From our other sites
The story
On the Hello! Project board on 5ch, a post criticizing fans who “can’t rest easy until the numbers are in” sparked a debate among Hello! Project fans. It appears to have started around the time Morning Musume’s exclusion from the Kōhaku Uta Gassen (NHK’s New Year’s Eve song contest) became a hot topic, with a post mocking fans fixated on view counts and attendance figures. That set off a flurry of counterarguments — some saying “there’s nothing wrong with numbers-chasing culture itself, but using it as a yardstick to sneer at other fans is a different matter,” others defending it with “if the numbers aren’t there, the agency can’t push for it” — and the discussion spiraled into talk of the agency’s negotiating power behind Kōhaku selection and the popularity gaps between the various groups under its umbrella.
What people said
it becomes a different story when you start sneering at people who do want to chase numbers.
If you're going to insist on your own way of being a fan, you should admit other people get their own way of being a fan too.
You're spouting some real nice-sounding platitudes, but
within the fandom itself people are literally comparing numbers just to drag each other down, so come on.
You think this guy is the one dragging people down?
The 'wolves' (a nickname for Morning Musume fans) who actually do that are the ones making a huge fuss over the Kōhaku snub.
I think the antis spamming copypasta in the Juice=Juice thread are the same type too.
Well, Hello! Project is its own kind of religion too, lol
Isn't this about the guy they nicknamed 'Okazu'? (a notorious fan/troll in the fandom)
Isn't it less about who's right, and more that both sides show the kind of ugliness typical of Hello! Project fans?
You know Hello! Project can't even keep going without the numbers you're trashing, lol
Guess as long as you're having fun, Angerme's struggles don't matter to you?
As long as I'm having fun, I don't care.
The rest of you can just slowly wither away.
That's basically what they're saying.
No matter how hard the creepy fans try, the agency has no intention of putting them on, so they won't be on next year either.
Go learn how the entertainment industry actually works, idiot!
I accepted that 'well, if the numbers aren't there, it's no wonder they couldn't get on,' so going forward I'll try to actively push the numbers up for next year — but if they still can't get on even with enough numbers, that's clearly on UP-FRONT (the agency), so I'll give up at that point.
That's all I'm saying.
I think he's right.
From that SPA! interview, though, it read like the other seven members besides Kubota are the ones fixated on going viral.
If you want to watch unpopular groups, maybe just drift over to underground idols instead?
When a group isn't popular, they complain about why it isn't.
When it does get popular, they turn around and try desperately to tear it down.
Their catchphrase is 'It's not easy for an idol group to keep selling out Budokan or Yokohama Arena, you know?'
Seems like they really don't want to hear 'Hello! Project isn't that popular.'
As for me, I'll watch what I want, when I want.
Honestly, it'd be best if everyone just enjoyed things their own way, without interfering with each other or sneering at each other.
Why is it that Japanese people, who love their own performative effort, always have something to say about other people's performative effort?
Says the guy who doesn't even have the guts to say he's quitting!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
So if you say you want to achieve that while still in Hello! Project, you're being arrogant, but if you quit like Kasahara did, suddenly it's not arrogant? What even is that logic?
Fans who believe it matters and work hard at it, and fans who believe it doesn't and don't bother — both sides have their own logic, and it's valid on both ends, so there's no need to fight over it.
I think 'people who can get on without doing anything' and 'people who can't get on unless they do something — and maybe not doing anything is exactly why they can't' are just in different positions.
Background and Key Points of This Debate
The selection process for NHK’s Kōhaku Uta Gassen performers is said to involve multiple factors beyond a song’s view count and buzz on social media — including the relationship between an artist’s agency and NHK, and past appearance history — making it a topic fans tend to split on, between those who think “it’s all about the numbers” and those who think “the agency’s negotiating power matters more.” In this thread, alongside the clash between those criticizing the ‘numbers above all’ mindset and those defending numbers-chasing culture, discussion also touched on the gaps in name recognition and popularity between Hello! Project’s various sub-groups, such as Juice=Juice and Angerme, as well as generational differences in how fans respond to ‘going viral’ as a metric — something that’s only become visible since the rise of social media. It’s worth noting that claims made in the thread along the lines of ‘the agency deliberately passed on a Kōhaku appearance’ reflect nothing more than some fans’ speculation; neither UP-FRONT (the talent agency) nor NHK has officially explained the criteria or circumstances behind the selection.
※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “A Post That Perfectly Captures the Ugliness of Hello! Project Fans Has Been Found.”
Leave a Reply