From our other sites
The story
In a Hello! Project thread, a request from a new fan — a former Johnny’s fan — sparked discussion. The gist: “I want more YouTube content showing what members do off-duty,” “Even shorts are fine, just give us more videos,” and “Put the lyrics up on screen at live shows.” The thread split down the middle: some agreed, saying “it’d be fun if they did it,” while others raised worries about doxxing and stalker-identification risks, and others pointed out that the DVD Magazine (D-Maga) has been getting thinner in content every year. Opinions were divided.
What people said
Something a friend of mine — a new fan going by 'Moremi' (and a former Johnny's fan) — said she wanted from Juice=Juice and Hello! Project:
・There's way too little YouTube content showing what members do off-duty — want more of it, like seeing their reactions in a haunted house, that kind of thing
It'd be fun if they did it
What about the other groups though
Come see them live
Watch the members, not a screen
Any more exposure than this would be dangerous
Is being identified actually a problem?
It's not like asking them to expose places from their everyday life — more like filming where they eat or what they visit while on tour, right?
Asking Hello! Project — basically its own isolated Galapagos island — for something that's standard everywhere else is a tall order
・Even shorts are fine, just want more of them (for free), it's lonely otherwise
・Want lyrics put up on screen at live shows (while keeping ticket prices the same)
On ticket prices — people would still pay even past 10,000 yen
Hello! Project is just unusually cheap; other agencies' live tickets routinely top 10,000 yen anyway
Especially BEYOOOOONDS ("Biyo")
They've got some nerve selling something that costs so little to make
Back in the day it had proper content, and plenty of people became fans through the DVD Magazine
Via the DVD Magazine (meaning, after watching reposts of it on Niconico Douga)
ANGERME's isn't even backstage footage — it's just a fixed-camera clip of the MC segment from every show
Hands down the most boring DVD Magazine by a mile
Though there aren't many, and they don't upload it to YouTube
Instagram Stories are kind of like that
Just members goofing around together
Tsubaki Factory was pretty good too — their 'Ikutsuba' content lets you learn a lot about them
Even if an unpopular group tries hard, that doesn't fix being unpopular
Maybe they'd have room to spare if they shut down the other groups?
Shut down Juice=Juice and the deficit's solved 😁
It's what you'd call a necessary evil
The real problem is the fossilized higher-ups at this crappy agency don't get that at all
If reposts are fine, couldn't the official YouTube channel just upload it directly?
You've been way too tamed by the agency lol
It's not even really selling in the first place
If anything, Juice=Juice fans are probably the ones buying the DVD Magazine the most
Being a fossil is just fine
But for you, isn't it just that 'staying a fossil feels comfortable', not that you're actually 'still buying fossil products like the DVD Magazine'?
As long as it's Juice=Juice, any content naturally ends up fun
It's less that they don't want to entertain fans and more that the agency's own tastes are just way too strong
That's exactly it
Harostation (Hello! Station) doesn't fit the times and nobody wants it, yet this agency keeps doing it anyway
'Nobody' wants it??
Have you seen the view counts??
Everything's paid content
And as a result, nobody but Sandaime J Soul Brothers has really broken through
Nobody even knows them these days anyway
Chasing short-term small change like that always ends up this way
Background and key points of this topic
Hello! Project has long centered its content strategy on paid, subscription-style offerings like the DVD Magazine (D-Maga) and the streaming program “Hello! Station,” putting it at odds with the idol/entertainment industry’s recent shift toward free YouTube shorts. The thread’s worry that “showing off-duty footage would just feed the stalker-doxxing crowd” reflects a real risk — footage of tour-stop locations could help pin down members’ living areas and lead to stalking — so the request can’t simply be written off as “the agency being lazy.” It’s also worth noting that the claim “Juice=Juice is running a deficit” is a self-deprecating rumor that circulates repeatedly among fans, not disclosed financial information.
*This article excerpts and summarizes the 5ch (Hello! Project) thread “New fan ‘Moremi’ (former Johnny’s fan): ‘I want content showing what members do off-duty. Even shorts are fine, just give us more videos. Put lyrics on the screen at live shows.’“
Leave a Reply