Dave Spector Slams Kohaku’s ‘Rejected’ Label for Unpicked Singers: ‘Way Too Rude’ — 5ch: ‘They Never Even Applied’

From our other sites

The story

After NHK announced this year’s lineup for its New Year’s Eve “Kohaku Uta Gassen” singing contest, broadcast producer Dave Spector raised a question about the word “rejected” (落選), commonly used to describe singers who weren’t picked. The 77th Kohaku, announced on November 13, features 41 acts total — 20 on the Red Team and 21 on the White Team. Spector’s argument: since Kohaku isn’t an open-application contest, calling someone “rejected” is rude. On 5ch, some agreed (“now that you mention it, that really is rude”), while others pointed out that some singers don’t even want to appear on Kohaku, and the discussion spread to a past incident where the comedy duo Downtown criticized NHK’s habit of saying “congratulations” to performers.

Broadcast producer Dave Spector updated his X (formerly Twitter) account by the 21st, voicing his objection to a certain turn of phrase surrounding NHK’s New Year’s Eve “Kohaku Uta Gassen.”

The press conference announcing the lineup for this year’s New Year’s Eve broadcast of “The 77th NHK Kohaku Uta Gassen” was held on the 13th, revealing the acts set to perform: 20 on the Red Team and 21 on the White Team, for a total of 41 acts.

In response, Spector posted: “People should stop using the term ‘rejected’ for Kohaku. It’s way too rude. Not everyone even applied.”

Source: sponichi.co.jp / Original article here

What people said

2AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:20
Just from the thread title I could already guess it'd be about 'rejected' (落選).
29AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:51
Re: #2
Wow, you're amazing.
I don't get why you can't put that talent to use at your actual job.
4AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:20
But if Dave Spector ever got picked as a Kohaku judge,
I bet
Dave

would tweet that he 'won a seat'

on Kohaku.
5AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:23
Calling it 'graduating' when you just weren't picked is weird too.
6AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:24
Who's even using the word 'rejected' for this?
11AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:31
Re: #6
When artists who actually wanted to perform don't get picked, that's treated as being 'rejected.'


The lineup for this year's New Year's Eve broadcast of 'The 77th NHK Kohaku Uta Gassen' was announced on November 13, and it drew a sharp line between the Red Team girl groups' fortunes. While =LOVE (Equal Love) and CUTIE STREET made their first-ever appearances and FRUITS ZIPPER and HANA kept their streaks going, Juice=Juice — which generated some of the biggest buzz of the year — suffered the heartbreak of being passed over.
13AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:33
Re: #6
I looked it up —
turns out it's mostly articles from outlets like Shukan Bunshun, FLASH, Tokyo Sports, Nikkan Gendai, Toyo Keizai, and Diamond.
7AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:25
NHK's whole stance toward the singers who get picked is 'congratulations,' not 'thank you,' after all.
46AnonymousNov 22, 2026 10:25
Re: #7
Well, of course.
Kohaku is the only music show left that can pull 30%+ ratings.
The network is handing the singers and their agencies the single biggest promotional stage there is, so 'congratulations' is the right word.
8AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:26
I thought this was going to be about how it's rude to assign women red and men white and pit them against each other like that.
10AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:28
Agencies push their own acts hard, after all —
are they really missing the mark that badly?
12AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:32
It's probably idol otaku (diehard idol fans) using the term —
idols obviously want to boost their name recognition by getting on Kohaku.
14AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:33
Downtown said this too —
'congratulations on your appearance' really does come off condescending.
For a popular act, shouldn't it be 'thank you for appearing'?
16AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:34
Sum up Kohaku in two characters?

'Who benefits?' (誰得)
18AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:36
Re: #16
I'd say the performers benefit. It raises their profile.
17AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:36
So there must be selectors involved —
shady selectors steeped in murky vested interests.
19AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:38
But I do think there's a real sense of 'being recognized by society' once you're on Kohaku.
Even artists whose parents opposed their career get accepted by their parents once they make it onto Kohaku.
21AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:42
Never really thought about it, but yeah, it is rude to slap the label 'rejected' on someone who never even asked to perform in the first place.
22AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:43
There are also suspicions he's a CIA spy, you know.
24AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:45
Re: #22
He said a drunk Akiko Wada once screamed at him, 'You're a CIA spy, aren't you!'
23AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:45
They used to say that if an enka singer got on Kohaku even once, they'd be set for life.
Unlike commercial networks, NHK can be watched even on the most remote islands, so its reach is enormous.
25AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:48
They never even entered the running and still got branded 'rejected' against their will — that is kinda sad lolololololol
26AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:48
NHK supremacy, lol
These days there's no way any remote island can only get NHK, lol
27AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:49
Re: #1
He would've gotten way more buzz saying this about M-1 instead.
28AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:50
I remember a story about how, back when Matsumoto was set to appear on Kohaku, NHK told him 'congratulations' and he was like, 'huh?'
33AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:52
Downtown used to go off about how
getting on Kohaku means being told 'congratulations' in this condescending tone.
80AnonymousNov 22, 2026 11:31
Re: #33
Hamada has actually performed on Kohaku, but Matsumoto only ever went along to cheer someone on.
37AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:56
If they want to soften the blow of 'rejected,' they could just declare they're 'graduating' instead (lol)
41AnonymousNov 22, 2026 10:05
Re: #37
What about artists who never even 'enrolled' in the first place?
40AnonymousNov 22, 2026 10:04
Re: #29
I don't get how you can even tell he's not putting it to use at work.
69AnonymousNov 22, 2026 11:15
Re: #40
Some people are only good at that one specific thing.
They're sharp in that narrow lane but it never translates into actual work.
47AnonymousNov 22, 2026 10:26
Wait, this is still a thing?
Is there even such a thing as a 'hit song' these days anyway?
51AnonymousNov 22, 2026 10:36
Re: #47
Love it so much it's destruction!
It's true, y'know☆ Why though☆ Dunno though (riffing on a trio of stock Kansai-dialect meme catchphrases)
55AnonymousNov 22, 2026 10:42
'Not selected' (選外)… that's weird too, huh. What should we even call it?
56AnonymousNov 22, 2026 10:44
Re: #55
NHK is the one doing the choosing, so isn't that fine as is?
74AnonymousNov 22, 2026 11:21
In response, Lou Oshiba had a word for Dave:

'It's a Red White Song Battle, right?' (a jab at Lou's trademark gimmick of randomly sprinkling English words into Japanese sentences)
76AnonymousNov 22, 2026 11:25
Re: #74
Real 'Lou-go' (Lou-speak) doesn't make the whole thing English.
Mixing it in — like turning 'nemimi ni mizu' ('news that hits you out of the blue') into 'nemimi ni wātā' by swapping in the English word for water — that's real Lou-go.

Background and Key Points of This Debate

NHK’s Kohaku Uta Gassen isn’t an open-application contest — NHK selects and invites performers itself, and the custom is to tell chosen singers “congratulations.” Media coverage, meanwhile, often describes singers who weren’t picked as “rejected,” even though that’s not an official term. Spector’s point zeroes in on how odd it is to use “rejected” for people who never applied in the first place, and on 5ch, many commenters praised it as “a surprisingly good point, for Dave.” The thread also touched on singers like Kazumasa Oda and Spitz, who don’t even want to appear, as well as Downtown’s long-running complaints about NHK’s condescending phrasing — suggesting the real unease isn’t just with the word “rejected,” but with the whole relationship between Kohaku and its performers.

※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “Dave Spector objects to a two-character term surrounding Kohaku: “They should stop. It’s way too rude.” — Users: “Surprisingly good point, for Dave”.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *