From our other sites
The story
A report that X JAPAN’s YOSHIKI (61) would play drums for LUNA SEA in place of the late Shinya (57) became a hot topic on 5ch. Many commenters drew parallels to the aftermath of hide’s death in 1998, when LUNA SEA’s SUGIZO joined X JAPAN as a guitarist. The discussion spread in many directions, from frustration that X JAPAN hasn’t released a new album in nearly 30 years — not since 1996’s “DAHLIA” — to concern over YOSHIKI’s health given his past serious injuries and surgeries, to differing reactions between LUNA SEA fans and X JAPAN fans.
What people said
After hide passed away, LUNA SEA's SUGIZO — the one hide was fondest of — ended up becoming X JAPAN's guitarist
Way too spot-on ☁🎀moe(adorable)🎀☁(ง ˙˘˙ )ว
Seriously, they're both adorable (:.;゜;Д;゜;.:) *pant pant*
X JAPAN only has YOSHIKI (drums) and PATA (guitar) left,
and LUNA SEA lost Shinya (drums)
Was it "globe extreme" or something, lol?
It's been 20 years, I don't even remember the name
No doubt about it
There's only Kiyoharu
These days he's not even doing the 'love song' routine — he's basically a one-trick 'Forever Love' or 'Endless Rain' act now
Toshl, meanwhile, has turned into a full-on variety-show personality
Toshl's definitely on variety shows a lot, but his singing hasn't declined at all — he can still carry a solo concert
That's so expensiiiiiiiiiive
Wow, that's rough
Yeah, that's right
There's a site that covers Mirei's story in detail
After a year of being left in limbo, some company finally picked her up recently — she tweaked her name slightly and has been quietly, gradually active on YouTube since
LUNA SEA fans clearly do NOT welcome it at all, lol
There's a world of difference in playing skill to begin with
Shinya was top-tier in Japan
At around 60, some fans have probably already dropped dead
Yeah
The otaku big-sister types who looked after me so much as a kid are all
in their 50s, pushing 60, or well into their 60s now
I feel like he's put out something solo though
DAHLIA was released in 1996, so that's exactly 30 years
someone from XY became an actor
and did a stage play co-starring as lead with Iikubo
but it's a shame he stopped recently — maybe someone told him to knock it off
Didn't he tweet something like 'maybe I'll just spill that'?
Come to think of it, doing that might actually count as a threat
given how badly he got hurt and had surgery in the past
Besides the drumming, he's also had various health scares and been rushed off by ambulance now and then
Oh, so that's what happened, lol
Had no idea, but XY's gotten confusing too, and fans can't keep up like this
Leaving things in limbo every time just isn't good
Though naturally he kept his tattoos covered with long sleeves
Didn't know he was appearing on a show like that, Sugi-sama, lol
Background and Key Points of This Topic
After hide’s sudden death in 1998, LUNA SEA’s SUGIZO transitioned from touring support to full member on guitar for X JAPAN, and commenters kept drawing on that precedent when discussing the idea of YOSHIKI drumming for LUNA SEA in Shinya’s place. It’s also well known that X JAPAN hasn’t released a new album in roughly 30 years — not since 1996’s “DAHLIA” — and the thread repeatedly voiced frustration over this long-running “always promising, never delivering” situation. YOSHIKI has suffered serious cervical spine injuries and undergone surgery in the past, and these days his activity centers on solo ventures like dinner shows, so it’s understandable that people are worried about his health going into this drumming stint. At the same time, X JAPAN and LUNA SEA have different fan bases, and because Shinya’s playing was so highly regarded, there was a noticeable gap in enthusiasm over this “stand-in” idea — a point of friction running through the thread.
※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “Apparently X JAPAN’s YOSHIKI (61) is going to play drums for LUNA SEA for the sake of the late Shinya (57)!.”





Leave a Reply