From our other sites
The story
A thread titled “Aren’t the current top two most popular members of Hello! Project Oda Sakura and Danbara Ruru?” appeared on 5ch’s Hello! Project board. Replies kept comparing concrete metrics — differences in how fast Danbara Ruru’s and Inoue Rion’s birthday events sold out, Instagram follower counts, TV appearance numbers — and a counterargument emerged that “the real top two right now are Ebata Fumika and Kawashima Mifu.” Posters also debated the link between singing ability and popularity, and the idea that a member’s true popularity only becomes clear after she graduates, turning the very definition of “popularity” within Hello! Project into the central question.
What people said
Danbara's got demand because of her singing, but in terms of actual "favorite member" rate, she's probably not #1.
She only clawed her way to the top late in her run, after everyone above her moved up and out.
In reality she spent a long stretch as a mid-tier member.
Michishige was on top too, by that logic.
She wasn't actually on top — Tanaka and Sayashi were still around.
Oda only ended up on top because everyone above her disappeared.
Both Danbara and Inoue held birthday events at KT Zepp Yokohama this year — Danbara sold out both sessions in the first wave, while Inoue had unsold seats left in the first session (though it did sell out eventually). So Danbara's more popular.
And the fact that she's being lumped in with Oda suggests this thread isn't really about SNS popularity or general popularity anyway.
Maybe it's all that smug center-position posing.
I'm curious how far Danbara, Inoue, Kudo, Matsunaga, Ebata, and Kawashima could each go if you let them do solo events with zero cap on venue size.
But isn't that the same for Oda too?
If people don't want to hear you sing, it doesn't matter how popular you were while active — you fade fast after graduating, like Sato Masaki did.
So basically, Sato Masaki wasn't actually popular.
though Kawashima gets more of that.
That's just Hello! Project otaku pretending to be outsiders.
There's even a chance her scale is smaller than Karin-chan's (Miyamoto Karin) now.
Miyamoto is less popular than Arisawa these days though.
Isn't that just because "Sakura no Shirabe" (her solo song) is the only thing selling?
For her 10th anniversary, she tried to hold an event where she wouldn't sing for once, but ticket applications completely flopped.
She ended up caving and announcing she'd reluctantly sing after all.
It exposed that she's just riding on the popularity of the music itself.
Juice=Juice is already at the phase where even a low-key event sells easily, though.
Then again, it's kind of cool that her singing is in that much demand.
Well, the #2 most popular these days is Nonaka…
Guess the times have changed.
I feel like Nonaka's actually the one more people support out of obligation.
The reasons for backing her feel more negative than with Oda.
Even her solo sales are partly driven by her herniated disc — nobody knows if she'll have to quit, so they buy tickets while they can.
It's surprising that Sato still holds onto a solid base of otaku even with such a long hiatus and barely any activity.
That's just her leaving herself an excuse — "I'm simply not actively working right now."
Even that got crushed by Tsunku.
Then that just means she's popular among Hello! Project otaku.
Which was correct all along.
That's just because she's keeping her activity limited.
I checked her Instagram follower count and it's still only 54,000.
Suzuki Airi has never had health problems, so she's fully earned the staff's trust on that front too.
Background and Key Points of the Debate
Hello! Project has no official popularity poll or ranking, so fans have no choice but to infer “popularity” from indirect metrics like how fast solo birthday event tickets sell out, Instagram follower counts, and TV appearance numbers. The reason the “Oda Sakura and Danbara Ruru” theory and the “Ebata Fumika and Kawashima Mifu” theory coexisted in the thread is that the conclusion shifts depending on which metric you treat as the standard. There’s also a structural issue behind why the discussion never quite lined up: the longer a member’s career, the more her image of “past popularity” tends to stick, which often creates a gap between that image and her actual current sales or social media response.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “Current Hello! Project Top Two → Oda Sakura, Danbara Ruru ← This.”

Leave a Reply