Category: Baseball

  • Giants’ Courtesy Visit to Draft Pick Oda Wraps Up in 5 Minutes—He Doesn’t Even Show; 5ch: ‘Forcing the Pick Is Now Just Causing Trouble’

    Yomiuri Giants’ first-round draft pick, Yokohama High School pitcher Shoki Oda (18), has declared his intent to pursue a career in American baseball and says he won’t enter contract talks. When the Giants made their customary courtesy visit to Yokohama High School on the 10th, Oda himself was absent — the whole thing wrapped up in about five minutes, with Scouting Director Yuujin Mizuno and others simply explaining the situation to the school. Mizuno reportedly said, “I’m sorry for the trouble this has caused.” On 5ch, opinion split between those criticizing the Giants for forcing the pick against the player’s wishes and those defending the move as technically within the draft rules, sparking a heated debate.

    [Giants] Oda Shoki’s Courtesy Visit Ends in 5 Minutes With Player Absent: “Sorry for the fuss…” Says Scouting Director Mizuno

    On the 10th, a courtesy visit was held at Yokohama High School for the Giants’ first-round draft pick, pitcher Shoki Oda (18), who has announced his intention to pursue a career in American baseball.

    Oda himself was not present. Instead, Scouting Director Yuujin Mizuno (61) and Scout Director Shinsuke Kuremaki greeted the school side, represented by head coach Hiroaki Murata (40) and others.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    6AnonymousNov 10, 2026 11:55
    Why apologize? That's just the right call to make.
    12AnonymousNov 10, 2026 11:57
    Re: #6
    Sure, no rules were broken — but the fact is, forcing the pick through against his wishes is causing real trouble right now. Issuing an apology first is just common sense.
    123AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:27
    Re: #6
    No, it's not the right call. 'Anything's fine as long as it's within the rules' is exactly the kind of move that gets you hated. Reading the room is a bare-minimum skill for any adult, and Mizuno clearly doesn't have it. Got it, you Giants trash? (「虚カス」 — a 5ch insult for Giants fans, swapping 巨人 "giant" for the homophone 虚人 "hollow man")
    28AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:00
    They already came for the courtesy visit with last week's 3rd-round pick — why'd they go back again?
    38AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:03
    Re: #28
    Probably to make sure that 3rd-rounder signs on a good note. If things stay sour with Oda, even that could get awkward.
    40AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:03
    They keep saying they want him to go through Japan first, but they're not doing it 'the Ohtani way.' (a nod to Nippon-Ham's respectful courting of Shohei Ohtani in 2012 despite his own MLB ambitions)
    50AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:06
    Re: #40
    Ignorance really is scary.
    42AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:04
    Oda already held a press conference announcing he's headed to the majors — the Giants drafted him anyway without his consent, so he doesn't even owe them a meeting. The Giants are the only ones who deserve the heat here.
    49AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:06
    Re: #42
    They burned a precious first-round pick to draft him, so they went in with eyes open — it's within the rules, so it's not really something to criticize. If it fails, they just end up looking foolish, that's all.
    58AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:11
    Yokohama High's side is being pretty childish too, honestly — embarrassing. Their handling of this was way too rude. Makes you question the school's character.
    74AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:15
    Re: #58
    You're allowed to say that — if you said the exact same thing back when Sugano and Nagano pulled the same stunt. (Tomoyuki Sugano and Hisayoshi Nagano both refused their original draft teams before eventually joining the Giants)
    66AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:13
    They have to go through the motions like this, otherwise the secret deal would get exposed.
    81AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:16
    Re: #66
    Sounds like they're setting up a story where 'Coach Matsui' is the one who finally talks the stubbornly absent Oda around.
    68AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:14
    If he can't cut it over there and comes back, is joining the Yomiuri Giants his only option?
    70AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:14
    Re: #68
    I'd guess he'd just go through the draft again.
    73AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:15
    Re: #68
    The Giants' negotiating rights run until the end of next March, right? After that, it'd belong to whichever team picks him in a fresh draft.
    72AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:15
    If getting drafted by the Giants actually blocked him from going to America, I'd get why he and the people around him are angry. But he can still go just fine either way. So wouldn't it be smarter to meet them, formally turn them down, and bank the goodwill? There's a real chance he could cash that favor in later if he ever works in Japan.
    84AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:17
    Re: #72
    If he's not signing, not sending him out there is just basic etiquette. A lot of people seem to think 'if he shows up to turn them down in person, people will say he was pressured into it' — showing up at all signals 'there's still a chance.' Not sending the actual decision-maker to a deal that isn't happening is completely standard in business.
    93AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:19
    Re: #72
    Are you seriously saying that about a high schooler?
    76AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:15
    Not sure why, but I've got a feeling Ikeda's going to get the cold shoulder on the team.
    83AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:17
    Re: #76
    It's the opposite — they'll have to treat him with extra care to patch things up with Yokohama High.
    77AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:15
    Just like a lot of people online mocked SoftBank when Rintaro Sasaki refused to sign with them, if Oda turns down the Giants, the Giants will get mocked the same way.
    86AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:17
    Re: #77
    He actually showed up at the ballpark and everything, so it's not even comparable — turned out completely differently.
    101AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:21
    Re: #77
    And because of that, Sasaki completely disappeared from the scene. Oda's headed the same way.
    78AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:15
    Honestly, the Giants' role in Japanese pro sports is already over, isn't it?
    87AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:18
    Re: #78
    Yomiuri's power ended the moment Nabetsune and Nagashima passed away. Everyone's on equal footing now.
    89AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:18
    Re: #83
    Still, surely the Giants have the upper hand here.
    100AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:21
    Re: #89
    If the Giants get banned from scouting there, it's the Giants who'll be in trouble.
    111AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:24
    Re: #100
    Would that even happen? If anything, wouldn't he get chewed out with 'go persuade him properly!' instead? It's the Giants we're talking about.
    115AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:26
    Re: #100
    It cuts both ways — the Giants would hate losing the ability to draft out of Yokohama High, and Yokohama High would hate no longer getting drafted by the Giants.
    92AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:19
    Right now, in popularity, performance, and money, 'the Toilet' (a derisive 5ch nickname for a rival team) is the real ruler of the league. The Giants were always just a relic propped up by Nabetsune alone, so they're fated to fade away like Johnny & Associates (the talent agency that collapsed after a major scandal).
    96AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:20
    Re: #92
    Isn't it a bit early to be trash-talking?
    95AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:19
    Would this be the first time someone's refused a Giants first-round pick? There was Yokawa for the developmental draft, I think.
    105AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:22
    Re: #95
    The Giants' first-round pick from the 1972 (Showa 47) draft — the year of the Yuguchi Incident — refused to sign. That's the only case of a refused Giants first-rounder in history. That same year, their 2nd, 4th, and 5th-round picks also turned them down.
    106AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:22
    There's no way Mizuno did this on his own call, right? Orders from Yomiuri?
    125AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:27
    Re: #106
    If that were the case, they'd have gone way earlier. This whole thing's a staged farce both sides coordinated behind the scenes.
    114AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:25
    Re: #111
    In Japan, amateur baseball actually outranks the pros.
    116AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:26
    Re: #114
    Seriously? The High School Baseball Federation is the strongest?
    120AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:27
    Re: #116
    College and corporate-league ball too. The High School Federation's got nothing to do with it.
    118AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:26
    Re: #111
    Pro and amateur baseball really don't get along. It's a weirdly split setup — two separate pillars for what's supposedly the same sport.
    127AnonymousNov 10, 2026 12:28
    Re: #118
    I've heard it's all connected going back to around junior high level, though.

    Background and Key Points of the Debate

    Under Japan’s draft system, a team is allowed to select a player even after he’s indicated he intends to refuse, and the drafting team’s negotiating rights normally stay in effect until the end of that fiscal year. There’s a real precedent for a refused pick from the 1972 (Showa 47) draft, so forcing through a selection like this isn’t unheard of. The thread split between those who saw it as “not a problem under the rules” and those who felt “ignoring the player’s wishes causes real trouble on the ground” — both sides pointing to a gap between the system’s official rules and how things actually play out. Some commenters brought up Rintaro Sasaki’s earlier refusal as a comparison, but the specifics of each negotiation and each player’s response differ case by case, a nuance that’s hard to capture from the article alone.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Nanimo Jikkyou G) thread “Giants’ courtesy visit to Oda ends in 5 minutes, and Oda doesn’t even show up.”

  • Orix Drops Out of Tokoda FA Race, Chunichi Left as Sole Bidder — 5ch: “There Goes ‘No-rix’ Again”

    According to a Hochi Shimbun report, Orix has withdrawn from negotiations to sign Hiroshima left-handed free agent Hiroki Tokoda, leaving Chunichi as the only team still in the running — a topic that lit up 5ch’s “Nandemo Jikkyo G” board. Posters mocked Orix’s now-familiar last-minute pullout with cries of “There they go again, ‘No-rix’!” (a 5ch nickname poking fun at Orix for repeatedly backing out of FA bids), while opinion split on whether Tokoda should actually move to Chunichi. The thread also dug into why the Hanshin Tigers went for Kojima instead of Tokoda, and compared Tokoda’s value against fellow Hiroshima free agent Shota Morishita, with debate continuing over whether to prize a veteran with a deep track record or a player whose tendencies are still unknown to opposing teams.

    1AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:16
    tps://i.imgur.com/v9Kxp16.jpeg
    From Hochi Shimbun
    4AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:20
    The Fighters and Yakult need to actually show some hustle.
    7AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:23
    Re: #4
    More than that, isn't that team basically a zombie at this point?
    5AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:22
    Chunidora (a mocking 5ch nickname for the Chunichi Dragons): "The fans are loud about it, and I guess I should show at least a little sincerity toward Manager Kudo too… If it's Orix, there's no way we'd lose on money, so might as well pretend to be in the bidding."
    Ori (Orix): "Oh! Chuni showed up, huh? Wouldn't it be funny if we pulled our hand back right here, lol."
    Chunidora: "Wha—!?"
    8AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:24
    Re: #5
    Chunichi's actually one of the wealthier teams — comes up every time, like clockwork.
    15AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:31
    Hiroshima's never had a player do the "declare-and-stay" FA move, right?
    There was that "cricket" guy though
    158AnonymousNov 9, 2026 21:04
    Re: #15
    That guy was a different caliber, so a "declare-and-stay" is fine this time, apparently
    20AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:34
    This is turning into "only Chunichi bids, and he ends up staying in Hiroshima anyway"
    21AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:36
    Re: #20
    There's that "No-rix" again…
    22AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:38
    Why'd Hanshin go for Kojima over Tokoda?
    Because he's cheaper?
    100AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:43
    Re: #22
    Maybe it's because facing Central League teams means they already have Tokoda's data figured out, so they don't really need him. A lefty who can eat 180 innings like Kojima becomes the priority.
    150AnonymousNov 9, 2026 21:01
    Re: #22
    He eats innings, plus he trains in the off-season with Ohtake, his college senior. Probably a safer bet than Tokoda, who's rumored to be drawing interest from multiple teams.
    27AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:42
    Does Chunichi actually have anyone decent to offer as compensation?
    For that matter, won't they struggle to even fill all 28 protected roster spots?
    50AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:00
    Re: #27
    Honestly, I don't think they'll have anyone decent left over.
    28AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:42
    Between Morishita and Tokoda, Tokoda's the better player, right?
    Why's Morishita so popular?
    38AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:49
    Re: #28
    Nah, Morishita's better.
    31AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:44
    Re: #29
    31 and 29, right?
    That gap actually matters quite a bit.
    34AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:45
    Re: #31
    Tokoda was the 2016 draft class.
    Morishita was the 2019 draft class.

    That's a 3-year difference in school year.
    39AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:49
    Actually, there's a decent chance the Giants end up landing nobody at all.
    Morishita's probably heading to SoftBank anyway.
    40AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:52
    Re: #39
    No way.
    The fact that the Giants are focused solely on Morishita says it all.
    42AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:54
    Re: #40
    After seeing how the Giants have treated Kai and Norimoto, I can't imagine anyone wanting to join them as a free agent.
    43AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:56
    Re: #42
    They haven't produced results, so that's just normal treatment, no?
    45AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:56
    Re: #42
    Norimoto's been given a rotation spot, and sure, Kai lost his position, but the Giants still found him a new role.

    If anything, that's pretty good treatment, no?
    47AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:57
    Why's everyone writing out "MLB" like that
    65AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:17
    Re: #47
    Sorry, what do you mean?
    51AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:01
    The Giants can't beat SoftBank on this one.
    Morishita's from Oita Prefecture after all.
    53AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:03
    Re: #51
    His hometown doesn't really matter that much, does it?
    55AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:04
    If it's just going to Chunichi, he'd rather stay in Hiroshima.
    58AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:05
    Re: #55
    Nah, Chunichi's going to get a lot stronger starting next year — if he wants to chase a championship, the timing's actually good.
    60AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:08
    Re: #55
    If the money's better, he should just go.
    I think Chunichi's run support is better too.
    62AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:11
    Re: #55
    Even setting money aside, between the current Chunichi and Hiroshima, it's clearly Chunichi.
    64AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:16
    With about 12 guys already in the "Tommy John Club," I don't think Orix can actually afford to pull out.
    68AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:25
    Re: #64
    And on top of that, their top 3 starters in the rotation have all had Tommy John surgery.
    With Espino gone too, they genuinely won't be able to get through games.
    80AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:34
    Tokoda's WAR is actually lower than Kanbayashi's.
    85AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:37
    Re: #80
    But the thing with Kanbayashi is he's all "spec" (tools/potential without results). Pitchers, worst case, can still be used as innings fillers.
    93AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:41
    Tokoda's basically a lefty version of Yanagi — not a guy you drop big money to sign.
    98AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:42
    Re: #93
    That's actually really good though.
    103AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:45
    Re: #100
    Tokoda, who you can reasonably expect to perform at a solid level, should be the higher priority.
    105AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:46
    Re: #103
    Teams already have data on a guy like Tokoda, so he'll get hit.
    Kojima's basically an unknown quantity, which works in his favor.
    110AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:47
    Re: #105
    I get what you're saying, but Tokoda — with a 2.76 ERA this season — is the safer bet.
    116AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:48
    Re: #105
    That logic applies to a guy who's just starting out, not to Tokoda, who's posted solid numbers for several years running.

    Background and Key Points of This Topic

    Under NPB’s free agency system, a player’s current team either retains him through a “declare-and-stay” announcement or loses him to another club after negotiations. This time the focus is Hiroshima left-hander Hiroki Tokoda: per a Hochi Shimbun report, Orix has withdrawn from the race to sign him, leaving Chunichi as the only team still negotiating — and that’s what kicked off the thread. “No-rix” is a 5ch-coined jab at Orix’s habit of backing out of FA negotiations at the last minute year after year, and it’s being used here in that same spirit. Where posters split was over how to weigh Tokoda’s value: one camp argued that having so much data on him from years of facing Central League teams works against him, while another argued that several straight years of solid results make him the more reliable pick — a divide that also shaped how people read Hanshin’s decision to prioritize Kojima over Tokoda. There’s also discussion digging into why fellow Hiroshima free agent Morishita is rated more highly, pointing to the three-year gap between their draft classes (2016 vs. 2019) as part of the explanation. Worth noting: none of this is settled — it’s all based on reporting at this stage, and no final destination has been confirmed.

    ※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “Orix Withdraws From Tokoda Bidding — Chunichi Now the Only Team in the Race.”

  • 46 Players Announced for This Year’s NPB Tryout Camp — Hiroshima and SoftBank Lead with 7 Entrants Each; 5ch: ‘Guys Have Monster Games at the Plate and Still Go Unsigned, Happens All the Time’

    On the 9th, the Japan Professional Baseball Players Association announced the 46 players set to take part in the tryout camp being held on the 17th at Vantelin Dome. Among players who were on NPB rosters this season, SoftBank and Hiroshima had the most entrants, with seven each. The list includes SoftBank’s Rikou Ogata, who played in this year’s Japan Series, and Hiroshima’s Masaya Yano. Opinions on the thread were split between the harsh reality that a strong tryout showing doesn’t necessarily lead to an actual contract, and the question of how much meaning the tryout system itself still has now that the ikusei (developmental-contract) system exists.

    NTV, November 9, 2026, 17:10

    On the 9th, the Japan Professional Baseball Players Association announced the lineup of players taking part in the tryout to be held on the 17th at Vantelin Dome in Nagoya. The tryout gives players who’ve been released by their teams a chance to showcase themselves in search of a new place to play. It used to be run by NPB itself, but the players’ association has handled it since last year.

    Among players who were on NPB rosters this season, SoftBank and Hiroshima had the most entrants. The list includes SoftBank’s Rikou Ogata, who also played in the Japan Series, and Hiroshima’s Masaya Yano. The entrants by position are as follows.

    Source: news.ntv.co.jp / Original article here

    2AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:04
    Honestly, watching 'Showa-retro exploration' videos is way more fun than watching the Peace-kun mascot at Omiya Park on YouTube.
    6AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:06
    I wonder who TBS's 'released players' special is following this time.
    7AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:07
    Hiroshima's released Yano, Tamura, and Maekawa to join the tryout; Kozono sits it out — all 46 entrants announced (Full-Count)
    news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/b8e055523634f2426d7ba60f909afd4e236678c1
    8AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:09
    Guys who already have their next team lined up don't bother showing up for this, you know.
    9AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:09
    27 pitchers, huh?
    Are they gonna give each of them like 2 outs to work with?
    10AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:10
    Wasn't the whole point that tryouts don't actually mean anything — just a chance to make some memories?
    24AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:28
    Re: #10
    Apparently they changed it to this format specifically so it wouldn't turn into just that.
    13AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:12
    Pretty much every year it's 5 guys or fewer who actually get signed out of this.
    Tight gate.
    73AnonymousNov 9, 2026 20:07
    Re: #13
    Can't be helped — tryout results don't actually decide who gets signed.
    Even homering in every single at-bat wouldn't be a sure thing.
    14AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:12
    Is Fujinami running a takoyaki stand these days?
    63AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:42
    Re: #14
    His wife's too busy filming 'Kakuzuke Check' (the celebrity luxury-goods guessing TV segment).
    15AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:16
    It's basically a graduation ceremony.
    Even if you go deep three at-bats in a row here, nobody's signing you.
    16AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:19
    Re: #15
    If you actually went deep three at-bats in a row, I'd think at least an independent-league team would scoop you up.
    64AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:45
    Re: #15
    Yeah, that's exactly it.
    Guys have monster games at the plate and still don't get picked up by anybody — happens all the time.
    So then what's even the point of the tryout?
    17AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:19
    Even if it's just a spider's thread,
    you still want to grab onto it if there's a chance of being saved.
    25AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:29
    Re: #17
    Nobody's out there thinking that hard about it, lol.
    This is more like a graceful send-off into retirement.
    19AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:22
    Tagami's nephew had a solid build and looked like he could turn into something, but I guess it didn't pan out, huh.
    20AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:24
    I wonder if they actually run doping tests for this kind of thing.
    Wouldn't be surprising if someone leaned on something for a do-or-die moment like this.
    21AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:25
    Ex-Carp guys probably need to go through an independent league as a stepping stone first.
    Jumping straight back into NPB seems like a stretch.
    22AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:26
    This lineup looks tougher than Chunidora.
    23AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:28
    Sakata Rei, huh?
    He's a knuckleballer.
    Guess he still hasn't given up on NPB.
    26AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:30
    Re: #24
    It's probably just that demand for a proper retirement send-off is high, which is why NPB stopped running it — but doesn't it end up the same even with the players' association in charge?
    Or maybe the association already paper-screens out the guys who are 'obviously not qualified to join' before it even starts.
    27AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:33
    Is this the kind of thing I could just casually show up to, even though I've never played baseball?
    I'm confident in my physical toughness — I don't even use the AC in winter.
    49AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:53
    Re: #27
    Are you even a dues-paying member of the NPB players' association? No, you're not.
    If it were a completely open tryout test, sure, you could — though you'd get cut in the first round, of course.
    55AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:25
    Re: #27
    Like back when Rakuten was founded — local high school baseball guys went to the pro tryouts in droves just for kicks. Not a single one passed.
    28AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:35
    Tough fighting over such a small number of spots.
    Guess that's one more reason not to aim for pro ballplayer — there just aren't many jobs in it.
    If you don't make it in Japan, there's basically nowhere left to make a living doing the baseball you love.
    Kids and parents know this too, which is why way fewer kids are even trying these days.
    If baseball were more popular overseas, you could at least play in Asia, South America, or Europe, but…
    34AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:39
    Re: #28
    The risk if baseball doesn't work out is just way too big.
    Parents basically have to go all-in on their kid as if dedicating their whole life to it, or the kid won't make it pro — and a lot of these guys go to high schools that exempt them from studying so they can chase Koshien, then end up dropping out and becoming criminals.
    37AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:43
    Re: #28
    Even in Korea, the world's third-biggest pro baseball league, the average salary is only around ¥20 million — cheaper than soccer, basketball, or even pro volleyball.
    In Taiwan's league, the world's fourth-biggest, the average salary is ¥6 million, so you genuinely can't make real money there.
    Mexico's even cheaper than that.
    With baseball, if you don't make it in the US or Japan, that's basically the end of the road.
    29AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:36
    It's really just the place where family comes to watch you in uniform one last time.
    Doing well here doesn't lead to an NPB contract.
    30AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:37
    Don't the Fighters or the Marines have anyone entering?
    45AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:50
    Re: #30
    Oh, Lotte did have someone.
    32AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:39
    With the ikusei (developmental) contract system around now, tryouts don't really mean much, do they?
    33AnonymousNov 9, 2026 18:39
    Has anyone actually become a real contributor after coming out of a tryout recently?
    Hiroshima looks like it's running short on players though.
    58AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:30
    Is there actually a team that would sign Kozono?
    59AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:31
    Re: #58
    There was an article saying the BayStars (Yokohama) might take him, lol 😂
    61AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:39
    I get backfilling roster spots after cutting dead weight, but SoftBank going this hard on ikusei (developmental) signings too is a lot.
    65AnonymousNov 9, 2026 19:46
    Re: #61
    Misread it as 'signed' instead of 'entered.'

    Background and key points of this discussion

    The tryout camp shifted from being NPB-run to being organized by the Japan Professional Baseball Players Association starting last year, and in practice it’s known for often being more of a “showcase” for players whose fate has largely already been decided beforehand. What split the thread was, first, whether the tryout still has any real meaning now that the ikusei (developmental) contract system already exists as a safety net, and second, how to square the harsh reality that a good performance doesn’t directly translate into getting signed. The recurring references to a “graduation ceremony” or a “graceful send-off into retirement” reflect the fact that there have been real cases of players who put up monster-game numbers at past tryouts and still didn’t get picked up — underscoring that how well you do at the tryout doesn’t determine the outcome. A misconception some readers fall into is the idea that “doing well here means you’re back in the pros,” but in reality players are more often re-evaluated after first passing through an independent league, and as the article notes, an immediate return to NPB isn’t easy.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Entertainment & Sports News+) thread “This Year’s 46 Tryout Entrants Announced — Hiroshima and SoftBank Lead with 7 Players Each, Camp to Be Held on the 17th at Vantelin Dome.”

  • Shoki Oda Now Favorite to Sign With Dodgers — 5ch: ‘Everyone and Their Dog Wants In With the Dodgers’

    Yokohama High School pitcher Shoki Oda (18) was selected by the Yomiuri Giants with their first pick in the 2026 draft, but on the 8th (9th Japan time), the U.S. Dodgers-focused outlet “Dodgers Blue” reported that signing Oda is one of the goals the Dodgers should pursue this offseason. Oda has already held meetings with five MLB teams, and the Giants are set to hold their official contract-greeting ceremony with him on the 10th. On 5ch, reactions mixed anticipation with anxiety — some expressed surprise that Oda, as an international amateur free agent, falls outside the scope of the NPB draft, while others brought up the harshness of minor-league life, the language barrier, and past examples of players who struggled abroad and came back to NPB.

    [Dodgers] Shoki Oda Now the Top Candidate for a Dodgers Deal — Minor-League Contract Would Be “Convenient,” Says U.S. Report

    On the 8th (9th Japan time), Dodgers-focused outlet “Dodgers Blue” named signing Yokohama High pitcher Shoki Oda (18) — the Giants’ first-round draft pick — as one of the goals the Dodgers should accomplish this offseason.

    Oda has already finished meetings with five MLB teams, and it’s been announced that the Giants will hold their official greeting ceremony with him on the 10th.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    2AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:09
    6AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:10
    Surpass Japan's own Virat Kohli
    8AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:11
    Everyone and their dog wants the Dodgers.
    Can Japanese people just stop following whoever's trendy already?
    Really shows our herd mentality as a nation.
    9AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:11
    Can a kid who's been baseball-obsessed since elementary school even speak English?
    The guys like that at my high school had the worst grades, but this kid's apparently fluent.
    99AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:32
    Re: #9
    At 18, if he goes to a local community college over there, six months is enough to get by in daily life.
    This guy's going into the minors, so he'll pick it up fluently in that same kind of environment.
    Same as Nishida — under 20 and the pronunciation really does come out cleaner.
    11AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:11
    Because watching 'Showa retro exploration' videos on YouTube is more fun than watching Peace-kun from Omiya Park. (a stray, off-topic copypasta-style line — Peace-kun is a peacock mascot at Omiya Park Zoo)
    14AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:13
    Even if he signs somewhere, isn't it through the draft?
    He's a rookie, so it's just a matter of whether he joins whoever picks him, right?
    Why's 'Dodgers most likely' even a thing?
    29AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:18
    Re: #14
    Right now, players competing outside the US aren't subject to the MLB draft.
    Rikuto Nishida of the Chicago [team] got drafted because he was enrolled at a U.S. college.
    MLB apparently wants to eventually set up something called an 'international draft' limited to foreign players competing abroad, but whether the players' union agreement will allow that is another question.
    30AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:19
    Re: #14
    He falls under international amateur free agent signing rules, so no draft is needed.
    61AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:25
    Re: #14
    Well, with guys like Ohtani already there as a senior, isn't it basically mutual love between Oda and the Dodgers too?
    18AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:15
    International amateur signings are open competition — the poorer teams actually have bigger spending pools for it.
    20AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:15
    Oh, so the draft doesn't even apply here.


    > He has declared his intent to go to the US as an 'international amateur free agent' aiming to sign directly with an MLB team without going through NPB,
    > and is therefore exempt from the US draft (the Rule 4 draft).
    21AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:16
    It's bad enough if the Giants had a secret deal with Oda,
    but if they burned a first-round pick with no deal at all, that's just hilarious.
    22AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:16
    If he's in an environment where failing is no big deal, I guess he's free to do as he likes.
    25AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:17
    This is basically the Giants having done to them what Kanno — who ended up joining the Giants anyway — once did to the Nippon-Ham Fighters.
    26AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:17
    Tasting failure early in life isn't such a bad thing either.
    28AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:18
    If he can't hack it in the majors and ends up in NPB, the Giants will probably scoop him up and just let him rot on the bench.
    42AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:20
    Re: #28
    Well, that's just how it goes.
    The Giants want him while he's young,
    but a guy who comes back after failing to make it abroad probably gets treated badly.
    115AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:38
    Re: #28
    The Tetsuya Yamaguchi route, huh?
    31AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:19
    Whether he can endure minor-league life with brutal bus rides of over 1,000 km one-way.
    32AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:19
    The Dodgers have way more money, so of course he'd go there —
    whether that's the right call is another story lol
    33AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:19
    People go on about the language barrier, but at 18 it wouldn't matter either way, right?
    Just do one of those cheap storefront English-conversation courses.
    36AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:19
    Ohtani's on the decline so now it's Oda, huh.
    Japan's own 'Virat Kohli' title passes from Ohtani to Oda too.
    39AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:20
    Even Miziorowski took three years to make his MLB debut,
    so for Oda it'll take at least 5-6 years minimum.
    At that point it's basically no different from going through NPB first.
    40AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:20
    Being the Dodgers' #1 minor-league prospect just means the roster above him is jammed, so even the good prospects can't move up.
    44AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:21
    Sure, it means starting in the Dodgers' farm system, but that's still got more promise than Hideki Matsui's old Giants.
    Get doted on by Ohtani, Yamamoto, and Sasaki.
    54AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:22
    Re: #44
    Do those guys even interact with the minor leaguers though?
    55AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:22
    Even if he hits reality and crashes in year one over there, then grinds for 5 years before coming back to NPB, he'd still only be in his early 20s.
    Being young is a real advantage.
    110AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:36
    Re: #55
    There's no way he'd give up after just one year.
    58AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:23
    Even Gosho Kato, a second-round MLB draft pick, couldn't produce results and ended up coming to Nippon-Ham.
    73AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:27
    Re: #58
    In NPB, about 70% of drafted players make it to the top team before they retire.
    In MLB, apparently only 9% of players ever make it to the majors.
    59AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:23
    Re: #1
    Going by this article, it's convenient for the Dodgers but bad news for Oda, isn't it?
    68AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:26
    Re: #59
    He surely knows full well he's choosing the route of clawing up from the bottom of the minors.
    There's obviously no guarantee of reaching the majors.
    63AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:25
    > "Maybe it'd be best to play for the Giants for about 5 years before trying MLB"

    It's just a hypothetical, but the Giants would never go along with that.
    82AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:29
    Re: #63
    Well, they'd probably just say they'll allow it to get him to sign, wouldn't they?
    96AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:32
    He can just treat it like going to college — grind it out in America for 4 years.
    Go for the majors during that time if he wants, and if it really doesn't work out, aim for NPB instead. Either way's fine.
    114AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:38
    Re: #96
    That's where Rintaro Sasaki is smart about it —
    even if he doesn't make it in the majors, a Stanford degree massively widens his future options.
    109AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:36
    Maybe he values the experience more than the money. If that's his philosophy, that's smart and admirable.
    He already understands at this young age that there are things money can't buy.
    118AnonymousNov 9, 2026 12:39
    Re: #109
    Whether he succeeds or fails, it'll be a reference point for the high schoolers who come after him.
    He needs to have a plan for what happens if it doesn't work out, too.

    Background and Key Points of This Discussion

    The focus here is that Oda is treated as an “international amateur free agent,” meaning he can sign directly with an MLB team without going through the NPB draft. The unusual situation — a US team’s interest surfacing right after the Giants took him with their first-round pick — is what drew attention. Some comments took a sober look at the risk of the challenge, citing figures suggesting roughly 70% of NPB draftees make it to the top team, while less than 10% of players in MLB ever stick in the majors. It’s worth noting that speculation about a “secret arrangement with the Giants” is not backed up anywhere in the reporting — it remains pure conjecture from the forum.

    *This article is compiled as an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuho+) thread “[Baseball] Shoki Oda Now Favorite for Dodgers Move — Minor-League Deal “Convenient,” Says U.S. Report, Despite Giants’ First-Round Pick.”

  • Giants to Formally Greet Draft Pick Shoki Oda on the 10th — 5ch: “There’s Already a Precedent Named Roki Sasaki”

    It’s been decided that the Yomiuri Giants’ formal greeting meeting with pitcher Shoki Oda of Yokohama High School — their first-round draft pick — will take place on November 10. At a press conference on October 15, before the draft, Oda said a minor-league contract with an MLB club or enrolling at a U.S. college were both options on the table, and right after the Giants picked him first overall, he told TBS in an interview, “My resolve to take on America hasn’t wavered one bit.” On 5ch, discussion split over whether this “forced pick” made sense, with users citing signing bonuses, agents’ cuts, and real examples of players who’d gone to the U.S. before, debating whether joining the Giants or heading straight to MLB was the smarter move.

    It was decided on the 8th that the Giants will hold a formal greeting meeting on the 10th with pitcher Shoki Oda (18) of Yokohama High School, whom they picked first overall in the draft.

    At a press conference on October 15, Oda stated that, in addition to a minor-league contract with an MLB club, enrolling at a U.S. college was also an option.

    Even so, the Giants went ahead and picked him first overall at the draft meeting on the 22nd. Right after being selected, appearing in an interview on TBS, which was broadcasting the draft live, Oda said, “It’s an honor to be picked, but my resolve to take on America hasn’t wavered one bit,” making clear his intention to challenge American baseball remained unchanged.

    Source: hochi.news / Original article here

    4AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:11
    Did something Darvish said change his mind?
    5AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:12
    Feels bad for him — sounds like ex-major leaguers are quietly pressuring him to just toe the Giants line.
    6AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:12
    Why should he waste his precious time on the Giants when they picked him without even asking?
    7AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:13
    Don't need him on the Giants — doubts he can even hack it in NPB, let alone the majors.
    63AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:47
    Re: #7
    If it comes to that, that's just how it goes — he'd probably be fine with that outcome himself.
    9AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:16
    Turn down the Giants and go to the majors already.
    16AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:20
    I think he'd be better off signing a favorable deal with the Giants first and going to MLB after.
    Someone should make him read that Slam Dunk story (the basketball manga) about the guy who figured he'd magically get better just by moving to America — and flopped.
    65AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:48
    Re: #16
    There's already a guy who did exactly that — his name's Roki Sasaki.
    18AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:21
    Was wondering why he wouldn't just go through NPB first, but apparently the Dodgers are offering something like 700 million yen?
    If that's true, yeah, he's going.
    Even if it doesn't pan out, 700 million yen is basically a win on its own.
    24AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:25
    Re: #18
    He's from a single-mother household, so he's got his mom and sister's futures to think about too.
    Though the Giants would still pay a 100 million yen signing bonus.
    39AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:34
    Re: #18
    That's not really what Darvish was saying though.
    No way the Giants let a talent they picked first overall just rot away in A-ball or Double-A.
    35AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:32
    Re: #30
    These days meals and gear are covered by the club, so it's not that different from NPB.
    69AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:49
    Re: #35
    Actually in NPB, players pay for most of their own gear.
    Sponsors only cover it for a handful of star players.
    Satozaki (a former NPB catcher, now a TV commentator) said the same thing.
    38AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:34
    There's almost no upside for the Giants here, but they should do it for the good of Japanese baseball — raise him right and send him off to the majors.
    74AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:52
    Re: #38
    The Giants, player development? Don't make me laugh.
    He'd be way better off going to Chunichi.
    88AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:59
    Re: #74
    'Chuni-Dora'? lmaooo (slang for the Chunichi Dragons)
    55AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:44
    Re: #24
    Well, 500 million yen at most.
    That said, over half of it disappears to taxes and the agent's cut.
    Factor in the cost of living in the minors in the U.S., and there's not that much breathing room left.
    Minor league pay itself is peanuts, and there's no second helping.
    If he wants to make life easier for his mom and sister, succeeding in MLB is the only way.
    64AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:47
    Re: #55
    The agent's cut isn't actually that big.
    68AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:49
    Re: #64
    Obviously the Giants would just pile money onto the agent.
    80AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:54
    Re: #64
    Nowhere near as bad as taxes, sure.
    But even 5% isn't nothing.
    That works out to tens of millions of yen off the top.
    Add in all the other expenses and it really starts to add up.
    57AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:46
    He keeps saying he 'won't waver,' but if he ends up with the Giants, everyone's going to assume there was a secret deal all along.
    61AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:47
    Re: #57
    He's only saying his resolve to eventually try the majors won't waver. In other words, he'll still be demanding something from the Giants down the line when it comes to posting him.
    77AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:53
    He'll go to the minors, and a few years later quietly retire, I bet. I'm guessing everyone's thinking the same thing.
    81AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:55
    Re: #77
    Most high-school draftees in America get a post-retirement scholarship, so they can still go to college afterward.
    They get recommended into a school, with tuition and living costs covered by the club.
    Morii, for instance, was guaranteed a 39 million yen scholarship from the Athletics after he retires.
    83AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:57
    If he joins the Giants as a first-round pick, barring something extreme, he won't get cut before age 25.
    They'll even help find jobs for his sisters, and if his mom wants to remarry, they'll line up a decent match for her too.
    Keep playing in the majors — I mean the first team — and they'll hook him up with a Nippon TV announcer for a wife, plus a front-office job waiting after he retires.
    86AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:59
    Re: #83
    Women from Kyushu tend to stay local, especially in Fukuoka.
    That's why there's a surplus of single women there.
    No need for a Tokyo team to play matchmaker.
    87AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:59
    Morii went to Toho, after all — he was probably eyeing a U.S. college from the start.
    His mother went along with him, so maybe they're a Japanese-American family.
    91AnonymousNov 8, 2026 21:00
    Re: #87
    And he's been at Toho since elementary school, too — must come from a good family.
    94AnonymousNov 8, 2026 21:01
    Re: #87
    In America, even players who get into college on a baseball scholarship often turn pro and then keep taking classes during the off-season, aiming to eventually graduate.
    The club covers tuition during that time.
    There's a well-developed system for letting guys go to college after they retire.
    89AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:59
    Re: #82
    Aside from Nei, they're actually developing pretty well.
    The back half of this season was decent, content-wise.
    If the pitching and hitting click, next year they'll be fighting Hanshin for the A-class spot (3rd place) — with the Giants 1st and the Baystars 2nd.
    Kudo became manager at a good time, in a way; next year they can be competitive no matter who's managing.
    93AnonymousNov 8, 2026 21:01
    Re: #89
    If 'developing pretty well' is the ceiling, that's still below the Giants lol
    99AnonymousNov 8, 2026 21:05
    Funny how former major leaguers, who have zero reason to flatter the Giants, are all saying going through the Giants first is the smarter move.
    Guess they genuinely believe a real top prospect wouldn't just get buried and forgotten there.
    104AnonymousNov 8, 2026 21:08
    Re: #99
    They'd be pouring a huge chunk of their entire under-25 bonus pool just into Oda — that's special treatment.
    The Rangers, of all teams, brought over 10-plus staff and even the guy nicknamed 'Korea's Otani,' a hugely touted prospect, just to sit in on their meeting with Oda.

    Background and Key Points of This Debate

    Under NPB’s draft system, a club can go ahead and pick a player even if he’s publicly stated he wants an American baseball career. Being picked doesn’t obligate a player to sign — refusing restricts his ability to play in Japan for a set period, but it doesn’t block him from signing with an overseas club. Without knowing this, it’s easy to misread the situation as “he got picked, so his own wishes don’t matter,” but a formal greeting meeting is really just the opening move in negotiations — it doesn’t mean his path is locked in. Where the thread split was over whether joining the Giants would end up being a shortcut to the majors or a detour, with one side citing hard numbers like signing bonuses, agents’ cuts, and minor-league living costs, and the other arguing his own wishes should simply be respected. The repeated references to real precedents like Roki Sasaki and Yu Darvish show this kind of debate has played out before.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuho+) thread “Giants to hold formal greeting meeting with Yokohama’s Shoki Oda on the 10th — forced first-round pick despite stated intent to challenge MLB… in talks with multiple MLB clubs.”

  • Ichiro Slams Plan to Move Scorching Koshien Indoors to a Dome — 5ch Split on the Idea

    Ichiro Suzuki, special assistant to the Mariners chairman, reportedly said “Come on, give me a break” when asked about proposals to move Koshien’s tournament to the air-conditioned Kyocera Dome to beat the extreme heat, during a coaching visit to Oita Maizuru High School on November 7-8. He also voiced discomfort with the tiebreaker rule used in extra innings, saying “Having the game suddenly change with runners placed on first and second feels wrong.” On 5ch’s Geinou/Sports News+ board, his comments sparked a broader debate over the pros and cons of heat countermeasures — touching on students being mobilized to cheer in the blazing sun, the brutal conditions at regional qualifying tournaments, and even questions about why Koshien is treated as sacred in the first place.

    Ichiro, on calls to move the scorching-hot Koshien to the Kyocera Dome: “Come on, give me a break” — comments made while coaching at Oita Maizuru High. Also on the tiebreaker rule: “Suddenly having runners on first and second… it feels wrong for the game to change like that”

    Ichiro Suzuki (53), who starred in Major League Baseball with the Mariners and other teams and now serves as special assistant to the Mariners chairman and instructor, visited Oita Maizuru High School in Oita City on the 7th and 8th to coach the school’s baseball team.

    During casual conversation with players at practice on the first day, Ichiro shared his view: “The idea that Koshien is too hot so let’s just use the Kyocera Dome instead — come on, give me a break.”

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    7AnonymousNov 9, 2026 00:50
    The teams at Koshien are already the cream of the crop, culled from thousands of schools — what's the point of coddling just Koshien?
    You're starting from the wrong premise entirely.
    11AnonymousNov 9, 2026 00:51
    It's honestly kind of creepy how everyone treats Koshien like it's sacred.
    12AnonymousNov 9, 2026 00:53
    This tiebreaker rule, seriously…
    it's basically ruining traditional baseball lol
    It only exists to end games faster.
    13AnonymousNov 9, 2026 00:54
    High school baseball won't change until somebody actually dies.
    Though I bet the number of kids willing to play will just keep shrinking before that happens.
    14AnonymousNov 9, 2026 00:54
    Leave it to the guy who rounds up high school girls to use as his practice opponents to have a different take on this, huh.
    16AnonymousNov 9, 2026 00:55
    What are they even going to do if Koshien Stadium gets wiped out by a disaster someday?
    17AnonymousNov 9, 2026 00:55
    They're taking these countermeasures precisely because it's gotten hotter than it used to be.
    22AnonymousNov 9, 2026 00:59
    You're the one being ridiculous, Ichiro.

    Forcing girls to play full 9-inning games shows zero respect for the sport.
    43AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:12
    Re: #22
    Come to think of it, now that Matsui's gone,
    who's going to bat cleanup for Kobe Chiben?
    28AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:02
    It's not just the players who suffer in the heat.
    The students who get basically dragged out there and forced to cheer in the blazing sun have it just as hellish lol
    Ichiro, you need to understand that side of it too!
    97AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:51
    Re: #28 Re: #42
    I wonder if Ichiro realizes his beloved Chiben Wakayama has had mandatory whole-school cheering squads ever since the prefectural qualifiers
    (except for third-years with entrance exams coming up)

    And it's even worse because the local stations TV Wakayama and Wakayama Broadcasting Radio
    have been doing the foolish thing of airing every single prefectural qualifier live since forever

    Then again, Chiben Wakayama is probably the single biggest success story in the high school baseball business —
    they basically locked that in the moment they built their school right next to Kiimidera Stadium, the only venue for the prefectural tournament
    29AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:02
    The idea that Koshien is something special is really just conditioning.
    There was even a time in the past when the national high school tournament wasn't held at Koshien at all.
    33AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:06
    Re: #29
    Yeah, you're right that treating Koshien as something special
    is basically just conditioning.
    What makes it worse is that both the parents' generation and the kids themselves genuinely buy into it.
    42AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:12
    The real issue here isn't the players who actually make it to Koshien — it's the students dragged out to cheer at the brutal regional qualifiers for public schools, the "local Koshiens," who really have it rough.
    The players themselves actually have it easier once they're at Koshien environment-wise, so they're probably fine as is — it's everyone around them that's the problem.
    45AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:13
    Haven't heard anything about the 7-inning idea in a while.
    Did they already give up on that?
    52AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:17
    Re: #45
    They've already rolled it out at the regional rookie tournaments.
    50AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:16
    Koshien is honestly a terrible stadium, but say that out loud and Hanshin Tigers fans lose their minds, so nobody dares say it anymore.
    53AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:18
    Re: #50
    I mean, a logical criticism I'd understand, but if someone just calls it "crap" out of pure emotion, anyone would get mad about that.
    51AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:16
    The soccer Inter-High tournament has teams playing 6 games in 8 days out in the blazing sun too, you know.
    Baseball just gets singled out as a punching bag because it's more high-profile.
    74AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:31
    Re: #51
    But soccer's Inter-High doesn't force the whole school to show up and cheer, does it? Meanwhile brass bands basically get conscripted so hard it's like they're told to skip their own competitions for it.
    63AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:26
    I get that playing at Koshien in the blazing midsummer heat is brutal, but if they move it to the Kyocera Dome, travel costs for the students and parents coming out to cheer would skyrocket.
    75AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:31
    Re: #63
    Osaka and Nishinomiya aren't even that far apart though.
    67AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:26
    If they can't reassure parents about safety, they'll just keep losing ground in the competition to recruit talent.
    If they're fine with that, sure, go ahead and keep insisting on 9 innings and Koshien.
    70AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:28
    Re: #67
    If it's not 9 innings, it's not baseball anymore — it's a different sport entirely.
    69AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:28
    Because for old folks, nothing beats sitting in an air-conditioned room consuming footage of shaved-head kids suffering through military-style training in the brutal heat as feel-good "inspiration porn."
    76AnonymousNov 9, 2026 01:31
    Re: #69
    And then there's scooping up dirt from the field when you lose, or singing the school anthem when you win — it genuinely feels cult-like to me. Are Japanese people just dumb, or have they just gone numb to it? Does nobody find this weird?
    111AnonymousNov 9, 2026 02:06
    Re: #1
    Classic move from Ichiro haters —
    they'd bash him no matter which side of the argument he took.
    113AnonymousNov 9, 2026 02:08
    Re: #111
    Nah, nobody's bashing him.
    If anything, the High School Baseball Federation was the one testing the waters
    to see which way this would go.
    I bet whoever's really pulling the strings behind the scenes is laughing as it spirals into a textbook elite-cult situation.
    117AnonymousNov 9, 2026 02:10
    Re: #111
    I mean, when Ichiro coaches a powerhouse school they bash him for it saying "go coach a weak school instead," and when he coaches a weak school they bash him saying "go coach pros instead." That's the level we're at.

    Background and Key Points of This Debate

    In recent years, discussion of heat countermeasures at Koshien has mostly centered on things like changing the opening-ceremony start time and pitch-count limits, while moving the tournament indoors to a dome has remained an unrealized proposal — which is why Ichiro’s remarks drew attention as pushback against that specific idea. The tiebreaker rule, introduced to high school baseball around 2018 to bring prolonged extra innings to a quicker close, was something Ichiro criticized for feeling abrupt, rather than something he called to abolish outright. The thread split over whether the bigger issue is the burden on the players themselves or the burden on the students and parents mobilized to cheer, with many commenters pointing out that the cheering sections baking in the sun — and the regional qualifiers — are actually tougher than what the players on the field experience. Some also argued that the sense of Koshien being “special” is nothing more than conditioning, with a number of voices questioning the tournament’s whole mythic status. Going by the headlines alone, it’s easy to mistakenly assume Ichiro opposes heat countermeasures altogether — but it’s worth noting his actual complaint was specifically about the dome as a solution.

    *This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “[Baseball] Ichiro on calls to move the scorching Koshien to a dome: “Come on, give me a break” — Also on the tiebreaker rule: “It feels wrong for the game to change like that”.”

  • Panasonic Disbands Its Corporate Baseball Team — Two-Thirds of Players Retire, One-Third Transfer — 5ch: ‘They’re Real Employees After All’

    Panasonic’s storied corporate baseball team suffered a walk-off loss to NTT West in the quarterfinals of the Japan Championship, bringing its 76-year history to a close. Manager Takaharu Inoue fought back tears, saying, “It’s my responsibility that I couldn’t get them the win.” With the team disbanding after this tournament, two-thirds of the roster will retire while one-third will keep playing by transferring to other teams. On 5ch, commenters debated the merits of corporate baseball’s employment system — which lets retired players stay on as regular full-time staff — against the reality that many former athletes struggle to adjust to office life and end up quitting anyway.

    <Corporate Baseball Japan Championship: NTT West 5-4 Panasonic> ◇Nov. 8 ◇Quarterfinal ◇Kyocera Dome Osaka

    Panasonic (Osaka), which is disbanding its team after this tournament, closed out 76 years of team history with a walk-off loss. In an all-Osaka showdown against NTT West — runner-up at this summer’s Intercity Tournament — Panasonic clawed back from a 3-run deficit at one point, only to fall in the bottom of the 9th. The winning run came home on a wild pitch by 24-year-old right-hander Seiya Kakimoto, a 152 km/h (94 mph) flamethrower who was taken by the Seibu Lions with their second-round draft pick.

    Manager Takaharu Inoue, 35, didn’t second-guess himself for calling on Kakimoto — who had started two games this tournament and helped the team reach the final eight — out of the bullpen: “I had him pitch in a crucial spot, and I have absolutely no regrets. If Kakimoto couldn’t pull it off, there was nothing more to be done.” His eyes welled up as he added, “It’s painful to see it end here, but everyone fought without giving up right to the finish. It’s my responsibility that I couldn’t get them the win.”

    Source: nikkansports.com / Original article here

    2AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:43
    Honestly, I'd rather watch an Osaka night-view video channel on YouTube than watch Peace-kun from Omiya Park (a famously hyperactive peacock livestreamed from a Saitama zoo).
    3AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:46
    Corporate baseball beats pro baseball, honestly — they just keep you employed after you retire.
    7AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:54
    Re: #3
    That's exactly why some parents say 'no going straight to the pros, but corporate ball is fine' — though in the end that player got drafted this year and is heading pro anyway.
    12AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:58
    Re: #3
    Most of them are just contract employees, and even the full-timers often can't adjust to office life and end up quitting. It's awkward being surrounded by highly educated coworkers. Even Shohei Ohtani's dad quit Mitsubishi Heavy Industries right after retiring from baseball.
    4AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:48
    Don't need 'baseball' (yakyu — written mockingly) when we've got soccer, volleyball, and rugby.
    15AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:00
    Re: #4
    Well, that's one way to look at it, but you could also call it a dark future for soccer, volleyball, and rugby as professional sports — if their pro leagues end up operating at the same level as baseball's corporate teams, now and going forward.
    5AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:49
    Corporate baseball exists purely for company PR, so why brand it with a grand name like the 'Intercity Tournament'?
    11AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:57
    Re: #5
    Because the teams represent their cities.
    6AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:50
    Forget all that — Gamba Osaka has dropped into the relegation zone.
    8AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:55
    Baseball's declining again, huh. It just keeps shrinking.
    10AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:56
    Re: #1
    For people who claim baseball is popular — what's the excuse for why NPB's farm teams, the independent leagues, and corporate ball have zero popularity?
    71AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:42
    Re: #10
    In the Osaka area, the Hanshin Tigers are huge! But there's a group of fans who couldn't care less about Ohtani — Tigers for life, nothing else!
    72AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:43
    Re: #71
    The Kansai TV ratings for the Climax Series against Yokohama were low, and last year's Japan Series against the Hawks was down too.
    77AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:52
    Re: #71
    I bet there isn't a single person in Japan who actually thinks baseball as a sport is interesting in itself.
    13AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:58
    I know people close to me who played corporate/industrial-league baseball, and most haven't had great lives after retiring. A lot of the JR West/East guys do stick around with the company, though.
    14AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:58
    Wait, what!? That nationally beloved, super-popular sport, baseball!?
    16AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:01
    At least if they have somewhere to work afterward, they won't end up doing anything stupid — that's a plus.
    18AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:03
    With the NOMO Baseball Club gone too, corporate ball's escape routes are getting pretty well sealed off.
    25AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:09
    Re: #15
    Gamba Osaka's average salary is actually higher than the Orix Buffaloes'. And the gap in the median is overwhelming. Pro baseball has a high Gini coefficient — same deal in the US. Among the four major US pro leagues, MLB stands out as having by far the highest Gini coefficient, the most unequal of them all.
    27AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:15
    Re: #25
    That's all just fantasy, lol. Orix gets covered during contract-renewal negotiations so we get estimated salary figures, but soccer has nothing like that at all, lol. And after all the bragging about 300 or 400 million yen, when the actual rankings of every Japanese athlete's income come out, those supposed 300-400 million yen J.League guys don't even make the list, lol. Even table tennis and badminton players rank in!
    32AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:18
    Re: #27
    Don't you think that income ranking itself might just be wrong?
    35AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:19
    Re: #27
    >we get estimated figures

    That's exactly what 'fantasy' means.
    30AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:16
    Is that why SoftBank drafts so many players onto its developmental (ikusei) roster?
    57AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:34
    Re: #30
    Apparently even if you get cut from SoftBank's developmental roster, SoftBank the telecom company will hire you, so it might not be that different from going to an amateur team like NTT East/West. Telecom companies also hire plenty of staff with just a high school diploma for on-site work, so you probably wouldn't feel too out of place.
    61AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:36
    Re: #57
    SoftBank's developmental cast-offs mostly just end up working at company-run phone shops, lol.
    73AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:45
    Re: #57
    The ones doing fieldwork go to subsidiaries or telecom construction contractors.
    33AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:18
    Baseball (yakyu, said mockingly) is done for — even Ohtani's starting to decline.
    37AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:21
    Re: #33
    Soccer's probably going to keep losing out to Ohtani alone again next year. With Matsui now a manager on top of Ohtani, even Japanese baseball overall gets a boost.
    40AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:24
    The real upside of corporate baseball is that it's unbeatable PR for B2B companies. Even some obscure parts maker or infrastructure company nobody's ever heard of becomes a household name overnight if they make it to the Intercity Tournament at the Dome and get on TV.
    45AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:26
    Re: #40
    Most of the crowd at the Intercity Tournament is just employees the companies mobilized. Corporate baseball genuinely has no popularity.
    47AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:27
    The J.League's own official figures put the average salary at 48 million yen.
    50AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:29
    Re: #47
    It's in the J.League Club Management Guide.
    48AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:28
    Re: #1
    With such a long history, they've only won the title or been runner-up a handful of times… And this is supposedly top-tier corporate baseball in the Kansai region?
    53AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:31
    Re: #48
    Is that a dig at Hanshin? Even competing in a league of just 6, then 12, teams, they've been matched in championship count by Vissel Kobe — a club with far less history and way more rivals to beat, lol.
    58AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:35
    Guys who've done nothing but baseball since childhood — there's no way they can function as regular office workers.
    62AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:37
    Re: #58
    At my company, before they disbanded the team, guys would just become regular employees once they retired. Some even became top salesmen. That's because they were already doing company work during the off-season anyway.
    59AnonymousNov 8, 2026 20:35
    In most other sports they're contract workers who usually get let go once they retire, but here they're real employees.

    Background and Talking Points

    Corporate baseball teams are run by companies mainly for advertising and employee-welfare purposes, and the fact that most players get full-time employee status rather than contract status is a major difference from how professional sports employ athletes. That’s the basis for the thread’s view that players “can stay on with the company after retirement” — though some commenters also note that many don’t adjust well and leave anyway, so stability isn’t necessarily guaranteed. The thread drifted away from the actual disbandment news into comparisons of NPB and J.League attendance and salaries, and debates about “baseball’s declining popularity” — a separate issue from the realities of corporate baseball itself. The thread never actually addresses the direct reasons behind the disbandment, such as the company’s management decisions or cuts to team funding.</parameter>

    </invoke>

    *This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geisports Speed+) thread “[Corporate Baseball] Disbanding Panasonic Sees Two-Thirds of Players Retire and One-Third Move On via Transfer for a Second Baseball Life.”

  • Oda to Meet with the Giants on the 10th — Sudden Reversal Has 5ch Buzzing ‘Yomiuri vs. Dentsu’

    Oda, a highly touted high-school prospect, is reportedly set to hold a courtesy meeting with the Yomiuri Giants on the 10th — a sudden reversal from what had widely been assumed to be a done deal for an MLB challenge, and the news set 5ch abuzz. In the thread, posters debated everything tied to the career decision: the scale of the signing bonus, the harsh realities of minor-league life in the U.S., and the career paths of players who go through NPB before heading overseas. Many pointed to Shohei Ohtani and Roki Sasaki as examples of how hard it is to jump straight to MLB out of high school, while others argued the decision shouldn’t be made on bonus money alone.

    1AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:17
    Regarding the possibility that he was asked to make a courtesy visit after being drafted: "Talks (with MLB clubs) had been scheduled to continue until the 17th, but there's a chance this is a sudden change of plans.
    2AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:21
    Oda, man, I believed in you.
    Let's aim for the majors five years from now!
    6AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:27
    If you don't have the talent, you're better off not going through Japan first.
    14AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:32
    Re: #6
    Depends on the goal, doesn't it
    If you want a long career as a pro ballplayer, going through NPB is the better bet
    8AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:29
    Yomiuri vs. Dentsu
    102AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:27
    I don't know the details, but it's only natural for a high schooler to waver
    Especially after seeing Re: #8
    15AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:32
    Isn't success as a baseball player not even Oda's ultimate goal to begin with?
    If so, he's better off moving to the US young and building a foundation and connections there
    35AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:46
    Re: #15
    If that's the case, going with Yomiuri makes even more sense — he can build connections and secure his future
    Doesn't Matsui still hold some kind of position with the Yankees?
    38AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:46
    Is it "tch, what a pain…"
    or "there's no contract as good as I thought"?
    41AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:48
    Re: #38
    If money's the priority, going through NPB is the only choice
    42AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:48
    Better to take the ¥800 million, right?
    He'd get a dedicated interpreter, so there's no reason to stick around Japan
    43AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:51
    Re: #42
    Does he actually get one?
    48AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:54
    Re: #42
    It's a world where some guys never pan out and retire after about five years
    If MLB is offering a signing bonus of like ¥700 million, going straight to MLB might actually be the lower-risk option
    57AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:00
    Re: #42
    "Possibly up to ¥800 million!" is just hype getting ahead of the story — realistically it's more like ¥200-300 million
    51AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:57
    Possibility that in talks with MLB clubs he was told he'd start in the Rookie League, and thought "wait, that's not what I was told"
    64AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:03
    Re: #51
    Rookie League → Single-A → Double-A → Triple-A → the majors

    That's almost certainly a non-negotiable condition the MLB club laid out

    That route is just how it works, but maybe as a sheltered high schooler he was dreaming of an instant "straight-to-the-majors debut!"
    52AnonymousNov 8, 2026 18:58
    To begin with, minor leaguers aren't in the minors because they want to be
    They're all desperate to get out as soon as possible
    Being in the minors doesn't automatically make you better either
    58AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:00
    Re: #52
    That's not necessarily true though

    The ball itself is different over there to begin with, so I get wanting to adjust to it as soon as possible
    60AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:00
    Even if Ohtani had skipped the Fighters and gone straight to the US, he almost certainly wouldn't have the fame or skill he has now
    61AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:01
    Re: #60
    At the end of the day, without going through NPB you just don't get name recognition in Japan
    71AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:09
    The ¥800 million figure is getting ahead of things, but if they pay Oda alone ¥800 million, they can't sign anyone else
    Is he really considered the kind of player worth betting the entire budget on?
    72AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:11
    Re: #71
    He is that caliber of a player
    78AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:12
    Honestly, what a waste
    Does today's NPB even have value?
    81AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:14
    Re: #78
    Why do you think NPB has no value?
    Ohtani and Yamamoto alone send its value through the roof
    80AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:14
    If Oda could pitch for the Dodgers starting next season, it'd be worth going
    84AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:16
    Re: #80
    There's just no way that happens
    Even starting out in NPB, he wouldn't be putting up numbers like that in year one
    89AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:21
    Re: #80
    There's no way a guy straight out of high school jumps straight to the majors lol
    If you don't know how the MLB system works, keep quiet
    82AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:14
    He'll get paid, sure, but can he actually make it from the minors to the majors?
    93AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:23
    Re: #82
    Is the minor-league development system still built on that "hunger" mentality — basically "claw your way up yourself"?
    Being properly developed within a club's own farm system seems like it'd be more cost-effective
    92AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:22
    You basically never see high-school rookies in the majors
    Actually, you don't see college rookies either
    Even the big-name rookies who made headlines don't get called up to the majors until they prove themselves in the minors
    Even Mizorowski (ed.: a prospect who came up through junior college), spent three years in the minors
    Oda isn't a physical elite type, so it'll probably take him five-plus years
    For an 18-year-old who grew up comfortably in Japan and can't speak English, five years of minor-league life sounds pretty rough
    96AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:23
    Re: #92
    Even if everything goes smoothly, it'll take at least three years to get up to the majors over there
    108AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:32
    Re: #92
    To begin with, in American sports going to college is the norm, so there aren't many pros straight out of high school
    The only guys who turn pro out of high school are the ones with family circumstances forcing it, or who are too far behind academically for college to be worth it, or who'd get cut off by NCAA eligibility rules anyway
    100AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:27
    Some people seem to think the majors and minors are just like Japan's top team and farm team, where talent alone gets you promoted right away, but in reality there are something like eight levels
    105AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:30
    Re: #100
    A minor-league contract is basically like Japan's developmental-player contract
    And each club has over 200 of those players
    Even SoftBank, which is known for fierce competition, has only about 50
    110AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:36
    If throwing a fast ball alone were enough to make it in the majors, Roki would already be the Dodgers' ace by now
    114AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:40
    Re: #110
    He is making it work though
    112AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:37
    How much was Sasaki's signing bonus again?
    At the end of the day the guy threw an NPB perfect game — he's a monster, a different class from Oda
    115AnonymousNov 8, 2026 19:40
    Re: #112
    He was 23 when he went over, so $6.5 million
    He's taking a massive pay cut relative to his talent

    Background and Key Points of Debate

    When a high schooler signs directly with an MLB club after graduation instead of going through NPB, they typically start out in the Rookie League or Single-A/Double-A ball, and it usually takes several years to reach the majors — in the thread, Roki Sasaki’s signing bonus (about $6.5 million) from when he posted to a US club came up as a point of comparison. Going through NPB lets a player build a track record and name recognition via the registered-roster and developmental systems, while going straight to the US means facing fierce competition, with each club carrying roughly 200 players on minor-league contracts. Where the thread split was over whether the reported signing bonus figures alone are enough to judge the merits of going to the US, with some suggesting the widely reported “up to ¥800 million” figure is getting ahead of the story and the real number is more like ¥200-300 million. The actual circumstances behind the career decision itself await an announcement from Oda or those involved, and the thread’s discussion remains limited to a general comparison of the NPB and MLB systems.

    ※This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “Oda-kun to visit the Giants on the 10th — sudden change of plans?!“.

  • Ichiro Hits .353 for His NPB Career—But Doesn’t Qualify for the All-Time Ranking, Baffled to Learn He’s 381 At-Bats Short

    Ichiro, who serves as Special Assistant to the Chairman of the Mariners, appeared in a video on the official “Power Pros / Pro Spirits” YouTube channel, and when asked who holds the highest career batting average in NPB history, he reacted with “Huh, is that me?” But it turns out his own .353 career average falls 381 at-bats short of the “4,000-at-bat minimum” required to qualify for the all-time rankings, so he isn’t even counted. The “-381” in the headline refers to that shortfall. On 5ch, opinions split over whether batting-average eligibility should be based on at-bats or plate appearances, and over how to weigh Ichiro’s unusually high number of infield hits.

    Ichiro Baffled by His .353 Average: “Isn’t That Me?”—The Shocking “Not Qualified,” and the “-381” That Comes With Being a Genius

    Appears on the official “Power Pros / Pro Spirits” channel… “Guys like Leon Lee, or Leron Lee…”

    Ichiro, Special Assistant to the Chairman and instructor for the Mariners, appeared in a video on the official “Power Pros / Pro Spirits” YouTube channel. Asked who recorded the highest career batting average, he reacted with “Huh, is that me?” But his own .353 career average left him outside the all-time rankings.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    2AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:06
    Watching Rei Lanlan (who pulls in ¥570 million a year) on YouTube beats watching Peace-kun from Omiya Park (a local park mascot) any day.
    5AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:17
    Just bring him back to NPB for one year and pad his at-bats up to 4000.
    Even batting under .100 the whole time, he'd still be the all-time #1 by a mile.
    18AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:41
    Re: #5
    Re: #14
    Doing the math, if he got just 3 hits in 381 at-bats, he'd clear the bar to take the top spot.
    6AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:18
    Even if you had him take 400 plate appearances right now, he'd probably still hit something like .280 without even trying.
    7AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:22
    Doesn't a walk not count as an at-bat?
    If so, that seems unfair to guys with a good batting eye—they'd end up excluded.
    At-bats should be fine as the standard.
    17AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:39
    Re: #7
    I think walks count toward plate appearances but not toward at-bats, right?
    44AnonymousNov 8, 2026 12:30
    Re: #7
    That's exactly why OPS—where walks are a huge factor—started getting valued so much.
    49AnonymousNov 8, 2026 12:49
    Re: #7
    A walk counts as a plate appearance but not an at-bat.
    If that's the case, it seems unfair to guys with a good eye, or guys who get pitched around—their at-bat count drops.
    The standard should just be plate appearances.

    If that were the case, I'd agree.
    10AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:31
    Re: #6
    A .700 batting average?!
    42AnonymousNov 8, 2026 12:22
    Re: #10
    You'd think any baseball fan would just read that as .280.
    55AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:06
    Re: #42
    He obviously knows that and is writing it that way on purpose.
    66AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:32
    Re: #42
    I get it, but I'd still prefer batting averages written with the decimal point, like ".280".
    11AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:33
    Whoever says it should be at-bats and not plate appearances clearly doesn't know baseball.
    38AnonymousNov 8, 2026 12:13
    Re: #11
    Well, for a single season the qualifying standard is plate appearances.
    14AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:36
    At 4000 at-bats with 1278 hits, that's .3195—just barely good enough for 2nd place.
    20AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:42
    I want to try chasing a 1.000 batting average: 4000 plate appearances, 1 hit, 3999 walks/HBPs.
    24AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:53
    Re: #20
    Impossible unless you've got an insanely good eye and are a master at fouling pitches off.
    21AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:49
    Top 10 all-time batting average (min. 2000 at-bats)

    .353 Ichiro (3619 AB, 1278 H)
    .337 Bass (2208 AB, 743 H)
    .327 Yoshida Masataka (2703 AB, 884 H)
    .325 R. Rose (3929 AB, 1275 H)
    .321 Cromartie (2961 AB, 951 H)
    .320 Lee (4934 AB, 1579 H)
    .31918 Wakamatsu Tsutomu (6808 AB, 2173 H)
    .31915 Harimoto Isao (9666 AB, 3085 H)
    .317 Boomer (4451 AB, 1413 H)
    .3150 O'Malley (2603 AB, 820 H)
    43AnonymousNov 8, 2026 12:28
    Re: #21
    Bass was ridiculously slow and had almost no infield hits, while Ichiro, by contrast, turned a ton of infield grounders into hits—so you can kind of tell what the "real" rankings and numbers would look like.
    47AnonymousNov 8, 2026 12:37
    Re: #21
    I thought Harry's career at-bat count was insane, but then there's a monster named Katsuya Nomura ranked above him.
    https://npb.jp/bis/history/ltb_ab.html
    87AnonymousNov 8, 2026 14:01
    Re: #21
    Huh? Tanizawa Kenichi isn't on here. He was always battling Wakamatsu for the batting title with averages over .350.
    Though these days he's a total old man.
    29AnonymousNov 8, 2026 11:56
    Ichiro: "If a .220 average is fine, I can hit 40 home runs."
    Fans: "What's even the point of that (lol)"

    Today

    Murakami: .207, 35 HR
    Okamoto: .232, 33 HR
    Fans: "Great job!"


    Why is that?
    36AnonymousNov 8, 2026 12:09
    Re: #29
    Back then it wasn't yet an era where OPS got valued.
    If today's style had been fine back then, I feel like guys such as Joshima and Iguchi could've easily hit 30+ home runs too.
    46AnonymousNov 8, 2026 12:33
    Re: #29
    Fans over there (in MLB) genuinely seem pretty okay with that approach.
    Satoteru (nickname for Yakult's Murakami Munetaka) will probably keep swinging for the fences the same way.
    Well, honestly, Ohtani's the same type too.
    37AnonymousNov 8, 2026 12:10
    Season batting average is qualified by plate appearances, yet the career batting average standard is based on at-bats—that mismatch is what's causing all this. Just change the "4000+ at-bats" minimum to "4000+ plate appearances." Ichiro would become the overwhelming #1, and Robert Rose would probably move up the list too.
    51AnonymousNov 8, 2026 12:59
    My favorite Ichiro season is '95.
    He came so close to winning the Triple Crown.
    54AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:05
    Re: #51
    He'd just end up being called the worst Triple Crown winner in history.
    57AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:11
    I heard Ichiro didn't get along with manager Doi and had a hard time getting called up to the first team.
    61AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:26
    Re: #57
    I used to think that too, but apparently that's not really the case.
    Doi actually used him on the first team fairly often and gave him chances, but Ichiro just couldn't deliver.
    I remember seeing him come in as a pinch hitter in Kobe, maybe his second pro year—he looked scrawny and unreliable and made a quick, easy out.
    Though he was completely dominant in the minors.
    86AnonymousNov 8, 2026 14:00
    Re: #57
    Both his first and second years he played in 40+ first-team games, but with no results to show for it he got sent back down.
    70AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:41
    Tony Gwynn
    Career average: .338 (3141 hits)
    Infield hits: 282 (approx. 9%)
    "Real" average: .307

    Ichiro
    Career average: .311 (3089 hits)
    Infield hits: 713 (approx. 23%)
    "Real" average: .239
    75AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:44
    Re: #70
    What even is a "real" batting average? 😂
    80AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:52
    Re: #70
    To begin with, sabermetrics generally holds that whether a ball hit into the infield turns into a hit or an out has a strong element of luck—
    so you could actually argue it's more impressive to beat out a ball hit right at an infielder using sheer athleticism.
    76AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:45
    Re: #1
    They should just use something like 1000+ hits.
    Why's it 4000 at-bats, a number nobody can even picture?
    78AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:48
    Re: #76
    Kaneda: "It's because I won 400 games."
    Probably this. (A joking nod to pitcher Masaichi Kaneda's 400 career wins.)
    82AnonymousNov 8, 2026 13:54
    Re: #76
    That's precisely to exclude the foreign hired guns who played before the Lee brothers.

    Background and Key Points of Debate

    The NPB career batting average rankings require a minimum of 4,000 career at-bats to qualify, and Ichiro falls 381 at-bats short, leaving him outside the list. The biggest point of debate in the thread was the inconsistency between single-season averages, which are qualified by a plate-appearance minimum, and the career ranking, which alone uses at-bats. Some pointed out that an at-bats-based standard disadvantages batters who draw a lot of walks, while others calculated that switching to a plate-appearance standard would make Ichiro the overwhelming No. 1. Opinions also clashed over Ichiro’s high number of infield hits: some argued his “real” average is lower than it looks because of them, while others countered that turning infield grounders into hits is itself a form of skill. His old remark that he could have hit 40 home runs if a .220 average were acceptable also reads, in hindsight, as ahead of its time given today’s power-focused trends. As for where the “4,000 at-bats” threshold itself comes from, some in the thread guessed it’s a nod to Masaichi Kaneda’s 400 career wins—though that’s just speculation, not an official explanation.

    *This article is composed from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geisoku+) thread “[Baseball] Ichiro Baffled by His .353 Career Average: “Isn’t That Me?”—The Shocking “Not Qualified,” and the “-381” That Comes With Being a Genius.”

  • TBS’s “Sunday Morning” Skips Giants’ New Manager Matsui for 3rd Straight Week, Fueling Speculation

    TBS’s “Sunday Morning” once again skipped any mention of Giants’ new manager Hideki Matsui in its November 8 broadcast, marking the third straight week the topic has gone untouched. The show covered a retirement special for pitcher Masanori Ishikawa, Samurai Japan, figure skating, and ekiden relay races, but Matsui’s name and footage were nowhere to be seen. Since the show had reported on the Giants’ new coaching hires just last week, buzz has grown on social media that the omission is deliberate, and posts speculating on the reasons have piled up on 5ch’s Entertainment & Sports News+ board.

    TBS’s “Sunday Morning” aired on the 8th, and for the third consecutive week it did not touch on the topic of Giants’ new manager Hideki Matsui.

    The episode featured Yakult pitcher Masanori Ishikawa, who is retiring from active play at the end of this season. Right from the start, the show covered baseball-world topics like Samurai Japan under new manager Tadahito Iguchi and Hiromu Ito’s bid for the majors. It then moved on to figure skating, kendo, ekiden, golf, and other topics.

    Finally, the show circled back to baseball at the end. It covered a wrap-up of Ishikawa’s old team Yakult and more on Samurai Japan, but once again Manager Matsui didn’t come up.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Read the original article here

    2AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:38
    Isn't it that the Giants side itself is refusing to give interviews?
    5AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:39
    Re: #2
    I feel like I've seen an article like that.
    Though that might've been a different story.
    8AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:42
    Re: #2
    There's an unverified, sourceless rumor going around that it's not the Giants but Matsui's personal sponsors who said no.
    4AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:39
    Did Godzilla (Matsui's nickname) burn some bridge with TBS in the past?
    14AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:45
    Re: #4
    But it's only Sunday Morning doing this.
    Mysterious.
    19AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:47
    Re: #4
    Well, it is the BayStars' network.
    44AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:53
    Re: #4
    Yesterday's News 7days and the sports show right after it actually gave him a decent amount of airtime.
    12AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:44
    Honestly the media's already as relentless about him as they were with Ohtani, so it's fine if they skip it.
    If it were the "Watanabe Channel" (a jab at Nippon TV, nicknamed after Yomiuri's longtime boss Tsuneo Watanabe, who's tight with the Giants), sure, they'd cover it — but it's a different story for TBS, Fuji, TV Asahi, and TV Tokyo to go chasing it.
    104AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:06
    Re: #12
    They're doing bits like "When will the No. 90 jersey unveiling happen?" but who cares.
    I've got zero attachment to a player's uniform number.
    15AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:45
    Has this show ever covered a new J.League manager?
    20AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:47
    Re: #15
    Comparing it to one of Japan's minor sports is a bit much…
    111AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:08
    Re: #15
    If Honda ever became a manager, I bet they'd cover that plenty.
    24AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:47
    I happened to catch it today and was shocked — they call it "sports news" but it was just endless baseball.
    The season's over, come on, surely there's something else to cover.
    130AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:13
    Re: #24
    Something else… sumo? Rugby?
    31AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:49
    If I were in Uehara's shoes, I'd ask the producer, "Why?"
    38AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:51
    Re: #31
    That kind of thing gets explained by the producer before you even go on air.
    That's why Uehara tweeted on X, "Ask the show."
    40AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:52
    Re: #31
    There's a chance Uehara himself is the reason.
    36AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:50
    No, to be precise, you should say it's either Takako Zenba or Yumi Karahashi who had some kind of run-in with Hideki Matsui.
    56AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:56
    Re: #36
    Yumi Karahashi posted (then quickly deleted):

    "As for what the show covers, it's not all something I can explain based on my own personal judgment — there are some tricky aspects to it…"

    so between those two, I'd bet it's Zenba.
    64AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:58
    Re: #36
    Isn't it just a staff decision, plain and simple?
    42AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:52
    Why's everyone talking like baseball is the default topic?
    There's no way someone like Matsui succeeds as a manager.
    Ohtani's on the decline and the end of baseball's dominance is in sight, so networks are going to stop covering baseball going forward.
    This is just the first sign of that.
    54AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:55
    Re: #42
    If that's the logic, then they should be covering in-season sports like the B.League or figure skating instead.
    Even the Tenno Sho (a top-tier Japanese horse race) had its star horse crash out of contention (though it wasn't some total long shot either), and it still didn't get Matsui-level coverage.
    60AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:58
    Aren't the Giants a Nippon TV team?
    90AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:03
    Re: #60
    Right? Why would TBS need to go all-out promoting them?
    112AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:08
    Re: #60

    That's beside the point — other TBS shows cover Hideki Matsui just fine.
    66AnonymousNov 8, 2026 09:58
    Baseball-obsessed uncles and aunties are a minority.
    Most of society has zero interest in sports.
    Most of the resentment out there comes from broadcasts running long or other shows getting bumped because of it.

    Go get a whiff of how the real world feels 😂😂😂
    88AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:03
    Re: #66
    There were people who superficially played along like baseball fans but gave totally clueless answers the moment you asked for details.
    92AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:03
    Re: #66
    The article's whole point is that on TBS, it's specifically Sunday Morning "alone" that isn't covering it.

    Yesterday's Joho 7 Days News Caster ran a feature on Giants' Matsui and Chunichi's Kudoh.
    74AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:00
    If this keeps up once the season starts, that takes some nerve.
    Actually, is TBS even okay with letting this slide?
    94AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:04
    Re: #74
    It'd be hilarious if the game footage ends up centered on SoftBank and Chunichi (or Hanshin?), with the Giants only getting a mention for the final score.
    79AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:01
    Re: #1

    And zero coverage of the U-17 Little Nadeshiko news too…
    There's already too much baseball talk as it is, and on top of that Matsui gets zero — it's laughable at this point, this has to be deliberate.

    J.League and soccer stories get next to nothing.
    Well, today they did run a story on the FIFA presidential race, but it was deflating watching a commentator who usually attacks the ruling party talk about it with such a smug look.
    86AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:02
    Re: #79
    Soccer just doesn't have the demand.
    Japan's a baseball country.
    128AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:12
    Sunday Morning's sports segment is meant to report on that week's results and match content — it's not a show for reporting on a specific team's personnel moves or a new manager mingling with fans.
    147AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:16
    Re: #128
    Last week they did mention Shimizu and Takahashi's coaching appointments by name, but they still showed zero of Matsui's name or footage.
    142AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:16
    A) TBS dislikes Matsui
    B) Matsui is refusing TBS

    Which is it?
    It'd make sense if Nippon TV disliked Matsui as a "traitor" to the Giants, but since he's come back, that whole traitor business should be water under the bridge.
    165AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:20
    Re: #142
    Sunday Morning says no but Sunday Japon says yes, so the problem is on Sunday Morning's end.
    150AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:17
    Sunday Morning is produced by TBS's News Division, while Sunday Japon and Hiruobi are made by the Information Programming Division — so something must have happened between the News Division and Manager Matsui.
    154AnonymousNov 8, 2026 10:18
    Re: #150
    They did run a Matsui feature on Hodo Tokushu (also a News Division show), so that theory doesn't hold up.

    Background and Key Points of the Debate

    Some in the thread point out that Sunday Morning is produced by TBS’s News Division, and its sports segment is meant to cover “that week’s results” rather than report on personnel news. On the other hand, last week the show did name the Giants’ newly hired coaches (Shimizu and Takahashi), and the fact that Manager Matsui alone got neither name nor footage is strengthening the view that the omission is deliberate. Even within the TBS network, shows like Sunday Japon and Hiruobi (produced by the Information Programming Division) cover Manager Matsui without issue, making it look like only the News Division’s programs are avoiding him — and that’s the crux of the debate. Unverified rumors (such as a veto from sponsor circles) have also surfaced, but without any confirmation they remain speculation for now. There’s also a view that since the Giants belong to the Nippon TV network, TBS has no particular obligation to cover a rival network’s team — but that doesn’t square with the fact that other TBS shows cover Matsui without any trouble.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Entertainment & Sports News+) thread “Wait, Again?! TBS’s “Sunday Morning” Skips Giants’ Manager Matsui for 3rd Straight Week — Social Media Stirs: “Is It Deliberate, or Is There Another Reason?”.”