From our other sites
The story
On 5ch’s Hello! Project board, a heated debate broke out over the unwritten rule that ‘little sister group Juice=Juice must never surpass Morning Musume.’ One spark was Juice=Juice members Ako Yumigeta and Rio Sakurai saying on Instagram, ‘Thanks to Juice=Juice, people think Morning Musume hasn’t disbanded’ and ‘Hello! Project’s name recognition is on the rise.’ In the thread, opinions split between those who cited Morning Musume’s 29-year history, TV appearances, and Kohaku Uta Gassen performances as the ‘reason they can’t be surpassed,’ and those who argued the comparison should be based on current ability and TV exposure rather than history — the argument never reached a resolution.
What people said
because history (the past) can't be changed
go right ahead and surpass them
It's about the present, not the past
I get why the Juice-bashing has taken over
Truth is, they just can't surpass them because they're not selling
I want Morning Musume to stay proud of that history and remain Hello! Project's flagship forever
but the achievements the graduated OGs left behind are massive
It's about the current Musume, though
and SMAP got surpassed by Arashi
Match and Higashi being the 'big brothers' isn't about popularity,
it's about respect
It's like how Master Roshi is revered by Goku and Krillin
it just never lasts
When did Angerme (mocking nickname 'Ankasu') ever surpass Musume?
But if they ever threw away that history, that's when Morning Musume would die too. They're a group built entirely on history
The only question now is how the agency handles it
No — within Up-Front, Morning Musume (mockingly 'Mokasu') and Tanabe's Juice=Juice are on equal footing
Don't get it twisted
And on top of that, they never even landed a TV commercial
but once I learned Morning Musume's history, I realized there's just no beating that
Today's Hello! Project exists thanks to Morning Musume's history, so I'm grateful. History is great
The one thing Angerme and Juice=Juice can never surpass Morning Musume on
is history. Because Morning Musume has a history of creating legend after legend
Is it even the same kind of organization anymore?
While everyone else inflates their performances competing for popularity and sales,
Hello! Project deliberately chose deflation as its counter-move
In other words, they don't assemble pretty faces, and they make the music they want instead of chasing trends
and history proves it
Knowing Hello! Project means knowing its 29-year history. That's common sense for any H!P otaku
The Morning Musume name is packed with history and tradition. Beautifully preserved. Bravo
Pull a move like that and there's no way to beat them. What a legacy. Their trump card. It's fine to lean on history
because that's Morning Musume's weapon. That's fine. Keep the preservation society going
Kohaku Uta Gassen
Mini Moni.
The media was saturated with nothing but Morning Musume
The current '26 lineup itself isn't scary at all — it's just that we hold deep reverence for Momusu's 30-year history
Morning Musume '26 without that suit of history ← garbage lol
If you ever abandoned that history and tradition, that's when you'd die too
swapping out the flagship group is sometimes necessary
The longer things run, the more unspoken rules build up within a group,
and that ends up causing all sorts of problems
Hello! Project runs on a different axis entirely: 'how far can you pursue your own unique expression'
They hone their craft competing within the Hello! Project empire
It's only Angerme otaku who do
They keep biting back undeterred, with lies and copypasta
This is probably just Angerme otaku trying to pit Musume and Juice against each other
No, they complain plenty lol
You just can't see it because their accounts are locked
Background and Key Points of This Debate
For nearly 30 years, Hello! Project has run on a structure with Morning Musume as its flagship while supporting multiple ‘little sister’ groups such as Angerme and Juice=Juice. The ‘history’ discussed in the thread refers to the accumulated weight of Morning Musume’s decades of media exposure and Kohaku Uta Gassen appearances — an asset that sits on a completely different axis from the current members’ own ability. The debate split over a single point: should a group’s standing be measured by ‘accumulated past achievements’ or by ‘current TV appearances and popularity’? Both positions reflect a clash that has repeated itself on 5ch for years. One thing readers can easily misread is that the ‘must-not-surpass’ unwritten rule isn’t an official policy from the talent agency — it’s simply an atmosphere and sense of hierarchy that fans themselves talk about. In fact, the Juice=Juice members’ own Instagram remarks were expressions of gratitude toward Morning Musume, not meant to stoke any rivalry.
Note: This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project) thread ‘The unwritten rule that little-sister group (Juice=Juice) must not surpass Morning Musume.’

Leave a Reply