky draw at Hina Fes (Hello! Project's annual festival) and had a regular radio slot.
An agency favorite on the level of Inoue and Inaba.
16AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:07
Is there a particular song or vocal part of hers that stands out?
20AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:09
Re: #16
Her signature moment has to be from "Yume Sae" (Even Dreams) —
the line "If this is a world where you can't even believe that, then now—", I'd say.
17AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:07
I wonder if she ended up isolated within the group.
18AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:08
Her popularity was hopeless, but they made her a subway-themed segment ("Chikatetsu") and gave her train-related work too — I'd say she was actually pretty fortunate.
21AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:09
The agency had zero taste, passing over the beautiful Hikaru Inoue to debut Ichioka instead.
22AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:09
She left without ever getting to sing GCG.
23AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:11
I think the agency actually treated Ichioka quite well.
Which might be exactly why her exit — leaving angrily without a graduation concert — happened the way it did.
25AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:12
I especially love the final chorus of "In a Night Sky Where I Can't Even Dream."
26AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:13
Rika-chan, who's always hard to read,
wrote on her blog about Ichioka's graduation that she was like a big sister who let her be spoiled, and that it was always fun being with her.
At least before that incident came to light, she really was looked up to by the other members.
27AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:14
I liked her take on "Hanamizuki" (Dogwood) back when they were singing ballads during the pandemic.
28AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:15
Also, I love the line "Aa nandaka hitori ni naritai kibun" ("Ugh, somehow I just feel like being alone") from "Only Lonely."
29AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:24
I'm also pretty fond of the little fake-out vocal part at the start of "Koshi Tanten."
31AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:27
At the solo fes, her vocals on that song about a senpai's umbrella or whatever really hit me.
32AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:31
Re: #31
I voted that as #1 that year.
33AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:31
She's not technically skilled, but her voice quality is so overwhelmingly good that no amount of skill from anyone else can touch it.
35AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:32
Natural talent and potential only get you so far if you stop honing them.
Such a waste.
38AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:36
Her singing was like an upgraded version of Kawashima's.
39AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:36
She used to get publicly dragged a lot in comparisons with Danbara.
40AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:38
At some live show during the pandemic,
when Ichioka, Honopi, and Akanechin covered a Stardust Revue song as a trio,
that's when I noticed how refreshing Ichioka's voice sounded.
41AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:40
On "Ookami," the ones the trainee otaku hype up the most rarely end up becoming big stars.
45AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:49
I'm pretty into trains myself, so Icchan's train-related bits were fun.
She even appeared at an event for Tobu's Spacia X, so I think the agency gave her favorable treatment.
50AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:58
Re: #45
At the very least, you could tell she was a genuinely real train lover.
46AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:52
Somehow this feels like we're talking about someone who's passed away, and it's unbearably sad.
51AnonymousNov 19, 2026 21:58
In terms of voice quality, she's a special one even looking across the group's whole history.
Omifu's one thing, but even Yuumi gets overshadowed by her.
Her best performance was "The Senpai Who Holds an Umbrella" — on that song,
it's a finished form nobody can surpass.
56AnonymousNov 19, 2026 22:01
Re: #51
Isn't her voice kind of husky/raspy though? I wonder if it'd be moving to hear live.
57AnonymousNov 19, 2026 22:28


Background and Key Points of This Discussion

In Hello! Project, it’s customary to hold a “graduation concert” to express gratitude when a member leaves — but Rena Ichioka left without one. The thread floated various theories about why, but since the agency never officially explained the circumstances in detail, none of it goes beyond fan speculation. Opinions on her singing ability were also split: some said she “wasn’t technically skilled but had a great voice,” while others argued that “because her range was narrow, the way she sounded like she was straining to sing actually created a sense of poignancy” — with views diverging depending on whether technique or expressiveness was valued more. Note that some posts containing excessive speculation about Ichioka herself or those involved have been omitted from this article.

※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project) thread “Not talked about much, but Rena Ichioka could really sing, huh.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *