From our other sites
The story
It’s come to light that Yokohama’s new mayor is receiving a ¥420,000 monthly rent subsidy — with the city even covering her move-in costs — sparking a firestorm on 5ch. Meanwhile, the former mayoral residence sits uninhabitable due to aging, yet still costs over ¥24 million a year to maintain, prompting criticism over this effectively double expense. The thread split three ways: some argued the cost was simply unavoidable for security reasons, others slammed the rent subsidy as way too high, and still others pointed out that the arrangement was set up by the city’s secretarial office before the election — not something the mayor personally requested — muddying the debate further.
Wom—… (a cut-off jab referencing “ma’am-kek,” a dismissive 5ch slang used to mock women in general)
Source: news.tv-asahi.co.jp / Read the original article here
What people said
No idea what they're even spending that kind of money on though.
I'm a Yokohama resident and I sure didn't vote for this woman —
I voted for Yamanaka 😤
And the rent subsidy is way too high — covering move-in costs on top of it is just nuts.
If it's ¥420,000, even a ¥100,000 subsidy would be plenty, and honestly even that feels like too much.
That's exactly why you're supposed to just live in the official residence.
Refusing that and going off to rent your own place and then saying 'well, security costs extra, so what can you do' doesn't fly.
She's a woman, so privacy needs to be taken into consideration there.
However you slice it, a luxury rental is just obviously safer — that's a given.
So you'd rather they keep using the official residence even if it costs ¥28 million?
So what…?
Are you saying it's fine to spend unlimited money in the name of safety?
City-hall-level security has always been good enough — that's exactly why it's set up that way.
Past mayors have actually done it that way, so this isn't a defense of anything.
It's not unlimited — that's why she's "settling" for a ¥420,000 place.
"We've always done it this way" — that exact mindset is what's been dragging Japan down.
I'm saying that mindset itself is already messed up.
The thing is, Yokohama's secretarial office had already decided this before the election anyway — it wouldn't have mattered who became mayor.
Would you be satisfied if she just lived in a ¥100,000-a-month apartment?
Yeah, I'd be satisfied.
You gonna move in there with her?
This wasn't her own idea.
The residence can't be lived in because it's being inspected over aging issues, so Yokohama's secretarial office arranged this instead.
Yeah but why did they need to arrange anything at all?
↑ Scrap that, I'll just take a ¥420,000 rent allowance for my own place instead.
Isn't this person actually pretty sharp?
Re: #64
The mayoral residence isn't just housing — it also does things like hosting official guests, so they're saying they'll keep it even with no one living there, which means the upkeep costs stay exactly the same.
So it's seriously just burning money for nothing then.
Apparently it's barely even used as a guest-reception venue anyway. And if it's about hosting guests, there's already city hall for that — no need to use the residence at all.
The residence is too run-down to live in, so the secretarial office had already been scouting a replacement during the election and just assigned her this one.
No, she should just rent her own place like anyone else — there was no need for them to arrange anything.
Wait, what do you mean? Can you not read Japanese or something?
The second you asked "satisfied?" and got "yeah, satisfied" back, you lost.
Anything you say after that just looks like you're dodging the point.
Because the other guy agreed to exactly the terms *you* set.
If you're gonna use a rhetorical question in an argument, it has to be phrased so the other side absolutely can't say yes.
Lesson learned — argument loser.
That's what I'm saying, it's not her own idea.
During the election the secretarial office found this place and basically told her "please live here."
If she didn't turn it down, that makes it her own decision.
So scrapping the old residence might be reasonable, sure —
but that doesn't mean the city needs to be providing the mayor's housing at all.
Well, it might get scrapped going forward.
But right now, bashing the mayor over this specifically doesn't really make sense, that's all.
Obviously.
What did you think we meant?
A guy who became mayor wouldn't pull something this dumb in the first place.
However you look at it, this isn't about gender.
I mean, this level of waste isn't even in the same league as Masuzoe (the former Tokyo governor notorious for his own expense scandal).
Her actual home is in Koto Ward, Tokyo, though.
Background and Key Points of the Debate
In Japan, it’s standard practice for local governments to provide mayors with a publicly funded official residence, and Yokohama’s previous mayors did make use of theirs. What’s at issue this time is that the residence itself is uninhabitable due to aging, and during the election period the city’s secretarial office arranged a ¥420,000-a-month rental apartment as a substitute — with information shared on the thread suggesting this wasn’t a perk the new mayor personally requested. At the same time, the unused residence continues to cost over ¥24 million a year in upkeep, creating an effectively double-cost structure that’s become the target of criticism. The thread was split between those who saw the expense as an unavoidable security cost and those who argued the residence should be scrapped or swapped for cheaper housing — with the real sticking point being less about the dollar amount and more the institutional question of “why keep an unused facility running at all,” a nuance that’s easy to miss if you only read the headline.
*This article is compiled as an excerpt/summary of the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “[Sad News] Yokohama’s New Female Mayor Hit With a Scandal Right Out of the Gate lmaooooo.”

Leave a Reply