From our other sites
The story
A thread appeared on 5ch’s Hardware/Industry (Geha) board after a poster who said they were playing the GTA series for the first time raised the question: “All I’m doing is running fetch quests, and it’s not fun at all.” The thread buzzed over the gap between Western media’s glowing reviews — including a 99 Metascore — and the actual feel of playing the game, with many commenters pointing to clunky aiming and monotonous traversal. The discussion gradually broadened into how much credit an open world’s sheer scale deserves, with comparisons to Nintendo titles and Shenmue, and opinion split over the yardstick of “it has the graphics and freedom, but how deep is it as actual gameplay?”
What people said
That one was garbage too, I uninstalled it after an hour.
There's nothing to talk about while traveling, so streamers just keep saying "the graphics are really amazing."
They've said the same thing like 100 times already.
Watching someone travel around isn't fun for the viewer either.
Score-wise, GTA5 was already plenty high, so I want to know how it's evolved beyond just the graphics.
Look at Breath of the Wild to Tears of the Kingdom — even the graphics barely evolved.
Personally I don't rate Tears of the Kingdom highly.
If GTA6's evolution is on that level, it's not worth buying.
The abilities, gameplay, and field all evolved though — and you call that "barely"? 🤔
It's gotten more linear with each entry in the series.
You're saying FF16 has a polished story and graphics? lol
Even calling it "you can do anything" is a stretch —
everyone can just punch or shoot, and even that doesn't really matter.
Is that really what Westerners consider fun? Makes no sense to me.
Maybe it's treated as the endpoint of those "[blank] Simulator" games Westerners love so much.
Since that gets praised, even Nintendo caved and followed suit.
Nintendo should just go back to making fun games.
I mean, most of the games Nintendo actually puts out are still area-based.
The exceptions are basically just Breath of the Wild and the Xenoblade titles.
Still, plenty interesting for a game nerd like me. I kind of feel like modern GTA isn't really meant to be enjoyed as a game in the traditional sense anymore.
I wonder why Kurabe, who loves Shenmue, doesn't rate this very highly.
What's the difference?
Maybe he just hasn't played it yet?
His complaints about the awards race have nothing to do with liking it, hating it, being a fanboy, or a hater.
Yeah, the original Shenmue did feel kind of like GTA to play.
It's less about fun as a game and more about enjoying the possibilities of an open world.
Its only standout appeal is the sheer, unmatched volume bought with a massive budget and a vast open world.
If you gave both studios the same brief — make a fun game on a limited budget — Nintendo would make the better product.
Nintendo is just better at crafting actual gameplay.
If Nintendo made it, you'd just get a barren, empty-feeling open world where there's nothing to do, like Xenoblade Chronicles X.
Sounds like some country's RPG series.
A genius has arrived.
The Witcher hasn't had a new one in ages lol
Isn't that just because you're causing chaos the whole time?
At least it kindly lights up the next objective for you.
Doesn't GTA kindly point you to the next objective too?
Background and Key Points of This Debate
The GTA series has long been known as a title where critical acclaim and individual players’ satisfaction can diverge sharply, and this time too, questions were raised about the actual feel of the gameplay despite glowing reviews from Western outlets. The thread split roughly into two camps: one over how much credit the sheer graphical and open-world scale itself should get as part of the “game experience,” and another over how the monotony of the mission structure should factor into scoring. The recurring comparisons to Nintendo titles are an extension of a long-running debate on the Geha board over whether to prioritize “freedom to do anything” or “tightly crafted depth of play” within the open-world genre. Though not mentioned directly in the thread, it’s worth noting that the Metascore is an average of review scores from multiple outlets, and doesn’t capture differences in satisfaction driven by playtime length or individual play style.
*This article is compiled as an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (Hardware/Industry [Geha]) thread “I’m playing GTA for the first time, and all I’m doing is running fetch quests — it’s not fun at all.”
Leave a Reply