From our other sites
The story
Photos of a meal served at a children’s cafeteria hosted by comedian/TV personality Yasuko became a hot topic on a 5ch thread. The menu featured fried shrimp, fries, and corn, drawing comments about the lack of protein and poor nutritional balance — while others pushed back, arguing it’s unfair to criticize a free, volunteer-run support effort at all. Yasuko has publicly shared that she grew up in a children’s group home, and the thread also debated an operational concern: whether these children’s cafeterias are actually reaching the families that need them most.
What people said
Looks like simmered winter melon
Might not exactly be kid-friendly though
Wait, she's that young?
Honestly, if it's gonna be like this, I think curry or something — like other people are suggesting — would've been better
This one's reservation/lottery-based, you know
It's not reaching the kids who actually need it
Yasuko grew up in a children's group home and didn't really know how to survive on her own, so when she aged out of the facility she just joined the Self-Defense Force because they take care of everything for you. That's all it was.
Remember when a reporter showed up while Sugi Ryotaro was running a soup kitchen in a disaster area and some idiot asked him, 'Is this just self-promotion?'
Sugi basically said, 'Of course it's self-promotion — you can buy self-promotion with money, so go ahead and do it too' — that was badass
I say this because I've been through something similar myself, but there are a lot of garbage people who barely do anything meaningful and then put on a hero act like 'I helped! I worked for so-and-so!' turning it into inspiration porn, acting like some understanding insider even though they did nothing themselves
Honestly, feeding kids is a good thing, but this menu doesn't look like something kids would actually enjoy, and it's lacking in several nutrients too
I'll grudgingly let the lottery system slide, but at least think about the nutrition in the menu
The first thing poor households lack is protein, so that's what you should be trying to make up for
The menu basically mirrors what a poor household's meals look like — lacking in protein
It's weird that they're turning that exact situation into the 'support'
> I'll grudgingly let the lottery system slide, but at least think about the nutrition in the menu
Who do you think you are? lol
Once someone's been labeled 'fair game to bash,' people act like they can bash them no matter what they do
There are surprisingly a lot of messed-up people like that out there
So are the kids who show up really visibly from poor families?
The place I help at only runs twice a month, so not really — it feels more like the kids are just coming to hang out
It's actually the opposite
I wouldn't call them rich kids, but most of them are from at-least-decent households
These things have basically no promotional reach, so the only option is to post about it online — meaning only kids whose parents are savvy enough to dig up that info end up showing up
The truly struggling kids at the bottom can't even reach it
That's why I quit helping with this kind of support
Re: #94
I see… so there are vulnerable people here too who are info-poor and end up getting none of the support they actually need
Getting the word out is genuinely hard
Even when you ask public schools to let you put up flyers so you can reach poor kids, they almost always refuse
At my place we did boxed lunches, and the kids who took them home did seem to be the poorer ones
Sounds like a well-behaved crowd
I heard my place tried that a few times too, but there were kids trying to grab extras saying 'this one's for my parents, this one's for my siblings,' and explaining that it's one per kid was such a hassle they stopped it quickly
At my place, taking extras for family is fine
What's feeding them one meal a week supposed to accomplish?
Using food as a hook to connect kids who are genuinely struggling to welfare services, that's one purpose
On top of that, it's also about giving kids with nowhere else to belong a space where they can feel 'at least here, I'm allowed to be'
I mean, that basically means 'survive the whole week off this one meal'
Reality's harsh like that
There's also the goal of preventing isolation during child-rearing or kids eating alone — it's not just about poverty
You mean the 'Mom's Kitchen' ads?
That was quite a while ago, wasn't it?
Background and Key Points of the Debate
There are said to be more than 10,000 children’s cafeterias across Japan, most run by volunteers using donated ingredients. Donations tend to skew toward grains and processed foods, since protein sources like meat and fish cost more to procure — a structural reason protein often ends up in short supply. The thread split over two issues: how much criticism is fair to level at a well-intentioned, unpaid support effort, and an operational concern that announcing lottery slots on social media favors households savvy enough to seek out that information, making it harder for truly struggling families to get through. That Yasuko herself grew up in a children’s group home is a fact she has shared publicly, and it came up as background context for understanding her activities. The questions raised about nutrition and how the program is run are also issues that apply more broadly to soup kitchens and food-assistance efforts in general.
※This article is compiled as an excerpt and summary from the 5ch (Nanademo Jikkyo G board) thread “[Image] Here’s the jackpot day at Yasuko’s Cafeteria wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww.”
Leave a Reply