From our other sites
The story
The Game Awards 2026 announced its Game of the Year (GOTY) nominees, and once again not a single highly-rated Microsoft title — including Forza Horizon 6 (Metascore 90), Gears E-Day (87), and CoD: MW4 (85) — made the list. On the main 5ch thread, posters noted that this pattern has continued for years, with many suggesting host Geoff Keighley is simply hard on Xbox, while others raised doubts about the authority and selection criteria of the GOTY award itself, broadening the debate into a question of the award’s overall value.
What people said
Translated from English
Nominees for #TheGameAwards 2026 Game of the Year:
It didn't sell enough to be #1.
Why tell a lie that gets caught that fast?
It's basically a Keighley Direct sponsored solely by Sony.
Guess it's on us for watching it. Yeah, I know.
Well, GTA's practically engaged to PlayStation at this point.
I'm starting to wonder what the point of GOTY even is anymore.
Well, any authority that hands out awards like this ends up corrupted eventually.
And there's no mechanism in place to prevent that corruption.
If it gets too blatant though, everyone's gonna lose interest lol
If the money involved balloons too much, it'll go extinct like E3 did.
But they keep hyping it up as an 'awards race' (when really it all comes down to money).
Might be best to view GOTY the same way you'd view the Monde Selection or the Kanda Curry Grand Prix at this point (both are awards widely seen in Japan as more pay-to-play than merit-based).
Well, Astro Bot kind of proved it's worth about as much as a gold medal at a fried chicken grand prix…
Are there still people out there who buy a game just because it was nominated or won something?
Personally I think Astro Bot is a solid (even good) platformer,
but the sales just weren't there at all.
If that game hadn't been a Sony title, it might actually have been held up as a model example of what an awards race should look like.
Saying it has to compete within the racing game field is basically admitting it's not GOTY material to begin with.
Just let it duke it out in its own genre category.
Though Gears rated lower than Saros anyway (´・ω・`)
Meanwhile our SIE just had its 11-year nomination streak snapped (´・ω・`)
Wolverine was probably supposed to be the one that got in, but…
The thread title already assumes everyone knows that — that's exactly why it says 'again' this year.
Indiana Jones and the Great Circle

GOTY wins:
・Won GOTY at 33 outlets, including Eurogamer, Gamescom, and more
https://goty.gamefa.com/year/2024/
GOTY nominations:
・Nominated for GOTY at a huge number of outlets, including the D.I.C.E Awards, Golden Joystick Awards, and more
↓
The Game Awards 2025
・Only nominated in the Action/Adventure category — extending the streak of keeping Microsoft titles out of the overall GOTY race
Yeah, I thought that too — should've done a simultaneous PS launch (´・ω・`)
It's not just 'cold treatment' — it's well known overseas that Geoff Keighley is openly anti-Xbox.
Maybe say that after it actually beats RE9 at the GJA…
GOTY goes to 'Resident Evil Requiem'! 'Mecha Chameleon' also sweeps 4 categories — winners of the historic 'Golden Joystick Awards' 2026 announced
https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/756dd84aca3182ff11aba689b8e107e358af5c89
The GJA winners are picked by a worldwide gamer vote, so if it loses there, that just means gamers worldwide are the ones giving it the cold shoulder lol
Geoff worshipped Kojima, and having him poached by Microsoft sent him into a rage —
he's probably never nominating another Microsoft title again, barring a new Kojima game.
He's hardcore about it — he probably won't even nominate Kojima anymore.
Last year it was Geoff who chose the money from '33' over Kojima and Death Stranding 2.
Overseas leaks showed Kojima's face was pretty rough about it too.
・Control Resonant (Metascore 83)
・007 (Metascore 87)
・Phantom Blade Zero (Metascore 86)
Excluded Microsoft titles:
・Forza Horizon 6 (Metascore 90)
・Gears E-DAY (Metascore 87)
・CoD: MW4 (Metascore 85)
Seriously, this was a banner year for Microsoft titles.
The host is openly hostile on social media all the time anyway — Microsoft should just cut ties with TGA already.
Forza Horizon 5, which won all 4 categories it was nominated in, gets left off,
while Ratchet & Clank, nominated but winning absolutely nothing, gets treated like GOTY material — what a garbage list.
And for that matter, where did Deathloop and Psychonauts 2 go, given they were GOTY nominees too?
Background and Key Points of This Discussion
The Game Awards, hosted by Geoff Keighley since 2014, is one of the gaming industry’s biggest award shows, and a GOTY win or nomination is said to carry significant weight for media exposure and sales. Nominees are decided not solely by Metascore or sales figures but by a vote among judges selected by the organizers, so a highly-rated title isn’t guaranteed a spot. The claim raised in the thread that “Xbox has gone 12 years straight without a nomination” comes from a forum post and should be treated with caution, since it is not an officially tallied or published statistic. Likewise, the many posts discussing the host’s attitude toward Xbox are speculation based on past patterns, not evidence officially presented about the selection process.
※This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware/Industry (Geha)) thread “[Sad News] Microsoft First-Party Titles Get Zero GOTY Nominations Again This Year“.

Leave a Reply