From our other sites
The story
Right after Metacritic opened user-score voting for GTA6, a strange phenomenon caught fire on 5ch: a sudden surge of zero-point ratings hit The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, a game released long ago with no connection to GTA6 whatsoever. Thread participants repeatedly spotted posts combining “10 for GTA6, 0 for Zelda,” fueling speculation that the unrelated Zelda title was being targeted as “payback” for review-bombing campaigns against GTA6. There were also reports that Ocarina of Time’s rating count jumped from roughly 20,000 to over 23,000 within just a few hours, with the sheer abnormal pace of the vote increase itself becoming a point of debate. Meanwhile, opinions among posters remained divided on who started it first and whether Metacritic’s response was adequate — the root cause and who’s responsible were left unresolved.
What people said
Right before GTA6's user score opened
After it opened
The guy who took the job: "Got it, boss" (おかのした — 5ch meme slang for a snappy "roger that")
Dunno though
From what I can tell, it looks like Zelda alone is getting focus-fired
When the brigaded votes get removed, the score drops
■ Nintendo games
When the brigaded votes get removed, the score goes up
Weird, isn't it
9.0 28,898 ratings Breath of the Wild
8.8 15,902 ratings Tears of the Kingdom
8.9 3,628 ratings Fire Emblem: Three Houses
8.5 1,130 ratings Fire Emblem Engage
8.5 2,900 ratings Xenoblade Chronicles 2
8.8 1,898 ratings Xenoblade Chronicles 3
Wonder what it looked like before this all kicked off
Verified-purchaser ratings
tps://i.imgur.com/vp8xX92.jpeg
Low-score brigading
tps://i.imgur.com/oLHk3Tt.png
tps://i.imgur.com/ZwgxZOq.png
The verified-purchaser rating only has about 1,200 likes, so that rating's probably fake
They made an enemy of a fanbase for a game that sold over 30 million copies on day one
It'll keep going until everything's destroyed
Wasn't there somewhere with a bad reputation for scorched-earth tactics…?
And on top of that, Ocarina of Time is already a second remake
I don't get why people are being this relentless about it
That's way too many!
The thread isn't even an hour old and it already went up by 500
They're probably all zeros, huh
So isn't this just people swarming the user score instead?
GTA has the PS Store and Xbox too
And honestly, GTA racks up over 100,000 ratings on each of those, yet its Metacritic user score sits at only around 20,000
Plus you can rate it without even buying it
Actually, I think the reason Nintendo doesn't let people rate Switch games is a deliberate strategy to avoid hurting sales with low scores
After seeing this garbage bombing war unfold, you'd still want a rating feature?
If it only let verified buyers rate it, it'd work fine, like on PS or Xbox, no?
Wolverine
Background and Key Points of This Topic
Metacritic’s user-score system lets anyone vote without proof of purchase, and “review bombs” — clashes between organized positive and negative voting blocs — regularly break out right after a popular title’s release. What stands out this time is that the target was Ocarina of Time, an unrelated, already-released older title with little buzz of its own; the dominant view in the thread was that it was being hit as “payback” against Nintendo’s fanbase for the low-score brigading aimed at GTA6. That said, who cast the first zero-point vote and whether there was any organized coordination remains pure speculation on 5ch, not something that’s been proven. What readers can easily get wrong is that a sudden crash in a user score doesn’t reflect the actual quality of the game — these hour-by-hour spikes and drops are, in most cases, the result of organized voting driven by fan rivalries.
※This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware/Industry (Console Wars)) thread “[Sad News] GTA6’s User Score Opens → For Some Reason, Ocarina of Time Starts Getting Zero-Bombed 🥹“.
Leave a Reply