Reactions to a “correct answer” comparison pic for middle-aged men’s fashion — 5ch: “New Balance just doesn’t work”

Written by

in

A thread on 5ch’s “Nandemo Jikkyō G” (Anything Goes Live) board shared an image comparing good and bad examples of “middle-aged dad” fashion.

Replies piled up over whether New Balance sneakers actually pair well with a jacket, and whether tucking your shirt in makes you look sharper. Many also agreed with the take that “looking clean-cut just means wearing clothes that actually fit your body.”

1Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:22:26.43ID:ID:oPGmcuBy0
The left one's seriously lame lmaooo
3Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:24:14.96ID:rmaq1xQZ0
Take the photos in the same pose, come on
53Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:01:29.68ID:hPHojCvB0
>>3
Exactly this!
And honestly, they should've matched the composition and size too, or it's not a fair comparison
76Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:20:40.30ID:Ja+QbKq/0
>>3
This.
Also the facial expression needs to match, or it's not really a comparison
4Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:24:20.27ID:gj8wBDtM0
In the end all you can do is make yourself look as sharp as possible
7Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:25:16.43ID:l86kzwDJ0
It's a no-go the moment New Balance is involved
14Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:26:43.32ID:lYJJ0q5U0
>>7
But they're the comfiest to wear, though
10Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:26:06.02ID:CfGjFS5td
So basically an undercut and glasses equals stylish?
11Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:26:14.55ID:TWhkdMTx0
Jacket and tie with sneakers, though…
12Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:26:17.64ID:xhtMuUrn0
Thought it looked a bit off, then realized it's a Seoul (Korean street-style) thing
This old guy actually pulls it off well
https://livedoor.blogimg.jp/kaikaihanno/imgs/9/9/9993bc6e.jpg
56Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:03:27.74ID:hPHojCvB0
>>12
He's got a sharp build to begin with, so it looks decent even left as-is
13Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:26:25.86ID:zn/7sUSq0
If your gut isn't sticking out, tucking your shirt in makes you look better, right
15Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:27:15.19ID:MpBK4Mct0
The left one's deliberately styled to look sloppy
The sizing's off too
18Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:30:16.48ID:zn/7sUSq0
>>15
Someone up top said "looking clean-cut just means wearing clothes that fit your body size" — yeah, I really feel that now
16Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:28:55.04ID:ATT/fuNW0
You're better off not wearing New Balance
19Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:30:39.34ID:p/KsqJUZ0


Sneakers with this outfit just look wrong
44Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:52:55.81ID:A9aMRl7Q0
>>19
It's not weird these days anymore (lol)
Even old guys gotta update with the times or they'll get left behind
59Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:06:33.08ID:hPHojCvB0
>>19
Talent managers, startup founder types, people trying to look stylish — this is basically their go-to look now

It's easy to move around in

Feels like it's gotten more common since the earthquake
96Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:32:53.27ID:xhtMuUrn0
>>19
This has kind of a "BEAMS guy from 20 years ago" vibe (BEAMS = a Japanese fashion brand)
21Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:32:29.45ID:Bz0DwsUba
Bugs me that some of them skip the belt
22Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:32:29.78ID:dM86Xpgp0
Middle-aged guys with a try-hard undercut ("iki-ri tsuu-buro") are cringe to look at, just stop
25Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:40:05.07ID:3+wpBb+50
A "fashionable" old dude is just cringe
27Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:40:46.78ID:lYJJ0q5U0
>>25
Totally get that
38Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:51:22.00ID:sE3bf+Pw0
If he's not even wearing a hat, he clearly doesn't get it
41Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:52:23.75ID:CjYyZ9Ky0
Should middle-aged guys wear glasses even if their eyesight's fine?
42Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:52:42.08ID:zn/7sUSq0
>>41
You'll get presbyopia eventually anyway
45Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:53:46.28ID:p/KsqJUZ0
>>44
Nobody's even looking at an old guy's outfit anyway
46Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:54:44.09ID:dYq8v23W0
>>45
You lose
48Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 07:55:24.45ID:NYC5K9Ed0
Feels like the shoes just don't match the rest of the outfit overall…
60Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:07:33.82ID:9vTs6EwS0
>>48
Well it's a New Balance ad, so can't be helped
73Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:17:14.91ID:DVK5/wSB0
If you're doing sneakers with a jacket, at least go leather, like Stan Smiths
New Balance just doesn't match
75Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:18:59.11ID:hPHojCvB0
>>73
Leather sneakers are actually the lamest option for this style lmao
82Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:26:26.04ID:hPHojCvB0
Comparison photos
Good example


Bad example

84Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:27:57.90ID:sE3bf+Pw0
>>63
He's got a full head of hair, you baldy
Once you're older, styling your hair's a hassle, hence the hat
87Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:28:48.43ID:hPHojCvB0
>>84
I mean YOU'RE the bald one
Anyone trying to stick a hat on him is bald
86Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:28:33.16ID:oPGmcuBy0
You can't grasp the importance of balancing casual and formal without knowing some fashion history

Middle-aged guys keep recycling the all-casual outfits that were trendy in the 1990s, which is why they end up looking like overgrown kids

92Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:31:24.33ID:hPHojCvB0
"Inbound uncles" (older foreign tourists) are all over Tokyo these days
And it's pretty much all like this lol

98Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:35:11.01ID:hPHojCvB0
>>93

101Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:38:37.57ID:hPHojCvB0
Uniqlo

This is pretty rough too if you ask me lol


103Anonymous2026/08/23(日) 08:41:14.00ID:BCub8PUK0
>>101
So damn lame!

*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyō G) thread “[Image] The “correct answer” for old-guy fashion has been found lmaooooo”.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *