Category: Baseball

  • New Giants Manager Hideki Matsui Could Be a Secret Weapon in FA Negotiations — 5ch Asks: “Who’d Say No to Him?”

    With Hideki Matsui named the new manager of the Yomiuri Giants, one thread comment suggested, “If he’s the one negotiating with free agents, who could possibly turn him down?” The discussion ranged widely: comparisons with legendary players built on his combined 507 career home runs in Japan and MLB, the reality that active players like Shohei Ohtani and Seiya Suzuki are now surpassing his numbers, an anecdote from Ichiro about Matsui’s impeccable manners, and even a head-to-head comparison with Hiromitsu Ochiai — leaving opinions sharply divided.

    “If Hideki Matsui were the one negotiating with free agents, they might all sign with the Giants” — fans of rival teams are reportedly nervous about the “immeasurable effect” of the Giants’ new manager: “Who’s going to say no when Matsui himself is making the pitch?”

    It’s a bright piece of news for Japanese baseball.

    Hideki Matsui has officially become the Giants’ new manager. This long-anticipated dream scenario has finally come true, and longtime fans are buzzing with comments like “I’m definitely going to the stadium next year” and “Maybe I’ll watch the broadcasts again after all this time” — Matsui-mania has taken over.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    10AnonymousOct 25, 2026 16:14
    Yoshii and Tanishige turned down Nagashima's invitations.
    Taguchi and Nori (catcher Atsuya Furuta's nickname) turned down Hoshino's.
    30AnonymousOct 25, 2026 16:20
    Re: #10
    They're all men of real character.
    443AnonymousOct 25, 2026 18:18
    Re: #10
    Hoshino would've turned it down too.
    31AnonymousOct 25, 2026 16:21
    Only 9 players in history have hit 500+ home runs:
    Sadaharu Oh — 868
    Katsuya Nomura — 657
    Hiromitsu Kadota — 567
    Koji Yamamoto — 536
    Kazuhiro Kiyohara — 525
    Hiromitsu Ochiai — 510
    Hideki Matsui — 507 (combined NPB/MLB)
    Isao Harimoto — 504
    Yoshinori Kinugasa — 504
    64AnonymousOct 25, 2026 16:28
    Re: #31
    Yamamoto and Ochiai are the really impressive ones — most guys on this list went straight from high school, but Yamamoto came from college, and Ochiai dropped out of college and came up through the industrial leagues (non-pro baseball) instead.
    372AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:45
    Re: #31
    There's an oddly thin gap between Ochiai and Harimoto, don't you think?
    772AnonymousOct 26, 2026 01:48
    Re: #31
    Kiyohara, Harimoto, and Kinugasa are the only three whose career-high season still only hit the 30s.
    85AnonymousOct 25, 2026 16:33
    Ohtani showing up really deflated how impressive Matsui's numbers look now, huh.
    92AnonymousOct 25, 2026 16:36
    Re: #85
    So is that why he rushed into becoming manager — his shelf life was about to expire?
    96AnonymousOct 25, 2026 16:37
    Re: #85
    He's not just being passed by Ohtani — Suzuki's already ahead of him too. Okamoto and Murakami will probably catch up next.
    195AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:01
    Re: #85
    It's not just Ohtani — the real killer is that Japanese position players in general are proving they can hold their own on both offense and defense in MLB, one after another. That's what kills the rarity value. By WAR, Seiya Suzuki has already topped Matsui's best season, and his career total is about to pass Matsui's too.

    Ichiro, on the other hand, racked up so much WAR on defense that even by modern metrics he still holds the #2 spot behind Ohtani.
    205AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:03
    I mean, the Yankees' official account congratulated him on X just for becoming the Giants' manager. No other Japanese player gets that kind of treatment.
    213AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:07
    Re: #205
    The Yomiuri Shimbun's ad budget is no joke.
    214AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:07
    Re: #205
    Then why'd he only get 1 vote for the Hall of Fame? Talk about overrated lol
    227AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:09
    Re: #205
    Probably because they won't have to watch Matsui throw out first pitches anymore. Nothing could make them happier.
    244AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:15
    Ichiro: "He always keeps the Giants' gravitas, dignity, and tradition in mind in everything he does — it was the same back in his Yankees days. We've had a lot of conversations these past three years, and he's different from me in every way. I bet Hideki Matsui felt the same way [about the Giants]."

    — When did you feel his sense of dignity most?

    Ichiro: "For example, at dinners, even when I'd show up in denim shorts and a T-shirt, Matsui would come in a jacket. He'd say, 'That's out of respect for the restaurant.' The more I heard him talk, the more embarrassed I felt about myself."

    (lol)
    Sounds like Ichiro's just the one with no manners.
    272AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:21
    Re: #244
    Ichiro was also stunned that Matsui refers to himself as "watashi" (a more formal, polite way of saying "I").
    277AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:23
    Re: #244
    Guess he's embarrassing himself off the field too, then.
    293AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:25
    Re: #244
    Does Ichiro not know what a dress code is? Matsui lived in NY — there's no way he could've gotten away with ignoring dress codes there lol
    303AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:27
    Honestly nobody's hyped about this at all. Pretty sure he's kind of disliked.
    306AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:28
    Re: #303
    People are hyped — the Showa-era-born Giants fans, anyway.
    310AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:29
    Re: #303
    Sports Nippon ran it as the front page, ahead of both the Japan Series and the Kikuka Sho lol
    322AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:31
    Re: #303
    No, people really are hyped. You just want it to not be a big deal.
    348AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:38
    Nobody's turning down a pitch from a National Honor Award winner.
    358AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:39
    Re: #348
    The National Honor Award has been losing its prestige since 2013.
    369AnonymousOct 25, 2026 17:44
    Re: #348
    It's basically just a Yomiuri Shimbun award at this point.
    433AnonymousOct 25, 2026 18:13
    Matsui: "Oda, come play with us at the Giants."
    Ohtani: "Oda, come play with us at the Dodgers."

    He's going to the Dodgers 100%. Matsui only has influence over guys in their 40s and up.
    440AnonymousOct 25, 2026 18:17
    Re: #433
    By the time Oda makes his MLB debut, Ohtani probably won't even be playing half the games anymore.
    515AnonymousOct 25, 2026 18:58
    Matsui is clearly a notch below Ochiai. Ochiai won the Triple Crown three times; Matsui never won it once. And in terms of baseball theory and coaching ability, Matsui's nowhere near Ochiai either.
    522AnonymousOct 25, 2026 19:01
    Re: #515
    Ochiai could never have signed with an MLB team — he had no position he could actually play defense at, so he's clearly a tier below.
    531AnonymousOct 25, 2026 19:06
    Re: #515
    [Career title counts in the three major categories]
    Hiromitsu Ochiai — 20 NPB seasons
    Home Run King: 5 times
    RBI King: 5 times
    Batting champion: 5 times

    Hideki Matsui — 10 NPB seasons
    Home Run King: 3 times
    RBI King: 3 times
    Batting champion: 1 time

    Matsui probably couldn't have pulled off three Triple Crowns, but if he'd stayed in Japan he probably would've won at least one. He'd likely have ended up around 8 Home Run titles, 8 RBI titles, and roughly 5 batting titles, with a career total of around 670 home runs.
    Ochiai's career total was 510.
    547AnonymousOct 25, 2026 19:13
    Re: #515
    Still, Matsui's a step up from Ochiai, who only ever played in Japan — Ochiai's more in the same tier as guys like Michihiro Ogasawara.
    581AnonymousOct 25, 2026 19:36
    Back in the day, a lot of players desperately wanted to join the Giants and turned down other teams' draft picks — Egawa, Motoki, Uchiumi, Nagano, Sugano, that kind of thing. The Giants brand from back then just doesn't exist anymore.
    591AnonymousOct 25, 2026 19:48
    Re: #581
    A brand only survives as long as people are under the illusion that it's the best. Joining the Giants used to be the absolute peak for a Japanese athlete.

    These days MLB has taken that spot, but joining the Giants is still generally more popular than joining any other NPB team.
    593AnonymousOct 25, 2026 19:50
    Re: #591
    Even just looking domestically these days, teams like SoftBank or Hanshin seem to have more brand power lol
    595AnonymousOct 25, 2026 19:50
    Re: #591
    You think so? Depends on the position situation, but sure, plenty of guys would happily go to SoftBank. With the Giants your career stats don't even grow that much.
    763AnonymousOct 26, 2026 01:39
    When did Matsui suddenly get treated like he was some legendary superstar lol
    766AnonymousOct 26, 2026 01:41
    Re: #763
    He's aged well over time, like a fine wine.
    770AnonymousOct 26, 2026 01:44
    Re: #763
    I mean, from the perspective of actual active players in the FA generation, it's probably a different story than from guys posting here, right?
    792AnonymousOct 26, 2026 02:48
    Re: #763
    Well, Matsui is a star. The four-straight-intentional-walks game (from his Koshien high school days) and the fact that his MLB numbers, while not jaw-dropping, came packaged with a World Series MVP — he's just someone blessed with a great story.

    Background and key points of this discussion

    During his playing career, Hideki Matsui recorded a combined 507 home runs in Japan and MLB, but he never won a Triple Crown and claimed the batting title only once. The thread’s comparison to Hiromitsu Ochiai (a three-time Triple Crown winner) is grounded in that gap. At the same time, Hall of Fame vote totals fluctuate year to year, so the “1 vote” cited in the thread reflects a single year’s result rather than a true measure of his overall standing as a player — a point that’s easy to misread. Also, in practice it’s usually team front offices and GMs who lead free-agent negotiations, not the manager personally sitting across the table. The thread’s disagreement comes down to two competing views: one holds that Matsui’s achievements have “lost their rarity” now that active players like Shohei Ohtani and Seiya Suzuki are putting up comparable or better numbers, while the other emphasizes his fame and influence, citing his National Honor Award and the Yankees’ official congratulations. Neither view is really grounded in how free-agent negotiations actually work.

    ※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “[Baseball] “If Hideki Matsui negotiated with FA players they might all sign” — the Giants’ new manager’s immeasurable effect: “Who’s going to turn Matsui down?”“

  • SoftBank Manager Kokubo Skips Draft Meeting — 5ch Asks, ‘Why Isn’t Kokubo There?’

    On October 22, 2026, to coincide with the NPB draft meeting broadcast on the TBS network, a thread on 5ch’s “Nandemo Jikkyō” (anything-goes live-commentary) board filled up with posts speculating on each team’s picks and describing the scene at the venue. The post that drew the most attention questioned why SoftBank Hawks manager Hiroki Kokubo was nowhere to be seen, with comments like “Watching the manager miss the lottery draw is the best part — don’t skip out on that!” Other popular posts included a roundup of first-round pick predictions from the sports dailies, and one pointing out that Aoyama Gakuin University has produced a first-round draft pick for four straight years.

    1AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:51
    Because there wasn't one.
    12AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:55
    SoftBank's Kokubo isn't even there.
    If the manager's not showing up, at least send out Oh or someone.
    15AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:55
    Re: #12
    Kokubo's stuck to his policy of staying completely hands-off on roster building.
    14AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:55
    Why isn't Kokubo here?
    16AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:55
    Re: #14
    Maybe he headed to Aoyama Gakuin?
    17AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:56
    Re: #14
    He's busy prepping for the Japan Series
    Jojima's there, so there's no need for him to go.
    19AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:56
    Re: #14
    He's in Yokohama, so he can't make it.
    20AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:56
    Watching the manager miss the lottery draw is the best part — don't skip out on that!
    25AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:57
    Re: #20
    True that
    This is part of the show too — they should actually make the manager do it.
    22AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:57
    Sponichi Sankei Nikkan Hochi Daily ChuSpo
    Tigers Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe
    Giants Komoda Komoda Watanabe Komoda Komoda Watanabe
    DeNA Kawajiri Yonezawa Komoda Fujisawa Komoda Suzuki
    Carp Yamazato Watanabe Yamazato Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe
    Swallows Komoda Fujisawa Komoda Suzuki Suzuki Suzuki
    Dragons Suzuki Suzuki Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe

    Hawks Oda Komoda Suzuki Komoda Suzuki Suzuki
    Lions Suzuki Suzuki Komoda Suzuki Miyahara Miyahara
    Fighters Komoda Suzuki Komoda Komoda Komoda Komoda
    Buffaloes Kawajiri Kawajiri Kawajiri Suzuki Yonezawa Yonezawa
    Marines Suzuki Suzuki Suzuki Yonezawa Suzuki Suzuki
    Eagles Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe Watanabe
    32AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:58
    Re: #22
    Hiroshima's short on talent at literally every position, even counting free agency — the feeling that Watanabe alone won't fix that is off the charts.
    23AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:57
    Aikawa's there, so Kokubo might as well show up too.
    Does he not get that the draft is basically a fan-service event these days?
    33AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:59
    66AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:02
    The Giants don't even have a power hitter — can they really afford to be drafting a guy like Komoda?
    73AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:02
    Re: #66
    His main skill is hitting, isn't it?
    68AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:02
    The stream's on U-NEXT, but why do I have to pay money just to watch a draft, of all things?
    75AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:03
    Re: #68
    Who was streaming it last year again?
    82AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:03
    For your own favorite team, which would you want them to take high — a high schooler, a college player, or someone from the corporate leagues?
    88AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:04
    Re: #82
    Just so you know, I'm a cat person (an unrelated 5ch joke aside, not a team reference) — probably a long shot, but I want Oda.
    91AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:04
    Re: #82
    We're losing two starters, so I'm not asking for much — just two immediate-impact starters who can realistically win double digits.
    93AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:04
    Re: #82
    College guy, no question about it.
    90AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:04
    Re: #75
    They used to just stream it on YouTube, no problem.
    92AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:04
    Re: #90
    Do it again this year too 😠
    129AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:06
    It's dumb for Chunichi to go after Watanabe
    when they've already got Ishii.
    159AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:07
    Re: #129
    This, exactly
    They don't even have room for Watanabe.
    221AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:09
    Another exclusive-bid pick for the Fighters? (a "one-team lottery" where only one club bids, guaranteeing the signing)
    It's gonna end up like Kiyomiya all over again.
    267AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:10
    Re: #221
    Is Kiyomiya actually considered a success?
    378AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:14
    tps://i.imgur.com/GhYuI7b.jpeg
    396AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:15
    Re: #378
    Oi, what are you laughing at? (said in a Kansai jab)
    404AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:16
    Re: #378
    Love the expressions on the two people right behind him
    They look like they're about to say 'this is seriously hilarious.'
    434AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:17
    Aoyama Gakuin University has produced two first-round draft picks every year for four years running
    2023: Tsunehiro (Hiroshima), Shimomura (Hanshin)
    2024: Nishikawa (Lotte), Sasaki (Hiroshima)
    2025: Nakanishi (Chunichi), Oda (DeNA)
    2026: Watanabe (Rakuten), Suzuki (SoftBank)
    441AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:18
    Re: #434
    Nishikawa's a huge hit
    Wonder how the others panned out.
    447AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:18
    Re: #434
    Misho's about the only other one so far (nickname for one of the other picks).

    Background and Key Points

    In Japan’s professional baseball draft, when multiple teams submit a first-round bid on the same player, a lottery decides which team gets negotiating rights — and the facial expressions of the team reps drawing lots become a talking point every year. The thread’s focus on Manager Kokubo’s absence comes from the fact that at many clubs it’s the manager himself who draws the lottery slip, which makes the contrast stand out; however, scouting and roster-building decisions are handled by the front office, and it’s not unusual for the on-field manager to have no involvement in the draft at all. As for Aoyama Gakuin University, posts in the thread point out that it has produced two first-round draft picks every year from 2023 through 2026 — four years running — cementing its reputation as a university that scouts watch closely. Several posts also grumbled about the draft’s paid livestream on U-NEXT, but it’s easy to overlook that the broadcast was free on YouTube in past years, meaning the streaming setup changes from year to year.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyō) thread “[TBS] Professional Baseball Draft Meeting.”

  • Pro Baseball Draft Broadcast Taps Minaki Fujimoto as Guest — Fans: ‘First We’ve Heard She’s Into Baseball’

    The ‘2026 Professional Baseball Draft Conference’ aired live on TBS starting at 4:40 PM on the 22nd. After Minaki Fujimoto was brought in as the broadcast’s guest host, Hello! Project fans on 5ch’s Hello! Pro board reacted with comments like “First I’ve heard Mikitty was into baseball” and “Wouldn’t Mai Satoda, Rika Ishikawa, or Asami Konno have been a better fit?” TBS announced that only the first and second rounds of picks would air live, with later rounds covered via rolling updates, while off-air chatter buzzed about each team’s first-round pick and the reputations of the top prospects.

    1AnonymousOct 22, 2026 15:42
    The 'day of destiny' is back again this year…!
    We'll bring you live coverage of the conference that decides the fates of young players chasing a spot in professional baseball.
    What kind of drama will unfold this year…?!
    2AnonymousOct 22, 2026 15:53
    ■ Maria Makino ■ Live Commentary Stream: 2026 Draft Conference ■ 10/22 4:45 PM~ YouTube Fighters MIRU ■
    https://kizuna.5ch.io/test/read.cgi/morningcoffee/1792631965/
    4AnonymousOct 22, 2026 15:59
    Lost interest in this ever since Poncho died (nickname of a well-known baseball stats commentator)
    6AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:18
    First I've heard Mikitty was into baseball
    9AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:25
    Should've been Mai Satoda, Rika Ishikawa, Asami Konno, or Melon Shibata here
    not Mikitty
    10AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:31
    Could've had Maria as the guest instead
    Mikitty's not even into baseball, is she?
    11AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:33
    Wait, it's Mikitty? Not Makino? lol
    12AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:35
    Guess they cast her for that 'mom's-eye view' angle or something
    14AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:37
    Fujimoto's the one more people recognize since she's in commercials too
    Makino's only known to a small niche, so she's the weaker pick
    15AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:38
    Same as every year — TBS will probably only air the 1st-round pick
    Go online if you want to see the lottery results for round 2 and beyond
    18AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:40
    Apparently this is TBS's plan:
    Live broadcast for 1st and 2nd round picks
    Rolling updates from the 3rd round on
    22AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:42
    Anyone here watching on Sky A?
    28AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:45
    Re: #22
    I had a spare channel slot on my Select 5 cable plan, so I switched to Sky A just for this month
    25AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:45
    If it were Shibata, she'd probably break into 'This Is Unmei' (a song titled 'Destiny') for us
    27AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:45
    They should just make Oda ineligible to be drafted
    29AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:46
    At this stage he's already more built than Ohtani was
    32AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:57
    Sky A doesn't pile on the entertainment stuff, so it's easier to watch
    Fewer commercials too
    34AnonymousOct 22, 2026 16:58
    Komoda's pretty overrated, honestly
    Oda probably won't get picked at all
    35AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:00
    Komoda's raw talent is what it is, can't help that
    I do think Hirata could break out if he goes in the 4th round
    38AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:02
    Sueyoshi will probably get picked, but what about Gakki? Hasn't he not even filed his 'death notice' yet (slang for declaring you won't turn pro)?
    39AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:02
    Isn't Oda also someone who hasn't filed anything either?
    40AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:03
    For me, Maeda's head and shoulders above the other high-school pitchers
    I expect him to perform on Orix's Miyagi's level
    45AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:05
    Guess this year's draft ends up being Watanabe's year after all
    57AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:07
    A secret deal, here it comes━━━━(°∀°)━━━━!!
    63AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:08
    If Oda ends up with the Giants, he's gonna get ripped apart for it
    69AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:09
    No way he goes to the Giants!
    If he turns them down, that'd be unprecedented
    72AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:09
    The Giants can't develop players anyway
    Might be better off going to America
    I dunno though
    74AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:09
    Stuff like this is exactly why 'yakyu' gets side-eyed by everyone (mocking slang for baseball)
    78AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:10
    The Giants, tossing their first-round pick straight in the gutter lol
    86AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:11
    This Oda guy never even planned to go NPB in the first place — so why's he standing by at the press conference venue?
    88AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:12
    If Rakuten wanted a catcher, there were guys like Ota and others available
    93AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:13
    Re: #88
    Ota's a free agent this year
    101AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:14
    Komoda going to the Fighters uncontested was a lucky break
    Is Oda-to-Giants outside interference, or a secret deal?
    108AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:15
    Re: #101
    It's pure interference
    Oda probably won't even sit down at the negotiating table
    104AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:15
    They should just ride in the same taxi together

    Background and Key Points of This Topic

    Because the NPB draft conference uses a lottery system, the outcome of the first-round picks is always the year’s biggest draw, and it’s become standard practice for terrestrial broadcasters to air only the first and second rounds live while treating the third round onward as news-flash updates. This time, TBS brought in Hello! Project alum Minaki Fujimoto for its broadcast, while at the same time Maria Makino was doing live commentary on a separate YouTube channel — meaning the same conference ended up covered live by multiple outlets with different talent. On the thread, many comments compared the two programs’ choice of talent, with some favoring other members from the same generation, such as Mai Satoda, Rika Ishikawa, and Asami Konno. Note that many of the actual draft results had not yet been determined at the time of the thread, so comments about individual teams’ negotiations should be read as viewer speculation.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Pro board) thread “■ Minaki Fujimoto ■ TBS TV ‘Professional Baseball Draft Conference 2026🈑🈓 The Day of Destiny Is Here Again This Year…!’ ■ 16:40-19:54 ■“.

  • Giants Take Yokohama’s Shoki Oda with Sole First Pick — 157 km/h Righty Who Declared for MLB

    The NPB draft meeting was held on October 22, and the Yomiuri Giants used their first-round pick to select Yokohama High School pitcher Shoki Oda (a third-year, 157 km/h-max right-hander) who had publicly declared his intent to pursue a Major League career — and they were the only team to pick him. With a domestic club locking down a player who had his sights set on negotiating with an MLB team, whether he actually signs now comes down to his own decision. On the 5ch “Geinou Supo Sokuhou+” (Entertainment & Sports Breaking News+) thread, discussion split over corrections to posts that misunderstood how the posting system and the pro draft declaration work, whether a candidate for new manager might be used to help persuade him to sign, and whether there’s any precedent for a player turning down a Giants first-round pick.

    <NPB Draft Meeting> ◇October 22

    The “NPB Draft Meeting, supported by Lipovitan D” was held on the 22nd starting at 4:50 PM.

    The Yomiuri Giants used their first-round pick — and were the only team to do so — on Yokohama High School’s Shoki Oda (3rd year), a right-hander with a fastball topping out at 157 km/h who has declared his intent to pursue a Major League career.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    9AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:14
    Are they going to get Matsui on board as the new manager to talk him into signing?
    88AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:21
    Re: #9
    He's from a generation that doesn't even know who Matsui is.
    That's not gonna do anything.
    209AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:28
    Re: #9
    (Matsui is) the 5th-highest home run hitter among Japanese players in MLB history.
    13AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:15
    They don't allow posting (the overseas posting system), do they?
    What are they gonna do?
    253AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:30
    Re: #13
    Is your info stuck 10 years in the past?
    They allow posting now.
    They approved it for Shun Yamaguchi, Sugano, and Okamoto.
    254AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:30
    Re: #13
    Both Yamaguchi and Sugano went through the posting system, you know.
    289AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:32
    Re: #13
    It's SoftBank that doesn't allow it.
    67AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:18
    Something feels off about TV cameras being there for Oda.
    Can't blame people for suspecting there was some secret deal.
    78AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:20
    Re: #67
    Sasaki, Ohtani.
    108AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:22
    Re: #67
    Well, there's a chance it happens, so they'll lock him up just in case.
    73AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:19
    If he were really set on the US and nothing else, he wouldn't file the draft declaration, right?
    83AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:20
    Re: #73
    The rule is you file the pro draft declaration whether you're headed to MLB, the KBO, or an independent league.
    91AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:21
    Re: #73
    MLB teams count as "professional" clubs, so to negotiate with a team over there you absolutely have to file the pro draft declaration.
    180AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:27
    Re: #73
    If he were 100% set on a US college, like Rintaro Sasaki, he wouldn't need to file. But if there's even a hint of signing with a US team or going the college route, he has to file it even for the US path.
    145AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:25
    The Giants have lost their minds.
    They should be drafting a slugger to fill the hole Okamoto left first.
    They've already got plenty of good pitching talent.
    153AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:25
    Re: #145
    They're taking Yoshida, aren't they?
    235AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:29
    Re: #145
    There's no slugger this year worth taking in the first round.
    172AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:26
    The Giants already have the whole plan drawn up.
    Make someone with MLB experience (Matsui, Uehara, Takahashi) the new manager, and have them talk Oda into signing.
    207AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:28
    Re: #172
    "MLB experience" — wait, you mean Hisanori Takahashi? lol
    218AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:28
    Re: #172
    Hey, that Takahashi — you mean the Hisanori one? lol
    173AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:26
    Tomorrow: Matsui announced as manager.
    Then straight to Yokohama High School.
    185AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:27
    Re: #173
    They wouldn't do that before the Japan Series.
    203AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:28
    Re: #173
    Besides, Oda doesn't even know Matsui's playing days.
    294AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:33
    Jojima (former SoftBank catching legend) was after him, but with the Giants grabbing him alone at No. 1… is there actually any chance he signs?
    306AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:33
    Re: #294
    It'll come down to persuasion. He clearly needs a mechanics overhaul anyway.
    319AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:34
    Re: #294
    Jojima already fumbled it once with Rintaro Sasaki, so he can't afford to gamble twice.
    382AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:38
    Re: #294
    SoftBank doesn't allow posting, so he'd turn them down anyway.
    309AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:33
    But the fact that he filed the pro draft declaration means he was open to joining NPB, right?
    328AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:35
    Re: #309
    He can't negotiate with MLB teams without filing it either.
    This whole premise is off from the start.
    404AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:40
    Re: #309
    Guess they'll just have to invent an "NPB-decline" version of the pro draft declaration.
    321AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:34
    I hear the minor-league development setup these days is way better than it used to be, and you get to learn English too.
    I can't see a reason to go to the Giants.
    This isn't the Showa era anymore.
    349AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:36
    Re: #321
    For a position player like Rintaro, getting to the US as early as possible is probably best, since the style of play and approach at the plate are totally different over there.
    But for a pitcher, plenty of predecessors have proven that if you go straight from Japan and just adapt to the different ball, you can go all out from year one.
    325AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:34
    Would turning down a Giants first-round pick be a first in history?
    332AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:35
    Re: #325
    Either way it goes, it'll be interesting.
    400AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:40
    Re: #325
    There was actually one guy who did — but that was over 50 years ago.
    340AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:36
    Which team's popular these days? SoftBank?
    365AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:37
    Re: #340
    Teams with deep pockets where it's easy to get playing time — the Nippon-Ham Fighters and the (Yokohama) DeNA BayStars.

    Background and key points of debate

    Under NPB’s draft system, a player must file a “pro draft declaration” to become eligible either for selection by an NPB club or for negotiation with an MLB team. The reason Oda filed the declaration despite publicly stating his intent to try his luck in the US comes down to this rule — and the fact that some posts on the thread mistook the filing as “proof he wanted to join NPB” shows just how confusing the system is. On the other hand, the Giants’ sole first-round pick goes through regardless of Oda’s own wishes, so whether he actually signs is still up to future negotiations and is by no means settled at this point. Posters debated whether a potential new-manager candidate like Hideki Matsui might be used to help persuade him to sign, as well as whether there’s precedent for a player turning down a Giants first-round pick (a case from more than 50 years ago still remembered among longtime fans), with opinions split. Note that this article does not cover unverified claims about Oda’s family’s appearance or background.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou Supo Sokuhou+) thread “[Baseball] Giants Push Through a Sole First-Round Pick on Yokohama’s Shoki Oda — 157 km/h Righty Who Declared for the US“.

  • Giants’ potential No. 1 draft pick Oda sparks 5ch debate over his ‘MLB-bound’ comments

    On the 5ch thread “Giants Acting Manager 183,” discussion continued around Oda, the Asia University pitcher the Giants are reportedly considering for their first-round draft pick. Oda has previously said, “I’m interested in Major League Baseball, but if I could be coached by someone with MLB experience, I wouldn’t rule out playing in NPB.” His comments sparked worry in the thread that he might end up refusing the Giants’ pick. The Giants have a history of passing on players like Daisuke Matsuzaka and Shohei Ohtani in the past, and the discussion expanded into wishful speculation that only a setup with manager Hideki Matsui, coach Hiroki Kuroda, and traveling coach Ichiro could win him over, as well as into the futures of Koji Uehara and Tomoyuki Sugano.

    1AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:19
    Previous thread
    Giants Acting Manager 182
    4AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:23
    8AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:26
    If he turns down being the No. 1 pick, that'd be the first time in decades
    51AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:29
    Re: #8
    I think it happened once, in 1973? Kobayashi from Aichi Gakuin University
    9AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:26
    They wouldn't draft him without good odds of signing him
    This is the team that ran away from Matsuzaka and Ohtani, remember?
    33AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:28
    Re: #9
    They managed to land Uehara and Sugano, so there's no way they're passing on this…
    36AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:28
    Isn't our team (the Giants, over some Sagami connection) banned from recruiting out of Yokohama?
    48AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:29
    Re: #36
    Well, that kills any chance of Hara's 'three times' angle
    41AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:28
    120AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:36
    Re: #41
    Doesn't he look a little happy about it?
    43AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:29
    Doesn't feel like the hellish vibe you'd expect from Asia University's baseball team
    57AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:30
    Re: #43
    The seniors shown here endured all the hardship and became gods lol
    The underclassmen are still slaves though
    72AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:31
    Re: #43
    Asia University's current manager is a guy named Shomura (a Tokai University grad, former Hachinohe Gakuin University manager), so the old-school customs are probably fading now (lol)
    44AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:29
    Say what you want, but our team's name value is huge
    No player has ever been drafted by our team and turned it down
    70AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:31
    Re: #44
    There was one, a really long time ago (1973)
    50AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:29
    Is there maybe some secret deal with Oda like, 'Just (falsely) announce you're MLB-bound so every other team backs off, then we'll be the only ones to draft you and it's a lock for the Giants'?
    78AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:32
    Re: #50
    There's precedent for players privately specifying their preferred team or region before the draft
    Some chunk of those 'going corporate league/college' announcements are just smoke screens to dodge other teams, based on behind-the-scenes negotiations
    58AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:30
    Besides Saito, has Yokohama had any other cases like this?
    90AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:34
    Re: #58
    Tsuburaya, plus Tahara and Kinoshita who both ended up in the developmental league
    Way back there was also Anzai, who was a teammate of Takeshi Aikawa
    96AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:35
    Re: #90
    Turns out there are more than you'd think lol
    I vaguely remember Tsuburaya lol
    65AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:31
    Are they going to hand him uniform No. 18?
    83AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:33
    Re: #65
    If it has to be in the teens, 12 is open too
    79AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:32
    As I said before, I'm interested in Major League Baseball, but if I could be coached by someone with MLB experience, I wouldn't rule out playing in NPB
    85AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:33
    Re: #79
    Then it'd have to be manager Matsui or Okajima
    80AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:32
    Re: #70
    Ah, the year of the Yuguchi incident
    135AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:38
    Re: #80
    Probably only our team has had a No. 1 pick flame out within a single year
    94AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:34
    Is Oda even a sure-thing prospect to begin with?
    106AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:35
    Re: #94
    Everybody's already this hyped, so I don't even care if he turns out to be a bust lol
    101AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:35
    Jumping straight to America carries a high risk of failure, and there's no going back
    Better to build a track record in Japan first
    — that's the scare tactic (to talk him out of MLB)
    138AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:38
    Re: #101
    The Fighters fed Ohtani that exact line and it worked out, but will it work this time?
    115AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:36
    We're probably the only NPB team this cozy with the Yankees
    131AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:38
    Re: #115
    Three posting cases:
    Yamaguchi: Blue Jays
    Sugano: fell through
    Okamoto: Blue Jays

    2 out of 3 went to the Blue Jays though
    122AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:36
    Manager Matsui
    Coach Kuroda
    Traveling coach Ichiro

    It'd take a lineup like that to even get his attention — Uehara's being underrated here
    140AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:39
    Re: #122
    Yeah, a coach's or manager's playing record really does matter

    Hirai signed because of coach Hisashi Yamada
    Matsuzaka signed because of manager Toshi (Higashio)
    127AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:38
    Aren't they keeping No. 18 open in case Sugano ever comes back?
    137AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:38
    Re: #127
    He could just take No. 19 again
    When Uehara came back he got stuck with a number like a switchboard operator's anyway
    139AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:39
    Re: #127
    Hara's not even involved anymore, so that promise might get broken lol
    147AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:40
    Are they gonna make Wheeler the manager and ban Japanese in the clubhouse or something lol
    150AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:40
    Re: #147
    Sounds like Rakuten HQ
    152AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:41
    Isn't the negotiating deadline two days before next year's draft?
    170AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:43
    Re: #152
    It's shorter now

    Background and Key Points

    It’s well known that the Giants have historically avoided drafting players seen as likely to refuse the pick, but actual cases of a player rejecting the Giants are extremely rare — the thread cites pitcher Kobayashi of Aichi Gakuin University in 1973 as apparently the only such case for the team. Asia University’s baseball team is known for its strict hierarchy, but the current manager is Shomura, formerly of Hachinohe Gakuin University, so how much of the old-school culture remains is unclear. The idea of a coaching staff built around manager Hideki Matsui, coach Hiroki Kuroda, and traveling coach Ichiro is purely wishful thinking from fans in the thread, not an official team announcement. Likewise, the talk about the futures of Koji Uehara and Tomoyuki Sugano is speculation, not anything either player has stated themselves.

    *This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch Hello! Project board thread “Giants Acting Manager 183.”

  • Giants Draft Shoki Oda and Seima Ikeda From Yokohama High With Picks 1 and 3 — 5ch: ‘Now That’s an Aggressive Draft’

    In the 2026 autumn draft meeting, the Yomiuri Giants used their sole first-round pick on ace pitcher Shoki Oda from Yokohama High School (Kanagawa), then followed up in the third round by taking shortstop Seima Ikeda, also from Yokohama High. Ikeda has reached Koshien four tournaments in a row, won the national title at the spring Invitational (Senbatsu) in his sophomore year, and brings a strong throwing arm to shortstop — he’s even hit 152 km/h (94 mph) off the mound as a pitcher. On the thread, opinion split over the Giants taking two players from the same school back-to-back: some called it a ‘hostage pick’ meant to pressure Oda into signing with the Giants, while others saw it as simply an honest evaluation of talent.

    Seima Ikeda (3rd-year), the infielder from Yokohama High (Kanagawa) who helped his team reach the final four at this summer’s Koshien, was selected by the Giants with their third-round pick.

    Ikeda has played in Koshien four tournaments running and won the national title at the spring Invitational (Senbatsu) in his sophomore year. His appeal lies in shortstop defense built on top athleticism and a strong arm, and he’s also hit 152 km/h (94 mph) as a pitcher. Giants scouting director Kuramatsu, who scouted him at this summer’s Koshien, praised him: “He stands out for his toughness in close plays, and his hitting has gotten more powerful too.”

    After his team was eliminated in the semifinals at this summer’s Koshien, Ikeda made his future plans clear: “I want to show everyone a version of myself that’s changed once again, and turn pro.” He added, “In the pros, I want to become a player like Kazuo Matsui.”

    Source: hochi.news / Original article here

    4AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:11
    Feels like it's full-on youth-development mode until Sakamoto and Tanaka actually retire for real.
    5AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:12
    Feel kinda bad for the guy, getting accused of being drafted just to keep Oda from leaving the Giants.
    67AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:58
    Re: #5
    Well, they've got a track record for this kind of thing.
    7AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:12
    Classic hostage pick from the 'Garbage-Sellers' (a derisive nickname for the Giants/Yomiuri)
    Same playbook as when they drafted Lee Kyung-il
    That's how they landed Tetsuya Utsumi
    9AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:12
    Man, the Giants play dirty.
    69AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:02
    Re: #9
    They're losing to SoftBank on financial muscle and losing to the Tigers on popularity, so the Giants — slipping from their throne as the sport's top dogs — are fighting with their backs against the wall. Guess that makes them desperate.
    11AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:13
    If he actually signs, this is a 'super heel' (pro-wrestling-style villain) start to a career.
    37AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:30
    Re: #11
    Feels bad that people assume that about him.

    If he were going to cut a secret deal anyway, he'd do it with a team willing to grant posting after just a few years. Teams like Nippon Ham or Lotte would post him without a fuss.
    13AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:15
    Oda: "If it's the Giants, I was planning to go pro in Japan anyway."
    19AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:19
    Re: #13
    Would be nice if his debut game is at Koshien, the ground where he made his memories.
    14AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:16
    Feels like the old Yomiuri is back — the 'Evil Yomiuri.'
    But honestly, that's fine by me.
    It wouldn't be any fun otherwise.
    16AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:18
    Reminds me of back when Nakahata complained about being a 3rd-round pick, so the Giants signed Hirata and Ninomiya outside the draft just to get him to sign.
    Their first-round pick that year was Shinozuka.
    20AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:20
    It'd be boring if they just played it safe, picking off corporate-league and college players one by one.
    This is the first aggressive draft they've pulled off in a while — fun to watch.
    21AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:20
    Pretty wild that the Giants made a pick like this knowing full well people would call it a package deal or a secret arrangement.

    (Not a compliment, to be clear.)
    22AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:21
    Giants scout Noriyuki Saito is a Yokohama High alum — he must've pushed hard for this one.
    23AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:21
    New manager's gonna be Kazushige Nagashima, and the Giants dynasty legend begins. (A joke — he's the son of legendary Giants figure Shigeo Nagashima.)
    24AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:21
    Ikeda's got real strength, and his defense is sharp too.
    26AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:22
    Think they've got the moat filled in already, 'Phony Giants' (a derisive pun on 巨人/Giants)? Manager Matsui to close the deal, huh. Dirty tactics — typical of the 'eternally filthy' team (a jab twisting Nagashima's famous 'the Giants are eternal' line).
    27AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:22
    Just how much do the Giants love Yokohama High, lol
    28AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:23
    If they ever agree to a posting system, maybe there's a chance for Oda too down the line?
    30AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:24
    Lol, that's some classic Giants pettiness — haven't seen it in a while.
    34AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:25
    If it's a package deal, does that mean Ikeda himself wasn't actually worth a 3rd-round pick?
    35AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:29
    If they'd at least try to win him over with words, like Kuriyama did with Ohtani, I could respect it.
    This just looks like a fixed match…
    42AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:33
    He'll probably pretend to refuse signing with the Giants for about a week.
    60AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:52
    Re: #42
    You can't seriously weigh the Dodgers against the Giants.
    If the Dodgers don't come calling, he'll probably end up with the Giants.
    52AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:46
    Looks like Yokohama High's manager is going to end up being the one persuading Oda.
    53AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:47
    Re: #52
    Yokohama High manager Hiroaki Murata, on Giants first-round pick Shoki Oda:
    "With Oda, we had talked about the possibility of a forceful pick happening. I didn't want it to catch us off guard, so I made sure we were prepared for it. I just spoke with him, and his resolve hasn't changed at all. I want to support the path he's decided on."
    https://x.com/hochi_giants/status/2113198474175152255
    55AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:48
    I figured some team would break the unwritten rule on Oda, but it's shocking that SoftBank passed on him.
    I thought the Hawks don't take early picks that seriously, so I expected them to take a flier on him just for fun.
    63AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:54
    Re: #55
    SoftBank already learned their lesson with Rintaro last year.
    Getting stood up by your own first-round pick is just embarrassing.
    66AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:57
    Re: #55
    They do take it seriously, you know.
    Their lottery luck is just garbage, so they haven't landed the guys they actually wanted.
    The only lottery pick they've won since Seigi Tanaka was Maeda.
    Before that, their luck was so bad they couldn't even win the backup-to-the-backup lottery.
    62AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:54
    Getting picked by the Giants these days just doesn't carry much value anymore.
    81AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:14
    Re: #62
    If you're putting up results, you'd rather be with a team that'll hand you a ticket to the majors within your first five years as a high-school draftee.
    64AnonymousOct 22, 2026 18:55
    Why didn't the Tigers go for Watanabe?
    They could've easily gotten Sakakibara as a fallback pick anyway.
    73AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:06
    Re: #64
    Probably because Fushimi's return was already locked in.
    If so, they can get by for another year or two.
    They might've also judged that finding the next Kinmoto was the more urgent problem.
    They struggled hard this year when he went down with an injury.
    78AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:11
    That catcher who got drafted alongside Utsumi just to get Utsumi to sign got cut pretty quickly, right?
    79AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:14
    Re: #78
    He was a 6th-round pick who lasted 6 years, so he actually hung around a while.
    Though he barely had any first-team experience.
    84AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:15
    Ikeda's arm is seriously something else.
    87AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:19
    Re: #84
    His height is the one drawback.
    But like it says, his defense doesn't even need polishing — it's already ridiculously good.

    Background and Key Points of This Discussion

    There’s historical precedent for a team picking players from the same school in both the first and third rounds, and the thread brought up the case of the Giants drafting Lee Kyung-il in order to land Tetsuya Utsumi, as well as the old story about Kiyoshi Nakahata’s signing. That said, the ‘hostage pick’ and ‘package deal’ theories are purely fan speculation — the Giants have never officially admitted to trying to sway Oda’s decision, and Yokohama High manager Hiroaki Murata has stated that Oda’s resolve hasn’t wavered. At the same time, Ikeda has real credentials on his own merits: strong shortstop defense, a powerful arm, and a fastball that’s topped out at 152 km/h (94 mph) as a pitcher — enough to justify the pick on talent alone. Where the thread splits is on whether to weight this as ‘strategy’ or ‘honest scouting,’ and it’s worth noting that neither view is based on any official team statement.

    *This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geisokuho+) thread “[Draft] Giants Take Yokohama Shortstop Seima Ikeda in Round 3 — Crowd Erupts Over Yokohama Duo Pick Alongside First-Rounder Shoki Oda.”

  • Shoki Oda: “My resolve to challenge America hasn’t wavered” — No hesitation even after Giants make him their No. 1 pick

    At the Nippon Professional Baseball Draft Meeting, the Yomiuri Giants selected pitcher Shoki Oda (18) of Yokohama High School (Kanagawa) with their first-round pick — even though Oda had already declared his intention to pursue a career in the United States. Appearing live on air, Oda reaffirmed his stance: “My resolve to challenge America hasn’t wavered one bit.” On 5ch, discussion split between users suspicious of a possible “secret arrangement” between the Giants and Oda’s camp, and those expressing sympathy or criticism toward the Giants, who stand to forfeit their first-round pick entirely if he doesn’t sign — with posters also bringing up past cases involving other teams in similar spots.

    Sports Nippon [October 22, 2026, 19:06]

    The “NPB Draft Meeting, supported by Lipovitan D” was held on the 22nd at a hotel in Tokyo, where the Giants made the bold call of selecting pitcher Shoki Oda (18) of Yokohama High School (Kanagawa) with their No. 1 pick, despite his declared intent to try his luck in the majors. Oda, who also joined via live feed on TBS’s broadcast of the “2026 NPB Draft Meeting,” shared his current thoughts.

    After a segment aired covering the struggle and emotions behind his decision to pursue America, Oda appeared live and spoke about being picked No. 1 by the Giants: “Honestly, I was surprised to be selected. It’s an incredibly honorable pick, but as I said at yesterday’s press conference, my resolve to challenge America hasn’t wavered one bit.”

    Source: sponichi.co.jp / Original article here

    3AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:33
    Is there really no secret deal with the Giants here?
    5AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:33
    The Giants getting in the way of a kid's dream is just the worst.
    7AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:34
    He's from a single-mother household, so they'll probably cozy up to the mom and pull every trick in the book to get him to sign.
    11AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:34
    Re: #7
    The Giants: "C'mon, it's about the money, right? Money money money money"

    Those Kyojin scumbags (a common derogatory nickname for the Giants) are the absolute worst.
    23AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:36
    Re: #7
    Word is signing with an MLB team nets him upwards of $3 million.
    The Giants can't exactly hand over under-the-table cash, so there's no way they win this no matter what.
    48AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:39
    Re: #7
    Dodgers: "Here's a 500 million yen signing bonus."
    Oda: "Thank you so much."

    Giants: "…"
    10AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:34
    So does this mean the Giants have no first-round pick at all this year?
    Someone who actually knows the rules, explain.
    13AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:35
    Re: #10
    They should've just picked him lower, like SoftBank did — idiots.
    20AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:36
    Re: #10
    If he doesn't sign as things stand, yeah, that's exactly what happens.
    27AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:37
    Re: #10
    Same thing happened last year — SoftBank's No. 1 pick, Rintaro, fell through too.
    14AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:35
    Sounds like a great kid who cares about his family. Go get 'em in the majors, I'm rooting for you — and the Giants totally deserve this.
    16AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:36
    For a second I misread that as "I have absolutely none" instead of "it hasn't wavered at all" (a pun on how similar the two phrases sound in Japanese).
    19AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:36
    Once he's in the majors he's going to have Japanese media chasing him every single day — rough.
    22AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:36
    Poor Mizuno, getting sent out to ambush him for a reaction — way too harsh a job to pull.
    25AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:37
    And here he was waiting for the draft results in his school uniform lol
    28AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:37
    Tried to control him with money the way they did with Yoshinobu Takahashi, and it backfired on them, huh.
    29AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:37
    Why'd he even file the "intent to go pro" declaration in the first place?
    32AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:37
    Re: #29
    It's required by the rules.

    Under the Japan High School Baseball Federation's regulations, any active high school player who wants to negotiate or try out with a pro team — including teams overseas — must submit a "Declaration of Intent to Go Pro" to the Japan Student Baseball Association.
    33AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:37
    Yomiuri's a bunch of idiots.
    Seriously, what a shameless organization.
    35AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:37
    Guess baseball's finally started ignoring the domestic league too, huh.
    37AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:38
    Oda himself said it was 50/50, so that pretty much confirms there was a secret deal.
    38AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:38
    He'll get crucified for the rest of his life if he backs down now, so he absolutely cannot waver.
    50AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:39
    Why aren't they drafting any position players?
    91AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:45
    Re: #50
    There probably just weren't any position players worth taking. This year's been called a weak draft class from the start.
    102AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:45
    Re: #50
    There wasn't anyone who stood out as ready to contribute right away.
    61AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:40
    So I guess the Giants saw this falling through coming, and basically put in a reservation for "see you in four years"?
    76AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:43
    Re: #61
    What actually happens in a case like that?
    Would they have to draft him again later as a former minor leaguer?
    66AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:41
    There's no precedent for someone going straight to the majors and succeeding.
    No way he just makes it work right out of the gate.
    79AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:43
    Re: #66
    Everyone said Ohtani's two-way thing was impossible too, and he pulled it off.
    "No precedent" doesn't mean "impossible."
    Let him be the one who blazes the trail.
    77AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:43
    The fact that only the Giants picked him already tells you it's a lost cause. Oda's resolve to go to the majors is rock solid. He's the type who doesn't waver once he's decided something, so the odds are extremely high he ends up signing with the Dodgers.
    90AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:45
    Did TBS know about this in advance too?
    A fully produced VTR package, him appearing live, a letter from his mom —
    that's way too polished to be a coincidence.
    110AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:46
    Re: #90
    They probably put the package together before his press conference announcing the US bid,
    and once that happened they couldn't patch the gap, so they just aired it as-is.
    100AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:45
    A team with no manager — give me a break.
    111AnonymousOct 22, 2026 19:46
    Re: #100
    The storyline where he can't refuse once Matsui personally talks him into it.

    Background and key points of the debate

    To negotiate with an MLB team, a current high school player must first submit a “Declaration of Intent to Go Pro” to the Japan Student Baseball Association before the draft. Oda went through this process before entering the meeting — but under the rules, if a team can’t reach an agreement with the player it picked, that team’s first-round pick for the year is considered used up, with no option to make a replacement selection. The thread’s biggest point of contention was whether there was a “secret arrangement” between the Giants and Oda’s camp — but that remains pure speculation on 5ch, since neither Oda nor the team has said anything confirming a deal. One thing readers can easily get wrong: a forced pick doesn’t mean the player is guaranteed to sign — in the end, it’s Oda’s own decision that determines where he lands.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisoku Speed+) thread “[Draft Meeting] Shoki Oda: “My resolve to challenge America hasn’t wavered one bit” — No hesitation even after Giants forced the pick.”

  • Giants’ First-Round Pick on Star High School Pitcher Sparks ‘Secret Deal?’ Buzz on 5ch

    On 5ch’s “Nandemo Jikkyo G” board, reactions blew up over the possibility that the Yomiuri Giants might use their first-round pick on star high school pitcher Oda. Oda is widely believed to be eyeing a direct route to MLB, following in the footsteps of Roki Sasaki and Shohei Ohtani, so speculation flew across the thread that if the Giants really do draft him, there must be some kind of “secret deal” already in place. At the same time, more level-headed voices pushed back, asking “is he really worth a secret deal?” and noting “if he turns the Giants down, it’s the scouts who’ll take the heat” — so opinions in the thread were split.

    1AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:08
    😪
    9AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:13
    I mean, they'll have to allow early posting at this point, right?
    Uehara's gonna blow a gasket
    11AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:13
    Re: #9
    Well, that's just how the times are now
    Still whining about it at this point seems worse honestly
    10AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:13
    If he actually joins, I'd be happy even with a 'posting at 25' promise attached
    15AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:14
    Re: #10
    He won't be satisfied unless it's the Sasaki/Ohtani route
    13AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:14
    Why is Oda-kun even at what looks like a press conference venue? If he's not planning to join a Japanese team, he could just stay out of sight
    24AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:16
    Re: #13
    There are other Yokohama High draft prospects there too, so he probably just tagged along
    30AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:17
    Did the Giants (mocking slur 'Kyo-kasu,' used by rival fans) lose it after getting crushed in the Climax Series?
    37AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:18
    Re: #30
    The Giants never had a shot to begin with
    If anything, it was the Tigers who got demolished
    39AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:18
    Wouldn't he sign if the manager personally came to recruit him?
    Oh wait, they haven't even decided on a manager yet lol
    49AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:21
    Re: #39
    So that's what the Hideki Matsui appointment is for!?
    This whole thing's being set up like a TV drama
    47AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:20
    I really can't believe anyone these days would want to join the Giants badly enough to get dragged online over it
    50AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:21
    Re: #47
    That's true if he refuses to sign
    But if he does sign, it's definitely a secret deal
    55AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:22
    Re: #47
    Just being the Giants gets you flak already, let alone this…
    'Secret deal, secret deal,' they keep saying…
    56AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:22
    Re: #47
    If anything, unlike hardcore baseball fans,
    doesn't the general public not care how a player ended up joining a team these days?
    51AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:21
    I could buy a secret deal if he were from a Tokai University-affiliated school, but no way for a Yokohama High kid
    54AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:22
    Re: #51
    Kuwata from PL Gakuen was a secret deal, you know
    74AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:24
    If he ends up joining the Giants after this, he's gonna get torn apart with all kinds of rumors, true or not
    82AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:26
    Re: #74
    Even if he refuses, he'll get flak from Giants fans too
    76AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:25
    True that
    22: 10/22 (Thu) 17:21 ID:tQ9p6oPF
    If he's going for the majors, there'd be no need for a live broadcast from the high school — so why is there a press conference room set up, I wonder
    80AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:25
    Re: #76
    Well, that's just because it's Yokohama High, I guess
    100AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:30
    Re: #76
    Ikeda's there too
    95AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:28
    If he's the only one picked in the first round while his praying teammates get passed over, the mood in that room is gonna be awful
    Is the Giants gonna throw in some kind of package pick?
    106AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:30
    Re: #95
    If they're still around in the later rounds, they might pick them as a bargaining chip
    98AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:29
    Actually, can the Giants even afford to spend their first-rounder on a high school pitcher?
    Their position players have been a mess if you look at the last 10 years of drafts
    102AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:30
    Why is it that whenever the Giants do it, people call it a secret deal lol
    128AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:33
    Re: #102
    Just people nitpicking
    You lose if you let it get to you lol
    115AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:32
    If he joins the Giants, he'll get slammed as a 'secret deal'
    If he refuses, Giants fans will slam him — so Oda's getting torn apart either way

    I can't see the Giants, who haven't even picked a manager yet, risking wasting their first-round pick, so it really does smell like a secret deal
    Would be funny if he actually goes to the majors like he's declared though
    122AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:33
    Re: #115
    Well, if he succeeds, people will forget about it
    Like with Ohtani
    123AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:33
    Re: #115
    If he refuses, it's the scouts who'll get slammed, not him
    126AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:33
    Re: #115
    Giants fans really aren't gonna slam him
    If anything they're currently furious asking why they even picked him
    117AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:32
    If we're talking about a new manager who'd pull something like this, there's only one guy it could be
    121AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:33
    Re: #117
    H-Hara-san… (stuttering in shock — Tatsunori Hara, former Giants manager known for bold, controversial moves)
    135AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:35
    Actually, if there's a secret deal, wouldn't they not need to burn the first-round pick on him?
    138AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:35
    Re: #135
    That's a show of sincerity, isn't it
    141AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:36
    Re: #135
    If a team like the Fighters forces the pick anyway, the secret deal goes to waste
    137AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:35
    Is he really worth making a secret deal over?
    Doesn't look like he'll be a standout from year one anyway
    140AnonymousOct 22, 2026 17:36
    Re: #137
    Fair point
    Are they really gonna post him off to MLB right when he's about to break out, like with Sasaki (nicknamed 'Sasa-rō')?

    Background and key points of this discussion

    The baseball world has seen “secret deal” controversies around Giants draft picks flare up repeatedly, and the thread brought up the case of Shigeru Kuwata from PL Gakuen as a past example. At the same time, the view that a team with no history of forcing picks is more likely to be suspected drew pushback too, with several commenters dismissing it as “just nitpicking” — so this isn’t something that can be stated as settled fact. Whether Oda himself truly intends to go straight to the majors, and how he’ll respond to the Giants’ courtship, remained unconfirmed at the time of the thread — and it’s worth noting that even the new manager situation (speculation about Hideki Matsui taking the post) hadn’t been finalized either. It’s also worth remembering that “secret deal” talk is a recurring staple of draft-season speculation rather than a definitive accusation against any specific team or individual — closer to a guessing game among fans than a factual claim.

    ※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “Oda Giants wwwwwwww.”

  • Hanshin Tigers Batting Coach Hiroki Uemoto to Step Down — Third Departure After Fujimoto and Koyano, as Head Coach Wada Shifts to Roving Coordinator

    It was learned on the 21st that Hanshin Tigers batting coach Hiroki Uemoto (40) will step down at the end of this season. He reportedly told the club himself right after the team’s Climax Series elimination was confirmed following the October 17 game against DeNA. This season has already seen coaches Shuji Fujimoto and Eiichi Koyano both decide to leave, making Uemoto the third departure. Head coach Yutaka Wada is also expected to be reassigned to a roving coordinator role, making this an unusually large wave of personnel changes for a team that just won back-to-back league titles. On a 5ch (Geinou/Sports Breaking News+) thread, opinions split over the reasons behind the departures — from doubts about manager Kyuji Fujikawa’s handling of the team and his character, to other factors like a lack of player development.

    [Hanshin] Another shockwave! Even batting coach Hiroki Uemoto is leaving… He’d given notice right after the Climax Series elimination on the 17th. The third departure after coaches Fujimoto and Koyano — an unusual shakeup of the position-player coaching staff

    It was learned on the 21st that Hanshin’s batting coach Hiroki Uemoto (40) will leave the team at the end of this season. He gave notice to the club after the October 17 game against DeNA, in which the team was eliminated in the final stage of the Climax Series.

    Coach Uemoto, who spent his entire 12-year playing career with the Tigers, served as the team’s academy coach and as manager of Tigers Women before taking over as the farm team’s position-player coach in 2024.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    2AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:34
    If you remember what Fujikawa was like back when he was a TV commentator, this makes total sense.
    6AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:36
    Fujimoto — ex-Yakult, an outsider
    Koyano — ex-Nippon Ham, an outsider
    Uemoto — from Hiroshima, an outsider
    7AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:37
    Re: #1
    Hard to say if Fujikawa alone is to blame.
    If it's gotten this bad, it's not just the on-field staff falling apart — something behind the scenes must be broken too.
    8AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:37
    Some people seem confused, but the truth is simple: the roster's too thin behind the core players to properly develop anyone, so they got cut.
    9AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:37
    People were saying 'Crybaby Kyuji' (a mocking nickname for manager Fujikawa) would wreck the team.
    Guess this is it.
    11AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:38
    Lmao, a team that just won back-to-back pennants is disintegrating in midair.
    12AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:39
    It's less that Hanshin is strong and more that everyone else in the Central League is weak right now.
    I don't think Yokohama [DeNA] is all that different from the Chunichi Dragons or zombie Yakult either.
    Get the tuning just slightly wrong and even a back-to-back champion ends up like this.
    76AnonymousOct 22, 2026 10:10
    Re: #12
    Hiroshima, Yakult, and Chunichi are all still playing Showa-era baseball (old, outdated style), which is why they're weak.
    13AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:40
    Just change the manager already.
    There's no reason to be this attached to Fujikawa.
    54AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:59
    Re: #13
    No team anywhere fires a manager who just won two straight regular-season titles.
    14AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:40
    Basically it's '​I can't keep working in a place like this!'
    16AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:41
    If Fujikawa were ever going to quit, this was the year to do it.
    You can already see him sticking around until the team crashes, then quitting — just like Takatsu did.
    17AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:41
    Having this many people leave all at once is a bit much, though.
    18AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:41
    While we're at it, Shuta Tanaka should go too.
    20AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:42
    I guess getting shut out three straight games in the Climax Series is what put the batting coach's job on the line.
    22AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:43
    This definitely isn't the kind of staff shakeup you'd expect from a team that just won the pennant.
    The Central League's so sloppy overall that Kudo's Chunichi might flip it all in just one year — which would be kind of pathetic in its own way.
    23AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:43
    I mean, that's only three people.
    Compared to what 'Sen-chan' [nickname for former manager Senichi Hoshino] did back in the day, this is still nothing.
    28AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:46
    Believe it or not, this is still the Central League champion.
    30AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:48
    Re: #28
    More like 'first place in the Japan Series qualifiers.'
    31AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:49
    Even teams that win the Japan Series go through staff shakeups.
    32AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:49
    Offensively, outside of the proven hitters in the 1-5 spots, nothing really worked.
    The third-base coaching and in-game strategy got slammed constantly too.
    They won back-to-back titles, but that doesn't mean everything was going well.
    33AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:49
    This kind of thing's been happening since the dark ages (Hanshin's long losing era).
    At least this time it happened after the season ended, so it's better.
    35AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:51
    Not well-liked by the younger coaches.
    Fujikawa won't last much longer either.
    37AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:52
    This reminds me of the Abe era [Giants manager Shinnosuke Abe]. In the end he just surrounded himself with his own guys, ended up with a staff full of rookie coaches, and nobody was left who could actually teach anything.
    38AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:54
    Everyone keeps saying 'change him, change him,' but then who else could've actually led this team to back-to-back Central League titles?
    It's not like just anyone could pull that off.
    42AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:55
    Re: #38
    I'm personally fine with Kyuji [Fujikawa], but I think 'Donden' [nickname for a manager famous for dramatic turnarounds] would've gotten the same results.
    40AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:54
    More importantly, what about Shuta Tanaka? If they just keep him on as third-base coach, I'm gonna be pissed.
    43AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:56
    Fujikawa: 'You're fired! And you're fired! And you're fired too!'
    44AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:56
    Honestly, putting Kawato [veteran Hanshin figure Kosuke Kawato] in some kind of special morale-boosting role would actually make things better.
    He wouldn't give actual baseball instruction, but he'd speak his mind to players, the manager, and coaches on the mental side — scolding and encouraging them. He's got a sense of humor too.
    He'd also make a good shield against the 'mass-media trash' (slang for the press).
    47AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:57
    He said the Climax Series loss was his own responsibility, but honestly the coach was the one who handled it with real integrity.
    48AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:58
    Compared to the pitching coaches who developed guys like Kudo, Kinoshita, and Jingu,
    on the hitting side basically nobody came up through the ranks at all.
    Maekawa was about the only 'maybe, if he hadn't gotten injured' case.
    52AnonymousOct 22, 2026 09:59
    Fujikawa: 'With this bunch of coaches, we just don't have enough intimidation left for storming out to yell after a hit-by-pitch…'

    Background and Key Points of This Topic

    What stands out about this round of personnel moves is that Uemoto’s departure wasn’t a firing by the club — he reportedly approached the team himself right after the Climax Series elimination on the 17th. Combined with coaches Fujimoto and Koyano also deciding to leave, and head coach Wada being moved to a roving coordinator role, this adds up to an unusually large staff shakeup for a team that had just won back-to-back league titles. Opinions on the thread split between those blaming manager Kyuji Fujikawa’s handling of the team and his personality, and those who saw it as the result of a thin roster beyond the core players that made proper player development difficult. It’s worth noting that while the original article makes clear the departure was initiated by Uemoto himself, most of the comments focus on pinning responsibility on the manager personally, with only a few pointing to structural issues like the club’s development system or lack of roster depth.

    ※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports Breaking News+) thread “[Baseball] Hanshin, another shockwave! Even coach Hiroki Uemoto is leaving… Third unusual departure after coaches Fujimoto and Koyano, as head coach Wada also moves to roving coordinator.”

  • Shohei Ohtani to Skip Offseason Surgery — Front Office Chief Friedman: ‘No Plans For That’ — Doctor’s Call Is to Rest the Knee

    Dodgers President of Baseball Operations Andrew Friedman stated clearly at the season-ending press conference on the 21st (22nd Japan time) that pitcher Shohei Ohtani “has no plans to undergo surgery this offseason.” According to the doctors, the plan instead is to rest his knee. This season, Ohtani was sidelined late in the year by issues with his left knee and right biceps, and in September he landed on the injured list for the first time since joining the team. In the 5ch Geisoku Sokuho+ (celebrity/sports tabloid board) thread, opinions split sharply — some posted images pointing to changes in his physique and griped about his frequent absences from fielding and his string of injuries, while others defended him by comparing his workload to other pitchers.

    Dodgers President of Baseball Operations Andrew Friedman (49) and General Manager Brandon Gomes (42) held a season-ending press conference on the 21st (22nd Japan time) at their home ballpark, Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles, California, where they addressed pitcher Shohei Ohtani (32).

    Friedman denied that Ohtani has any plans to have surgery this offseason, saying “there are no such plans.” He added, “The doctors are saying Shohei’s knee needs rest.” This season Ohtani also spent time on the injured list (IL) due to conditioning issues with his left knee and right biceps, among other things. After the season ended, Ohtani himself addressed the possibility of surgery, saying, “At this point I’m still not quite sure, and going forward I want to see how things play out, including whatever solutions come up.” Since moving to MLB, Ohtani has had surgery on his right elbow in 2018, his left knee in 2019, his right elbow again in 2023, and his left shoulder in 2024.

    In his third season with the Dodgers, Ohtani took on his full two-way role from opening day for the first time in three years, joining the starting rotation. But conditioning problems with his left knee and right biceps kept him off the mound in the second half, and in September he landed on the injured list (IL) for the first time since joining the team.

    Source: hochi.news / Original article here

    2AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:11
    Go to a good university and get a good dog
    That way, seniority-based promotion sets you up for life

      (∪^ω^) Woof woof!
    = 〔~∪ ̄ ̄〕
    =  ◎――◎
    4AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:13
    Wait, is (Freddie) Freeman the front office chief now? (mixing up the Dodgers first baseman Freeman with exec Friedman)
    6AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:15
    Step one: lose some weight
    10AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:17
    Re: #6
    His gut's bigger than Roberts'… (Dave Roberts, Dodgers manager)
    47AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:46
    Re: #6
    Wait, seriously, not AI?
    Where'd the disciplined Ohtani go
    American food is no joke
    7AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:15
    Ohtani should hit fielding drills and diet before making excuses
    9AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:16
    Better not to put off the surgery
    He's still got 7 years left on his deal
    63AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:54
    Re: #9
    At this rate he could list 'surgery' as a hobby on his resume
    Either way, out of those 7 years left, he'll probably be at his best for 2-3 of them, tops
    11AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:17
    By the time he retires he'll probably look like Nomo does these days (Hideo Nomo, the pioneering Japanese MLB pitcher)
    12AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:18
    He probably tweaked something from parenting — carrying the kids, lifting them up, getting jumped on, straining muscles he wasn't braced for
    Two kids plus a dog
    Just holding them is heavy enough, and doing the 'up-up' toss over and over would hurt anybody
    13AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:19
    Forget the injuries — am I the only one worried about whether things are okay with Rushing?
    You two should get along
    15AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:23
    Ohtani skipping out on fielding looks bad
    16AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:23
    How many surgeries is this now? Maybe the doctors finally told him to stop
    But there's no way his elbow, shoulder, back, and knee hold up for another 7 years — the guy's falling apart
    18AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:26
    Guess compensating for the knee pain turned into a habit of swinging without using his lower body
    19AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:27
    Looking back, it really has been nothing but injuries, huh
    21AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:28
    He barely fields and only pitches once in a while
    Why does he get hyped up this much?
    22AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:29
    Re: #21
    He's actually thrown more innings than Snell or Glasnow
    23AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:29
    Feels like every time this guy slumps at the plate or gets hit hard, he immediately blames an injury and disappears
    28AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:31
    Re: #23
    Is that so? Wasn't he still playing even when he tore his elbow ligament?
    25AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:30
    Well, next season's the real test
    Whether he fades out like this or bounces back at least somewhat
    33AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:34
    Re: #25
    Well, well
    Well, yeah
    Well, you're a 'well' too
    31AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:33
    Re: #22
    What's the point comparing him to guys who aren't being overhyped in the first place?
    64AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:55
    Re: #31
    The point is it's hard for any pitcher to keep throwing year after year
    Glasnow was being treated as an ace just two years ago
    Glasnow's 9 years of innings pitched are probably about the same as Ohtani's last 6
    People here keep saying Ohtani gets hurt too much or doesn't pitch enough, but they're not looking at anyone else
    Other guys are injury-prone too
    32AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:34
    It's fine to write off the first half, just get the injury fixed
    Think about what's best for the team
    34AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:35
    If you want to protect your knees, lose weight!

    s://i.imgur.com/up4lq1P.jpeg

    ↓
    How he used to look (2023)
    https://www.yomiuri.co.jp/media/2023/03/20230307-OYT1I50189-1.jpg
    45AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:44
    Feels like the type who says he's fine, plays, and only brings up 'actually it hurt' after a bad result
    78AnonymousOct 22, 2026 08:02
    Re: #45
    He blamed the WBC for it too, didn't he (World Baseball Classic)
    49AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:47
    Isn't that exactly why there's a manager and management staff — so players don't have to make that call themselves?
    Dysfunction at the top is the real problem here
    58AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:51
    The Ohtani haters on X look like they're about to get sued
    66AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:56
    Re: #58
    They're underestimating it, assuming 'there's no way Ohtani would ever sue'
    But even if Ohtani himself doesn't
    for the sponsors and agents who've poured huge money into him
    the damages would be on a totally different scale than slandering some random celebrity
    Seriously, they have no idea what they're risking
    62AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:52
    Bad leg: Shunsuke Nakamura (former Japan national team soccer star)
    Bad knee: Shohei Ohtani
    74AnonymousOct 22, 2026 08:00
    Re: #62
    Funny thing about Shun was, whenever told to go to the hospital, he'd just say 'a miracle happened' and it'd be healed
    67AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:56
    Re: #1
    Of course your body breaks down if you're always swinging full-force like that
    If you can't crank out home runs with a relaxed, 70-80% swing like Ochiai did, you can't really call yourself elite (Tatsunori Ochiai, legendary NPB slugger)
    Not getting injured is part of what makes a player elite too
    70AnonymousOct 22, 2026 07:58
    Re: #67
    You can push your body when you're young, but once you're past 30 it stops cooperating
    That's just as true for regular people
    His physical peak is behind him, so from here it comes down to technique

    Background and Key Points of This Discussion

    Since joining MLB, Ohtani has undergone surgery almost every year — his right elbow in 2018, left knee in 2019, right elbow again in 2023, and left shoulder in 2024. What President Friedman denied this time was “plans for surgery,” not the knee problem itself. In the thread, images showing changes in his physique sparked a wave of speculation about his diet and the toll of playing both ways, but there was also pushback noting that other starters like Glasnow have been injury-prone too, so Ohtani isn’t uniquely fragile. Some posts flatly declared the injury a “lie,” but it’s worth noting that neither the team nor Ohtani himself has said anything disputing the injury itself — their comments have only addressed monitoring his condition and giving it rest.

    *This article is compiled as an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuho+) thread “Shohei Ohtani to Skip Offseason Surgery — Front Office Chief Friedman: ‘No Plans For That’ — Doctor’s Call Is to Rest the Knee.”