From our other sites
The story
Ise Suzuran, a member of Hello! Project’s ANGERME, caused a stir on 5ch’s Hello! Project board after saying on a TV show featuring popular comedian Akashiya Sanma that she “doesn’t want to give herself an image of being good at singing or dancing” and would “rather be a hard-to-explain jack-of-all-trades.” Some thread posters praised her, with comments like “Impressive that she’s actually living up to her words” and “Bold of her to push back on Sanma like that,” while others pushed back hard, arguing “It’s strange for someone who’s mediocre at both singing and dancing to say this” and “She should become the best in the group first before saying that.” The discussion eventually spread from Ise’s personal remark to broader criticism of ANGERME’s lack of a distinct group identity.
What people said
Sanma: You don't want an image of being good at singing and dancing?
Ise:
She's actually living up to her words
She's got a lot of different sides to her
Of course — she's the only one who's ever caused a stir on the daily awards circuit
Feelings statements
Difficult personality
Oronamin C and Cola
Nothing
No wonder they don't sell
Otherwise it's just embarrassing
https://livedoor.sp.blogimg.jp/wolfnews/imgs/d/6/d6a9c674.png
Sanma ties everything to soccer, and Makino ties everything to baseball
Mastering one thing lets you apply it elsewhere
People hype them up just because they're Hello! Project idols, but it's really not that big a deal
Very few people can actually push through it
This just sounds like her making excuses
The fact that Juice=Juice barely makes guest appearances anymore these days
But the fact that neither the members nor the fans seem bothered by it
With a leader like this, no wonder ANGERME turned into a skill-less group with no appeal
They can only speak in vague terms, so the other members get confused and the group ends up falling apart
Background and Key Points of This Topic
ANGERME has long been seen as a group where every member has roughly the same level of singing and dancing ability, with few members standing out for one signature skill — and Ise Suzuran herself has repeatedly made headlines for posting long, emotional statements on her blog. Her latest comment extends that pattern, showing a deliberate stance against being evaluated for excelling in any one specific area. The split in thread reactions comes down to whether people view this as calculated self-branding on her part, or as an excuse for not standing out in either singing or dancing. What tends to get overlooked is that the discussion blurs evaluation of Ise as an individual together with evaluation of ANGERME’s direction as a group — many of the replies that expanded into group-wide criticism aren’t actually arguments against Ise’s original comment itself.
*This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread「[Sad News] Ise Suzuran: ‘I Don’t Want to Give Myself an Image of Being Good at Singing or Dancing — I’d Rather Be a Hard-to-Explain Jack-of-All-Trades’」.



Leave a Reply