From our other sites
The story
After release, GTA6’s Metacritic user score sank into the 5-point range, standing in sharp contrast to its critic-driven Metascore. Reports pointed to complaints about the 30fps cap, the portrayal of the two protagonists, the newly added life-sim elements, and the possibility of organized review bombing. On 5ch’s Nandemo Jikkyo G board, the departure of Dan Houser — who wrote the scripts for GTA4 and 5 — and the resulting change of writers became a hot topic, sparking debate over the shift in content and the split in opinion over ‘political correctness.’
‘GTA6′ Metacritic user score splits opinion, landing in the 5-point range. Complaints over the 30fps cap, the two protagonists’ portrayal, and life-sim elements — some pointing to review bombing
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
So it's really that rough, huh?
Founder Dan Houser left after making [GTA]5.
Ah, the 'he just quit' pattern. Can't be helped.
Why would the founder leave when it's such a cash cow?
Apparently the male nudity scenes got a lot more frequent.
The male protagonist being whipped by his wife Lucia is apparently so over-the-top that people are calling it a netorare game (a genre built around your partner being 'stolen'/cheating). Also, the gay mob characters and NPCs are said to be nearly invincible and overpowered.
The Metascore is just major outlets' scores. The user score is the real, accurate rating.
Of course this happens when you pander to everyone to boost sales. It'll sell, but users end up hating it, so there's no future in it.
The stuff being mocked in the game is already something the left finds tiresome too, so of course it is. Maybe it's about time you updated your views?
The question is whether that kind of portrayal is even necessary in GTA in the first place.
It's a story about a trashy couple at the bottom of society — isn't that fine as it is? I thought it portrayed their low-life scumminess pretty well.
So is that necessary for GTA? Is that what users actually wanted from GTA? Or do you just fundamentally lack the intelligence to understand what 'PC contamination' even means?
Since when did GTA become this cynical? It's always been a series that, from the immigrant's perspective, depicted the stifling closed-in feeling of old American society and the working class.
Seems totally fine to include a woman when telling a story about criminals, right? Calling it 'PC contamination' just because a woman shows up means your hatred of PC has scrambled your brain.
No, that's not it lol. You don't understand what 'PC contamination' even means in the first place, so your whole argument is off track — you're not even on the same playing field. Try googling 'Emily-ification PC' — even you should be able to get it right away.
I don't get it. Don't run away from the argument — you explain it.
I don't get it either, so explain it for me.
That's the backlash from PC contamination spreading to a sickness-inducing degree.
Is gang warfare between color gangs really the 'stifling working-class feeling' you're talking about?
Working class and the underclass are basically equivalent. Maybe you should study up more on political correctness.
Exactly. Being able to move freely within that world is what makes GTA fun. A game where you're forced into being some old hag's slave with even your actions restricted isn't GTA.
You're not forced to. Whether you keep Lucia happy or not is entirely optional.
The moment you refuse to even look it up, you've already lost.
Ciri being the protagonist is just following the source material — this comes up every time.
GTA V was so good that it became a series where people expect a good story too.
Red Dead Redemption 1 and 2, as well as GTA V, IV, and San Andreas, all got huge praise for their stories. A lot of them lean into nostalgia and pathos matching the mood of the times in America, and they're often pretty depressing.
Background and Key Points of This Topic
The GTA series’ founder, Dan Houser, left the company after writing the scripts for GTA4 and 5, and GTA6 has been handed off to a new writing team. Metacritic’s Metascore is an average of scores from major media outlets — a separate metric from the user score — and the gap between the two is often a point of debate for major titles. Unconfirmed information about the new writers’ backgrounds circulated within the thread, but no concrete details have been verified as of this article. Posters also never settled on a shared definition of the term ‘PC contamination,’ and the mismatch over what exactly people meant by it was one reason the debate dragged on.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread ‘[Bad News] GTA6 Blows Up Because a Woman (‘mansan’ — derisive 5ch slang for women) Wrote the Script.’

Leave a Reply