Director Narimichi Sugita Warns of Jidaigeki Crisis: ‘Just Save Uzumasa Already’ — 5ch Reacts: ‘I Mean, They’re Fictional Japanese People Anyway’

From our other sites

The story

Director Narimichi Sugita, known for jidaigeki (period drama) channel productions like “Homecoming” and “Promise,” took the stage for the keynote speech at “Inter BEE 2026,” held November 18 at Makuhari Messe, to discuss the appeal of jidaigeki and its potential for overseas expansion. He argued that Japan should sell its culture abroad by leveraging the uniquely Japanese aesthetics of “exhilaration,” “poetic justice,” and “human warmth,” while also sounding the alarm over the current crisis in passing down filming techniques and skilled talent to the next generation. Reactions on 5ch were split over where to place the blame for jidaigeki’s decline — some pointed fingers at TV networks’ programming policies or the casting of Johnny’s talent, others argued that the “poetic justice” formula epitomized by Mito Kōmon has simply worn out its welcome, and still others claimed that television merely coasted on the legacy left behind by Showa-era jidaigeki films.

Mynavi News

“To sell Japanese culture overseas, start with jidaigeki” — Narimichi Sugita, who directed works like “Homecoming” and “Promise” for a period-drama-specialty channel, took the stage on the 18th for a keynote speech at “Inter BEE 2026,” held at Makuhari Messe in Chiba. While discussing the appeal of Japanese period dramas and their potential for overseas expansion, he also warned that the transmission of production techniques is in crisis.

The appeal of jidaigeki, which connects to works like “Shōgun” and “Demon Slayer”

Source: news.mynavi.jp / Original article here

What people said

3AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:28
They're fictional Japanese people to begin with, though.
80AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:16
Re: #3
That's true of basically every drama — they're all fiction.
What's this guy even talking about
4AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:30
I've heard that China's movie-studio-town facilities are so well-equipped that even indie historical live-action adventure games end up with needlessly lavish costumes.
5AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:32
There's also the Korean approach of just milking one narrow era over and over, but people would complain about that too — though honestly, Japan does pretty much the same thing.
6AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:33
Lol, I thought this guy was dead. Guess he's still alive.
He's not Sō Kuramoto though — who am I mixing him up with?
7AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:34
True, it is weird that China and Korea can build lavish sets for their period dramas but Japan can't.
15AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:42
Re: #7
Korea just reuses the same sets. Though the recent ones use CG.
8AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:34
Even now, 'the underling overthrows his lord' stories like in NHK's Taiga dramas are popular.
But the type of jidaigeki popular in the late Showa era — where the authorities solve things instead of the victims — that only lasted through the baby-boomer generation.
12AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:40
Why don't they do Chūshingura anymore?
It's been over 10 years since I've seen it at year-end.
A rerun would be fine lol
17AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:42
Re: #12
Maybe it's because nobody gets rewarded in the end — that's probably not great.
14AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:40
Just go all-out like those over-the-top Chinese anti-Japanese war dramas (kōnichi shinju).
https://imgur.com/6vr7Bd2.jpg
16AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:42
It's the TV networks — not us — who disrespected Japanese culture the most, killed off jidaigeki, and flooded the airwaves with garbage variety shows full of Johnny's and Yoshimoto talent.
20AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:43
Re: #16
It's thanks to Johnny's talent doing jidaigeki that we can still barely watch any on terrestrial TV at all — you've got it totally backwards.
18AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:42
Japanese jidaigeki are so obsessed with historical accuracy and chasing realism that there's little room for fantasy or romance. Also, when people say 'jidaigeki,' it's always samurai-centered stories about bushi, with no breadth. Lately, riding the Netflix wave, time-slip and body-swap stories have shown up, and some of them are actually fun, but I think the lack of breadth is on the creators' side more than the viewers'.
22AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:44
Re: #18
It's totally sloppy — the Edo period spans 300 years, yet they use the same costumes the whole time.
25AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:45
Re: #18
Mid-Showa era period films were wild and anything-goes.
At some point, sorcery and yōkai just quietly disappeared from jidaigeki.
23AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:45
Re: #1
>He also cited 'exhilaration,' 'poetic justice,' and 'human warmth' as the three pillars of jidaigeki's appeal, explaining that a uniquely Japanese aesthetic underlies them.

People are sick to death of Mito Kōmon and the cherry-blossom tattoo reveal (a reference to recurring jidaigeki clichés).
54AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:05
Re: #23
In the end, that kind of lazy poetic-justice formula is one of the reasons jidaigeki fell apart.
76AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:16
Re: #23
Also, with the rise of the internet, it's come out that Mito Mitsukuni never actually traveled around like that, that Ōoka Echizen didn't really hand down rulings like in the show, and so on — a lot of that stuff has been debunked.
35AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:52
To begin with, TV didn't actually nurture TV jidaigeki itself —
actors and crew were trained through the period films of various directors from the Kurosawa era,
and TV just gradually ate through that inheritance bit by bit.
42AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:55
Re: #35
Before Kurosawa's jidaigeki, there was the golden age of Toei period films.
But the film industry abandoned that —
it lost popularity and shifted to yakuza (ninkyo) films and docudrama.
Kadokawa Haruki briefly revived it,
but basically, there are no producers left anymore.
Now it's falling apart for real in the TV drama world too Re: #1
46AnonymousNov 19, 2026 07:58
Godzilla is a hit.
Shōgun is also big in scale.
On the flip side, there's Ozu-style stuff too.
We don't need anything half-assed in between.
59AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:08
Re: #46
So you're saying — make a movie where they gather seven ronin to defeat Gojira (a Seven Samurai x Godzilla mashup joke).
48AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:01
Oh right, didn't Meguro come back after appearing in Shōgun Season 2?
If he actually learned something from Sanada-san while he was at it,
they should just crown him as the new jidaigeki star.
49AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:02
Re: #48
He's too big a name now, they can't use him for that.
53AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:04
Stuff like Rurouni Kenshin, which made good money, is set in the early Meiji era — I wonder if that even counts as jidaigeki.
61AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:09
Re: #53
Apparently the general view is that 'jidaigeki' only covers up through the Meiji Restoration.
63AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:10
NHK's Taiga dramas, which are supposed to be the ones doing this properly, probably don't even count as jidaigeki since they ignore historical accuracy lol
82AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:17
Re: #63
'Jidaigeki' originally meant stories like a retired lord from one of the Gosanke houses, or the shogun, or an Edo town magistrate wandering the streets and dishing out punishment to villains — which is historically absurd nonsense to begin with.
So in a sense, today's Taiga dramas ARE 'jidaigeki' lol
70AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:12
Sets and costumes aside, what's really bad about recent Taiga dramas is the dialogue.
There's no archaic flavor to the language, the actors' voices sound shallow, the speaking tempo has no pauses — honestly everything feels light and cheap.
That'd be one thing if it were a show like 'Kamakura-dono' or 'Kusa Moeru' that deliberately goes for a modern-language tone, but…
86AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:19
Re: #70
That'd be the '70s, maybe up to the '80s at the latest —
the era when the generation who had actually lived through the war in real time were still involved in writing and production.
85AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:18
The point is, make jidaigeki that actually feels like 'jidaigeki,' the way it was from the Showa era through early Heisei.
We don't need gimmicky twists or some newfangled take on historical accuracy — just make it with the same vibe as Showa-era Hissatsu Shigotonin or Mito Kōmon.
I want to watch dramas with that same gritty, intense energy from back then.
96AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:25
Re: #85
I think the opposite. Unless it shifts toward something that gets young people interested too — like the live-action Rurouni Kenshin films — while still keeping what's good about jidaigeki,
the whole genre is just going to die off along with the current old-folks generation.
102AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:31
Re: #85
It became wall-to-wall Mito Kōmon clones,
people started thinking jidaigeki was boring, and that's exactly what made the genre itself decline.
91AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:23
Lately 'narou-kei' (web-novel-style isekai/fantasy) stuff is popular, right?
The historical genre on Narou is actually pretty good.
Why not try making a narou-style jidaigeki?
95AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:25
Re: #91
There were a few Chinese period dramas like that.
103AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:32
Thinking about it now, Japanese jidaigeki are definitely made through a Western value system that only took hold after the Meiji era.
105AnonymousNov 19, 2026 08:33
Re: #103
Not just jidaigeki — I personally have this bias where I assume a lot of 'traditional' Japanese culture actually only dates back to the Meiji era.

Background and Key Points of This Discussion

It’s worth noting that this talk was given by someone connected to a broadcaster running a period-drama-specialty channel, at “Inter BEE,” a trade fair for industry professionals. In jidaigeki production, the aging of technicians responsible for costumes, set pieces, and sword-fight choreography in Uzumasa (Kyoto), along with a shortage of younger successors, has long been seen as a persistent problem, and Director Sugita’s comments extend from that context. In the thread, commenters pointed to different angles for the decline — “TV network programming,” “fatigue with the Mito-Kōmon-style poetic-justice formula,” “the casting of Johnny’s talent” — without converging on a single cause. It’s also worth noting that the success of “Shōgun” was an English-language production, and isn’t directly tied to the crisis in technical succession facing Japan’s domestic jidaigeki production system. Neither the article nor the thread addresses the point that conflating the success of an overseas production with the decline of the domestic industry can easily lead to a misunderstanding of the real situation.

*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “‘The ones who disrespect Japanese culture the most are…’ — Director Narimichi Sugita discusses the potential and crisis of jidaigeki, pointing to differences with China and Korea: ‘Just save Uzumasa already’.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *