Kiyoharu’s Cover of ‘Kurenai’ with YOSHIKI on Piano Sparks Debate — 5ch: ‘If You Don’t Like It, Don’t Watch’

From our other sites

The story

A video of Kuroyume/SADS vocalist Kiyoharu singing X JAPAN’s classic “Kurenai” to YOSHIKI’s piano accompaniment sparked a thread on 5ch’s Hello! Project board. The original poster called the performance “way too sloppy,” pointing to missed lyrics and pitchy notes. The thread then split between defenders (“that’s just the kind of artist Kiyoharu is — you have to judge him on those terms”) and harsher critics (“he’s simply worse than HYDE or Hiroto Komoto”). The discussion eventually drifted from “Kurenai” itself into a broader chat about the lineage of 80s-90s visual-kei vocal styles, name-checking bands like DEAD END and LUNA SEA.

Why doesn’t he just sing it properly?

Source: youtu.be / Original article here

What people said

3AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:46
Re: #1
It's an old video, but with singing like this, I feel like Ado actually does it better.
5AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:49
Re: #3
Ado is like a trillion times better.
4AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:49
There's also a separate TikTok clip of Kiyoharu doing an impromptu 'Kurenai' with YOSHIKI at what looks like a Costco — that one's even worse.
6AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:49
It's fine, honestly. If you don't like it, don't watch it.
11AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:52
Re: #6
I'm a YOSHIKI stan, so I'm watching it regardless.
7AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:50
After listening to Kiyoharu, HYDE's vocal quirks suddenly sound cute.
9AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:51
The TikTok comments are actually pretty reasonable — mostly critical.
10AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:52
Re: #8
I've never really looked at YouTube comments, but that sounds like a fair take.
12AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:53
Re: #10
What's even good about singing this half-heartedly?
13AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:53
Wasn't he even getting the lyrics wrong on top of it?
14AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:54
Re: #11
'Shinja' (devoted fan) is written with characters meaning 'one who believes' — so if you're complaining, I guess that means you don't believe, huh?
18AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:58
Re: #14
No need to change the subject. What's actually good about this half-hearted singing?
15AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:55
You've got to give him credit for not sucking up to YOSHIKI and just doing his usual thing.
19AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:58
Re: #15
That's fair, actually.
17AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:57
Kiyoharu's cover of X JAPAN's 'Rusty Nail' is just as sloppy and rough.
https://youtu.be/mKpmvf9NFF0?si=OGaMDugYmV5WB3S5
20AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:59
Still a hundred times better than how Hiroto Komoto normally sings.
21AnonymousNov 21, 2026 20:59
HYDE covers X JAPAN songs a lot too, and compared to Kiyoharu he sounds ridiculously good.
22AnonymousNov 21, 2026 21:00
Guys like Hiroto Komoto and HYDE at least stay on pitch, right? Why is Kiyoharu off-key on top of everything, and he doesn't even remember the lyrics.
23AnonymousNov 21, 2026 21:04
I mean, this is a guy who once went as far as selling off the rights to his own band's trademark.
26AnonymousNov 21, 2026 21:09
Re: #23
Ah, I see — Kiyoharu's just not someone you should expect sincerity from…
24AnonymousNov 21, 2026 21:08
Is this really such a sacred song that it needs to be sung seriously? lol
27AnonymousNov 21, 2026 21:14
Re: #26
After all that back-and-forth mess, he only recently made a comeback, so I think most fans aren't expecting some squeaky-clean image from him anyway.
28AnonymousNov 21, 2026 21:16
If he started singing seriously, he wouldn't be Kiyoharu anymore. That's rock and roll for you.
36AnonymousNov 21, 2026 21:56
DEAD END are the originators, and they're insanely skilled musicians.
43AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:00
Re: #36
So DEAD END were great players too, huh. That's probably why the bands our generation used to stan all respected them so much.
45AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:01
If anything, 80s-90s visual-kei vocal styles are basically the original ancestor of Hello! Project-style singing.
48AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:03
Re: #45
Haha, yeah — now that you put it that way, that's true.
49AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:04
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4lsFIctSpQo&pp=ygUV562L5bCR44Gh44KD44KT56Wt44KK

hide covering Nirvana
56AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:09
Re: #49
Brings back memories. This lineup got absolutely roasted in hide and Oshima-san's column.
50AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:05
Listening to DEAD END's 'Serafine' and stuff, I feel like LUNA SEA are the band that inherited that musicality the most.
60AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:14
Re: #50
Wrote my post and then just read Re: #50's comment, lol — yeah, seriously, that's basically LUNA SEA circa up to 1992, word for word, lol.
51AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:06
Terada and Kiyoharu were close for a while, right? There are even some mysterious two-shot photos of them together.
54AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:07
Re: #51
Huh, really. Tsunku♂ is close with INORAN too, isn't he? They were drinking together recently and took a two-shot photo.
53AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:07
DEAD END – Serafine (1989)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=trwJq63IcQc
58AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:13
Re: #53
Every single detail is a perfect match for LUNA SEA during their 1st-2nd album era, lol.
57AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:10
When X heard that DEAD END was about to make their major-label debut, they pushed back their own debut date.
59AnonymousNov 21, 2026 22:13
Re: #57
Whoa, really?!

Background and Key Points of This Debate

Kiyoharu is the vocalist of Kuroyume and SADS, and he’s stuck to his own idiosyncratic singing style ever since his debut. The thread’s references to him “selling off trademark rights” and to his bands’ repeated breakups and reunions are based on real events, and among fans there’s a well-established sense that expecting a textbook, by-the-numbers vocal performance from him simply misses the point. The video itself isn’t new — it’s a clip that has circulated repeatedly online for some time — but it resurfaced this time partly because of the unexpected pairing with YOSHIKI. The thread split between a “normative” camp arguing he should sing more carefully out of respect for the performance and his collaborator, and an “individuality” camp arguing that this quirky approach is simply who Kiyoharu is and should be judged on those terms — and it’s easy to miss that both sides are actually arguing from a place of goodwill toward him. In its second half, the discussion drifted away from “Kurenai” itself into a broader chat about the vocal lineage of 80s-90s visual-kei acts like DEAD END, LUNA SEA, and X JAPAN, so this isn’t simply a bashing thread.

*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “Kiyoharu (Kuroyume & SADS) singing ‘Kurenai’ with YOSHIKI on accompaniment is way too sloppy — is this okay?“.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *