From our other sites
The story
Comedian Yasuko has been running a children’s cafeteria called “Yasu-Mattari” once a week since September, but social media buzz had spread claims that “she’s only there occasionally.” In response, the operation’s official X account pushed back on the 21st, insisting “there has never been a single scheduled day she’s missed.” On 5ch, opinions crossed swords — some felt it’s natural to call a once-a-week event “occasional,” while others pointed out that showing up only on event days doesn’t mean she’s actually involved in the prep and running of it — sparking debate over how to interpret the rebuttal.
Yasuko’s Children’s Cafeteria Hits Back at “Isn’t She Only There ‘Occasionally’?” Claims: “I Have Never Once Missed a Day”
The official X (formerly Twitter) account for “Yasu-Mattari,” the children’s cafeteria run by comedian Yasuko (28), posted an update on the 21st pushing back against posts about Yasuko.
Since September, Yasuko has kept providing free meals to children once a week.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
aren't both Yasuko and her haters trying way too hard?
Yeah, I kind of think that too.
It gets talked about so much, I can't help but think it must feel good to be doing it, lol.
Though I do know people (an acquaintance) who've quietly been doing this kind of volunteer work for years.
At this rate she's going to burn out.
Some tolerance for just ignoring it might be needed too.
Feels like it should be closed just Mondays or Wednesdays, not the other way around.
Well, contract-related businesses are usually closed on Wednesdays—
since 'water' (mizu) in 'Wednesday' superstitiously suggests a deal 'washing away.'
I kind of get why she makes enemies, somehow.
If that's the case, just open every day and announce which one day a week she'll actually show up.
the kids there are well-off anyway.
it's more efficient for her to go earn money elsewhere.
True, and she lives in Chiba Prefecture with a rescue cat.
Eating once a week doesn't mean you're fine skipping meals the rest of the time.
This isn't really supporting kids — it's self-promotion under the name of 'support.'
Do you even know how often soup kitchens typically run?
She's not involved in the prep, cleanup, or running of it.
'Never missed a scheduled day' isn't the same thing as 'only shows up on scheduled days'…
What is it that bothers people so much?
I bet the culprits are neighborhood kids. Most senseless trouble at schools or after-school programs comes from kids anyway.
Is there even a point to doing it this way?
And it's reservation-only, too.
With the TV publicity effect and apparently even eel (a pricey treat in Japan) being served, I bet the odds of getting a spot are brutal.
Background and Key Points of This Debate
Thousands of “children’s cafeterias” operate across Japan, but most run just once a month or a few times a month, kept going by volunteers out of their own pockets — daily operation is rare. Against that backdrop, a once-a-week schedule is actually relatively frequent by the usual standard, yet on social media it’s easy for people to perceive “once a week” as too little instead. The debate went off track because the official account’s statement, “there’s never been a day she’s missed,” was ambiguous — as the exchange between res61 and res64 shows, it’s unclear whether it means “she’s always there on event days” or “she’s also involved in the prep and running of it.” On top of that, social-contribution activities started by celebrities tend to draw heavy attention, which also invites closer scrutiny and criticism of how much they’re actually doing and how involved they really are — and this exchange is a textbook example of that.
*This article is compiled as an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “[Entertainment] Yasuko’s Children’s Cafeteria Hits Back at ‘Isn’t She Only There Occasionally?’ Claims: ‘I Have Never Once Missed a Day’.”
Leave a Reply