From our other sites
The story
On the overseas podcast ‘The Asian Game,’ which specializes in Asian football, journalist Michael Church reportedly said that “if you’re picking a Japanese manager, it should be Makoto Hasebe” when discussing who should succeed national team manager Hajime Moriyasu. Reactions on 5ch clashed head-on: some praised Hasebe’s reputation among teammates and his coaching license earned in Germany, while others worried about the fact that he has zero track record managing a club side. The debate also brought in evaluations of manager Tsuyoshi Oiwa, along with cases like Tsuneyasu Miyamoto and Masami Ihara — “star players who struggled as managers” — underscoring just how tricky picking a national team boss really is.
Some Push Hasebe Makoto to Succeed Manager Hajime Moriyasu — Foreign Pundit Also Praises Manager Tsuyoshi Oiwa, But Admits “Not 100% Certain”
Regarding who will succeed manager Hajime Moriyasu, it seems overseas experts specializing in Asian football are rallying behind Makoto Hasebe.
On the 19th, the Asian football-focused podcast ‘The Asian Game’ looked back on the eight-year Moriyasu era. While discussing who should be Japan’s next national team manager, journalist Michael Church offered his view: “If you’re picking a Japanese manager, I’d pick Makoto Hasebe.”
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
Nice, lol
Let's make this the new 2get-troll format lol
Wait, look closer — that's actually post #3 lol
now that's a blast from the past
he used to contribute to Soccer Digest all the time back in the '90s
If Hasebe actually managed, he could easily put up Oiwa-level results.
Oiwa is a lottery ticket that's already confirmed to be a loser.
Hasebe is a lottery ticket whose numbers just haven't been drawn yet.
Don't use the national team as a training ground for rookie managers.
Like you can trust the character judgment of a guy who throws around "100% certain."
Manager Oiwa might actually be pretty decent?
It was attacking, proactive football that was genuinely fun to watch.
"Attacking, proactive football that's fun to watch"
or
"Possession-based football that takes control"
Managers described that way almost always turn out to be duds.
Pretty sure that's a rule!!
he'll just end up like Zico.
He should rack up real managerial experience first.
https://video.twimg.com/amplify_video/1570796358659117057/vid/720×900/Qwi9hiKpB2cONDNI.mp4
No way!
Who at Dentsu could even pull that off?
Someone with soccer experience?!
Think before you type!
Japanese Manager Rankings (by major trophies won)
#1 Tatsuya Oniki — 8 titles total (5 league, 1 League Cup [nicknamed the "Snack Cup" after its confectionery sponsor], 2 Emperor's Cup, 0 ACL)
#2 Akira Nishino — 6 titles total (1 league, 2 League Cup, 2 Emperor's Cup, 1 ACL)
#3 Kenta Hasegawa — 5 titles total (1 league, 3 League Cup, 1 Emperor's Cup, 0 ACL)
#4 Hajime Moriyasu — 3 titles total (3 league, 1 League Cup, 2 Emperor's Cup, 0 ACL)
#5 Takayuki Yoshida — 3 titles total (2 league, 0 League Cup, 1 Emperor's Cup, 0 ACL)
#5 Takeshi Okada — 3 titles total (2 league, 0 League Cup, 1 Emperor's Cup, 0 ACL)
#5 Yasutaro Matsuki — 3 titles total (2 league, 1 League Cup, 0 Emperor's Cup, 0 ACL)
— Masatada Ishii — 2 titles total (1 league, 0 League Cup, 1 Emperor's Cup, 0 ACL)
— Yasuharu Sorimachi — 2 titles total (0 league, 1 League Cup, 1 Emperor's Cup, 0 ACL)
— Takashi Hori — 1 title total (0 league, 0 League Cup, 0 Emperor's Cup, 1 ACL)
— Tsuyoshi Oiwa — 1 title total (0 league, 0 League Cup, 0 Emperor's Cup, 1 ACL)
(´・ω・`)
Hasebe's dead last lol
Hasebe should at least try managing a club once.
There's precedent — Miyamoto, the former "cerebral captain," was a total mess managing Gamba, turns out he just didn't have the aptitude for it.
Ihara and Nanami were also said to be headed for managerial success, and look how that went.
Miyamoto just didn't have people's respect.
Maezono was on a TV Tokyo travel/challenge show once where passersby had to guess his full name.
"Do you know my name?" — "Maezono… Mr. Maekiyo?" — "Yes! Let's just go with Maekiyo from now on!"
I died laughing lol
Just let Nobuhiro Takeda manage — he's got an S-class coaching license.
He seems like the type to bring out the best in the team and its players while quietly working to fix any problems.
Hasebe looks rational, but he's actually got a pretty emotional streak.
Rage-Mode Hasebe (´・ω・`)
Manager Honda is a far more realistic pick.
Hasebe already earned his DFB B+ coaching license in Frankfurt and has experience managing youth-level teams.
Once he finishes the JFA Pro course, which should be soon, he'll be qualified to manage the national team or a J.League club.
He's even worked as assistant coach for Frankfurt II (4th division) while also serving as a Japan national team coach, and he's working toward his DFB Pro license too.
Don't lump him in with self-proclaimed "managers" who don't hold any license at all.
Wasn't it Nanami who ordered the low block against Brazil like he was casting Geass (mind control)? lol
Background and Key Points of This Debate
Before Moriyasu, Japan’s national team cycled through both domestic and foreign managers, so this time the story generated buzz for the opposite reason: a foreign commentator naming a Japanese candidate. Hasebe is well-regarded for the trust he earned as a player and holds a German coaching license (DFB B+) plus some youth-level managerial experience, but he still has no track record running a top-flight club side. The thread split between skeptics who argued he’s simply being pushed on name recognition and image, and supporters who pointed to his hands-on experience and coursework in Frankfurt as making him a realistic candidate. Past cases of Tsuneyasu Miyamoto, Masami Ihara, and Hiroshi Nanami struggling as club managers were cited as proof that playing success and managerial aptitude are two different things. Opinions on Tsuyoshi Oiwa were similarly split, with some praising the quality of his friendly-match performances and others wary of his thin J.League track record — leaving the debate over Moriyasu’s successor wide open with no clear consensus in sight.
※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports Express+) thread “[Soccer] Some Push Makoto Hasebe to Succeed Manager Hajime Moriyasu — Foreign Pundit Also Praises Manager Tsuyoshi Oiwa, But Says “Not 100% Certain”.”
Leave a Reply