From our other sites
The story
On 5ch’s early-risers thread, a debate broke out over whether front-load or top-load washing machines actually get clothes cleaner. It kicked off with a post claiming ‘people mock you for using a front-loader,’ which drew pushback that this is just a lingering impression from the days when front-loaders had a lot of early defects, along with a steady stream of comments insisting that the old-school twin-tub washer is still the best of all. Posters also compared how each type works: front-loaders use a gentle tumbling action that’s easy on clothes, while top-loaders rely on friction washing that lifts out dirt at the cost of wearing down the fibers. Others raised the front-loader-specific risk of entrapment accidents, broadening the discussion beyond cleaning power to include safety and how much upkeep each machine demands.
What people said
If you're using a Kantaro-kun (a popular Rinnai gas clothes dryer), go top-load.
Either way, you eliminate hang-drying time — and with it, the dust and pollen that get on clothes outside.
Because it's cheaper than a front-loader.
That's typical of organizations that value cheap equipment over labor costs.
They're cheap, and apparently they get dirt out easily.
Factor in the hassle of hang-drying and see how much that changes the labor-cost math.
They're getting covered in mud every single day anyway.
What's even wrong with clothes being a little damp?
and someone who can stay right beside the machines,
running several twin-tubs as a pipeline
gets you more than double the throughput of a fully automatic washer.
You save water too.
In my house it's just one person running one machine.
With a top-loader, they won't.
Top-load: friction-washing strips dirt out along with the fibers (damages clothes), tangles everything up, wastes water.
About the only upside is being able to toss in a forgotten item mid-cycle.
Even without turning it on, a front-loader can kill — if they climb in and the door shuts.
Seriously?
What are the national safety standards even doing?
Do they suffocate?
Shrinking aside, the fabric's functional properties are probably ruined too.
Though I'm just speculating here.
If you're wearing Uniqlo, maybe fix that before you start lecturing people about washing machines.
there have been accidents where a cat tries to climb out, ends up shutting the lid on itself,
and the owner runs the machine without noticing.
for either type.
That's gross…
So what's your actual routine, then?
but models with an anti-entrapment feature can be opened from inside.
they basically last forever.
Just pick one up cheap on Mercari (a Japanese flea-market app) and keep it maintained.
did that disappear because of rising non-regular employment and poverty, or because front-loaders took over?
There are still plenty of top-load-plus-Kantaro-kun (gas dryer) people around today —
it suits anyone doing a lot of laundry who wants to dry a load at the same time.
Background and Key Points of This Debate
Front-load washing machines originated overseas in hard-water regions, built around a ‘tumble-washing’ mechanism that was carried over into Japan — a country with mostly soft water — more or less as-is, which is part of why early domestic models drew criticism for weak cleaning performance. Top-load machines, by contrast, rely on friction washing driven by water currents, which gets dirt out but tends to wear down clothes and use more water. Opinions in the thread split between ‘today’s front-loaders have improved’ and ‘twin-tub is simply unbeatable in the end,’ and no single conclusion was reached. What tends to get overlooked is that, more than any gap in cleaning power, the real deciding factors are everyday practicalities — whether a machine can dry as well as wash, how much installation space it needs, and how much daily upkeep it demands — meaning this isn’t a topic that can be settled by a simple ranking of better or worse.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread ‘People say you’re an idiot if you use a front-load washer, but is top-load really that much better at getting dirt out?‘
Leave a Reply