From our other sites
The story
A thread that kicked off with the post “Kitakata ramen isn’t tasty at all” blew up on 5ch’s Nandemo Jikkyo G board. Kitakata ramen is a regional specialty hailing from the Aizu region of Fukushima Prefecture, known for its flat, curly noodles and light soy-sauce broth. The thread split into camps arguing over comparisons to Jiro-style and Ie-kei ramen, jabs that “people are just eating the hype, not the ramen,” and differences in quality between franchise shops and long-established originals — with defenders and detractors going back and forth.
What people said
They're just not tasty at all.
you come back around to Kitakata ramen and go 'yeah, this is actually good.'
Yeah, that's what happens once you've really mastered ramen.
Isn't that just because you got older and Ie-kei/Jiro-style got too heavy for you?
I feel that. Jiro's basically food for big dudes who want to stuff themselves with meat and volume.
If you just want a big portion, Taishoken does the job fine too — though it's got less pork.
Every ramen should just use curly noodles.
Sano ramen's the knockoff, actually.
The way the noodles get all wavy and twisted, it's like 'earthworm ramen.'
I like Ie-kei but can't stand Jiro-style.
They get lumped together as 'ramen for people who eat the hype instead of the food.'
Honestly, neither one's that great to begin with.
the people lining up at Yoshimuraya
or Ramen Jiro Jimbocho are eating the hype,
but saying ALL Ie-kei and Jiro-style fans are just hype-eaters
is a bit of a stretch.
Aren't they basically opposite tribes to begin with?
Fans of 'chokkei' (direct-lineage) shops especially are on another level —
if you can't enjoy it unless the soy sauce is slammed, that's truly end-stage.
Isn't that 'orthodox Ie-kei,' not 'chokkei'?
Maybe the first bowl is hype, but after that it's your own tongue doing the judging.
But ramen nerds will absolutely trash a shop the second they find out the soup's actually made in a factory.
Eating Ie-kei or Jiro-style forever would be brutal.
Why would you put yourself through pointless torture like that? lol
for me, eating it because it's 'tasty' isn't really the point 🥺
but it gets rough when every single shop, left and right, is just another tonkotsu place.
There's a Tora Shokudo in Fukuoka City — you should go check it out.
It's not the thick noodles that are the problem — curly noodles are the real dealbreaker.
Those thick, chewy 'washi-washi' noodles are a genuine revolution 😭
I'll pass on Jiro.
Or is there an actual definition covering both the noodles and the soup?
The noodles are thin, floppy, flat noodles.
The soup is a light chicken-stock-and-soy-sauce base.
It comes with chashu too, but overall it's a light-tasting ramen.
It's not 'mind-blowing delicious' so much as 'the kind of good you could eat every single day.'
It's popular, right?
Aburasoba (brothless ramen) has crazy-low ingredient costs, so it's pretty easy for just about anyone to turn a profit on it.
It costs half as much to make as regular ramen but sells for the same price — that's aburasoba (brothless ramen) for you.
Douse it in vinegar and chili oil, then chug a ton of water after — cures constipation. The ultimate health food.
Background and Key Points of the Debate
Kitakata ramen originates from Kitakata City in the Aizu region, and is sometimes counted alongside Sapporo and Hakata ramen as one of Japan’s “three great ramens.” It’s defined by flat, curly noodles and a light chicken-and-soy-sauce broth. The thread’s disagreement centered on whether comparing it to Jiro-style and Ie-kei ramen even made sense — underneath that is a divide between ramen judged as “food built for eating in bulk” versus ramen judged on “authentic flavor.” The recurring jab that fans are “just eating the hype” also kept resurfacing, aimed at a broader ramen culture where buzz and long lines often drive a shop’s reputation more than the food itself. Though it wasn’t raised directly in the thread, there’s also a real gap in craftsmanship between franchise locations and the long-established originals within Kitakata City — and which of the two posters have in mind likely fuels a good share of the disagreement.
*This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “[Sad News] Kitakata Ramen Isn’t Tasty At All… It’s Way Overrated.”

Leave a Reply