GACKT questions whether blood ties really matter — 5ch fires back: “Could you say that to your own parents?”

From our other sites

The story

On the 17th, musician GACKT posted a lengthy message on X asking, “Does blood really matter that much?” and argued that being a parent isn’t about whether you’re biologically related. The remark was picked up by 5ch’s Geinou/Sports News+ board and sparked a thread full of mixed reactions. Beyond the debate over the idea itself — that blood ties shouldn’t be treated as paramount — many posters questioned GACKT’s standing to make the point, noting he was raised by his own biological parents, which made the argument “unconvincing” to them. The thread ranged widely, touching on genetics and instinct as well as the history of adoption.

GACKT: “Does blood really matter that much?” — Long post shares his view that “being a parent isn’t about…”

Musician GACKT updated his X account on the 17th, sharing his personal thoughts on “blood ties.”

Posing the question “Does blood really matter that much?”, he opened by writing, “I’ve never once thought blood ties were important.”

Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Read the original article here

What people said

5AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:24
Could you say that to your own parents' faces?
11AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:30
Re: #5
I'm estranged from mine, so I can say it all day long.
6AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:25
Those isekai web novels where someone raises a slave's child with overwhelming love get me every time.
7AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:26
Inheritance stuff is a whole different story, though.
8AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:27
Forget "important" or not — wanting to pass on your own genes (blood ties) is a biological instinct, and that very instinct is why life has thrived. Nobody asked how you personally feel about it.
70AnonymousNov 17, 2026 15:31
Re: #8
If genes are all you've got to pass on, you're no different from an animal.
80AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:09
Re: #8
All that "genes, genes" talk is for animals — for humans, it's about passing down values. If your own biological kid got kidnapped and raised to be a terrorist, do you really think you'd still feel love for them?
9AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:29
His best-known credits: the "Celebrity Rank Check" variety show, Fly Me to the Saitama, and the Furin Kazan drama.
12AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:31
Okinawa is all about ancestor worship.
Forget all that — just turn the sentiment into a song already.
"Blood ~ Does It Really Matter That Much~"
14AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:32
He wrote a ton, but it's just common sense:

There are good parents without blood ties, and bad parents with them.
20AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:36
Re: #14
Exactly.
He just stretched something that could've fit in 100 characters out as thin as possible.
40AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:52
Re: #14
He rambles on forever, but that's really all he's trying to say lol
This goes for anything — teachers, bosses, friends.
If you don't like the tie, just cut it. Even with parents, you can sever that bond.
17AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:34
Would you say the same thing to someone who's actually suffering because of their blood ties?
48AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:59
Re: #17
This.
It'd be convincing if he'd been raised as a foster kid with no blood relation, but he was raised by his own biological parents like anyone else.
23AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:38
Okinawan yuta and noro (local shaman/priestess figures) would surely insist blood ties are absolutely essential.
83AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:11
Re: #23
Apparently that's not even really true anymore these days.
As long as business is good, I guess.
25AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:40
What, are you planning on adopting a kid or something?
Think whatever you want, but it's precisely because of blood ties that parents raise kids unconditionally for free.
Though rich people do raise adopted kids half as a hobby.
26AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:41
It depends on the situation.
And you're clearly the one in "that situation."
Just keep telling yourself that in your head.
31AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:42
You guys just put GACKT on a pedestal and then bash him for it — if you think of it as just some guy in his 50s posting, it's a perfectly ordinary, reasonable take.
32AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:43
If you're able to have kids of your own, you shouldn't be the one saying this — there are people out there who can't, for reasons beyond their control.
33AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:44
There are same-sex married couples who want kids of their own too, you know.
34AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:45
"Never did I think / this shares my very blood — / how loathsome, this mosquito" — Naitō Jōsō (a classical haiku playing on the irony that a blood-sucking mosquito shares no real kinship)
35AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:46
Back in the day, family lineage mattered more than blood, so adoption was totally normal.
43AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:53
Hideyoshi killed people even when they were blood relatives — cruelly and unreasonably so.
46AnonymousNov 17, 2026 14:57
It is important — that's just biological instinct.
53AnonymousNov 17, 2026 15:01
A lot of American celebrities adopt kids. Well, that's partly rooted in Christian values, though.
59AnonymousNov 17, 2026 15:06
Re: #53
Japan used to be full of adoptions too, back in the day.
58AnonymousNov 17, 2026 15:05
Humans are ultimately just vehicles for genes — the "real" thing is the genes, the blood.
72AnonymousNov 17, 2026 15:35
Re: #58
That's just an animal talking.

Background and key points of debate

GACKT’s post presented a view of “parenthood” that doesn’t treat blood ties as absolute, and given the rise of special adoption arrangements and common-law families in Japan, the idea that parenthood doesn’t have to hinge on blood is nothing new. What split the thread wasn’t the substance of the argument but the question of “who’s saying it.” Some see it as “unconvincing” or “empty idealism,” given that GACKT himself was raised by his biological parents, while others took it at face value as “just an ordinary opinion from a man in his 50s.” Discussion also divided between those framing genetics in terms of instinct and inheritance, and those arguing that passing down values is the true essence of parenthood, with some bringing up situations — like brood parasitism or inheritance disputes — where blood ties carry real practical stakes. Also referenced was the 2004 paternity-test controversy involving former Hikaru Genji member Juno Osawa, though this has no direct connection to GACKT’s post and was simply raised as a past example of blood-tie controversies in the entertainment world.</analysis>

<parameter name="board">mnewsplus

*This article is compiled as an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “[Entertainment] GACKT: “Does blood really matter that much?” — Long post shares his view that “being a parent isn’t about…”.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *