From our other sites
The story
None of Juice=Juice’s songs made the cut for the Japan Record Award’s Best Work Award this year. Instead, it emerged that Hello! Project as a whole would receive a Special Award — sparking a mixed reaction on 5ch’s Hello! Project board, with some calling it fair since the snubbed song was released last year, and others suspecting the agency pulled strings behind the scenes. The Best Work Award’s female-artist slots went to ILLIT, Equal Love (=LOVE), HANA, and FRUITS ZIPPER, leaving Juice=Juice as the only one left out. The thread also buzzed with speculation over who would actually show up to accept the award.
[Best Work Award]
Ai no FIRE / Leon Niihama
It’s Me / ILLIT
Source: tbs.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
It's last year's song, so that's fair enough.
Did they even do anything this year?
ILLIT
Equal Love (=LOVE)
HANA
FRUITS ZIPPER
Yeah, that's fair.
Has to be either 'Mrs.' (Mrs. GREEN APPLE) or 'Milk' — nobody else is even in the running.
This isn't about 'Moremi' not being flashy enough — some garbage agency basically told them 'do it this way.'
All just to keep the pecking order intact.
Seriously, what a garbage agency.
But 'Sukisugite Horobu!' ('I Love You So Much I Could Die!') also started streaming last fall, you know.
That's because the single itself came out this year.
That's because it's avex.
Same goes for Aina's Special Vocal Award.
There's no actual rule saying a song is disqualified just for being from last year.
[Official criteria]: 'Awarded to a work demonstrating outstanding artistry, originality, and creative vision across its composition, lyrics, and arrangement. It must be elevated by excellent singing, have earned strong public support, and be recognized as strongly reflecting and representing that year.'
Eligibility is limited to works already selected for the 'Best Work Award.'
One group hogging all the glory isn't good.
Yeah, that song's the real culprit here.
She's the current Hello! Project leader.
This basically reads as a rejection notice from the TV side.
Even the non-Juice members must be baffled, so there's no joy there either — and obviously none for Juice=Juice.
They lost to this??
'June Bride' by SHOW-WA & MATSURI
Only 660,000 MV views after 6 months.
Makes no sense.
Why this year?
An award you win just for turning on streaming? Lol.
Yeah, I seriously think that's exactly how it'll go.
Background and Key Points of This Discussion
The Japan Record Award actually has two separate kinds of recognition running in parallel: the ‘Best Work Award,’ which judges individual songs, and the ‘Special Award,’ which honors a group or its overall activity. In this thread, the two got conflated — the fact that no Juice=Juice song made the Best Work Award list, and the fact that Hello! Project as a whole received the Special Award, were discussed as if they were the same decision, fueling complaints about ‘agency favoritism’ and a ‘garbage agency.’ One poster, however, accurately quoted the actual selection criteria for the Best Work Award (which weighs artistic merit in composition, lyrics, and arrangement, plus public support), pointing out that it isn’t simply about how old or new a song is. Some posters also speculated that the Special Award might be tied to Hello! Project’s songs finally becoming available on streaming services this year — but that’s purely 5ch speculation, not an official explanation, and should be taken with caution. As for who will represent the group at the ceremony, names like Nonaka, Fukumura, and Oda came up, but none of this is confirmed — it’s all guesswork and wishful thinking.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project) thread ‘Record Award: Juice=Juice Not Nominated, Special Award Goes to Hello! Project.’
Leave a Reply