From our other sites
The story
According to Bloomberg reporting, even as the yen touched its strongest level against the dollar in six months, Japanese retail investors have actually been piling into more short-yen positions — with data from the Financial Futures Association of Japan and others putting the estimated net short position at ¥3.61 trillion. On 5ch’s News Speed+ (Newsplus) thread, reactions were split over whether this “contrarian bet” made sense. Alongside speculation about exporters like Toyota cashing in on currency swings, plenty of posters dismissed FX trading outright as “gambling,” some sharing firsthand accounts of losing tens of millions of yen — and the discussion spiraled into a broader debate over whether retail FX trading is worth it at all.
Yen hits 6-month high, but retail investors double down with contrarian short-yen bets
(Bloomberg): Japanese retail investors are taking a contrarian stance against the yen’s rapid climb. Even as the currency strengthens to its highest level against the dollar in six months, individual traders have been building up bets against it.
Bloomberg’s analysis of margin (FX) trading data from the Financial Futures Association of Japan and the Tokyo Financial Exchange found that retail investors’ net short-yen position rose last week to an estimated ¥3.61 trillion, up from August. Bearish yen positioning had peaked at ¥4.41 trillion in July — the highest level since 2015.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Read the original article here
What people said
No idea, but the next BOJ policy meeting where a rate hike could be decided falls on the 17th (Thu) and 18th (Fri). After that, Japan heads into a 5-day holiday stretch from the 19th (Sat) through the 23rd (Wed). Once the holidays wrap up on the 24th (Thu), Japan might be stepping into a whole different world.
Toyota makes the most money around ¥135 to the dollar, so despite pouring huge investment into operations at home and abroad, they'll probably still post higher profits.
Chart-wise, that looks like it could be the mid-term target
The minpaku (Airbnb-style private lodging) operators are gonna go under lol
Is now the time to sell?
If the yen keeps strengthening like this, it's a buying opportunity
Well, I think selling once would net you more, but if you're at the "honestly no clue" level, you probably won't know when to re-enter either
Just hold it and sit tight
the ones who trust the yen the least are actually the Japanese themselves
During the Lehman Shock, investors worldwide dumped stocks and other assets and used the cash to buy… the Japanese yen.
are showing this much enthusiasm for pushing the yen higher, so why is this happening?
Does betting against them actually pay better?
If Japan can't solve its own debt problem either, that becomes yen-weakening pressure too
Right now the US situation is more serious, so the yen's strengthening
Dead simple reason — a stronger yen means losses for certain people
There are guys who've been profiting off the weak yen
They want it weak, so they're desperately talking Japan down to steer things that way
If Japan sells US Treasuries to buy yen in order to stop the yen's slide,
US bond yields rise, and that's a headache for America
Going full long
Guess you're done for if the yen strengthens.
They say "buy dollar-yen and go to sleep, and you'll build yourself a fortune" — it's basically gospel at this point.
We've had that drilled into us over and over since the US started its relentless run of rate hikes.
Long is the only way to win!
It's baffling how many retail traders throw themselves into it so desperately
Are they doing it as a substitute for pachinko or slots?
You've actually got better odds with pachinko or slots…
But you can't win tens of millions of yen doing that
Started FX back in 2013, down ¥35 million total oz
I've only got about ¥10 million in cash left now
I could've just bought a house with the money I torched on FX — threw that chance straight in the trash ＞＜
Saw a salaryman on the train saying something like, "Slots and pachinko just don't pay off anymore, so I started FX."
He was explaining it like, "It's got more thrill than slowly bleeding out money I worked hard for! Betting like this, you can move around 2 million yen easy!" lol
I thought, that's not really a "bet" in the normal sense — but I guess given the price you pay if you lose, calling it gambling is actually accurate.
With FX you can't win tens of millions either, you know
It puts on the appearance of a legitimate financial product, but underneath it's really just illegal bookmaking (a "nomi-koi" style operation where the broker bets against you instead of routing trades to the real market)… ＞＜
You see the news sometimes about some housewife making hundreds of millions of yen and getting busted for tax evasion
Gamblers chase that dream
You can easily make money on futures
Though since it's zero-sum, the opposite can happen too
who was that policy even for?
It hasn't doubled a single thing
That's "glasses guy's" policy (a nickname for former PM Kishida)
Must be talking about NISA, but that thing barely grows your money
And it's risky for what it's worth
What got sacrificed to chase that "doubling asset income" goal was way too big
Prices shot up, and the yen collapsed at an absurd, unprecedented pace in a short span of time —
and the administration never once corrected course on it the entire time it was in power
All of that hits ordinary people's lives directly
Prices rose mainly because inflation from overseas spilled into Japan — the weak yen itself is actually a net positive for Japan
Re: #803
Talk about "the yen's credibility" and the like is just spin
If you look hard enough there are some, but they're outliers who just happened to win — you definitely can't generalize from them
Started with ¥5 million and it shrank to ¥2 million in about 3 years
Meanwhile my monthly contributions to the new NISA went from ¥0 to ¥6 million in 2 years and 9 months
Background and key points of this discussion
FX margin trading data is published by the Financial Futures Association of Japan and the Tokyo Financial Exchange, and retail investor positioning is watched by market participants as a gauge of sentiment. This round’s ¥3.61 trillion net short-yen position is up from August, but it’s still below July’s ¥4.41 trillion (the highest level since 2015) — so this isn’t actually the “biggest contrarian bet ever.” The thread suggests several factors are tangled together in driving the currency, including the new Takaichi administration’s aggressive fiscal stance and expectations of a BOJ rate hike. At the same time, alongside views calling FX a “zero-sum game” or “just gambling,” commenters pointed out that retail traders keep piling in because it offers more of a “dream of hitting it big” than pachinko or slots — suggesting it functions less like investing and more like a high-stakes gambling product. One thing readers can easily misread: a rise in short-yen positioning doesn’t automatically dictate where the market is headed — it only reflects the behavior of a slice of retail investors.
※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (News Speed+) thread ““ú–{‚ÌŒÂl“ŠŽ‘‰ÆA4’›4000‰‰~‚̉~”„‚è@‰~‚‚É‹t’£‚è@‚±‚̂܂܉~‚i‚Þ‚Æ‹§ƒƒXƒJƒbƒg‚à š2 [‚¨’f‚èš].”
Leave a Reply