From our other sites
The story
The Nikkei has reported that Nagoya City has fallen into the ranks of “local allocation tax recipients” — municipalities that depend on grants from the central government. The news that the central city of Aichi Prefecture, home to Toyota Motor, has landed in a state normally associated with tight finances has caused a stir. On 5ch, many pointed to the operating costs of the Asian Games — which ballooned to more than three times the original budget — and the stalled redevelopment around Nagoya Station as the culprits. At the same time, opinions clashed over how to judge the era of former mayor Kawamura, who slashed spending, versus criticism of the current mayor and city council, and the discussion even spread to talk of Nagoya breaking away from Aichi Prefecture.
Nagoya Falls to “Handouts from the Government”: A Cash-Strapped Designated City, Talk of Independence from the Prefecture Reignites — Nikkei
Designated Cities at 70 (Part 1)
September 22, 2026, 2:00 AM
Source: nikkei.com / Original article here
What people said
I couldn't believe my eyes. It looks like nothing more than sandlot baseball.
https://x.com/8anchaeha/status/2101951696893341893?s=46
People around the world are going to think this is what "TOYOTA quality" is.
Once an image takes a hit like that, it's hard to recover.
Wasn't it already near the station?
They already have their headquarters in Tokyo
They've already got a base in Nagoya and pay taxes there too
No idea why they're even holding this garbage tournament, but it's racking up a massive deficit
If they were doing this during a recession, fine, but doing it during inflation makes no sense at all
Just like the Tokyo Olympics — they trick everyone into thinking "we can do it cheap," get the project moving, then jack up the budget later. Nothing but tax thieves.
"A building as long sideways as the Great Wall of China."
Get a move on already.
Things were actually good when that guy was mayor
He kept council member salaries down and put the money into welfare and improving citizens' daily lives
But the council members who couldn't line their own pockets under him used every trick in the book to drive him out — and this is the result
Funny how the current mayor has basically reversed everything the previous mayor did
Wasn't he supposed to be his disciple?
Back to the good old days of council members and the prefectural governor calling the shots
I'd say don't be so cheap about council member pay
They're elected officials chosen by the citizens
It's not the same as grabbing a discount item at the supermarket
He was nothing but a crowd-pleasing old man itching for a fight in every direction
and Nagoya's definitely in on it too (lol)
well, that's what Nagoya's own citizens voted for
The Asian Games failed because they cut out Japanese ad agencies
and instead outsourced everything to some French events company, GL, that knows nothing about Asia.
Yet they're broke enough that they can't even rebuild the Meitetsu department store
The more you run down the countryside, the more cheap labor flows into Tokyo, and the regions decline
The internet age only sped that up further
These days it's only foreign immigrants coming to Tokyo, isn't it?
No decent industries, full of welfare recipients, a finished city
Sapporo is… yeah
Their finances are so bad that unless they suddenly scrap projects worth several billion yen without any consultation, they're headed for collapse
That giant white elephant known as Sapporo Dome (lol)
Aichi Prefecture's industrial strength is amazing, but within Nagoya City alone, the people sucking up money on welfare benefits might actually outweigh it
They can't even run an event on that scale competently, yet they talk about being a "secondary capital" — don't make me laugh.
I feel like it actually drew a bigger crowd than the Tokyo Olympics did
That reminds me of the whole shambles of the Tokyo Olympics
and those awful pavilion buildings at the Osaka Expo too (lol)
The Asian Games itself is going fine, isn't it?
If you're comparing it to the Olympics, the Olympics got slammed with plenty of criticism too
The real problem is just that they bid for it and are burning through money
Turning the athletes' village into disaster-relief containers afterward is actually a pretty good idea
It's blowing up into a huge controversy worldwide on social media, though!
Not many people know this, but
among cities that serve as prefectural capitals, can any of them beat Kawasaki's population?
Yokohama, Osaka, Fukuoka — Fukuoka's only about 100,000 people away.
They really need to build a Shinkansen station in Kawasaki
They should urgently build a new station connecting to Musashi-Kosugi
And of course, every Nozomi train should stop there
Kawasaki's population is growing too, but Fukuoka's is growing even faster
Will it actually overtake Kawasaki?
Well, they're both among the few designated cities where the Japanese population is still increasing, so I hope both keep it up
Even though they'd never admit they actually live in Kawasaki (lol)
Isn't it because that crowd is using the hometown tax donation system, causing heavy tax revenue to flow out?
Background and Key Points of This Discussion
It isn’t unusual in itself for a government-designated city to become a recipient of local allocation tax grants, but because Nagoya, home to Toyota Motor’s headquarters, has long carried a strong image of financial comfort, this report drew attention precisely because of the gap with that image. Behind it, commentators point to several factors, including the Asian Games budget — originally pegged at around 100 billion yen — ballooning to more than three times that amount, as well as the stalled redevelopment around Nagoya Station. Opinions on the thread split between those blaming the current financial troubles on the Games’ operation and the current mayor and city council, and those who praised the spending cuts made under former mayor Kawamura — reflecting a real divide over how to judge municipal management. It’s also worth noting, since it isn’t obvious from the article itself, that Toyota Motor’s head office functions are already located within Nagoya City, leaving little room for any renewed “attraction” effort.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (News Express+) thread “Nagoya Falls to “Handouts from the Government”: A Cash-Strapped Designated City, Talk of Independence from the Prefecture Reignites.”
Leave a Reply