From our other sites
The story
An inmate serving time at Nagano Prison has filed a provisional injunction with the Nagano District Court seeking an order for the state to provide nutrition, claiming that despite being unable to eat due to an eating disorder, the dosage of his nutritional supplements was reduced — causing his weight to fall from 63.4kg to 43.7kg (at a height of 170cm). Bengo4.com reported the story on November 19, 2026. The thread split between sympathy for the inmate and a colder view that “he’s serving a sentence, so it’s on him,” with discussion also turning to the legal question of whether the state had already ordered meal/supplement provisions or a transfer to a medical prison.
Nagano Prison Inmate’s Weight Falls from 63.4kg to 43.7kg: “Couldn’t Eat and Had Supplements Cut Too” — Files for Provisional Injunction – Bengo4.com –
By Shunsuke Ichinomiya, November 19, 2026, 10:55 AM
An inmate serving time at Nagano Prison (Suzaka City, Nagano Prefecture) has filed a provisional injunction with the Nagano District Court seeking an order for the state to supply necessary nutrition, claiming that amid an eating disorder that left him barely able to eat, his nutritional supplements were cut, causing him to fall into a severe state of malnutrition.
Source: bengo4.com / Original article here
What people said
Maybe they should commercialize it?
There are actually reported cases of diabetes improving from eating prison barley rice lol
What BMI did he go from and to, exactly?
It says right there — 170cm.
Exactly this.
Like, what's a guy doing hard time even complaining about?
He should be grateful he's even getting basic food, clothing, and shelter.
The police barely apologized for cases where wrongful convictions led to death,
and they keep repeating the same mistakes — that's exactly why people think they're idiots.
In the first place, prison medical care doesn't run on health insurance — isn't it all paid out of public funds? Which also means it doesn't have to follow insurance rules either.
Also, the reason the rules got stricter is that nutritional supplements became cheap and widely available at ordinary drugstores. Even now, in remote areas or when a patient physically can't get to a pharmacy, doctors can still prescribe them under insurance for malnutrition if they document the reason.
Feels like the medical staff's knowledge here might be the real problem.
For legal purposes, whether it's public funds or insurance doesn't matter.
Judgments go by the drug's package insert and the standards/guidelines of insurance-covered medicine.
And honestly, supplements aren't even necessary for eating disorders in the first place — just eat food. If someone's throwing up every meal, they'll throw up the supplements too.
Nagano Prison is actually a traffic-offenders' prison, so it mostly holds fairly decent citizens who caused accidents.
Just kidding.
According to Horie (Takafumi Horie, who did time there), Nagano Prison has some of the best food of any prison in the country.
What a waste, not eating it.
Whoaaaa, no way.
Because he's just on a hunger strike.
Being liquid, a little probably gets absorbed before it comes back up compared to solid food, but you still can't just hand someone a tool for purging.
The only reason hospitals keep prescribing it is to protect doctors from legal types who have zero clue what's actually happening on the ground.
If someone were truly in life-threatening danger, you wouldn't give them supplements at all — you'd do tube feeding straight into the stomach.
And if they resist even that, it's done in a psychiatric ward under physical restraint.
If that's really the situation, a regular prison can't handle it, so moving him to a medical-equivalent prison sounds right.
People who lose weight this fast usually see a spike in triglycerides first as the body tries to balance its energy — so cutting supplements right at that point makes no sense either.
The medical staff involved sound incompetent from A to Z.
Re: #79
Sharing your "feelings" without actually knowing anything (lol)
Not everyone, but little by little the purging frequency drops, and it settles to a point where it no longer harms the body.
The real question is whether he went from overweight to a healthy range.
At 170cm, going from 63.4kg to 43.7kg means he went from normal weight to way too thin. If it's a hunger strike, that's on him, but if it's genuinely an eating disorder, I think there's room for sympathy. Though the full truth isn't clear yet.
170cm and 43kg is seriously dangerous. Even at 150cm, 43kg would already be skin and bones.
He probably can't even do prison labor at that point and would just be a liability, so
I think they should've sent him to a medical prison already.
The lawyer's argument is built on the Constitution and the Act on Penal Detention Facilities, so it's a solid case. Looks like he might actually win lol
[The argument: based on Article 25 of the Constitution, which guarantees the right to life, and Article 56 of the Act on Penal Detention Facilities and Treatment of Inmates, which sets out medical measures in penal facilities, the state has a duty to supply nutrition according to an inmate's health condition.]
They provided meals, supplied supplements on top of the required calorie count, and ordered a transfer to a medical prison — so I don't think the state abandoned its duty at all.
If the state loses, it'll only be because they said something unnecessary and got caught on a technicality.
Also, the article reads as if he'd been in danger this whole time, but looking again, his BMI only hit 15 — the hospitalization threshold — as of October 21st, so that's actually pretty recent.
That'd work if you're allowed to fit inmates with exploding collars or something — otherwise the management costs would be way too high.
Share a room and you'll just get bullied by senior inmates.
And if that causes trouble, you end up in the punishment cell.
Seems like it'd be easier to make a break for it once transferred to a medical facility.
If he deliberately starved himself down to skin and bones as part of a plan, that's actually some serious willpower.
Background and Key Points of This Story
A provisional injunction is a procedure for seeking urgent protection of one’s rights from a court without waiting for a ruling in the full lawsuit; the key issue here is how far the state actually went in providing medical care. As noted in the latter part of the thread, the article reports that the inmate’s BMI reached 15 — the threshold for hospitalization — as of October 21, and that a transfer to a medical prison was ordered at that point. Leaving out this detail makes it easy to walk away thinking “the state just neglected him the whole time,” but it’s easy to overlook that meals and supplements were, in fact, provided continuously. It’s also often overlooked that supplement therapy for eating disorders is considered to have limited effect when vomiting is involved — a gap between actual medical practice and the legal argument for a “duty to provide nutrition” that tends to get buried as a technical point.
*This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5channel (News Flash+) thread “Nagano Prison Inmate’s Weight Falls from 63.4kg to 43.7kg: ‘Couldn’t Eat and Had Supplements Cut Too’ — Files for Provisional Injunction.”




Leave a Reply