From our other sites
The story
Among the Yahoo! News comment reactions, remarks like “Senior citizens have TV Tokyo’s ‘Toshiwasure Nippon no Uta’ (Year-End Japanese Song Special) — that’s enough for them” and “Enka singers are disappearing from Kohaku” became a hot topic. On NHK’s Kohaku Uta Gassen (the New Year’s Eve song contest), the enka singers who get a slot have been narrowed down to proven heavyweights like Sayuri Ishikawa and Fuyumi Sakamoto, reflecting the fact that no new generation of young enka singers has emerged. On 5ch’s Geisportsuku+ (celebrity/sports news) board, the thread argued it’s premature to lump Kohaku and the TV Tokyo program together as “shows for the elderly” — pointing out that TV Tokyo’s lineup actually leans more toward kayōkyoku (traditional pop) and folk songs than enka — and the discussion grew into a debate over how the very age bracket labeled the “enka generation” has itself shifted over time.
Yahoo! Original Article
[Trending on Yahoo! Comments] “Is TV Tokyo’s Enka Show Enough for Seniors?” “The Era When Enka Singers Vanish From Kohaku” – Opinions on the Generational Gap in Year-End Music Shows
11/18 (Wed) 15:23 JST
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
It's a waste having slots taken up by enka or old-time singers.
There's live streaming online now too — Kohaku's just outdated.
Today's Kohaku isn't the Kohaku seniors remember anymore.
If there's nothing on it they actually want to hear, there's no reason to stick with it.
Shows how little effort the commercial networks are putting in.
I'm not young myself, but I still spend New Year's Eve drinking with friends every year, so I haven't watched it in years either.
Hasn't the lineup been announced yet?
This year it's broadcasting live from Hachioji.
I couldn't stand watching Takashi Hosokawa and Kiyoshi Maekawa clowning around.
so the whole "elderly = enka" equation is already off to begin with.
They only turn it on because the kids or grandkids are visiting and they feel obligated.
Their real battleground is New Year's Day.
They'll never drop something like "Bakushou Hit Parade," and Nippon TV's going all-in on the Hakone Ekiden.
It's probably 80-plus, or just enka fans regardless of age at this point.
People in their 70s now are the Beatles and Takuro Yoshida generation.
By the time people our age become elderly, "Toshiwasure" will probably have turned into an anime-song special — stuff like Haruhi or K-On!
Apparently after careful deliberation they decided to cut the enka that old folks actually enjoy, so I guess that's just how it goes.
So is grandma gonna be singing "♪ Fuwa Fuwa Time" now?" (a line from the K-On! theme song)
I can picture an elderly Aya Hirano still doing the Haruhi dance.
They're out there replaying old songs on YouTube. They listen to Western music and Showa-era kayōkyoku just as readily as anything else.
No way, no way.
It's all Vocaloid and whatever's trending on TikTok.
Honestly, songs hardly ever get passed down like that — I think people just burn through whatever was popular in their own generation and move on. Take Hikaru Utada: when she first blew up I was sure her songs would transcend generations, but looking back now, they're firmly "oldies" territory.
these days even if she turns it on on New Year's Eve,
she switches the TV off and goes to bed almost right away.
I get the feeling of "it's just a bunch of people I don't recognize."
People assume it's wall-to-wall enka, but there's actually not that much enka on it.
If anything, the lineup hits home for the generation that's heavily represented on 5ch, and for their parents — and that enka lineup gets good reviews from that generation too.
Every so often there's footage of some Showa-era legend that makes people in their 80s and 90s tear up with joy, or the artist shows up in person singing and it's enough to knock you off your chair.
It's gotten to the point where parents who find Kohaku boring switch over to TV Tokyo and end up sticking with it because it's more entertaining.
The parents of 5ch users are probably more into rock, folk, Group Sounds, New Music, Western music, jazz, and kayōkyoku anyway.
5ch's core demographic is people in their 60s, so their parents are already dead.
The ratio of enka has shrunk compared to the past.
There's more kayōkyoku now.
Isn't it more the folk-song generation?
Apparently the ratio of those kinds of songs has been growing lately.
it's the same as the Baby Boom Echo generation (Japan's post-boomer "junior" cohort, roughly Gen X) getting nostalgic over '80s songs.
That generation likes to think of themselves as way younger than the old folks, but really they're not that different — they just want to hear songs like "Hisame" or "Yukiguni," from the exact same era when Yutaka Ozaki, BOØWY, Rebecca, Barbee Boys, and the Being-label acts were big.
It's really just a difference of genre, not of era.
With songs too, it's just about wanting to soak in the nostalgia of that era.
Tokusatsu shows from your formative years are still enjoyable even in reruns,
but watching tokusatsu that's airing right now is boring because you're watching it with a middle-aged guy's sensibility.
It's the same as not finding it fun that the current Ultraman is just set up as some college student.
It's tough for a young enka singer in their 20s or 30s to compete against the likes of Ado or Mrs. GREEN APPLE.
Young people are all chasing after frilly-dressed girl idols or Korean-makeup boy idols anyway.
Since neither young people nor middle-aged people listen to enka, new talent can't break through.
The only ones who get a slot are proven heavyweights, mainly Sayuri Ishikawa (49 appearances) and Fuyumi Sakamoto (38 appearances).
Pretty much none of today's enka singers in their 30s or 40s have a hit song to their own name.
Maybe Kiyoshi Hikawa, at best?
Background and Key Points of the Debate
TV Tokyo’s “Toshiwasure Nippon no Uta” tends to be seen as an enka-centric show, but posters in the thread pointed out that its actual lineup has shifted toward more kayōkyoku, alongside a wide range of classic rock, folk, and New Music acts. On Kohaku, meanwhile, enka appearances have been narrowed down year after year to proven names like Sayuri Ishikawa and Fuyumi Sakamoto, and the discussion also touched on the structural problem that no new generation of young enka singers can break through while competing against artists aimed at younger listeners, such as Ado or Mrs. GREEN APPLE. Opinion split over exactly who counts as the “enka generation”: some argued the true core audience is 75 and older, while others countered that today’s 70-somethings grew up on the Beatles and Takuro Yoshida and belong to a different category altogether from enka fans. The point readers are most likely to get wrong is lumping Kohaku and the TV Tokyo program together as the same kind of “enka show for seniors” — the thread’s real debate was actually about how different the two shows’ content is.
*This article is composed of excerpts and a summary from the 5ch (Geisportsuku+) thread “‘Is TV Tokyo’s “Toshiwasure Nippon no Uta” Enough for Seniors?’ ‘The Era When Enka Singers Vanish From Kohaku’ — Opinions on the Generational Gap in Year-End Music Shows.”
Leave a Reply