Canada’s Social Media Age Verification Bill Could Force Adults to Show ID Too, Sparking Debate

From our other sites

The story

In Canada, lawmakers are considering Bill C-34, modeled on Australia’s ban on social media for users under 16. Depending on how age verification is implemented, adults could also end up needing to prove their age with ID. On Lemmy’s c/canada, discussion spread around how the bill would actually be enforced — or whether it would be enforced at all. Opinions split over who the regulation really serves: some worried about the risk of handing over ID, some suspected ad-driven data collection or ulterior motives from Big Tech players like Meta, and others floated the idea that it’s really about tracking activists.

Bill C-34 is Canada’s version of Australia-style social media regulation, but how it would actually be enforced — or whether it will be enforced at all — remains an open question. Australia’s social media law completely bars under-16s from major platforms, covering TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, Snapchat, Threads, and X.

Source: 604now.com / Original article here

What people said

4Anonymous2026-11-20 17:36
Don't bother with verification — all it does is hand them provable info about you. Just quit social media and this law will get forced into repeal anyway.
5Anonymous2026-11-20 17:53
Re: #4 If they demand ID, people will just move to other services. I had my ID stolen once before, and I went through years of credit-lock hell afterward.
6Anonymous2026-11-20 18:13
If you're the type to hand over your ID just to keep using Facebook, I feel like you're already a lost cause.
7Anonymous2026-11-20 20:21
I genuinely don't get who benefits from this. With all the breaches and unauthorized access that keep happening, the timing feels like buyers are just waiting the second a database like this gets built.
8Anonymous2026-11-20 20:41
Re: #7 Propagandists and dictators, that's who.
9Anonymous2026-11-20 23:02
Re: #7 Accurate age and demographic data is extremely valuable to the ad industry.
11Anonymous2026-11-20 22:31
Re: #7 Meta is one of the companies that pushed this movement in the first place. Basically, they get to champion age verification while changing nothing about their own black-box algorithm and keep cashing in.
10Anonymous2026-11-20 23:09
If this ends up hurting adults too, gating access by age could backfire and actually maximize the harm instead.
13Anonymous2026-11-21 02:21
I can't see this as anything but a way to track activists.
14Anonymous2026-11-21 01:10
Re: #2 "Australia pushed that ban so hard because it lets the online gambling industry keep running ads." Ohh, so that's the real reason.
16Anonymous2026-11-21 02:42
Well, that's it then — social media is finished.
18Anonymous2026-11-21 01:09
Re: #7 Legacy media, that's who.

Background and Key Points of This Debate

Canada’s Bill C-34 is modeled on Australia’s system of banning under-16s from social media and verifying users’ ages, and the sticking point is that if implemented, adults could also find themselves needing to prove their age with ID in certain situations. The thread split over the question of “who actually benefits” — some argued demographic data sells at a premium to the ad industry, others argued that Big Tech platforms like Meta are leading the push for tighter regulation precisely to protect their current opaque algorithms, and still others floated the theory that the real goal is surveilling activists, with no consensus reached. It’s also worth noting, since readers might easily get the wrong impression, that as of the original article even how the bill would be implemented — or whether it will be implemented at all — was still undecided; it has not actually been passed or enforced yet.

*This article is a condensed, editorially translated digest of a thread from the overseas forum Lemmy c/canada titled “Canadian Adults Will Have To Prove Their Age To Keep Social Media Under New Bill.” Responsibility for the translation rests with this site’s editorial team.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *