Dutch Court Bans China’s BYD SUV Over Design Resemblance to Land Rover

From our other sites

The story

A Dutch court has ruled that a Chinese BYD-made SUV bears too close a resemblance to Land Rover’s popular “Defender” model and has banned its sale across Europe. Overseas commenters on Lemmy compared the two vehicles in the images cited in the ruling and split into two camps: skeptics asking “is it really that similar?” and wondering if this is just protectionism in disguise, versus those arguing that if BYD deliberately tweaked the design bit by bit to avoid looking too similar, that would indeed be a problem. The thread also brought up reports that BYD’s European offices had been raided, as well as the classic example of the Mazda Miata drawing inspiration from the Lotus Elan, sparking a broader debate about where “copying” ends and “inspiration” begins.

A Dutch court has banned the sale of a Chinese-made SUV in Europe for resembling the Land Rover Defender

Source: reuters.com / Read the original article here

What people said

2Anonymous2026-11-21 04:05
The article doesn't actually show both cars side by side, so here are the vehicles in question.
[image][image]
They're similar, sure, but honestly it's a pretty vague kind of similar. If you called it a 'Chinese Land Rover' I'd get what you mean, but it's not like you'd actually mistake one for the other. This looks like a protectionist rationale to me.
https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/de882d17-c37d-4586-abb0-12a07490a8ae.jpeg
https://lemmy.ml/pictrs/image/d0c5809b-acc0-4fdc-995c-d2bb666af32e.jpeg
5Anonymous2026-11-21 08:09
Re: #2
I think the gist of the accusation is this: BYD started from Land Rover's design and then tweaked it just enough to claim 'it's different enough' — kind of like a student copying someone's homework but changing just enough to avoid getting caught. If that's actually true, it's a real problem.
6Anonymous2026-11-21 09:54
Re: #2
Wait, is one of those plastic hunks of junk in the photo supposed to be the current Land Rover Defender? Honestly they should've just banned both outright. Nobody needs either of those eyesores.
7Anonymous2026-11-21 07:20
Re: #2
Honestly, neither one looks like a Defender to me. Where did that boxy look go? What about the little side windows on the roof?
3Anonymous2026-11-21 07:41
Both of them should've been banned
4Anonymous2026-11-21 07:51
So then why can't they ban America's giant pickup trucks?
8Anonymous2026-11-21 07:47
Re: #2
Isn't Land Rover itself owned by Tata, an Indian company, anyway?
9Anonymous2026-11-21 12:37
Here's the full ruling (in Dutch):
https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/details?id=ECLI%3ANL%3ARBDHA%3A2026%3A34365
10Anonymous2026-11-21 10:57
Re: #14
Apparently BYD's European offices got raided. Maybe someone was naive enough to leave incriminating paperwork lying around.
14Anonymous2026-11-21 10:33
Re: #5
Unless someone on the design team comes forward and confesses, isn't that basically impossible to prove?
And honestly, I don't think that's what happened here. Plenty of other cars have been developed the same way. The famous example is the Mazda Miata, which took inspiration from the Lotus Elan.
11Anonymous2026-11-22 00:53
Re: #2
Honestly the only real differences are the headlights and part of the front end. The rest looks pretty similar to me. It's basically just a bit taller with slightly toned-down fenders.
12Anonymous2026-11-21 09:58
Re: #7
Both of them in the photo look like someone just bolted some plastic junk onto four wheels, if you ask me. Neither screams 'rugged, no-compromise off-roader.' Neither one is a real Land Rover Defender.
13Anonymous2026-11-21 10:02
Re: #12
I think the whole modern approach of 'mass-producing multiple trims off a single production line' makes it harder to give cars distinctive styling these days. Land Rover hasn't been 'off-road first, everything else second' for decades anyway — at this point it's just another luxury SUV.

Background and key points of this debate

The EU’s standard for registered design infringement isn’t about whether an ordinary consumer would actually mistake one car for the other — it’s a legal standard based on whether the two designs create a different “overall impression” in the eyes of an “informed observer.” The pushback in the thread along the lines of “you wouldn’t actually mistake one for the other” largely stems from a mismatch between the everyday, consumer-level standard of “misidentification” and the legal “similarity” standard used in design law. BYD has been rapidly expanding EV sales in Europe in recent years, and the EU has simultaneously been ramping up protectionist measures such as additional tariffs on Chinese-made EVs — so there’s room to read this ruling as part of that broader trend. It’s worth noting that the claim about a raid on BYD’s European offices is only speculation raised within the thread and is not a fact confirmed in the article itself.

*This article is excerpted and loosely translated into Japanese by our editorial team from the thread “Dutch court bars Chinese SUV in Europe over resemblance to Land Rover Defender” on the overseas forum Lemmy c/europe. Our site takes responsibility for the translated content.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *