From our other sites
The story
International political scientist Ruri Miura (46) commented on her X account about former Jungle Pocket member Shinji Saito, who was sentenced to four years in prison for non-consensual sexual intercourse and non-consensual indecent acts. Miura argued that “feeling anguish, having one’s dignity trampled on, and being traumatized must be considered separately from establishing a crime,” and put forward her view that “letting the authorities exercise power over just about anything to police men with bad character isn’t right.” On 5ch, rather than debating whether sentencing and character judgment should be kept separate, most comments questioned the credibility of her remarks by pointing to her own past background, with some also noting that the victim’s perspective was missing from the discussion.
International political scientist Ruri Miura (46) updated her “X” account on the 19th, commenting on former Jungle Pocket member Shinji Saito, who had been handed a four-year prison sentence.
Saito, charged with both non-consensual sexual intercourse and non-consensual indecent assault, was sentenced on the 16th at the Tokyo District Court (Presiding Judge Yuko Ito) to four years in prison (prosecutors had sought seven). Saito filed an appeal the same day.
Miura opened by saying, “No matter what, the public just can’t seem to grasp that feeling anguish, having one’s dignity trampled on, and being traumatized must be considered separately from establishing a crime.” She continued, “I myself speak with an understanding of sexual victimization as a background, but at the same time, as an intellectual, I’m talking about the stable interpretation and application of the law, the legitimacy of physical detention by state power, and the balance between crime and punishment. In short, letting the authorities exercise power over just about anything to police men with bad character isn’t right.”
Source: tokyo-sports.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
Give preferential treatment to men with good character
Simple as that
Or wait, is she going easy because there might be some bad-natured guy among her acquaintances? lol
But then also, 'the law says…'
It's a double standard — she just wants to say this part
Is this person even an intellectual?
Do intellectuals go around calling themselves intellectuals?
What about the position of the vulnerable victim, who couldn't refuse because he exploited his position over her?
Saito's the one in the wrong — of course he deserves prison.
I don't get why anyone would defend the guy who basically forced her into oral sex through intimidation.
This is practically a rape case!
I do have some thoughts about that part lol
Yoshimoto, of all places lmao
'Bad-natured' is just your own personal opinion
lmaooooooo
This so-called 'intellectual' (with scare quotes) hasn't hit the mark on a single point.
Whether someone's a good guy or a bad guy doesn't matter — the courts have simply updated the old assumption that 'if you don't want it, you'd just run away,' which turned out to be completely wrong.
This too is brainwashing from TV and movies —
all of it exaggerated fiction
The question is whether it should legally count as sexual intercourse.
Anal, given the psychological impact, could arguably be included though…
It got stricter because there are idiots who go wild thinking 'it's just oral, no big deal.'
If two people who both think oral is no big deal want to do it with each other, fine — but forcing it on someone who finds it painful is not okay
it's a complete criminal's-eye view
Even Shiraku, who's usually soft on sex offenders, flatly said there's no second chance for Saito on this one
they fired him right away, so even Yoshimoto apparently considers this a dealbreaker
> "as an intellectual"
What kind of label is that even, lol
It's just that it escalated into actual intercourse, so it's become a bigger deal.
Is she trying to say the person who got touched is also partly at fault?
It's basically like robbery, isn't it —
Threaten someone to take their money.
Threaten someone to force sex on them
He apparently figured that since she's a fan of his, anything goes as consent lol
Did he actually attend Yoshimoto Kogyo's training properly? Or was he asleep through it?
Doesn't seem like a 'strong woman' either, lol
The prosecutors indicted because the case was referred to them by police.
The court ruled because the prosecutors requested a sentence
What's scary is that some percentage of people out there just can't understand that
Hooray for vigilante justice?
This person is a Tokyo University graduate, but she's also apparently one of the people who writes Tokyo University entrance exam questions — she's basically assigning the reader the task of 'summarize what I'm trying to say'
He angered the other party so much that even a settlement became impossible, leaving him cornered on all sides.
That's different from just being a 'man with bad character.'
Exactly, exactly —
shouldn't that be 'bad character AND bad judgment'?
Background and Key Points of This Topic
Tougher penalties for sex crimes expanded in scope following the 2023 revision of Japan’s Penal Code (which created the new crime of non-consensual sexual intercourse), and Saito’s sentencing drew attention as a real-world example of that law in action. Miura’s argument itself was a legal point — that “whether a sentence is appropriate” and “condemning someone’s character” should be kept separate — rather than a defense of the sentence itself. On the thread, however, rather than debating that legal point, most comments focused on questioning Miura’s standing and credibility, citing her past involvement in her husband’s company’s subsidy-fraud case and in compliance training for the entertainment industry. At the same time, some pointed out that the victim’s perspective was largely absent, revealing a split in how people weighed the legal argument about sentencing against the victim’s feelings.
※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisuto Sokuho+) thread “Ruri Miura: ‘No Sympathy’ for Former Jungle Pocket Member Saito, But Says Using State Power to ‘Police Bad-Natured Men’ Isn’t Right“.
Leave a Reply