Liella!’s New CD Sales Stumble — 5ch: ‘This Is Brutal Right After the Fes’

From our other sites

The story

The sluggish sales of Liella!’s new CD (which comes bundled with serial-code bonuses for the Tokyo, Nagoya, and Fukuoka Day 1 shows) have become a hot topic on 5ch’s Love Live! board. While some report that stock itself hasn’t actually run out, others point out that in first-week sales it’s already trailing Hasunosora Girls’ School’s new song (15,000 copies in its first week) and Ikizu Live’s new release on Amazon’s rankings. The thread floated several competing theories for the slump — reactions to a recent event, stock and shipping issues, and store disruptions from the ongoing flu outbreak — without reaching any consensus.

What people said

1AnonymousNov 20, 2026 06:49
Early-sale day (for the album released Oct 13 and below)
Release day (1,674 copies and below)
For reference, here's what the weekly sales looked like for the album released on October 13
2AnonymousNov 20, 2026 06:59
Looking at Animate, stock seems plentiful, so it doesn't look like a sellout
3AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:03
After a fes where everyone kept chanting "Liella! is the best, Liella! is the best," this is rough
4AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:04
Meanwhile Hasunosora's latest song has sold over 30,000 copies
5AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:04
Re: #4
It only sold 15,000 in its first week — because it ran out of stock
6AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:06
Isn't there a real chance this loses to Ikizu Live's new release?
52AnonymousNov 20, 2026 12:15
Re: #6
On the Amazon rankings it's already losing
7AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:10
Does the Odawara store have a lot of 'hoshi' stans? (hoshi-shin — fans of some other "star"-themed franchise)
8AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:12
Re: #7
That store barely carries anything outside female-oriented goods to begin with — even for a new Love Live release they often stock like 5 copies, tops
9AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:14
The sports-day event was so bad it's probably driving off even longtime fans at this point
This thread's been saying so over and over too
12AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:37
After watching this Love Live Fes I ordered a Liella! CD on Amazon for the first time ever — ship it already
Stock's not supposed to be sold out though
13AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:40
https://x.com/i/trending/2123246825486401739

It's just the flu going around, can't be helped
14AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:42
Producer Takezawa must be holding his head in his hands too — they gave Liella! that much favorable treatment at the fes, and that whole incident even ended up working as a tailwind for them, and still this happens
15AnonymousNov 20, 2026 07:45
"We'd been held back until now" "Now we can show you the real Liella!"

So… what was that about?
16AnonymousNov 20, 2026 08:01
Re: #15
They did pull it off, for real
And the result was just… "oh. okay."
17AnonymousNov 20, 2026 08:12
Giving Nijigasaki a run for its money (and not in a good way)
20AnonymousNov 20, 2026 08:50
They might have genuinely lost fans over the flat-floor seat-upgrade mess

Even among people I know, two who used to catch at least one Liella! show every tour are saying they're skipping this one
27AnonymousNov 20, 2026 09:29
Re: #20
Wasn't Hasunosora also doing flat seating with upgrades next week? Though since it's a pilgrimage site that might be a different story
33AnonymousNov 20, 2026 10:19
For Fukuoka, right before the Zombie Land Saga show over in Saga, there's a schedule clash with Roselia in that same Fukuoka
And on top of that, their venue only holds 2,500 while this one holds 6,000, so people are saying "isn't this backwards?"
51AnonymousNov 20, 2026 12:13
Re: #33
Roselia's venue isn't flat-floor, so from the fans' point of view it actually ranks higher
39AnonymousNov 20, 2026 11:10
・ Being surrounded by so many kouhai (junior groups) like this, I'm overwhelmed
・ If you ever want to see Aqours, come to Numazu — Aqours will always be in Numazu
・ The final chapter is coming, so please look forward to it… well, it says "final" but it's actually still continuing (lol)
・ The anime starts in January and a new era begins, so please support us — let's meet at the big tour and the graduation show
・ Please at least remember the name Ikizu Live when you go, and if you don't mind, please follow the official X and YouTube too
・ We want to keep going, so please lend us your strength (crying)

There's one line in that MC that single-handedly kills the festive mood…
41AnonymousNov 20, 2026 11:25
Re: #39
Well, it's also on them for not making content people actually want to spend money on…
56AnonymousNov 20, 2026 12:30
Day 1, Sayu: "All of us members were looking forward to this day. I'm filled with gratitude for all of you who always support us, for everyone discovering Liella! for the first time, for everyone watching the stream, for our senpai, and for all our kouhai. I'll keep cherishing the things I love as I keep moving forward."

Day 2, Sayu: "Going through both days, I really felt all over again how glad I am to love the Love Live! series. I want to cherish the words that saved me — the ones my character Kanon was told by Coco-chan (I welled up right here) — and keep pushing forward in true Liella! fashion so the things I love and enjoy can keep going."

Re: #39 should apply to TBS and aim to get on staff at Hodo Tokushu (their news documentary show)
50AnonymousNov 20, 2026 12:06
It looked like they were about to pivot to a variety-show direction and that idea basically died — and instead of broadening what they do, it ended up tainting their core activities too
Liella!'s cast really should think for themselves more and speak up
They were just running along the rails they were handed, straight toward a cliff — I don't get how they can still trust management this much
53AnonymousNov 20, 2026 12:19
Re: #50
The main cast was picked through open general auditions, so I feel like there's a real power imbalance with management
Riyu got personally courted (sankō no rei-style), so she might be able to speak her mind, but there's a language barrier on this side
54AnonymousNov 20, 2026 12:21
https://www.billboard-japan.com/d_news/detail/167596/2
Looks like on Billboard, the combined total for the 17th and 18th is under 13,883 copies
55AnonymousNov 20, 2026 12:23
Re: #54
That's absolutely no reference point!
57AnonymousNov 20, 2026 12:36
The fes itself was pretty good, but in the end it's "well, the anime though…" throwing cold water on everything
59AnonymousNov 20, 2026 12:43
Re: #57
With a solo show you end up with a bunch of so-so songs padding out the setlist, so getting your fill at the fes and leaving it there might honestly be the right call
67AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:52
Nijigasaki's merch sells forever, so there's no reason to cut it
69AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:03
Re: #67
It's not selling that much, come on
68AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:58
Apparently a Hasunosora member was really hurt back at their 1st Fukuoka show when management told her "lol it wasn't even full"
If that's the bar, the 'Hoshi no Ko' (Star Kids) must be a nervous wreck getting told that every single time
70AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:15
Re: #68
Liella, being all "management can do no wrong," will probably just say "we'll try harder next time!" and leave it there
73AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:33
It's going to be half-empty anyway, so I'd rather Fukuoka got the roomy, fancy chairs again this time
Spare me Hasunosora's cramped folding pipe chairs
75AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:45
Re: #73
Worse than the cramped pipe chairs is the fact that they created the "Goma-Saba Block" — which is basically an obstructed-view section…
77AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:59
Title | Merch series/projects | Product types | Including character/art variants
Nijigasaki Academy School Idol Club — 16 — 155 — 1,787 types
Hasunosora Girls' School Idol Club — 14 — 84 — 559 types
Superstar!! — 13 — 102 — 883 types

Nijigasaki really did have a ton of merch…
78AnonymousNov 20, 2026 16:30
Re: #77
Where'd this data even come from?
81AnonymousNov 20, 2026 17:02
Re: #77
It's because Liella's merch is crafted carefully enough piece by piece that it actually sells

Different in both quality and profit from Nijigasaki just churning stuff out

Background and key points of this discussion

The “Billboard weekly” figures often cited for a CD’s first-week sales are tallied on a Monday-start week, so the numbers for the 17th and 18th quoted in the thread cover only part of that week. Treating them as a final ranking can be misleading, and the reply to post #54 — “that’s no reference point at all” — appears to be flagging exactly that. It’s also worth noting the Love Live! series runs three units in parallel — Nijigasaki Academy School Idol Club, Hasunosora Girls’ School Idol Club, and Liella! — which already invites comparisons over merch variety and venue capacity. In this thread, opinions split over whether to blame the slump on reactions to the recent “sports day”-style event, stock and shipping conditions, or store disruptions from the flu outbreak, with some posts flatly declaring popularity has dropped and others pointing to temporary causes instead.

※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Love Live!) thread “Liella!’s new CD (with Tokyo/Nagoya/Fukuoka Day 1 first-run serial codes) isn’t selling at all.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *