IGN Japan’s Kurabe Sparks Debate: “You Can’t Fairly Judge Pre-Release GTA6 for GOTY”

From our other sites

The story

IGN Japan reviewer Kurabe (@RineD1987) stirred up discussion on 5ch’s gaming hardware board (Geha) after posting on social media that he doesn’t think a game can be fairly considered for GOTY (Game of the Year) at The Game Awards (TGA) before it’s even released, in response to GTA6 landing a GOTY nomination. The thread split between posters pointing out the problem with advance review codes going to only a handful of outlets, and others countering that everyone who’s actually played it pre-release has raved about it. The discussion also touched on broader doubts about TGA’s selection process itself — including the fact that past nominated remakes like the Final Fantasy VII Remake and Resident Evil 4 Remake have never actually won the top prize, and suspicions about Metascore manipulation.

What people said

1AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:32
Kurabe no Kuu-chan @RineD1987
Speaking as someone inside the media industry, yes, outlets do get the game before release. But in most cases that's only the assigned reviewer — it's rare for an entire outlet's staff to get early access. Even the number of codes you receive depends on the size of your outlet, so I really don't think a pre-release game can be properly considered for GOTY.
7AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:35
Kurabe's brain got fried by Ocarina of Time, so of course he's salty at GTA as a rival — that's lame.
Everyone who's played it pre-release is already raving about it.
14AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:36
Re: #7
Even if the people who did play it loved it, the point is that pool is still just a handful of outlets — that's the actual problem.
16AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:36
Re: #7
That's not what he's saying though.
Though I do appreciate you volunteering a look inside your own head.
12AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:35
Even if it's like Last of Us 2, where only one outlet raised questions,
this time the publisher and TGA's handling has been so clumsy
that regular users have doubts too, so it probably won't turn into a pile-on against IGN Japan.
23AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:37
Re: #12
Last of Us 2 really was trash though.
18AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:37
There's a bit of a 'wait, THIS hardcore Shenmue otaku is saying this?' vibe to it
He's probably already played it

Is it really not that fun?
96AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:15
Re: #18
Kurabe worships Shenmue and Breath of the Wild but really hates photorealistic Western games, Kurabe
I've never once seen him praise one.
34AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:42
If it were a game you could normally get your hands on early, fine, but
this is a game thoroughly locking everyone out until release day,
and it's already up for GOTY — however you slice it, that's bizarre,
and it's basically proof money is changing hands.

GOTY has become a prize you can just buy, it's worthless now.
36AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:44
Re: #34
Oh wow, so Smash Bros bought its way in too, huh.
37AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:44
True, but he actually said it out loud…

Kurabe's gonna get blacklisted lol
41AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:46
Re: #37
He's at an age where he could live fine even if he got blacklisted at this point
He's always saying whatever he wants anyway.
42AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:47
Having the Ocarina of Time remake win feels a bit off too
I feel like Resident Evil 9 or thereabouts would be the right call
but a GTA that hasn't even come out yet should be out of the question in the first place.
43AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:48
Re: #42
I mean, it comes out in like 12 hours.
55AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:59
Remakes never actually win GOTY anyway, yet it still got nominated lol
57AnonymousNov 18, 2026 12:59
Re: #55
Both the Resident Evil and FF7 remakes made it to the final nominees — that award was TGA.
59AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:00
Re: #55
'Remakes never get picked' (no evidence, no real reasoning behind that)
61AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:01
But what are they gonna do about it, I wonder
If it really is nominated, TGA's reputation — already shady to begin with — doesn't just stay at zero, it goes negative, right?
66AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:03
Re: #61
This is going to be worth watching lol
If they shamelessly let it win anyway, that's its own kind of joke.
62AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:01
Re: #57
Nominating a remake at all is pure favoritism
since it can never actually win anyway.
79AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:09
Re: #62
I watch TGA every year so I get that
You can't win there unless it's fun AND shows real innovation or a legitimate evolution
but if it's reworked into basically a different game, like FF7 was, I don't think it'd be weird for it to win.
64AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:02
Is 'remakes never won before so they never will' really all you've got?
65AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:03
Re: #64
At major Game of the Year (GOTY) awards such as 'The Game Awards (TGA),' the world's largest gaming award show, no remake has ever won GOTY.
• Nomination track record: Remakes that earned high praise and GOTY nominations do exist — like the 'Final Fantasy VII Remake' and 'Resident Evil RE:4' — but none have gone on to win the top Game of the Year prize.
• Award tendencies: Many media awards and TGA itself tend to favor 'completely new (original) titles' in their selection criteria. Remakes are typically honored in a separate category instead, such as 'Best Remake / Remaster.'
69AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:04
007 ← Hollywood favoritism (Amazon just announced the new James Bond)

Control ← favoritism for a friend of Geoff's (Geoff Keighley, TGA's host, known for cozy ties with developers)

Grand Theft Auto VI ← total farce

Phantom Blade Zero ← fair

Resident Evil Requiem ← fair

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time ← fair


Honestly, it's not just GT6 — 007 and Control also make you go 'huh?'
Though I do like those two games.
70AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:05
Re: #69
The remakes are favoritism picks too
since there's already a separate 'Best Remake' category just for remakes, yet they still get nominated for the top award.
72AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:06
Honestly, it's fine if GTA6 wins GOTY
it'll just mean a lot more people worldwide start mocking the award for being that kind of prize going forward.
76AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:07
Re: #72
If GTA6 had gotten delayed, Wolverine might've had it locked in.
87AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:11
Re: #66
Americans don't have a concept of shame, so no damage done

Re: #72
It's already been outed as a 'Geoff' pick with only a 40% approval rating as of last year, so it's fine
It's already just a scheme for Geoff to cash in as much as he can.
73AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:06
Sad news
Smash Bros for Wii U was also nominated before release

75AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:07
Re: #70
TGA doesn't even have a category like that — did the AI just not tell you that?
80AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:09
Re: #75
At major Game of the Year (GOTY) awards such as 'The Game Awards (TGA),' the world's largest gaming award show, no remake has ever won GOTY.
• Nomination track record: Remakes that earned high praise and GOTY nominations do exist — like the 'Final Fantasy VII Remake' and 'Resident Evil RE:4' — but none have gone on to win the top Game of the Year prize.
• Award tendencies: Many media awards and TGA itself tend to favor 'completely new (original) titles' in their selection criteria. Remakes are typically honored in a separate category instead, such as 'Best Remake / Remaster.'
77AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:08
What he's saying is pretty reasonable, honestly…

Though Rockstar (the post uses a kanji pun — 岩=rock, 星=star — as a stand-in for 'Rockstar Games') should've just moved the release up a week or something.
83AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:10
Re: #77
Honestly they should just set the GOTY nomination cutoff at the end of November
Plenty of publishers want to launch around Black Friday anyway
Nintendo probably ships early since they're aiming at kids, though.
82AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:10
Realistically, everyone except the people involved thinks this is crazy.
84AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:11
Re: #82
Honestly, I bet even the people involved know it's crazy but can't stop themselves at this point.
100AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:16
If the Metascore ends up low on top of this, that's the full jackpot of bad looks (役満 — mahjong's top-scoring hand, used here to mean 'hitting every box').
101AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:17
Re: #100
That's pretty plausible actually
Same goes for '007' and that colorful whatchamacallit game — people are asking 'why'd these get nominated, money?' too, since their Metascores weren't great either

Seems like more and more review sites are refusing to inflate scores for cash these days.
104AnonymousNov 18, 2026 13:24
Re: #100
Given the lockdown is so tight that nothing's leaked at all, only hand-picked reviewers can even review it, so the score can't really come out low
By the time any low reviews show up, the GOTY ceremony will already be over lol

Background and key points of this discussion

The Game Awards (TGA) announces its GOTY nominees every November, and the list often includes titles that haven’t even launched yet by announcement time. This is based on advance review codes distributed to media outlets before release, and since those codes go only to select outlets and staff for the main game, not every outlet gets to evaluate it under the same conditions. Kurabe’s point was a critique of this distribution structure, not a judgment on ‘whether GTA6 is actually good’ — a distinction that’s easy to miss. The thread split between those who argued that if the small number of people who did play it pre-release rate it highly, there’s no problem, and those who countered that the pool of people who got to evaluate it is simply too small, making the selection process opaque. The discussion also touched on the fact that remakes like the Final Fantasy VII Remake and Resident Evil 4 Remake have been nominated before but never actually won the top prize, raising the question of whether GTA6 or the Ocarina of Time remake would fall into that same pattern this time. Some posters also linked Metascore results to financial influence from publishers, though it’s worth noting that claim remains speculative.

※This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware/Industry (Geha)) thread “[Sad News] IGN Japan’s Kurabe: “GTA6 got a TGA nomination but there’s no way it can be considered for GOTY lol”“.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *