From our other sites
The story
The Game Awards (TGA) announced its Game of the Year nominees, sparking a wave of reactions on 5ch’s “Nandemo Jikkyou G” (Live Everything G) board. The nominee list includes the yet-to-be-released Grand Theft Auto 6 and the remake The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, prompting questions about how a game that hasn’t even shipped can be eligible, as well as debate over how remakes should be treated. The TGA’s eligibility window is traditionally set as any game released by the third Friday of November (Pacific Time) each year, and some pointed out that this standard hasn’t changed from year to year — but others felt uneasy about nominating a game before its reception has even settled, leading to a clash between what’s technically allowed by the rules and what simply feels right.
What people said
・Resident Evil Requiem
・The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Can't help it, there's a one-nomination-per-publisher rule, but I think they could still take home a Best Studio-type award
They won it back in the VGA days (the show's old name before it became TGA), so they're not doing too badly
Though the 3DS version of Ocarina of Time didn't win anything
That's stirring up controversy overseas too
A Metascore of 96 was bound to get nominated — remake or not
TGA really does lean on Metascore after all — no game with a Metascore in the 70s has ever been nominated before, and sure enough Crimson Desert, sitting in the 70s, didn't make the cut either
But doesn't that just mean the devs were forced to rush it out to hit the deadline — nobody's worried about bugs and stuff?
Under TGA's own rules it meets the conditions for nomination, so outsiders kicking up a fuss doesn't really change anything
Every year, anything released by the third Friday of November (Pacific Time) is eligible — whether it's out before the nominees are announced doesn't matter
Getting nominated before release, before reviews have even settled, basically means they're picking it on name recognition alone though
47 Anonymous, Still Running 2026/11/18 (Wed) 09:24:45.65 ID:QTp2wu0w0
Re: #39
Rockstar delayed it so many times that the release date they finally landed on is right up against the deadline — isn't the point that they forced it to line up on purpose?
Honestly it'd be scary if it turns into another Cyberpunk situation (a reference to Cyberpunk 2077's disastrous buggy launch)
This is probably the same guy who derailed things in Re: #30 [literally 'flew a plane' — 5ch slang for hijacking a thread with an off-topic tangent], but here he's saying it'd be scary if it goes full Cyberpunk, right?
So this guy was talking about the game's quality from the start, not the nomination rules — the whole 'he's complaining about the selection process' thing is just your own assumption, isn't it?
If it's your first playthrough, going in with 'Metascore 96! A TGA GOTY nominee!' hype sky-high, I think it'd blow you away
Overseas fans really do love Zelda — enough to make you go 'there's no way this is a 90' [implying the high score owes more to fan love than raw quality]
That's some serious favoritism (忖度/sontaku — bending rules to curry favor)
No, they didn't change anything — the third Friday's always been the cutoff
But psychologically, people still feel like 'an unreleased title shouldn't count,' and that's where the pushback is coming from
That's not right
Every year, anything released by the third Friday of November (Pacific Time) is eligible — whether it's out before the nominee announcement doesn't matter
If it were truly impossible it wouldn't even get nominated
If GTA stumbles, I could actually see it winning
If GTA stumbles, I feel like Resident Evil takes it instead
Remakes do make it to nominee status
But they never actually win
Things are already heated over nominating a GTA6 that isn't even out yet — letting it win on top of that would cause even more chaos
If GTA falls through, it's gotta be Resident Evil
Either way it kills my enthusiasm
So what would actually satisfy you, then?
Background and Key Points of This Debate
The Game Awards (TGA) is a major gaming awards show held every November, and eligible titles are traditionally those “released by the third Friday of November (Pacific Time).” As posters in the thread pointed out, this standard hasn’t changed year to year, and any game released by the day before the nominee announcement can qualify. The real point of contention was narrower: even granting that GTA6 meets the criteria, is it actually appropriate to nominate a game before its reception has had time to settle? That’s where the technical correctness of the rules and people’s gut-level sense of fairness diverged. As for the Ocarina of Time remake, posters noted past cases of remakes making it to nomination, citing its high Metascore (96) as the deciding factor — though it’s worth noting that’s just thread-level folk reasoning, not an officially stated TGA criterion.
*This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (“Nandemo Jikkyou G”) thread “[Tragic News] Here Are The Game Awards’ GOTY Nominees lolololololol.”
Leave a Reply