Shoki Oda’s Path Wavers Amid MLB Lockout — 5ch: ‘Not Even Saying Hello Is Part of the Plan’

From our other sites

The story

Right-hander Shoki Oda (18), the Yokohama High School ace who has declared his intent to pursue MLB, is being forced into a decision about his future due to the effects of the lockout. He has met with 10 teams including the Dodgers and Yankees, holding a three-hour discussion with the Dodgers — seen as the favorite — while U.S. media have reported that signing with the Yomiuri Giants could also become a realistic option. The negotiation deadline is reportedly March 31 next year. On 5ch’s Geino/Sports Breaking News+ thread, posters debated doubts about the Giants’ player-development environment, comparisons with pitcher Rintaro Sasaki (who chose to attend a U.S. college instead), and the pros and cons of life in the minor leagues.

[MLB] ‘I Think Shoki Oda Will Sign With the Giants’ — Caught Up in the Lockout, a Painful Choice Looms: U.S. Report

The outlook is growing murky for Shoki Oda (18, Yokohama), the 157 km/h-throwing right-hander who has declared his intention to take on MLB.

So far he has met with 10 teams, including the Dodgers, Yankees, Mets, Rangers, Blue Jays, and Cardinals, and sat down with the Dodgers — considered the favorite — for nearly three hours.

Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

What people said

4AnonymousNov 19, 2026 00:56
Re: #1
This right here is why the minors are a dead-end gig 🥲
5AnonymousNov 19, 2026 00:56
With Matsui and Ma-kun around, that place is basically New York already (Ma-kun = pitcher Masahiro Tanaka's nickname)
8AnonymousNov 19, 2026 00:57
One scenario floating around: even when scout Mizuno came to see him, Oda didn't so much as say hello
9AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:00
Did he see that coming all along?
81AnonymousNov 19, 2026 05:15
Re: #9
(ヾノ・∀・`) Nah, nah, forget it lol
10AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:03
Dentsu's pulling the strings behind the scenes on this one… (Dentsu = Japan's dominant ad agency, a go-to conspiracy-joke target)
13AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:05
People have been saying a lockout was coming a year ago already.

Ahh, I see…

So it's a secret backroom deal after all, lol
14AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:06
> Negotiation window with the Giants runs out March 31

Huh, that short?
17AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:14
Re: #14
The reason Rintaro Sasaki's deadline was end of July was
that it was a special exception deadline for players still enrolled at an overseas school
15AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:10
Does the current Giants organization even have the setup to actually develop pitchers?
16AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:12
No way he signs with the Giants — he wouldn't even meet with Mizuno and sent him packing, yet he's spending hours in talks with MLB teams
21AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:19
Re: #16
It wasn't even a negotiation to begin with, just a courtesy greeting
Even with Ohtani, the development-plan documents didn't come out until their third meeting
18AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:15
Isn't he just going to go the college route like Sasaki did?
22AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:20
If he ends up signing there, people will just say that was the secret deal all along too
24AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:22
Look at it the other way — he's already got the Giants locked in as a safety net,
so he can take his time picking a path without rushing
25AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:23
Just lock in a posting guarantee after 5 or 6 years and call it done (posting = the system letting NPB players move to MLB)
26AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:26
Not succeeding in America is surely already factored into the plan.
Don't you dare pull something as painfully lame as blowing off a greeting and then signing with the Giants anyway
27AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:28
He's the type who won't even say hello, so by all means — off to America with him
28AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:28
Nah, just let him grind it out in the minors forever —
as a cautionary tale about a kid led astray by the people around him
29AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:30
There's no guarantee at all that he actually makes it big, you know —
even the guys hyped up as the high school 'Big 3'
never cracked the first-team roster and all got cut loose
30AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:31
Go on, Oda! Off to America you go —
there's no turning back now!
32AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:32
The second he returns a greeting, people start screaming 'secret deal' or 'collusion.'

To the old geezers who just want kids these days to show them some respect —
I get it, now please be quiet
33AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:36
He can just live his life as the next Uehara, nothing to be ashamed of ( ゚Д゚) (Uehara = Koji Uehara, former MLB reliever)
34AnonymousNov 19, 2026 01:36
If it's a lockout, wouldn't U.S. college ball be the move?
Can't earn money there though
39AnonymousNov 19, 2026 02:00
He should just get the Giants to agree to a special clause letting him head to America once he turns 25
44AnonymousNov 19, 2026 02:05
Re: #39
There's a pretty decent chance he gets released before he even turns 25 though
42AnonymousNov 19, 2026 02:04
Why? He already went to the US knowing a quick jump to the majors wasn't realistic —
sign a minor-league deal and spend a year or two in a league outside the lockout, that's fine
43AnonymousNov 19, 2026 02:05
Re: #42
> Minor-league contract players aren't exempt either
Oh, so that's how it is
48AnonymousNov 19, 2026 02:10
Seems like it's been nothing but underwhelming Japanese players lately —
guess America's finally caught on
49AnonymousNov 19, 2026 02:14
Re: #48
You're really giving off that 'I know everything' vibe.
That kind of old-guard — er, elderly — condescension really knows no limits
50AnonymousNov 19, 2026 02:19
There's also the corporate-league route —
going to the Giants would mean way too long a wait until posting (社会人 = Japan's corporate/industrial-league baseball, a common pre-pro path)
55AnonymousNov 19, 2026 02:38
Re: #50
Oh, the Giants will work something out there, lol —
something like 'we'll post you after three 10-win seasons' or 'after even one 10-win season that helps us win the Japan Series'

Background and Key Points of This Debate

In MLB, when a lockout follows the expiration of the collective bargaining agreement, it effectively restricts contracts for international amateur players too. In Oda’s case, the setup is such that — regardless of his own preference — if he can’t sign with a U.S. team before the system’s deadline (March 31 next year), staying in Japanese baseball becomes a genuinely realistic fallback. Where the thread split was over how to judge the minor-league environment: some called it ‘brutal,’ while others pushed back using testimony from players who’d actually lived it, insisting ‘the treatment is good.’ There were also posters who saw the meeting with the Giants scout as nothing more than a courtesy ‘greeting’ — a nuance that’s easy to miss from the headline alone, namely how precisely the word ‘sign’ in the reporting actually reflects the real stage of negotiations.

*This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geino/Sports Breaking News+) thread ‘[MLB] “I Think Shoki Oda Will Sign With the Giants” — Caught Up in the Lockout, a Painful Choice Looms: U.S. Report.’

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *