Category: Baseball

  • Kazuhiro Kiyohara Reveals He Had Knee Replacement Surgery, Begins Rehab — 5ch: ‘He’ll Definitely Be Back’

    Kazuhiro Kiyohara, formerly of the Seibu Lions and Yomiuri Giants, revealed on X (formerly Twitter) on November 3 that he underwent total knee replacement surgery on his left knee in mid-September. He said it was the same spot where he had major surgery during his playing career, and while reporting that he has begun rehab, he wrote that he’s “still getting around with a cane” but vowed, “I will definitely make a comeback.” On 5ch’s Geisupo Sokuho+ (celebrity/sports news) board, opinions split over whether this “comeback” meant a return to pro baseball or simply regaining everyday mobility, and the thread expanded into personal accounts about how well artificial joints actually work and how long they last.

    Former professional baseball player Kazuhiro Kiyohara revealed on the 3rd that he had undergone surgery on his left knee.

    Kiyohara posted an update on X, writing, “It was back in mid-September, but I underwent total knee replacement surgery on my left knee.” He went on to explain, “It’s the same spot where I had major surgery during my playing career.” He also revealed that he has started rehab, writing, “I’ll still be getting around with a cane for a while yet, but I’m going to keep working hard day by day so I can show you all a healthy version of myself,” before closing with a final declaration: “I will definitely make a comeback.”

    [Photo] “I will definitely make a comeback” — Kiyohara pushing hard through rehab

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    2AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:38
    Wasn't that Kevin Yamazaki?
    11AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:41
    Re: #2
    Rather than just fading out for good, properly coming back once and, if your body still lets you play, getting yourself back to where you can hit — that's the kind of choice you'd make again even with a second shot at life.
    3AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:38
    Did he already finish rehab for the *other* thing?
    18AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:44
    Re: #3
    That one takes a lifetime — he'll have to stay off it until the day he dies.
    22AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:44
    Re: #3
    To be serious for a second, the standard answer is that it 'never really ends until you die,' so that's kind of a dumb question.
    5AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:40
    A 'comeback'? Like, is he actually doing something?
    76AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:58
    Re: #5
    Apparently he hasn't officially retired yet — guess he's aiming for an NPB comeback.
    81AnonymousNov 3, 2026 20:03
    Re: #76
    lol

    Don't go treating Kiyohara like some burnt-out meth head.
    6AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:40
    Why'd he quit YouTube, anyway?
    9AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:40
    At least he hasn't reoffended — so far.
    34AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:49
    Re: #9
    Not getting caught again isn't the same as not reoffending. Once you've got a drug conviction on record, the suspicion follows you for life.
    12AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:41
    He's probably going to have to grind hard on losing weight — his autonomic nervous system's already shot, so he piles on pounds fast, and that old knee injury finally gave out because of it.
    14AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:42
    Come back and do what, exactly?
    17AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:43
    Re: #14
    What he wants to do is spelled out clearly in the article.
    19AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:44
    Wait, what — for a second there I thought he'd relapsed and gotten arrested again lol
    20AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:44
    Even back in his playing days he'd overdo the weight training, get hurt, and end up sidelined, so I always wondered if he was really serious.
    23AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:45
    'There's no such thing as retirement for a rehab guy' ← now that's badass
    24AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:45
    If he'd just stayed off the drugs, he could've landed a Giants coaching job by now.
    29AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:46
    Come on, make him the Giants' batting coach already — let him teach guys how to hit.
    30AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:47
    Did he cut ties with Mackoy?
    49AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:53
    Re: #30
    He hasn't posted a video in three years now, so he's probably severed that for good.
    32AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:47
    I heard joint replacement surgery isn't some miracle fix — wonder how this is actually going to go for him.
    45AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:52
    Re: #32
    Former pro wrestler Keiji Mutoh had both hips and both knees replaced with artificial joints, and these days he mostly gets around in a wheelchair.
    39AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:50
    Kiyohara's probably starting to understand now what Toyo Ebisawa was seeing out there in that legendary 9th inning (the pitcher famous for his nerve-wracking bases-loaded, no-out standoff in the 1979 Japan Series).
    40AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:50
    Motoki's basically turned into Kazuo Umezu at this point (the horror-manga artist famous for his long white hair) — guess all that reckless stuff from your younger days comes back to bite you once you're older.
    41AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:51
    My grandma got a knee replacement too, and she's walking around briskly these days — so what's with calling this a 'comeback'?
    46AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:52
    At least the pain goes away, that's a plus — though I hear the implant only lasts about 20 years or so.
    47AnonymousNov 3, 2026 19:52
    Guess he did one too many moonsault presses

    Background and Key Talking Points

    Kazuhiro Kiyohara has a history that includes a 2016 arrest and conviction for violating Japan’s Stimulants Control Act, and he has gradually eased back into public life since then, including through activity on YouTube. His left knee is the same spot where he underwent major surgery during his playing days, so this latest total knee replacement can be seen as an extension of dealing with that old injury. Opinions in the thread split over how to read the word “comeback” — some pictured a return to NPB (Nippon Professional Baseball), while others read it more soberly as simply regaining everyday mobility. On the subject of artificial knees, commenters who’d actually had the surgery chimed in with notes like “it’s not some miracle fix” and “they only last about 20 years,” tempering expectations. It’s also worth noting that the drug case is a closed matter from the past, and the article itself gives no indication of any confirmed reoffense since then — a distinction worth keeping in mind.

    *This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geisupo Sokuho+) thread “[Baseball] Kazuhiro Kiyohara Reveals He Underwent Left Knee Surgery — Began “Total Knee Replacement” Rehab in September, “I Will Definitely Make a Comeback”.”

  • Hanshin Enters the Race for Lotte’s Kojima — Set to Offer Roughly ¥1 Billion Over 3 Years

    In NPB’s free agent market, it’s reportedly expected that the Hanshin Tigers will offer Lotte pitcher Kazuya Kojima a contract worth roughly ¥1 billion over three years. The lefty, nicknamed “Mr. Opening Day Starter,” is also drawing interest from the Giants and DeNA, and on the 5ch “Nandemo Jikkyo G” (anything-goes live-commentary) board, posters traded a wide range of takes — from shock at the size of the offer to debates over Kojima’s career numbers, how he’d fit his new home ballpark, and how he’d actually be used if signed.

    Hanshin enters FA race — set to offer Lotte’s Kazuya Kojima roughly ¥1 billion over 3 years, bolstering the rotation by landing “Mr. Starter”

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    3AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:20
    Back in the day, only true elite players ever broke ¥100 million…
    Now guys at this level are pulling down ¥300 million+ a year. What times we live in.
    6AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:21
    For players who are good but not quite MLB-caliber, today's NPB is basically a free-agency dream.
    7AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:22
    Is he really worth paying that much for…
    12AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:23
    Better than losing him to the Giants.
    101AnonymousNov 3, 2026 09:16
    Re: #12
    Nah, we don't need him lol
    13AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:24
    There's still plenty of cash left over even after re-signing Sato Teru (Hanshin slugger Teruaki Sato).
    Though honestly what we actually need to reinforce is the batting lineup, lol
    15AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:24
    This is basically a done deal for Hanshin already.
    Show that much sincerity faster than anyone else and it's a lock.
    16AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:24
    This has gotta leave Hiroshima's trio of free agents pretty rattled.
    17AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:24
    Well, the money that used to go to pitcher Yuki Nishi just freed up.
    18AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:24
    It's just to stop Yomiuri and those Hanshin clowns (a derisive rival-fan nickname for the Tigers) from grabbing him.
    19AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:24
    They should drop guys like Nakagawa and Kojima and just go all-in on Yoshida.
    20AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:25
    Seriously, the Giants and Hanshin show up in free agency every single year.
    23AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:26
    Re: #20
    Surprisingly, SoftBank hasn't been in the FA market for three years now.
    24AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:27
    Re: #20
    Hanshin's actually been out of it for a while too.
    80AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:59
    Re: #20
    It's been something like 6 or 7 years for Hanshin, since Nishi.
    25AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:27
    No way other teams can compete with this.
    Hiroshima's probably bowing out.
    27AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:28
    Hanshin's unprotected list (the pool of players available as compensation) is garbage anyway — just sign with Yokohama instead.
    28AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:28
    Doesn't matter how many starters you stack if you can't score runs.
    30AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:29
    Hanshin's the number one team in attendance, yet
    they've been slacking on both FA signings and import pickups for years, so they're probably just swimming in cash.
    31AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:29
    He's just brutally bad against SoftBank and the Fighters —
    take that away and he's actually a pretty good pitcher.
    He just doesn't suit the Pacific League.
    35AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:30
    Kojima

    2019 ERA 4.31, 54.1 innings
    2020 ERA 3.73, 113.1 innings
    2021 ERA 3.76, 146 innings
    2022 ERA 3.14, 143.1 innings
    2023 ERA 3.47, 158.1 innings
    2024 ERA 3.58, 163.1 innings
    2025 ERA 3.72, 145 innings
    Career ERA through last season: 3.61 over 923.2 innings

    This season (2026) ERA 3.53, 117.1 innings
    Looks like he's never once posted a 2-point-something ERA
    39AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:31
    Re: #35
    Super consistent, that's solid.
    44AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:33
    Re: #35
    At Jingu he'd probably be even scarier than Naruse (in a bad way).
    92AnonymousNov 3, 2026 09:09
    Re: #35
    He's a pretty average pitcher, but racking up innings is his strong suit.
    ¥150 million or so sounds about right.
    36AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:30
    Hiroshima's a lost cause anyway — the real question is how much Yokohama offers.
    They've got that Tokyo-area advantage, so it's still up in the air.
    37AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:31
    Isn't DeNA actually the perfect fit here, more than the Giants?
    The Giants already added Ogasawara and Takemaru.
    41AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:32
    He doesn't give off that overpowering-stuff vibe, so he might suit the Central League.
    If Otake can make it work, Kojima can too.
    42AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:33
    My guess is Yokohama comes back with something like 3 years, ¥1.2 billion.
    50AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:34
    Which teams have the deepest pool for the player-compensation pick?
    53AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:36
    Re: #50
    That's obviously SoftBank, hands down.
    But Kojima's not on SoftBank's radar.
    51AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:34
    Kojima
    Morishita
    Tokoda
    Takahashi
    Espi
    58AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:38
    He gives up a ton of home runs, so Koshien (a park that suppresses homers) might actually suit him.
    60AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:40
    Re: #58
    Kojima might hold up fine at Koshien.
    Just steer clear of that gimmicky home-run bandbox Jingu, though.
    70AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:51
    Aren't they jumping into the race for Kosei Takahashi too?
    72AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:52
    Re: #70
    That guy's definitely MLB-bound, no way he stays.
    78AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:57
    Re: #70
    SoftBank's gonna come after him for real, so that'll be a tough ask.
    89AnonymousNov 3, 2026 09:06
    Satozaki (former catcher, now a commentator): "A ball that smacks the wall at Chiba Marine Stadium would clear the fence for a homer at Tokyo Dome."

    Kojima's road ERA
    2019: 5.52
    2020: 3.86
    2021: 2.76
    2022: 3.39
    2023: 3.61
    2024: 4.33
    2025: 4.48
    2026: 3.43
    95AnonymousNov 3, 2026 09:11
    Re: #89
    That's a landmine.
    At this level Hanshin's probably already got better pitchers than this.
    93AnonymousNov 3, 2026 09:09
    NPB's short on quality players across the board right now, pitchers and hitters alike.
    People saying 'don't need him' based on old standards just aren't keeping up.
    100AnonymousNov 3, 2026 09:15
    Re: #93
    Yeah, those college-draft first- and second-round righties who got hyped as 'MLB-ready' aren't doing a thing in the starting rotation.

    Background and key talking points

    Kazuya Kojima joined Lotte as their first-round pick in the 2019 draft and has built his reputation on durability, throwing over 100 innings in seven straight seasons, with a career ERA of 3.61. The thread’s central debate was how to weigh that track record given that his home park, ZOZO Marine Stadium, favors pitchers, and how that would carry over to the very different dimensions of his rumored destinations, Koshien and Jingu Stadium. Indeed, his road ERA has swung anywhere from the high 2s to over 5.00 depending on the season, which is a big reason opinions on him are so split. It was also noted that while the Giants and Hanshin show up in free agency almost every year, SoftBank hasn’t made a free-agent move in several years, which came up repeatedly as a point of comparison. As of this report nothing has been officially announced by any club, so the outcome could still change depending on the final terms and whether other teams counter.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (“Nandemo Jikkyo G”) thread “Hanshin jumps into the race for Lotte’s Kojima, ¥1 billion ready for 3 years lolololololol.”

  • Cubs Hit Seiya Suzuki with a Qualifying Offer — ¥3.65 Billion for One Year — 5ch: ‘An Offer Built to Be Turned Down’

    The Cubs have offered free-agent outfielder Seiya Suzuki a qualifying offer (QO), according to U.S. media reports. The QO applies to players who completed a five-year contract and have never received one before; the amount — equal to the average salary of MLB’s top 125 earners — comes to roughly $23.15 million (about ¥3.65 billion) this year. Suzuki is seen as a strong candidate for a multi-year deal worth over $100 million (about ¥15.8 billion), so he’s widely expected to turn the offer down. The thread covered how the QO system isn’t really meant to retain the player — it’s built on the assumption he’ll reject it, letting his old team collect draft-pick compensation once he signs elsewhere — along with stat comparisons to Imanaga and Tucker, and speculation about where Suzuki might land in free agency.

    Cubs give Seiya Suzuki a qualifying offer — worth ¥3.65 billion for one year, but rejection looks likely; contract near ¥15.8 billion predicted; decision deadline 6 a.m. JST on Nov. 18

    Multiple U.S. media outlets reported on the 2nd (Nov. 3 Japan time) that free-agent outfielder Seiya Suzuki (32), who left the Cubs as a free agent, has received a qualifying offer (QO) from the club. The QO goes to players who spent a full season with the same team and have never received one before; it guarantees a one-year salary equal to the average of MLB’s top 125 salaries. This offseason that works out to $23.15 million (about ¥3.65 billion).

    Suzuki has completed the five-year contract he signed in 2022 and is one of the most closely watched names on this offseason’s free-agent market. Since he’s in position to land a big multi-year deal, he’s unlikely to accept the QO. This season he hit .270 with 26 home runs and 86 RBI; over his career he’s hitting .269 with 113 home runs and 382 RBI. Several U.S. outlets are projecting a contract worth over $100 million (roughly ¥15.8 billion).

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    7AnonymousNov 3, 2026 07:53
    So the Cubs are just being cheap, huh?
    28AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:03
    Re: #7
    If he turns it down and signs elsewhere, the Cubs get a draft pick out of it — that's the whole point. It's an offer designed to be declined.
    9AnonymousNov 3, 2026 07:56
    Didn't expect Suzuki to stay this good for this long.
    Guess that's the Carp pedigree for you — same team that produced Kuroda. (said with a Hiroshima-dialect flourish)
    96AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:46
    Re: #9
    Though Maeken (Kenta Maeda) hasn't amounted to much lately.
    14AnonymousNov 3, 2026 07:58
    Is he turning it down?
    Has it gotten harder for him now that PCA (Pete Crow-Armstrong) runs the outfield?
    45AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:13
    Re: #14
    The front office already lost interest in re-signing him last year.
    Re: #28 is probably the real goal here.
    They'll probably lowball Imanaga with a stingy offer too.
    Feels like management just doesn't think much of Japanese players.
    18AnonymousNov 3, 2026 07:59
    Seiya just never seems to click with any team he's on.
    And he's bad with the media too, which doesn't help him.
    23AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:01
    Heard the Angels gave Ohtani a qualifying offer too —
    is there any upside for the player here? The whole thing's built around getting rejected.
    29AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:04
    Re: #23
    Didn't Imanaga turn one down last year? Or am I misremembering?
    41AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:12
    Re: #23
    I bet a guy secretly thinking "nobody really wants me, I might not get a good offer anyway" would just accept it, right?
    25AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:02
    No way he accepts.
    It'll be the Phillies or the Blue Jays.
    Personally I want him with the Phillies —
    since Schwarber's locked in at DH, they could shift Harper back to first base and let Suzuki actually hold down right field full-time.
    Hoping he finally wins a Gold Glove next year.
    35AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:08
    Wait, this garbage system actually exists?
    So they ask you "wanna extend at the average salary?" — basically "we don't rate you and have zero expectations, but here's a token extension anyway." That's pretty insulting.
    40AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:11
    Re: #35
    Yeah, it's a system that only benefits the team.
    The players' union wants it scrapped.
    With the new labor deal, this might actually be the last year QOs exist.
    37AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:09
    Can't hit .300, can't hit 30 homers, can't drive in 100 —
    mediocre across the board.
    55AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:19
    Re: #37
    Reminder: he's still the best Japanese right-handed hitter ever.
    48AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:17
    Isn't that average/homer line about the same as what Shinjo used to put up? Paying ¥3 billion for that just shows how out of control MLB salary inflation has gotten.
    54AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:19
    Re: #48
    Shinjo's bat was never this good. Suzuki looks reasonable if you benchmark him against Tucker (though that's only true using Tucker as the yardstick).
    50AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:18
    Do MLB teams actually turn a profit even with payroll spending like this?
    62AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:24
    Re: #50
    TV rights money gets pooled and split league-wide. Apparently 25 of the 30 teams are in the black.
    57AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:20
    So who's actually better, him or Tucker?
    58AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:22
    Re: #57
    Astros-era Tucker was clearly a tier above. But from his injury-plagued Cubs years onward, he's basically on the same level as Suzuki now — his defense has slipped too.
    63AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:26
    He's hitting .300 against lefties, so I'd love him on the Dodgers, but the outfield's already full.
    Would've loved to see the Ohtani-Suzuki buddy duo, but it's not happening.
    70AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:30
    Re: #63
    They're not even close, actually.
    Suzuki's complained that whenever he asks Shohei about baseball stuff, Ohtani won't tell him anything.
    64AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:27
    If a lockout's coming anyway, why not just accept this and push the decision back a year?
    69AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:30
    Re: #64
    I doubt there's a lockout coming.
    Even the Dodgers seemed to lose on purpose (to cool down the labor optics).
    Popularity's already slipping as it is — why would they risk tanking it further now?
    71AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:31
    Re: #64
    This year's free-agent class is thin on outfielders, so Suzuki's value is actually higher by hitting the market now.
    Even with a lockout, there'd still be plenty of time to negotiate — last time was also a lockout year, but back then he came over via the posting system, which left a really tight window.
    That created leverage concerns then, but this time he's a true free agent, so it doesn't apply.
    65AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:27
    Re: #62
    Just a surreal world I'll never have any connection to.
    75AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:34
    Re: #65
    Apparently MLB's total league revenue is around ¥1.9 trillion lol.
    At current dollar-yen rates it might actually be past ¥2 trillion now.
    77AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:35
    Here we go with the harassment again.
    Wish he'd just accept it like Imanaga did and stick it to them,
    but I guess he probably wants out anyway.
    85AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:40
    Re: #77
    Not even sure Imanaga's decision to stay was the right call anymore. With this year's numbers, a big contract might be out of reach.
    88AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:41
    33's about normal for a position player at this stage in MLB.
    Once you're past 30, MLB teams start treating you worse.
    90AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:44
    Re: #88
    Wait, what?
    This offer is built entirely on the assumption he'll reject it and leave — so the Cubs can collect a draft pick out of it.
    95AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:46
    He should just come to the Giants —
    he's basically a Matsui type anyway.
    97AnonymousNov 3, 2026 08:46
    Re: #95
    At the Giants he'd be pulling a ¥4 billion salary.

    Background and key points of this discussion

    A qualifying offer (QO) is a one-year contract a team offers a free agent whose future is uncertain, with the salary set at the average of MLB’s top 125 earners. If the player turns it down and signs elsewhere, his former team receives compensation in the form of draft picks — a system widely seen as skewed in favor of teams, which is why the players’ union has pushed to have it reformed. The “this is just harassment” take that came up in the thread misreads the system’s real purpose: in practice, it’s a routine procedural step aimed at star players who are expected — even assumed — to turn it down in favor of a bigger multi-year deal. Suzuki’s stats (.270, 26 HR, 86 RBI) drew mixed reactions when compared to Tsuyoshi Shinjo and Kyle Tucker, but there were plenty of positive takes too, citing his career numbers and his strength against left-handed pitching this season; posters also noted that a thin outfield class in this year’s free-agent market works in Suzuki’s favor.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisports Sokuho+) thread “[MLB] Cubs give Seiya Suzuki a qualifying offer — ¥3.65 billion for one year, but rejection looks likely.”

  • Oda Shoki to Meet with 10+ MLB Teams Despite Giants’ Forced First-Round Pick — 5ch: ‘Guess This Guy’s Dodgers-Bound Too’

    It’s been learned that Yokohama High School pitcher Oda Shoki will begin meeting with more than 10 MLB teams starting November 4. Yokohama manager Murata Hiroaki commented, “He’ll make his decision about America, and the meetings will proceed from there,” effectively confirming Oda’s own ambition to go pro in the majors. Meanwhile, the Giants had already taken the unusual step of drafting Oda with their first-round pick despite his known MLB leanings — a so-called “forced pick.” On the thread, some argued the Giants’ pick could ultimately go to waste, while others insisted the team should at least hear Oda out first. The discussion expanded into MLB’s age-based salary cap rules and past examples of Japanese high schoolers who tried to make it straight to the majors.

    Sports Hochi

    Yokohama’s Oda Shoki to meet with 10+ MLB teams, starting on the 4th… Yokohama manager Murata Hiroaki reveals it — Giants made a forced first-round pick

    November 2, 2026, 2:41 PM

    Source: hochi.news / Original article here

    3AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:02
    I'll crack up if Matsui's the one who gets dumped (likely a nod to Hideki Matsui's own forced first-round draft history)
    76AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:53
    Re: #3
    That's honestly plausible, no?
    I'd call it 50/50.
    If it were Abe, I'd put it at more like 5% though.
    6AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:04
    Oda: "Huh? America's offering me a billion yen though???"
    12AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:07
    Re: #6
    Then it's a 2-billion-yen under-the-table deal!
    15AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:08
    Pathetic, Giants.
    17AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:09
    Re: #15
    Not once has he gotten a proper response,

    and yet he won't go away,

    just keeps throwing his weight around,

    pathetic hysterics from a total nobody.
    23AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:14
    Is he really that good?
    27AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:17
    Re: #23
    Nah, not THAT amazing — he's given up a right-field-stand home run at Koshien to a fellow high schooler even with the low-restitution bats in play.
    It'll come down to how much he develops once he's over there. Even in Japan he'd need seasoning; he's not really an "instant-impact" type of pitcher.
    26AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:17
    Guess this guy's got that Dodgers smell on him too, in the end.
    35AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:21
    Re: #26
    For the Dodgers, retaining Skubal is miles ahead of this kid as priority number one.
    Second priority is signing Delacruz.
    Suzuki Seiya's maybe priority number three lol
    34AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:20
    If this works out and more guys start doing the same thing, Japanese pro baseball is finished.
    40AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:23
    Re: #34
    Look at Puerto Rico's league —
    once their players started getting scooped up by the American draft,
    the whole thing collapsed.
    41AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:23
    Well, that settles it.
    There's no way the Giants can offer 700-800 million yen.
    Still, this basically drags the Nagashima-Matsui lineage through the mud,
    so it's not like everyone's cheering a Japanese player heading to the majors either.
    What's the Giants even trying to accomplish, cornering a young guy like this?
    47AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:27
    Re: #41
    They paid Abe 1 billion yen and Nomaguchi 700 million back in the day, though.
    48AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:28
    Re: #41
    Even the cash-strapped BayStars managed to pay Nasuno 600 million back then, so the Giants can easily afford it lol
    It's the bonus cap that's the real problem.
    44AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:25
    Fukudome once said, "The minors are too brutal and the conditions too poor to really play baseball." Young players sleeping in the aisle of the team bus during road trips, that kind of thing — some talent does emerge out of that, but far more talent gets crushed along the way.
    52AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:29
    Re: #44
    And you think the Giants would actually develop him properly?
    53AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:31
    It's not about whether the Giants can develop him —
    if you can't dominate in Japan, there's no way you're clawing your way up through the minors.
    66AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:45
    Re: #53
    You never know until you actually try it.
    Re: #61
    That's probably why they're stacking the signing bonus extra high, no?
    55AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:31
    Doesn't MLB have some kind of cap on signing bonuses?
    57AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:33
    Re: #55
    Overseas signings got capped across the board because the Braves were gaming the system.
    56AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:32
    The Giants front office probably still thinks the "Giants" brand itself still has pull.
    64AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:41
    Re: #56
    It's not the Giants, it's NPB as a whole that's losing its pull.
    Might be futile, but SoftBank and the Giants are the only two even trying to fight that trend.
    58AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:33
    I wonder if he'll meet with the (San Francisco) Giants too.
    Hope he doesn't accidentally sign with them by mistake lol
    78AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:53
    Re: #58
    Even after the meetings, he can't sign with anyone until international free agency opens on January 15 next year.
    But starting in December there's a lockout, so they can't even call him.
    61AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:36
    Won't the under-25 rule kick in for Oda, capping his salary at around $550,000? Ohtani was under the same "slave rule" until 25 too — his salary was only around 70 million yen in those years.
    62AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:38
    No one's gone straight from high school to the majors and actually made it big.
    Even the two-way guy who tried it vanished without a trace afterward.
    63AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:41
    Re: #62
    Morii's hitting .220 with 3 homers and an ERA of 15, after all.
    75AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:51
    MLB's full of guys throwing 160+ km/h (99+ mph) — can he really hang with that?
    80AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:54
    Re: #75
    It's a world where even the Padres' Miller can get bounced from the rotation, after all.
    81AnonymousNov 2, 2026 22:56
    Even if he's dead set on America, he'd be better off going the college route first, like Rintaro did.
    89AnonymousNov 2, 2026 23:02
    Re: #81
    That route costs money too, though,
    and there's no time left for it now.
    Rintaro had already started prepping for college in the US by this point in the process.
    90AnonymousNov 2, 2026 23:02
    Well, the order doesn't matter, but he should at least hear the Giants out once before making a final call.
    That's just how the system works — even if you want the majors, you still have to file the pro-intent form.
    Ohtani was also fully set on the majors, but after actually listening he ended up compromising — maybe the Giants will offer Oda good enough terms too.

    Make it a condition that he gets posted after 3 years no matter his stats.
    He can't even dominate college hitters, so that'll cut down on his suffering in the minors.
    They'll cave because they don't want "the first-round pick we made for Matsui's sake got away" going down in history as an embarrassment lol
    99AnonymousNov 2, 2026 23:06
    Re: #90
    If it were really about Matsui, they'd have drafted a ready-made hitter instead.
    I don't think Mizuno's lying when he says they simply drafted Oda because he's an amazing talent.
    98AnonymousNov 2, 2026 23:05
    Egawa: "I have a contingency plan." (a nod to Shigeru Egawa's infamous 1978 draft standoff)
    100AnonymousNov 2, 2026 23:06
    Re: #98
    "I have a contingency plan" sounds more like something Shinjo would say lol
    103AnonymousNov 2, 2026 23:09
    Since the pro-intent form covers both NPB and MLB, if a team force-drafts a guy and he turns them down, doesn't that make him look like the villain?
    If there were an official way to declare "I want the majors but not NPB,"
    no team would dare force-draft someone who's clearly majors-bound.
    108AnonymousNov 2, 2026 23:12
    Re: #103
    Two years ago, Morii, also from Kanagawa, did exactly that —
    after filing his pro-intent form, he sent formal written notice to all 12 teams individually
    saying he wouldn't sign even as a first-round pick, then went to the US.
    Go that far and no team will touch you.

    Background and key points of this debate

    A “forced first-round pick” is the practice of a team drafting a player to lock up negotiating rights even when he’s openly leaning toward MLB — the player still retains the right to refuse to sign despite being drafted. The “international free agency opening (January 15)” mentioned in the thread is the date when amateur players can officially sign with an MLB team; before that, only meetings are allowed and no contract can be signed, and starting in December a lockout restricts even contact. Another point worth noting is the salary cap rule that applies to players under 25 (the so-called “slave rule” that Shohei Ohtani also went through) — right after joining the majors, both the signing bonus and salary can end up lower than what a top Japanese player would earn at home. On the thread, opinions split between criticism that “the Giants’ pick will end up wasted” and the view that “they should at least hear him out once,” with commenters also citing the case of a past high schooler who struggled after jumping straight to MLB (Morii) as grounds to doubt the chances of success.

    ※This article is an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (Geinou Supo Sokuhou+) thread “Yokohama’s Oda Shoki to meet with 10+ MLB teams starting on the 4th… Yokohama manager Murata: “He’ll make his decision about America, and the meetings will proceed from there” — Giants made a forced first-round pick.”

  • Motoki Daisuke’s Drastic Weight Loss Sparks Concern — 5ch Asks “Can He Handle 143 Games on the Road?”

    Former Yomiuri Giants coach Motoki Daisuke (54) attended the “Shigeo Nagashima Baseball School” held on October 31 in Sakura City, Chiba Prefecture, alongside Giants alumni Nakahata Kiyoshi (72), Makihara Hiromi (63), and Sadaoka Shoji (69). His Instagram post the following day showed him noticeably thinner than before — so much so that his uniform looked baggy on him — and fans quickly voiced concern. On 5ch, with other alumni his age or older looking robust by comparison, opinions split over whether this was simple weight loss or a sign of illness.

    2026/11/2

    Former Yomiuri Giants head coach Motoki Daisuke attended the “Shigeo Nagashima Baseball School,” held on October 31 in Sakura City, Chiba Prefecture. Alongside other Giants alumni, he helped coach a local youth baseball team. On November 1, Motoki posted about the event on Instagram, writing:

    《How are you feeling? I’m a bit worried. Please show us your lively self on the field again.》

    Source: jprime.jp / Original article here

    2AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:14
    Because watching an Osaka night-view video channel on YouTube beats watching Peace-kun at Omiya Park any day.
    4AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:17
    The second photo is Makihara, but
    I can't tell who's in the first and third.
    8AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:19
    Re: #4
    Isn't that Nakahata and Sadaoka?
    6AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:18
    Losing weight is obviously a good thing, right?
    Just don't do it with Mounjaro! (a diabetes drug also used off-label for weight loss)
    11AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:21
    Nakahata's 72 and he's still got no gut and hasn't lost any muscle — that's impressive.
    13AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:22
    Don't tell me the reason for the drastic weight GAIN is…
    79AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:57
    Re: #13
    Ramen, maybe?
    14AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:23
    After getting bullied by the late Otani back in the day…


    now one punch would finish this guy off easy.
    15AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:23
    He looks more frail than the kids from the youth baseball team who showed up.
    16AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:24
    Nakahata's 72, Makihara's 63, Sadaoka's 69 (turning 70 at the end of this month)
    and compared to those three looking full of energy, there's Motoki at 54…
    112AnonymousNov 2, 2026 15:12
    Re: #16
    Losing weight like that at 54 is worrying.
    His posture looks bad along with the weight loss, like he's actually losing muscle mass itself.
    Could be something like diabetes or a hormonal disorder.
    17AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:26
    That gets balanced out by his wife being, well, 'that' — so it's a wash.
    18AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:26
    They probably just don't make uniforms that fit a so-called 'average build' —
    even the current players are all like 180cm/90kg.
    19AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:26
    One perk of retiring a Giant is you get to wear the Giants uniform at events like this.
    20AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:27
    No no —
    he's probably not diabetic yet, just pre-diabetic.
    He should watch his diet, but living a normal life shouldn't be a problem.
    21AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:27
    He's way too thin.
    Even if it's not illness, losing this much weight means a middle-aged guy loses his power.
    Coaching jobs basically have no days off.
    Can he really handle traveling with the team for 143-plus games?
    25AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:28
    When a big guy suddenly turns thin, it's genuinely worrying.
    26AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:29
    Losing weight from diabetes — isn't that already a late-stage symptom?
    32AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:33
    "Pro baseball is a world where everyone gathered together is dumber than the dumbest person you've ever met in your life."

    67AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:53
    Re: #32
    Sounds like he was trying to pull the line that tattoo artist made about "idiots love a ¥5,000 bill" — and it completely flopped. (reference to an old internet meme)
    35AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:33
    When he went on that mask segment on Suiyoubi no Downtown (a Japanese variety show), it became a topic nobody wanted to bring up.
    37AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:34
    Re: #35
    The Suiyoubi no Downtown shill brigade shows up everywhere lol
    even elementary schoolers don't watch that show lol
    36AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:34
    If his diabetes has actually progressed this far,
    things like limb amputation or blindness could follow.
    I wonder if he's okay.
    Well, he's probably getting good medical care,
    so I'd guess he's fine.
    78AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:57
    Re: #36
    Amputation only happens to people who really neglect it or never exercise.
    Catch it before tissue death sets in and you're fine.
    Same with blindness — deal with it as soon as something feels off and it shouldn't be an issue.
    45AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:41
    Once you get older, being skin-and-bones is actually the thing people worry about.
    53AnonymousNov 2, 2026 14:46
    Re: #45
    Exactly this.
    When a middle-aged man or woman suddenly loses weight past 50, illness is the first thing you suspect.
    95AnonymousNov 2, 2026 15:05
    It's less that he just lost weight and more that he's lost more muscle than an average person.
    https://instagram.fhnd7-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t51.82787-15/883559054_18131628719482776_1874227269037093329_n.jpg?stp=dst-jpegr_e35_tt6&_nc_map=urlgen_bucketless&ig_cache_key=NDAxOTk2NDQ1MTY2NDM5MTIzNQ%3D%3D.3-ccb7-5&ccb=7-5&_nc_sid=58cdad&efg=eyJ2ZW5jb2RlX3RhZyI6IkNBUk9VU0VMX0lURU0ueHBpZHMuMzA3Mi5oZHIucmVndWxhcl9waG90by5DMyJ9&_nc_zt=23&_nc_ss=7b2a8
    97AnonymousNov 2, 2026 15:06
    98AnonymousNov 2, 2026 15:06
    He's probably going to bulk back up from here on — makes sense.
    …so why didn't he do that during his playing days lol
    101AnonymousNov 2, 2026 15:08
    Re: #98
    If he'd trained properly, he would've surpassed Matsui.
    114AnonymousNov 2, 2026 15:13
    Re: #101
    If we're going there,
    he wouldn't have been overtaken by Matsui in the first place,
    right?
    105AnonymousNov 2, 2026 15:11
    Japan's sports world kings of drastic weight loss:

    Baseball → Motoki
    Soccer → Narahashi
    Sumo → Takanohana
    109AnonymousNov 2, 2026 15:12
    Re: #105
    Takanohana rebounded (gained every bit of it back) beautifully though lol
    119AnonymousNov 2, 2026 15:16
    Re: #105
    Narahashi naturally had a small appetite, but bulked up for his sport — once he retired and went back to eating normally, he slimmed down in no time.
    Same deal as Minatogawa oyakata (a sumo stablemaster).

    Background and Key Points of This Story

    Motoki Daisuke was known during his playing days as a solidly built Yomiuri Giants infielder; since retiring, he’s worked as a TV commentator and head coach. 54 isn’t especially young on its own, but the contrast stood out because Nakahata Kiyoshi (72) and Sadaoka Shoji (69), who appeared alongside him at the event, have kept notably trim physiques despite their age. Thread commenters floated possibilities like diabetes or cancer-related cachexia, but these are purely speculation based on his appearance — neither Motoki himself nor the team has made any official statement about his health or condition. Some also pointed out the weight loss could simply be a healthy one, so it’s worth noting that losing weight doesn’t automatically mean serious illness.

    ※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports+) thread “[Baseball] Motoki Daisuke, rumored to be seriously ill after drastic weight loss, draws concern over being “too skinny” and his “baggy uniform”… he personally replies to comments [Ailuropoda melanoleuca★]“

  • Nippon Ham Set to Lock Up Reyes with 4-Year, ¥6.3 Billion Extension — Fans Split Over Salary Topping ¥1.5 Billion a Year

    Nippon Ham has reached agreement on a four-year, $40 million (roughly ¥6.3 billion) contract extension with infielder Franmil Reyes, a U.S. media source reported on November 1. Reyes was the team’s offensive anchor this season, batting .313 with 32 home runs to win the batting title. His salary now tops ¥1.5 billion a year, putting the deal among the largest in NPB history. On the 5ch “Geisoku Sokuho+” (entertainment/sports news) board, posters traded worries about his defense and baserunning and the risk of decline on a multi-year deal against arguments that the club’s deep pockets and Reyes’ production make the price fair, with the conversation spilling over into the posting system and the weak yen’s effect on contract costs.

    Nippon Ham to Extend Reyes for 4 Years, ¥6.3 Billion — Staying Put on a “Historic” Mega Deal… Foreign Reporter Says

    Nippon Ham has reached an agreement on a contract extension worth up to $40 million (roughly ¥6.3 billion) over four years with infielder Franmil Reyes, according to sources cited by reporter Mike Rodriguez — a former Spanish-language broadcaster for the Cubs’ local network, Marquee Sports Network, now working as an MLB insider — in a report filed November 1 (November 2 Japan time).

    In his third season with the club, Reyes hit 32 home runs and won the batting title with a .313 average.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    4AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:23
    Is he really worth that much…?
    38AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:30
    Re: #4
    Can't run, can't field
    Legs are a walking time bomb

    Fine on a one-year deal, but on a multi-year contract he's gonna slack off hard
    5AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:23
    If NPB had broadcast-rights money like MLB, we'd be seeing a lot more contracts like this.
    6AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:24
    If Nippon Ham has that kind of money, maybe they should just stop allowing posting, like SoftBank does.
    34AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:29
    Re: #6
    Other way around — they absolutely need posting money to fund stuff like this.
    They've got to keep posting players aggressively to bring in revenue, and their team culture doesn't lean on veterans much anyway.
    It's good that different teams have different styles.
    8AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:24
    Re: #1
    Given US inflation and the weak yen, it's actually a reasonable price…
    9AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:24
    Probably got bid up this high from competing with other NPB teams for him.
    10AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:24
    Leave it to Nippon Ham to really take care of its homegrown players.
    12AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:24
    31 years old, huh.
    Even SoftBank wouldn't pay this much.
    13AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:25
    Re: #1
    About a fifth of what Chris Tucker makes, lol
    15AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:25
    I'll say it again and again — you really do love me…
    Reyes~ (riffing on a well-known J-pop ballad lyric, swapping in Reyes' name)
    35AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:29
    Re: #15
    Without any hesitatiooon~ (continuing the song-lyric gag)
    17AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:25
    This is going to be a big loss, classic case of a guy declining right after signing a mega-deal.
    Even if he keeps up 30 HR/100 RBI for all four years, it's still overpriced.
    19AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:26
    Thought the Giants were gonna land him?
    70AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:39
    Re: #19
    Articles saying he'd likely stay with Nippon Ham were out early on.
    Only this board (Geisoku) was saying the Giants, Tigers, or SoftBank would sign him.
    20AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:26
    Are their sausages selling that well?
    A four-year deal? He'll probably only hold up for a year or two of it.
    22AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:26
    Thought the same thing when it was Raidel Martinez — aren't they overpaying their foreign players?
    Pay the Japanese guys more too.
    That's exactly why they all keep leaving for MLB.
    23AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:27
    Is he really worth paying that much for?
    He's basically an Obando. (a boom-or-bust former NPB import slugger)
    25AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:27
    Because of the weak yen, he's only pulling $10 million a year but it's still insanely expensive in yen terms.
    Weak-yen hell.
    26AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:27
    I'd get it if he were hitting 50 homers like peak Cabrera or Rhodes.
    27AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:27
    No way I'm buying Shauessen now.
    They're the company that pulled that beef-fraud scandal. (Shauessen is a popular Nippon Ham sausage brand)
    33AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:29
    Truly elite players might start making over ¥1 billion a year as the new normal.
    If the Tigers had given Satoteru a ¥1 billion salary,
    he might've dropped his posting request… (Satoteru: nickname for Hanshin's Teruaki Sato)
    115AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:47
    Re: #33
    No chance.
    Maybe ¥1 billion would've worked two years ago,
    but now he can easily get over ¥2 billion, and his heart's set on trying MLB anyway.
    55AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:34
    They've got that much money?
    If so, wouldn't it make more sense to pay their first-round draft picks more instead of foreign players?
    59AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:36
    Re: #55
    There's a cap on draft signing bonuses, so they can't pay more there.
    Probably means more players holding out at contract renewal time though.
    58AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:36
    His build looks like his legs could give out at any moment.
    96AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:43
    Re: #58
    He actually did land on the injured list a few times this season.
    61AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:36
    They'd never pay a Japanese player this much, no wonder everyone wants to go to MLB.
    Also, how can they even afford this?
    Weren't they supposed to be one of the poorer teams?
    They're basically a big-money club like SoftBank now.
    66AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:38
    Re: #61
    And this is the same company that committed beef mislabeling
    and defrauded the government, no less.
    68AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:38
    Re: #61
    It's the posting-fee money from Ito.
    95AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:43
    Re: #61
    Their business is worth over ¥30 billion.
    They can easily afford it.
    73AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:39
    Foreign players always coast once they land a multi-year deal.
    77AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:40
    Re: #73
    Even Ohtani broke down in his third year.
    85AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:41
    He's not worth that much.
    89AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:42
    Re: #85
    He is. For us, he's absolutely worth it.
    He's got by far the best numbers and the most popularity of any foreign position player in Nippon Ham history.
    88AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:41
    I haven't seen Nippon Ham products around much lately, are they doing okay?
    99AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:43
    Re: #88
    Nippon Ham, the parent company behind the team, is the #1 meat distributor in Japan and ranks near the top globally too.

    It's honestly hard to find a corner of Japan's meat and meat-processing industry that Nippon Ham isn't involved in.
    100AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:44
    In old-timer terms, he's probably about an O'Malley-level player, right?
    If they're really paying this much, the Japanese players are gonna revolt.
    Well, it'd be fun to watch that happen, lol
    126AnonymousNov 2, 2026 09:51
    Re: #100
    Comparing to the old days doesn't mean much — prices and currency values are totally different now.
    The weak yen and MLB's rising minimum salary make it harder to land good imports these days,
    and with NPB pitching having improved overall, there are fewer foreign hitters who can put up numbers like they used to.

    Background and Key Points of This Debate

    Unlike MLB, NPB doesn’t have massive broadcast-rights revenue, so team budgets depend heavily on the parent company’s business earnings. For Nippon Ham, the parent meat business is one of the largest in the country, and as posters noted in the thread, its business scale — reportedly over ¥30 billion — underpins contracts of this size. Transfer fees earned from posting players to MLB are also folded into team operating funds, and some point out that the club’s aggressive posting policy and its willingness to hand out big contracts are two sides of the same coin. The “beef mislabeling” scandal that came up in the thread was an actual incident involving the Nippon Ham Group in the early 2000s — not baseless mudslinging but a reference to real past events — though it’s easy for readers to conflate that history with how the team is run today. It’s also worth keeping in mind that when a salary is contracted in dollars, a weaker yen inflates the yen-denominated cost, which helps explain some of the reaction in the thread.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuho+) thread “[Baseball] Nippon Ham to Extend Reyes for 4 Years, ¥6.3 Billion — Staying on a “Historic” Mega Deal… Possibly the Biggest in NPB History.”

  • Ichiro: ‘I Was Floored’ — Sends Cheers to Old Friend Hideki Matsui on Becoming New Manager

    It made news when Ichiro commented “I was floored” about his close friend Hideki Matsui’s appointment as the Giants’ new manager, sending his encouragement with “There’s nothing I’m prouder of — I truly hope he gives it his all.” On 5ch, comments stood out contrasting how Ichiro and Matsui — once rumored to be on cool terms — had quietly grown close over time, with the fact that between these two former MLB players, Matsui got an immediate offer to manage while Ichiro has never received one. Some posts also touched on his connection to Shigeo Nagashima, making the backstory behind the managerial appointment a topic of discussion too.

    [Video]

    Ichiro speaks on Hideki Matsui’s appointment as manager

    Ichiro: “I Was Floored” — Cheers On Close Friend Hideki Matsui’s New Manager Appointment, “There’s Nothing I’m Prouder Of, I Truly Hope He Gives It His All”

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    6AnonymousOct 31, 2026 23:56
    The only one allowed to be 'floored' is Tadano (wordplay on former pitcher Mitsuo Tadano's name)
    88AnonymousNov 1, 2026 01:12
    Re: #6
    Wasn't it the Rikkyo University baseball team manager who got floored?
    7AnonymousOct 31, 2026 23:56
    I thought Ichiro straight-up hated Matsui's guts
    14AnonymousOct 31, 2026 23:58
    Re: #7
    Apparently once they actually talked, they suddenly got close
    8AnonymousOct 31, 2026 23:56
    Yeah, that's right, I kind of get the feeling he's going to turn into a good manager…
    18AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:01
    Ichiro should become the Buffaloes' manager too
    Kintetsu spirit 🔥 (Kintetsu Buffaloes, his old team before it merged into Orix)
    19AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:01
    A few days later, "I_hiro":
    "I was floored. Can't believe the offer to manage the Ma_iners landed on my desk. Any reason to turn it down? None — I'd be the first Japanese MLB manager, even before Ohtani." (names censored as a joke: Ichiro / Mariners)
    64AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:39
    Re: #19
    NPB would be one thing, but no legend wants to manage in MLB with all that brutal travel — he knows it firsthand. Lose and the media and fans tear you apart, and you've got to keep the players happy too.
    68AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:43
    Re: #19
    Never heard of a Hall of Famer becoming a manager in the majors
    20AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:01
    There's really no NPB team for Ichiro to manage
    He's not about to manage Orix, the team that ditched Kobe to merge with Kintetsu of all teams
    If someone like Akira Ogi were still around it might be different, but he's gone now
    86AnonymousNov 1, 2026 01:11
    Re: #20
    If Kobe ever got its own team in an independent Kansai league, there might be a shot
    21AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:02
    Well then, let 'Itaro' do some temporary coaching at least! (typo for Ichiro)
    24AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:04
    What did Ichiro even go to the majors for

    Was he just satisfied slapping infield singles in meaningless late-season games?
    37AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:13
    Re: #24
    Did you see his Hall of Fame induction ceremony?
    That says it all, doesn't it
    87AnonymousNov 1, 2026 01:12
    Re: #24
    He went there to become a legend with the third-highest vote share in Hall of Fame history
    34AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:12
    It's not exactly shocking
    Of course the Giants would offer Matsui the manager job
    58AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:28
    Re: #34 He'd hinted before about some kind of promise to Nagashima…
    Still, going straight to manager instead of coach was the surprising part
    In the end, sorry to former manager Abe's daughter and Chappy, but thanks, dad lol
    38AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:14
    Re: #37
    That really was a hollow ceremony lol
    42AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:16
    There are still so many twisted people here mocking this
    The two of them are getting along great, yet totally unrelated people mocking it is just laughable
    47AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:17
    Re: #42
    You think 9 innings is normal for a women's team?
    No way that's realistic
    43AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:16
    Anyway, the sheer awfulness of the heckling at Kintetsu games can't just be laughed off as 'well, that's the old Pacific League for you'
    Ichiro was a complete victim of it too
    That was like the single ugliest thing in existence, concentrated and boiled down
    No need to preserve the legacy of a garbage team like Kintetsu
    54AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:21
    Re: #43
    This is the team that offered a pay cut to Nomo right after he won the most-wins title
    That's a permanent stain on NPB history
    61AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:33
    These two somehow got close without anyone noticing
    63AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:35
    Re: #61
    Some people say they were close way back, but they really weren't on good terms
    65AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:40
    It's rough every time — the girls' all-star team gets mercilessly crushed
    I want them to play Chiben Kobe vs. Chiben Wakayama every year and get wrecked (two baseball powerhouse schools)
    72AnonymousNov 1, 2026 00:47
    Re: #65
    Still, I'd like to see it keep going until the boys actually lose to a women's team once
    82AnonymousNov 1, 2026 01:05
    Matsui: "Don't worry, Ichiro, I'll keep a spot open for you as batting coach"
    83AnonymousNov 1, 2026 01:07
    Re: #82
    Takayuki Shimizu: "…" (the Giants' actual batting coach, now left speechless)

    Background and Talking Points

    During his playing days, Hideki Matsui was seen as the heir to Shigeo Nagashima, the legendary “Mr. Giants,” and some posts in the thread referenced a promise made to Nagashima. This managerial appointment is viewed as a handover from the previous manager, Shinnosuke Abe. Where opinions in the thread diverged was over exactly when the once-rumored-distant relationship between Ichiro and Matsui actually grew close, and over the contrast that while Matsui — also a former MLB player — got an immediate offer to manage, Ichiro has never received a managerial offer from either NPB or MLB. The thread also contained a number of posts mocking the practice games Ichiro continues to hold against girls’ high school baseball teams, but those have been left out of this article since they lean heavily into personal mockery. It’s worth noting that little has been confirmed in actual reporting about whether Ichiro has managerial experience or ambitions, and much of the thread doesn’t go beyond speculation.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News Express+) thread “[Baseball] Ichiro: “I Was Floored” — Cheers On Close Friend Hideki Matsui’s New Manager Appointment, “There’s Nothing I’m Prouder Of, I Truly Hope He Gives It His All”“.

  • Kojima Kazuya’s FA Move Looks All But Certain — Minor-League Demotion After Just 2 Opening Starts Sparks the Friction

    Reports say a free-agent move is all but certain for Chiba Lotte Marines left-hander Kazuya Kojima. This season he was sent down to the minors after just two starts, unable to even get through five innings in either outing — and that episode is being cited as a source of friction between him and manager Saburo. In the thread, opinions split over how to judge Kojima’s pitching and career numbers, while a side debate broke out over manager Saburo’s own playing-career record and his managerial skills.

    Sat, Oct 31, 18:13

    Nikkan Gendai DIGITAL

    Lotte’s Kazuya Kojima likely to leave as a free agent… the friction with manager Saburo smoldering since being “sent to the minors after just 2 season-opening starts”

    Source: topics.smt.docomo.ne.jp / Original article here

    4AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:31
    Saburo was a second-rate player back in his playing days, wasn't he? They should make a guy who was actually first-rate the manager instead — this one's bland and has zero star power.
    21AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:42
    Re: #4
    Are you talking about our Orix, you jerk?
    35AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:00
    Re: #4
    When a first-rate player ends up on top, it turns into 'why can't you just do something this simple?!' — that's exactly what makes it hard.
    44AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:03
    Re: #4
    There's an old saying: a great player doesn't necessarily make a great manager…
    5AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:33
    Body blows are
    devastatingly effective
    on Taihei Saburo.
    (wordplay — comedian Taihei Saburo shares manager Saburo's nickname)
    6AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:34
    >>What's Mr. 'No'jima going to do about this, I wonder…

    Kazuya Kojima:
    "It's 'O'jima, dammit!!"
    (a riff on people botching his surname)
    7AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:34
    Saburo's wife is Michiyo Nakajima.
    8AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:34
    Fun fact: he was actually a Koshien-winning pitcher in high school.
    26AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:52
    Re: #8
    That's pretty well known already, isn't it.
    10AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:36
    Everyone's talking about Hanshin, but have guys like Kadobe and Tomita basically been written off completely?
    11AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:37
    Kodama's clearly got zero trust left at this point, huh.
    12AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:37
    Would a player who went FA specifically to escape a power-harassing manager really turn around and join another power-harassing manager?
    13AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:38
    Isn't he just the poster child of 'wins padded by run support, not skill' (nure-supo)?
    14AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:38
    Up until a few years ago he barely got any run support and kept racking up losses, but lately that hasn't really been the case. If he went to SoftBank, could he go something like 15-7? With Chunichi it'd probably be more like 5-12. Can't say about next season though.
    16AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:39
    He's Rank B, so the number of teams willing to grab him will probably be limited — maybe Rakuten, out of love for manager Yoshii?
    17AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:39
    Is there actually any team likely to scoop him up?
    19AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:41
    Re: #17
    Any team besides Hanshin or SoftBank wouldn't mind having him around. Just comes down to the money.
    24AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:49
    Re: #19
    And yet Hanshin is apparently the most eager of all.
    29AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:55
    Re: #19
    It's not about the money — the real question is whether a team would still take him even with a compensation pick attached. Teams without much young talent outside their protected list could make it work.
    18AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:40
    Just send him back to Iguchi's side already.
    20AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:41
    Everyone mocks Saburo as some kind of thug, but his wife was a former idol and she was cute, you know.
    22AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:45
    Any team would want a lefty at this level.
    23AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:49
    My favorite player always matched up well against Kojima and used to hit him a lot, so my impression of Kojima is 'easy pitcher to hit.' Still, I think he'd do better in the Central League.
    25AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:51
    If he moves to Hanshin, the compensation pick will probably be either Kadobe or Tomita.
    28AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:55
    This guy had an ERA in the high-3s even back in the dead-ball era, lol.
    32AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:58
    This season he opened with 4 innings/1 run, then 4⅓ innings/4 runs — couldn't get through 5 innings in either start — and after just two games he was ordered down to the minors to get back in shape.

    Calling that treatment unfair is honestly pretty naive. Well, maybe he'd cut it in a second-tier league.
    33AnonymousOct 31, 2026 21:59
    Who's even going to take him? You can't count on him for a rotation spot.
    34AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:00
    In Central League terms, maybe something like Masaya Ito?
    38AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:01
    Re: #34
    You can't lump a guy who's thrown 140+ innings for 5 straight years — and 100+ for 7 straight including this one — in with some scrub who broke down after 3 years.
    36AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:01
    Yakult's always short on arms — wouldn't he make the majors there immediately?
    37AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:01
    So he's basically holding a grudge over being sent down for being out of shape?
    39AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:02
    Nishioka bailed too — Saburo might end up taking a mid-season leave next year.
    48AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:07
    Re: #38
    Don't you dare call a pro with 101 career starts and 39 wins 'garbage.' Who do you think you are, the god of baseball?
    55AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:13
    Re: #48
    For pitchers, staying healthy is what counts — the ones who break down are the garbage. In reality most guys do break down, which is exactly why a durable-but-bad-ERA guy like Kojima ends up rated highly.
    60AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:16
    Re: #55
    If 40 wins makes you garbage, then most of pro baseball is sub-garbage — meaning your standard is just broken.
    63AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:24
    Re: #60
    Win totals don't matter at all. For a pitcher it's all about eating innings. If you say 'that's wrong,' then you and I just have different standards for what we want from a pitcher, and there's no point arguing.
    68AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:32
    Re: #44
    Would that line work on Ochiai or Kudo?
    70AnonymousOct 31, 2026 22:37
    Re: #68
    It works on top-tier players out of PL Gakuen.

    Background and key points of this discussion

    Free agency is a system letting players who meet conditions such as years of domestic service choose their next team freely; a move triggers either a player-compensation pick or a cash payment to the team they’re leaving. The core of this story isn’t really the FA process itself but the report that being sent to the minors after just two season-opening starts is what triggered the move — the causal link between the team’s handling of him and his decision to exercise free agency is, strictly speaking, only what’s being reported. Where the thread split was over how to judge Kojima: one camp valued his ability to log innings without injury over his ERA, while the other questioned his career numbers outright. The criticism of the manager’s handling also settled into the general point that playing-career achievements and managerial ability are separate things — worth noting this unfolded more as a debate over managerial decisions than a personal attack.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “[Lotte] Kazuya Kojima likely headed for free agency… friction with manager Saburo smoldering since being “sent to the minors after just 2 season-opening starts”.”

  • New Manager Hideki Matsui Takes the Field — Fall Camp Infield Stands Packed, 5ch Cheers ‘Welcome Back!’

    The new Yomiuri Giants regime led by new manager Hideki Matsui got underway on October 30 with the start of fall camp. On day one, more than 100 players, coaches, and staff gathered, and the infield stands — usually sparse on a weekday morning — were unusually packed. NHK’s flagship evening news program “News Watch 9” also led with an extended segment on the story. On 5ch, nostalgic excitement from older fans over his first managerial post in 25 years ran alongside cooler reactions like “anyone who isn’t a pro baseball fan is already sick of this” and “even Giants fans are losing interest,” making the generational gap in reception a key talking point.

    [Giants] New Manager Hideki Matsui Hits the Ground Running — Fans Go Wild Over His First Comeback in 25 Years, “Matsui, Welcome Baaack!” — Fall Camp Sees Unusually Packed Infield Stands

    The reborn Yomiuri Giants under new manager Hideki Matsui have gotten underway. Fall camp began on the 30th at Giants Stadium and Giants Town Stadium.

    On day one, more than 100 people gathered, including the new manager, coaching staff, players from the first through third-tier squads, and support staff.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    7AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:16
    This whole Matsui fever thing
    is probably incomprehensible to soccer fanboys ("sakabuta," a derogatory term baseball fans use for soccer fans)
    I don't get it either, honestly
    61AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:33
    Re: #7
    Kazu [Miura] couldn't even land a coaching job

    Apparently Nakata has no interest in the soccer world anymore
    Honda's a rare case who's still relevant, but he gets dragged lol
    8AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:16
    People who aren't pro baseball fans are already sick of this

    542 Anonymous Pinch Hitter @ Live Commentary Happens on the Baseball Ch Board (Wakuchoi ed5c-w2Pu [2400:2412:a681:d800:*]) Fri 10/30/2026 21:16:29.64 ID:LuKijyVy0
    NHK's News Watch 9 opened with 15 straight minutes on the Giants/Matsui

    545 Anonymous Pinch Hitter @ Live Commentary Happens on the Baseball Ch Board (Wakuchoi b841-JPLR [2001:240:2461:aed9:*]) Fri 10/30/2026 21:28:01.86 ID:OY/dvxoT0
    Re: #542
    lol, turns out people are avoiding it
    31AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:22
    Re: #8
    Well, probably only old geezers care about Matsui
    67AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:36
    Re: #8
    Thought it was a joke so I checked — turns out it's true, dying laughing
    86AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:45
    Re: #8
    Even Giants fans are already sick of it.
    9AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:16
    Of course everyone wants to watch now that Matsui's back with the Giants
    10AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:17
    https://img.portal.uqmobile.jp/detail/816afd8caa5778f85bf9a578cd6bdb8d_1793341607_2.jpg

    Anyway, cut those sideburns lol
    18AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:19
    Re: #10
    No, dye those sideburns. They look scruffy.
    11AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:17
    Re: #1
    A weekday morning crowd is gonna be nothing but unemployed old folks lol
    12AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:17
    I watched Matsui get intentionally walked five at-bats in a row live back in the day, and now he's a Giants manager
    Kind of incredible, honestly
    13AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:18
    Shocked to see he's gone full gray-haired old man
    Dye it, old man
    20AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:20
    Re: #13
    Yeah, zero sense of being put together
    Be a gentleman already!
    15AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:19
    Cracked up seeing his old man on TV, billed not as a cult guru but with some title like "director of the Matsui Memorial Hall" lol
    16AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:19
    Is the generation that gets excited over a guy like Matsui 60-plus?
    17AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:19
    If Matsui's estimated annual salary is 200 million yen

    that's way too cheap
    They've probably already recouped it in advertising value lol
    28AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:22
    Re: #17
    Matsui's only held that honorary "special advisor to the Yankees GM" title up until now, so of course he'd jump at this.
    19AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:20
    Matsui, Ohtani, and Ichiro all have that star charisma
    22AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:20
    Matsui only got the manager job because Shinnosuke Abe caused some scandal
    23AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:20
    Never understood why he got the People's Honor Award, or when he got turned into some kind of deity
    24AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:20
    Downtown's Matsumoto: "Matsui!!"

    https://youtu.be/-oHZJ8buy4w
    29AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:22
    Re: #24
    Theory: if Downtown makes you the butt of a bit, you're bound for big things
    35AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:23
    Re: #29
    Mitsumata Matazo: "…"
    Onigiri: "…"
    (two lesser-known comedians who got the same treatment from Downtown but never became stars — awkward silence)
    25AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:21
    The trash media's already gone into puff-piece mode lol

    They look thrilled to have found a Nagashima substitute lol

    As the saying goes, a mikoshi's best when it's light and empty-headed (i.e., a figurehead is easiest to manage when simple and pliable)
    26AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:21
    Neither this guy nor Ichiro has what it takes to be a manager
    27AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:21
    He came off like a figurehead/ornament
    That's why they're scrambling to stack his entourage with big names
    30AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:22
    His popularity before he bailed on the WBC was seriously something
    Feels like once Matsui left, Giants games stopped airing on free TV every single day
    36AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:24
    Re: #30
    I think it's because Nagashima stepped down as manager.
    32AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:22
    Do they even sell manager uniforms as merch? Or just player ones?
    39AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:25
    If you had to name baseball's "Four Heavenly Kings" of stardom over the past 30 years, it'd be Matsui, Ichiro, Ohtani, and one more
    Their popularity really is on another level
    70AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:36
    Re: #39
    Going by that lineup, the fourth would be Nomo
    41AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:25
    He says "ne" (the Japanese tag word like "y'know") way too much when he talks
    76AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:40
    Re: #41
    He also tacks "pyon" (a cutesy, rabbit-like speech tic) onto the end of his sentences a lot
    59AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:32
    The ones who must be freaking out right now are the Giants players
    They barely got any attention before, and now next year they're absolutely expected to win every single game lol
    78AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:41
    Re: #59
    Today's players probably can't even imagine that kind of pressure
    Expected to win every game, no room for a throwaway loss
    Get chewed out if you don't go full effort every single game
    Pitchers get their face zoomed in on national TV the second they're in a jam
    The cleanup hitter is expected to hit a home run every single time there's a scoring chance
    97AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:51
    After "Ohtani harassment," now it's time for "Matsui harassment" (a joking term for being bombarded with nonstop media coverage)
    106AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:53
    Re: #97
    NHK's News 9 opened with 20 straight minutes on Matsui
    98AnonymousOct 30, 2026 23:51
    Breakdown of WBC 2023 viewership by age

    First, Gen Z (25 and under). Slightly trending up, but still under 10% either way. Seems like very few people in this generation are even interested in baseball.

    The "core" demo (ages 13-49) isn't high either. Trending up a bit, but still more than 5% below the overall average.

    Middle-aged and older viewers are what's propping up the popularity. Those in their 50s-60s are 7-8% above the overall average. And for 70-plus, it's almost double the overall average. Baseball really is a sport sustained by its older fans.

    https://livedoor.blogimg.jp/rock1963roll/imgs/1/9/1982bc18.jpg

    Background and Key Points of Debate

    Since retiring as a player, Hideki Matsui had held the largely ceremonial title of special advisor to the Yankees’ GM, so this is close to his first hands-on role in Japanese professional baseball. His appointment as Giants manager came after the departure of previous manager Shinnosuke Abe, and while the thread floated some unverified speculation about the circumstances of that change, this article doesn’t get into those details. Where opinion split was over how popular he “really” is — against the nostalgic excitement over his star power of old, some pointed out that pro baseball’s viewership itself is aging. Indeed, age-breakdown data from the 2023 WBC showed viewership propped up by fans in their 50s and older, with Gen Z showing little interest, so it’s worth keeping in mind that this “fever” coverage is landing very differently depending on generation.

    *This article is compiled as an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (Geisports Sokuho+) thread “[Giants] New Manager Hideki Matsui Hits the Ground Running — Fans Go Wild Over His First Comeback in 25 Years, “Welcome Baaack!” — Fall Camp Sees Unusually Packed Infield Stands“.

  • NPB to Overhaul FA Compensation Rules — 5ch: ‘So If You’ve Got the Cash, You Can Just Take Whoever You Want?’

    NPB has settled on a plan to overhaul its “player compensation” system for free-agent transfers starting in the 2027 off-season, replacing the current rule — handing over one player — with a choice between transferring a draft pick or settling in cash. According to the Hochi Shimbun, the baseline would be a 2nd-round draft pick for an A-rank player and a 3rd-round pick for a B-rank player, with players 35 and older remaining exempt from compensation as before. On 5ch’s “Nandemo Jikkyo G” board, opinions split three ways: some argued that if cash settlements catch on, deep-pocketed teams will find it even easier to stock up on star players; others countered that since late-round picks have increasingly turned into core players in recent years, giving up a draft pick would actually hurt more; and still others suggested the new system could end up favoring weaker teams instead.

    1AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:37
    The player-compensation system will be abolished starting in the 2027 off-season → replaced with draft picks or cash
    October 30, 2026, 15:25
    6AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:41
    Seriously?
    So if you've got the money, there's zero downside — just take whoever you want?
    74AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:13
    Re: #6
    Whether they pick cash or a draft pick is up to the other side, isn't it?
    7AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:42
    Feels like NPB's basically turning into MLB's farm system at this point.
    10AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:43
    Seriously?
    So this year's the last one with player compensation?
    19AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:51
    The team receiving compensation gets to choose, so unless the salary's really high they'll go with cash.
    If it's something like ¥500 million (~$3.3M), they'll lean toward the draft pick instead.
    27AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:52
    Re: #19
    The choice belongs to the player's former team.
    28AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:53
    Re: #19
    Isn't it the team losing the player that chooses?
    21AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:51
    Won't this actually make FA moves stall out?
    42AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:00
    Re: #21
    Yeah, I think so too.
    Unless cash becomes the main option, teams will only go after elite A-rankers.
    32AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:54
    If it's an A-rank player, they should have to give up a 1st-round pick.
    This is so stingy.
    34AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:57
    Re: #32
    Well, if it's a 1st-rounder for A and a 2nd-rounder for B, FA moves become too hard to pull off, but if the compensation is only a 3rd- or 4th-round pick, that's too cheap a trade-off.
    35AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:57
    Most of SoftBank's current core players were 2nd-round picks, so this system could actually weaken SoftBank.
    38AnonymousOct 30, 2026 15:58
    Re: #35
    Even SoftBank doesn't poach an A-rank player every single year though.
    50AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:01
    SoftBank's just going to get even stronger.
    A player who slipped through SoftBank's protection list seems like a better bet than some random 2nd-round pick anyway.
    56AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:06
    Re: #50
    These days even non-1st-rounders often turn into core players, so the damage would be huge.
    59AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:06
    Re: #50
    Teams are basically built around their 2nd/3rd-round picks, so this would weaken them.
    They're just patching whatever hole they've got.
    63AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:07
    There's never anyone decent left unprotected anyway, so getting a draft pick instead is an incredibly sweet deal.
    71AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:11
    Re: #63
    A draft pick is only as good as your scouts' eye for talent, so it doesn't seem like much of a benefit.
    67AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:10
    Losing a 2nd-round pick stings, doesn't it?
    Do you have any idea how late a B-rank team's 3rd-round pick actually comes?
    70AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:11
    Re: #67
    All they'd have to do is scrap the pick-order reversal (the "snake" format where draft order flips each round).
    77AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:16
    If an A-rank player transfers in and doesn't perform…
    "It's his fault we don't get a 2nd-round pick this year!"
    …fans are gonna rip him apart for it.
    79AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:17
    Re: #77
    Having the cost get judged only after the results are in is kind of brutal, now that you mention it.
    82AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:18
    The Hochi article explains it more clearly:

    A-rank → transfer a 2nd-round pick
    B-rank → transfer a 3rd-round pick
    Cash settlement is also an option

    Players 35+: no compensation
    88AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:22
    Re: #82
    You're also missing that the B-rank range shrinks while the C-rank range expands to make up for it.
    83AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:18
    Have they even thought about what happens if one team signs two B-rank players?
    89AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:23
    Re: #83
    One of them's probably cash, right?
    91AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:24
    Honestly, A-rank players themselves are pretty rare these days, no?
    107AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:32
    Re: #91
    That's because A-rankers just go to MLB instead.
    94AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:25
    At this rate the Giants won't have a 2nd- or 3rd-round pick left in this year's draft.
    If there's no secret pre-draft deal (an informal arrangement teams sometimes strike with a prospect) in place, they won't get to play around with Oda.
    96AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:27
    Re: #94
    Not bad, if it means they still get two FA signings.
    95AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:26
    What happens if a team signs two A-rank players?
    98AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:27
    Re: #95
    They just made it so you can't land two A-rankers anymore.
    100AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:29
    So basically, if the Chunichi Dragons (mockingly nicknamed "Chunidora") lose a player to FA, two or three young guys overflowing with dreams and talent just get shipped off and buried in the Chunichi system instead?
    106AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:31
    Re: #100
    Now that you put it that way, this is starting to sound pretty bad.
    102AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:30
    If they're doing this, they need to make the 1st round a full reverse-order (weakest-team-first) draft, or bottom-tier teams won't be able to reinforce their rosters.
    104AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:31
    Re: #102
    The fact that the 3rd round starts from the top teams is kind of baffling too.
    108AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:32
    Re: #102
    Bottom-tier teams lose more players to FA in the first place anyway.
    109AnonymousOct 30, 2026 16:32
    Re: #102
    There'll be more B-rank players too, so bottom-tier teams actually come out ahead.

    Background and Key Points of Debate

    Under NPB’s current free-agent compensation system, the team signing an A-rank player must hand over one player as compensation, with detailed exceptions such as no compensation required for players 35 and older. According to reporting by the Hochi Shimbun, the new system would make transferring a 2nd-round draft pick the baseline for an A-rank signing and a 3rd-round pick for a B-rank signing, while also letting teams settle with cash instead. What split opinion in the thread was who actually stands to benefit from this setup. One camp argued that if cash settlements become the norm, financially strong teams will find it easier to land star players risk-free; the other argued that transferring draft picks would actually favor weaker teams (this is rooted in the fact that the revision also widens the range of players classified as B-rank, and that from the 3rd round onward, picking order starts with the lowest-placed teams). It’s also worth noting, as seen in replies 19, 27, and 28, that commenters themselves disagreed over who holds the choice between a draft pick and cash — it’s actually the player’s original team that decides — a point of confusion readers may stumble over too.

    *This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread, ‘NPB to Change FA Compensation’.