From our other sites
The story
A thread about Hello! Project idol Sakura Ishiyama’s manner toward fans at one-on-one meet-and-greet events has taken off on 5ch’s “Hello! Pro” board. While some praised her looks (“she’s gorgeous with light makeup”), many others piled on, saying she’s “cold” one-on-one — meaning she comes across as distant at handshake events, cheki (photo) sessions, and other face-to-face events. Some criticized the gap between this and her usual blog persona, while plenty of others defended her as simply very shy but sincere at heart, leaving fans sharply split on how to read her.
What people said
Well, "cold" isn't quite right — it's more that if you go in expecting "a beauty acting strange," you'll end up let down.
New fans should probably keep that in mind.
Even back when she was about 20, in her individual report from the "Midnight Bozu" show, Ishiyama was ice cold.
Unlike Shimakura's ice-cold report that Akinobu used to push (which at least made for good material), Ishiyama's wasn't even easy to joke about — I remember the vibe on the video got pretty awkward.
Guess she just sees them as worthless.
Honestly, anti-fans who don't even go to her meet-and-greets aren't needed anyway.
That's because fans go in expecting exactly that.
So the "not what I expected" effect happens pretty easily.
She's a good kid.
Kind of similar to Haru-san.
Haru-san is awkward too, but you can feel she's at least trying to win fans over.
Ishiyama seems more like she's trying not to force herself.
Neither is really better or worse.
I'm just plain annoyed, that's all.
Dude, that's… that's love.
Is this your first time falling for someone?
What are you even talking about, you weirdo.
Not getting annoyed at that would be the weird reaction.
But if a girl like that ever opens up to you, it's incredibly rewarding, right?
If anything, that makes her worth rooting for.
So she and Inoue are the "cold duo" of Juice=Juice — guess that's why they get along.
Inoue was actually warm back in her Kobushi Factory days and right after she transferred.
If we're talking "got popular and turned cold, i.e., doesn't need weak first-timers anymore," that's more like Oda or AKB's Sashihara.
(Ishiyama hasn't even become popular yet.)
Sakura Ishiyama
Sakura Seta
Kind of amusing.
In shogi there's also an Ishiyama Sakura.
Newcomers to the "Moremi" fanbase (a nickname used for her) should be told about that mix-up ahead of time — otherwise it's bad for everyone.
A lot of fans get burned buying two cheki at once hoping for different reactions.
Going by "you get exactly the response you expect," I always tell newcomers to try Kudo first instead.
There are people who defend her like that,
but nobody ever actually comes forward with "she was this sweet to me," so I've just accepted that cold is cold.
Something about how even when she thinks she's acting normal, fans still complain about it.
There's a gap between what she considers "normal" and what fans expect as "normal" given her image.
This isn't really a case of either side being wrong — it's just an unavoidable mismatch.
Background and Key Points of This Topic
“Shio-taiō” (“cold/salty response”) is a term used throughout idol culture to describe behavior at one-on-one fan events — handshake sessions, cheki (photo) sessions, and the like — that comes across as distant or lacking in warmth. Even identical behavior tends to split opinion sharply: some fans read it as standoffish, others as the flip side of shyness, and this thread followed that same pattern. Posters also noted an interview in which Ishiyama herself reportedly said she gets criticized by fans even when she believes she’s behaving normally. That gap — between how she perceives her own “normal” and what fans expect as “normal” — appears to be at the root of why opinions are so divided.
※This article has been excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “What do you think of Sakura Ishiyama?“




Leave a Reply